‘Bharat Mata' row may nurture divisiveness, claims Karassery
Mr. Karassery came down heavily on the tendency to worship symbols such as Bharat Mata at a discussion on 'Constitution and Bharat Mata' organised by the Calicut Press Club in association with the ICJ Alumni Network in Kozhikode on Saturday (June 28, 2025).
'Nothing is beyond criticism, be it the Constitution or Gandhi. Criticism will only nourish democracy,' he said. Tracing the history of the concept of 'Bharat Mata' to the times of the national movement, he said that nobody had the right to demand another person to worship anything. 'What the Governor did was anti-democratic and unethical. There is nothing wrong with him worshipping 'Bharat mata' in his personal space though', Mr. Karassery added.
Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) national vice-president A.P. Abdullakutty countered Mr. Karassery, recounting the beginning of the concept of 'Bharat Mata'. He said the concept of 'Bharat Mata' was rooted in the culture and tradition of the country. 'Those who criticise the Governor over the use of the 'Bharat Mata' portrait are playing dirty politics. Their intention is appeasement of the Muslim community. But they are underestimating the Muslims of this country. They are not that shallow,' he said. He used the opportunity to demand that the Prime Minister come up with a unified image of Bharat Mata against the backdrop of the differences of opinion regarding it and to include the said image among the official symbols of the country.
Director of Keluettan Study and Research Centre and Communist Party of India (Marxist) leader K.T. Kunhikannan pointed out that the Constitution does not support the concept of 'Bharat Mata' and that someone in a constitutional post shall hence not use it in official programmes. 'Myths are not part of history. The nation is made of history. The concept of 'Bharat' as well as 'Bharat Mata' are myths,' he said.
Calicut Press Club president E.P. Mohammed was the moderator of the session.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Indian Express
13 minutes ago
- Indian Express
Can elected govt be at whims and fancies of Governor, asks CJI
The Supreme Court bench hearing the Presidential reference asked the government Wednesday whether an elected government can be placed at 'the whims and fancies of the Governor' by vesting him/her with the power to withhold a Bill forever. 'But then would we not be giving total powers to the Governor to sit in appeals?… The government elected by majority will be at the whims and fancies of the Governor,' Chief Justice of India B R Gavai asked Solicitor General Tushar Mehta who appeared for the Centre. The bench said that to interpret that the Bill 'dies' the first time the Governor withholds it 'would be counterproductive to the power of the Governor and counterproductive to the legislative process'. The five-judge Constitution bench is hearing President Droupadi Murmu's reference on timelines fixed by a two-judge bench for the President and Governors to act on Bills sent by state legislatures. Delving into the contours of the Governor's discretionary powers under Article 200 of the Constitution, Mehta told the bench: 'It is not an asylum for retired politicians but has its own sanctity which was debated in the Constituent Assembly.' He said the Governor, though unelected, represents the President and is not just a 'postman' to mechanically approve Bills. 'A person who is not directly elected is not a lesser person,' he said. Addressing the bench which included Justices Surya Kant, Vikram Nath, P S Narasimha and A S Chandurkar, Mehta said the Governor has the option to grant assent to a Bill referred by the state legislature, withhold assent, refer it to the President in case of repugnancy with any Central law or return it to the state legislature for reconsideration. He said withholding is not a temporary act, and that 5-judge and 7-judge benches of the Supreme Court have interpreted it to mean that the Bill 'falls through'. Illustrating this, he said, 'Suppose a border state passes a Bill dealing with our external affairs, that we will permit a particular country's people to enter or not, then he cannot assent, he cannot refer it to President because it's not a repugnancy issue, and he cannot resend it to the House because if it is again passed, he cannot say no to it. So he will have to withhold.' He said the power 'has to be used rarely, sparingly, but that is the way the situation is'. The CJI then asked, 'If he doesn't exercise the option of resending the Bill for reconsideration, he can withhold it for time immemorial?' 'It dies,' Mehta said, reiterating that 'it (the power) is to be used rarely but power is conferred.' He said, 'The very language in which Article 200 is couched, it gives him options.' He said 'neither textually nor contextually, it is possible to conclude that the term withhold will have to be read as a temporary suspension of powers of granting assent till first proviso works out. There is no concept of temporary withholding of any Bill. If the framers of the Constitution wanted to link the term withhold in the main part of Article 200 to read only in the context of first proviso, two things would have been provided: (a) term withhold in the main part would have been qualified with the term subject to first proviso mentioned therein, (b) the first proviso would have mentioned that the Bill so withheld shall be reconsidered by the House, which is not there.' Justice Narasimha said the options must remain open-ended so that the political process has the chance to resolve the deadlock over a Bill. 'The way the political process occurs is not adjudicatory. Even assuming the Governor says I withhold, the political process can knock his doors and he can still open it and say, I will send it back to you, you consider and send it back. But to say… the first time he says, I withhold, the matter comes to an end… It can't be like that. It is counterproductive to the power of the Governor and counterproductive to the legislative process also. It has to be in a situation where it is open-ended,' he said. He was quick to add that the court understood that the Solicitor General was referring to Bills on subjects in the Union List. On the debate over the discretionary powers of the Governor, Justice Narasimha said, 'At that time we did not have impact assessment of a statute … Now, you see the amount of litigation it has thrown up by having provisions of this nature. Perhaps that could tell us whether the vision was right or not. Because the validity or correctness of a thought will come from its performance.' Mehta said he was 'not arguing that the Governor has unlimited discretion'. CJI Gavai said, 'We have some experience as to how some honourable Governors have exercised their discretion leading to so many litigations, but we are not going by that.' Mehta said, 'Indian democracy is a matured democracy. There may be aberrations on an individual level. But by and large, the democracy under this very Constitution has worked very effectively. And I personally experienced it during Covid times, how the Centre-state federal balance envisaged was on display. So it would be really hazardous to assess on the basis of some aberrations.'


Time of India
27 minutes ago
- Time of India
Bombay High Court dismisses election petition against BJP legislator Tamil Selvan
Mumbai: Observing that the petition comprised vague and generic pleadings, the Bombay High Court on Tuesday dismissed an election petition filed against the victory of Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) legislator Captain R Tamil Selvan. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now He won from the Sion-Koliwada constituency in the 2024 Maharashtra Assembly elections. Selvan petitioned the HC for the dismissal of the petition filed by Ganesh Kumar Yadav, the Indian National Congress (INC) candidate who emerged with the second-highest votes. Yadav earlier this year filed the election petition and, through his counsel Premlal Krishnan, challenged Selvan's election on grounds of non-compliance with certain rules and provisions, including those governing valid nominations under Section 33 of the Representation of People (RP) Act. Justice Milind Jadhav, who pronounced the judgment on Tuesday, said, "It is, however, prima facie seen that the Election Petition comprises vague and generic pleadings and there is a complete absence of material facts." Krishnan argued that averments in the petition were enough to lay the foundation for the challenge. Justice Jadhav noted that Krishnan "fairly argued that though what Petitioner will prove in evidence is not specifically in so many words stated in the Election Petition … Petitioner should be allowed to prove the same in trial. " Justice Jadhav, after hearing senior counsel Veerendra Tulzapurkar, who represented Selvan, said he did not subscribe to Krishnan's submission. The allegations, including "non-disclosure" of an arbitration award in favour of the Railways, were of "vague violations" by Selvan with no specific details whatsoever, the HC said, adding, "Alleged omissions do not amount to non-compliance with provisions of Section 33 or Rule 4A so as to constitute a defect of substantial character under Section 36(4) of the RP Act." Tired of too many ads? go ad free now The HC said, "It is seen that on scrutiny, the Returning Officer has not found any ambiguity or mistake, much less, non-disclosure or falsehood which can be deemed as suppression. It is in this context that when the Election Petitioner approaches the Court, he has to make a concise material statement of facts with all details in the Petition itself at the threshold. The Petitioner cannot improve his case in further pleadings, which is the attempt of Petitioner before me. " Once Selvan's nomination was held to be valid, it is deemed accepted and can only be rejected at the time of scrutiny. When the Returning Officer on scrutiny endorses each nomination, the nomination is considered valid, the HC held. The HC agreed with Tulzapurkar's submissions seeking dismissal of the EP as it does not contain a concise statement of material facts as mandated under Section 83(1)(a) of the RP Act.


Hindustan Times
43 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
Himachal assembly monsoon session: Pandemonium in House over job data during question hour
Employment concerns dominated the question hour of the Day 3 of Himachal Pradesh monsoon assembly session with Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) raising slogans and verbal duels between the ruling party and the Opposition. Himachal Pradesh CM Sukhvinder Singh Sukhu during the monsoon session in Shimla on Wednesday. (Deepak Sansta/HT) Dissatisfied with the reply given by the chief minister (CM), the BJP legislators left the house accusing the CM of not providing correct information on the number of jobs given by his government. Meanwhile, chief minister Sukhvinder Singh Sukhu called the BJP 'confused' and engaging in 'political drama'. The protest was triggered after what the BJP alleged, was the state government's failure, to give clear answers on job creation and appointments. BJP MLAs Vipin Singh Parmar and Satpal Satti had raised a question regarding the number of posts created and jobs provided in the state. Even as BJP accused the state government of failing to fulfil the promise of jobs to the youth, CM said that so far 23,191 youth have been given jobs in the government sector. He said that in the last two years, 5,960 new government posts have been created, while 1,783 unnecessary posts have been abolished. After the proceedings of the House, Sukhu, while talking to the media, said, 'Instead of asking questions, the BJP MLAs were engaged in creating ruckus. When the leader of Opposition Jai Ram Thakur stands up to speak the rest of the MLAs also start raising their hands. The BJP is divided into five factions and is not ready to listen to each other.' He said, 'During the previous BJP government, jobs were sold and papers were leaked. As soon as the Congress came to power, it dissolved the Coordinate Selection Board and formed a new board. Now appointments are being made in a transparent manner.' Lashing out at BJP, Sukhu said that the BJP is only trying to mislead the youth by spreading lies and confusion, while our government is engaged in providing real employment. 'The leadership of the former CM is in danger, which is why the BJP is repeatedly taking the path of walkout. Only scams happened during his tenure, while Congress is working to provide employment to the youth,' Sukhu said. Meanwhile, speaking to reporters outside the assembly, Jai Ram said, 'Today, during question hour, our members asked a very important question regarding employment but the CM did not give any clear answer and he was lying in the house, so we walked out.' Thakur alleged that the Congress government had failed to deliver on its pre-poll promises. 'They had guaranteed 5 lakh jobs in five years with 1 lakh jobs in the first year in permanent government positions with pensions. But instead of giving figures, the CM was arguing. The reality is that on July 31, 2024, the assembly was told that 34,980 jobs had been provided. On August 15, 2025, the CM said 23,195 jobs. There is a difference of around 11,000 jobs,' he said. 'Nearly three years have passed under the Congress government, but not a single unemployed youth got a job. They are even counting Himachalis who have gone abroad at their own expense and found employment there as jobs created in the state,' he alleged. Job trainee is just a change in name: Chief minister In response to BJP MLA Satpal Singh Satti's supplementary question regarding replacing the contract recruitment scheme with job trainee recruitment scheme, the CM clarified that contract jobs have been renamed as job trainee, which has been done under the orders of the court. 'The recruitment will be done through the selection commission. The change in nomenclature was done in wake of high court orders', he said. Jai Ram criticised the government's move to appoint recruits on a job-training basis for two years without regularisation, subject to a qualifying test later. 'This is a crude joke with the youth. Nurses are being hired through outsourcing agencies, and these agencies are linked to Congress leaders and their relatives. Money is being taken first, and then jobs are given,' Jai Ram alleged. Box: Sexual exploitation, forceful marriage of orphan girl from Pangi rocks house, CM assures action Sexual exploitation and forceful marriage of an orphan girl from Chamba's Pangi Chamba rocked the House, after which CM Sukhu informed that a suspect has been arrested and FIR has been registered. Responding to the issue raised by Bharmour MLA Janak Raj, under Rule 62, the CM assured that strict action would be taken in the matter. Janak Raj pointed out that a minor orphan girl was sexually exploited, after which she got pregnant. 'After the girl gave birth, she was sent to Jammu, where she was married to someone,' said Janak Raj. He also slammed the authorities for inaction saying that officials concerned did not take the required action in the matter. 'I urge the CM to take strict action against the officials who tried to cover up the matter,' he said. CM Sukhu said, 'Based on her statement, an FIR was registered on August 18 under Sections 65(1) of the BNS, Sections 4 and 17 of the POCSO Act, and Sections 9 and 11 of the Prohibition of Child Marriage Act, 2006. The minor delivered a child earlier this year, leading to the arrest of the main accused. The newborn's DNA profiling has been initiated for paternity confirmation.' Meanwhile, CM also said that the matter related to the sexual assault with a minor is very sensitive and assured action against officials found negligent. Inoperative bank account of the govt to be made operational: Sukhu Cash strapped Himachal to make inoperative bank account operative once again. While replying to the question raised by Congress MLA from Shahpur in Kangra, Kewal Singh Pathania over the FDR of the government in different banks, CM Sukhu told the House that the inoperative bank account would be made operational. Leader of Opposition Jai Ram said that it is a matter of grave concern that government accounts are inoperative that too when the state's finances are not in pink of health. He asked the government to fix responsibility. India should not play with Pakistan in Asia Cup Congress MLA from Indora, Malender Rajan, said that India should not play with Pakistan in the Asia Cup. Raising the concern during the Zero Hour, Rajan said that India playing Pakistan was not appropriate in view of the strained relations with the country and would be an insult to our soldiers. He strongly condemned the move and urged that a proposal should be sent to the Centre and the Board of Control for Cricket in India through the Assembly Secretariat to withdraw the permission given to the team to play against Pakistan. The Asia Cup is being held in Dubai and Abu Dhabi from September 9 to 28. India is scheduled to play Pakistan on September 14. Speaker Kuldeep Singh Pathnia assured the concern will be forwarded. CM assures action in death of Hamirpur student in WB BJP MLA from Barsar, Inder Dutt Lakhanpal, raised the issue of the death of a Hamirpur youth in an engineering college in West Bengal under Rule 62 and sought the government's response on the death of 22-year-old Kapil Kumar of village Bhaged in Hamirpur. Kapil was pursuing a course at Seacom Marine College, Howrah, since April this year and died under mysterious circumstances on August 9. An FIR was registered at Sankrail police station, Howrah City, on the complaint of his uncle. Lakhanpal said the West Bengal police had registered it as a drowning case, but the family of the deceased suspect murder. CM Sukhu said, 'The victim's uncle also moved an application with Himachal Police. I instructed DGP Ashok Tewari to take appropriate action. The application for a fair and transparent probe has been forwarded to the police commissioner, Howrah, and correspondence has been made by the Himachal DGP with his West Bengal counterpart on August 19.' HP assembly council chamber marks 100 years The Himachal Pradesh Legislative Assembly's Council Chamber on Wednesday completed 100 years since its establishment. Speaker Kuldeep Singh Pathania described it as a 'living witness to the history of democracy', where decisions taken have given 'a new direction' to India's politics and society. Construction of the building began in 1920 and was completed on August 20,1925. At the time, the Government of India Act, 1919, had come into effect, under which the British Indian Government comprised 145 members – 104 elected and the rest nominated. The summer sessions of the legislative assembly were held in Shimla during that period. It was in this chamber that Vitthalbhai Patel was elected the first Indian President (then referred to as the 'President' of the Council) and where the proposal to grant women the right to vote was passed. Speaking on the occasion, Pathania said the chamber has been a silent spectator to many historic events from the British era to the present day. 'This building is not merely a structure of stone, but an integral part of India's democratic journey. Democratic values were established here which gave a new direction to society,' he said. 'From here, democratic values were established, giving society a new direction,' he remarked. Bhabi ji ko pension to laga di: BJP while reminds govt of poll promise Taking a jibe at the CM Sukhu, BJP MLA from Una, Satpal Singh Satti, while reminding Congress of its poll promise of giving ₹1,500 per month to women in the age group of 18-59 years, said, 'You have given pension to Bhabhi Ji (Referring to CM's wife and Dehra MLA Kamlesh Thakur) while other sisters are waiting.' In a quirky reply, CM said that 'pension nahin salary lagi hai wo bi aap logo ki wajah se (she is getting salary not pension, that too because of you (BJP).' In 2024 bye-elections Kamlesh Thakur, wife of CM Sukhu, won from Dehra assembly seat. Your claims are like Dream 11: BJP BJP took dig at Sukhu-led Himachal government for failing to provide employment despite promising the same in election manifesto. 'Your claims on employment are like illusion to the youth just like Dream 11'. The Dream 11 is an Indian fantasy sports platform that allows users to play daily fantasy sports contests, primarily in cricket.