EXCLUSIVE Neighbours' fury as penny-pinching council rules homeowner's illegally built 'monstrosity' dormer is allowed to stay
Furious locals have complained the large development on the property's roof is out of keeping with the rest of the area and overlooks their homes, invading their privacy.
They also believe the decision will spark a 'planning free-for-all' with homeowners able to build what they want now and ask for permission later.
The row centres on a box dormer - a type of roof extension - at the back of the family home on Upham Road in Swindon, Wiltshire, that was built without permission.
In August 2019, homeowner Harjinder Saran was given the go-ahead for the construction of front, side and rear extensions and an outbuilding in the garden.
Those buildings went up in 2020 but so did the large box dormer extension, sparking immediate concern from neighbours.
One local, who can see the development from her garden and kitchen window, told MailOnline: 'I never expected it to go up so high.
'I thought it was enough when they built the shed in the garden. I don't understand why people think they can just do what they want.'
Another resident in a nearby property said he alerted Swindon Borough Council to the 'unauthorised development' while it was still being built five years ago.
He said, however, it took the local authority at least two years to issue an enforcement notice and problems then arose surrounding the 'legality' of it.
The enforcement notice told the homeowner Mrs Saran that the box dormer extension had not been built in accordance with the 2019 planning application.
It read: 'Remove the box dormer from the rear elevation of the dwelling.
'Remove all resultant material from the land following compliance and ensure the development is built in accordance with the approved plans.'
The homeowner, however, subsequently appealed the enforcement notice - with the council saying it had been withdrawn earlier this month.
A spokesperson for Swindon Borough Council told MailOnline that despite them being 'confident' there had been a 'breach of planning control', it was 'not in the council's best interests to continue with a lengthy and costly appeals process'.
Local Iain Melrose, 77, told MailOnline: 'Over four years ago Swindon Borough Council were made aware that this huge box dormer was being built without planning permission.
Furious locals have complained the large development on the property's roof is out of keeping with the rest of the area and overlooks their homes, invading their privacy
'Due to severe staff shortages and frankly total incompetence, it took two years to issue a breach of condition enforcement notice.
'Due to more incompetence between enforcement and legal there was an issue with the legality of the enforcement notice.
'My concern is that this monstrosity sets a precedent. I want to ensure that this doesn't happen to other people in future.'
Mr Melrose added that he thought the decision to remove the enforcement notice was less about money and more about the 'incompetence of the council'.
He claimed that the council knew they would lose the planning appeal as more than four years had passed since the box dormer extension went up.
Other residents in the area said they had concerns that the rear roof extension was 'invading their privacy'.
One neighbour, who did not want to be named, said: 'Our main concern is privacy. It is really high. It is too much.
'They can see right into our property'
Others, however, said they were not concerned by the development.
One who wished to remain anonymous said: 'It has never bothered us. It has not been a problem.
'We never objected in the first place. We got a letter saying it was being removed in April then we got another one saying it was now fine.
'I can understand why people might be angry. It does stand out quite a lot.'
Mrs Saran previously defended the decision to build the box dormer.
She told the Swindon Advertiser last year: 'We're not planning to take the box dormer down. We've written to the council but we haven't heard anything back.'
Mrs Saran added: 'If you look around Swindon there are box dormers all over the place, because it's too expensive to move.
'This meets all the building regulations and is safe.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
Country diary: The sense of emptiness in these driven-grouse moors stirs a deep melancholy
It's one of my midsummer rituals, if the forecast is right, to climb on to the moorland tops and await sunset. I build in several secondary goals: check if there are lapwings still on eggs in the sheep pasture below the summit (just two); see if there are curlew pairs breeding in the heather (only three). These exercises add to a personal dataset that is 50 years old. While I can confirm that, in all that time, snipes, curlews, lapwings and golden plovers have bred annually, both redshanks and dunlins have long gone and the other quartet is much diminished. As a result, Combs Moss is steeped in melancholy for me. It's not just the loss of breeding waders, but the sense of remarkable emptiness on these driven-grouse places. You stand there in the falling light, gazing across thousands of acres, Manchester twinkling as a child's toytown on the far horizon, and there can be no sign of any wild vertebrate life for minutes on end. Except your own troubled heartbeat. I love this place tenderly. I also lament its deeply arrested condition and, as I settle in for the sunset hour, I ponder how we can terminate legally these bird-killing rituals and create something richer. But my business isn't politics. There are few places more beautiful in our area than Derbyshire's cotton fields at dusk. In this moment, it's the common cotton-grass whose white-flossed heads, unfolding across the rolling moor, actually invoke some landscape in deepest Alabama. In Shetland and Orkney, in fact, people once had the patience and skill to pick, spin and knit this sedge floss into garments. There is a pair of christening socks in the Orkney Museum that is made from what they called 'Lucky Minnie's Oo', oo meaning wool in Shetlandic. Tonight, it flows as salt-white foam settled on a full tide, or even like the crusted snow blanketing this same place during most winters. I love it most where the dusk-tinted hanks of the bog-cotton mingle with the minute, hard, rose-tinged seedheads of the bent grasses. Together they create this enormous glittering sheet whose matrix colour, at last light, is the soft sepia of deep nostalgia. Under the Changing Skies: The Best of the Guardian's Country Diary, 2018-2024 is published by Guardian Faber; order at and get a 15% discount
The Sun
an hour ago
- The Sun
Garden pro's £3 B&Q plant blooms now to the end of summer & self seeds for free flowers next year – the bees love it
GARDENING and creating outside spaces with wildlife in mind is now essential going forward. And Rebecca Bevan, who works for the National Trust - has just written a book called Nature Friendly Gardening. 3 3 3 She said: 'Even the smallest outside space contribute to a mosaic created by the gardens across the neighbourhood. "Your garden could be providing the overwintering spot for the newts that breed in your neighbours pond in Spring, while their tree is the nesting spot for the blue tits which clean your roses of aphids. 'Even if all you have is a patchy lawn, you may well be hosting a healthy population of soil-dwelling grubs, which in turn might be helping to support blackbirds or starlings. 'If it's lumpy with anthills, so much the better - ants make up the majority of the diet of the beautiful green woodpecker, which is resident in Britain all year round.' Her seven top tips for nature gardening are: PLANT A FLOWERING SHRUB OR TREE Even the tiniest tree will have more flowers on it than a whole border of small plants. It uses the empty vertical space in a garden and hopefully provides places for birds to perch or even nest. PLANT LESS POTS AND HANGING BASKETS Put more perennial plants directly into the ground. Plants growing in soil need no extra water, feed, pots or potting compost and will last for years. Rebecca's favourite Perennials include... Foxgloves (Digitalis purpurea) – A native plant that grows well in gardens and seeds itself around. Popular with bumblebees. B&Q is currently selling Mr Fothergill's Oh Sow Simple Foxy Mix Foxglove flower seeds. Marjoram – (Origanum vulgare) Loved by pollinating insects, tolerant of sun or shade and almost any soil and useful in salads and cooking. Lungwort – (Pulmonaria officinalis) Great in shade with attractive spotty foliage for many months and flowers in early spring which are great for bees. Sedum (Hylotelephium spectabile) Very structural plant which flowers in late summer and has seed heads that last through winter. Sea holly (Eryngium) Great for a dry, sunny spot, these lovely spiky flowers attract many insects and their long-lasting seedheads are popular with birds. CHOOSE A FEW NATIVE WILDFLOWERS Hedgerow plants like cow parsley and red campion look great in gardens where you can admire them up close and they will attract native creatures. Kate steps out for 1st time since pulling out of Ascot to meet NHS staff & plants 'Catherine's Rose' in hospital garden DITCH THE WEEDKILLERS Especially on your lawn. Every weed is a wildflower which can help boost biodiversity. Clover and daisies in lawns can also keep them greener in dry weather. Less lovely weeds can be easily removed with a handfork or patio weeder for between paving slabs. MOW YOUR LAWN LESS OFTEN Once every 3 weeks will allow the grass to get lusher and some wildflowers to bloom. STOP TAKING WASTE TO THE TIP Stop taking your garden waste to the tip. Make a compost heap to recycle the nutrients and feed your soil or just make a pile for creatures to live in. LOOK AFTER YOUR SOIL It's a complex system of micro-organisms which recycle nutrients, help keep in air and water and feed plant roots. Too much digging or trampling can hurt it so keep it covered with perennial plants and stick to the paths. Also in Veronica's Column this week... Gardening news, top tips and win a Hydria Cascade water fountain NEWS! I was honoured to be a judge on the Robert Dyas Nominate Your Community Space competition - and the winner has been revealed. Volunteers from Day Drive Community Garden in Failsworth, Manchester plan to transform an unused garage site – to provide healthy food for those without easy access to it, offer workshops to empower individuals with new skills, and create a calming social hub in an otherwise urban environment. The retailer's nationwide competition encouraged people to nominate a green community space in their local area, which had the potential to be transformed for the mental and physical health of their community. The prize was £2.5k worth of gardening equipment and was part of Robert Dyas' ongoing Plant & Pause campaign, now in its third year, which encourages the nation to garden their way to better mental health. NEWS! A new YouGov survey, commissioned by Stiga - has shown that more and more people across the UK are embracing gardening - recognising that it's a fulfilling hobby that nurtures both nature and wellbeing. The survey found that 52 per cent of female respondents enjoy interacting with wildlife such as birds and butterflies, compared to 39 per cent of men. Whilst 29 per cent of men enjoy mowing the lawn versus 17 per cent of women. And although all ages enjoy gardening - it's the over 55s who claim to get the most out of it. WIN! Two Sun Gardening readers can get their hands on a stunning Hydria Cascade water fountain. To enter visit or write to Cascade Competition, PO Box 3190, Colchester, Essex, CO2 8GP. Include your name, age, email or phone. UK residents 18+ only. Entries close 11.59pm. July 19, 2025. T&Cs apply JOB OF THE WEEK It's all about deadheading this week - to ensure future on tying in climbing plants. Train cucumber plants upwards and pick courgettes before they get too big and turn into marrows. For more gardening tips and news follow me @biros_and_bloom
Daily Mail
5 hours ago
- Daily Mail
EXCLUSIVE When Queen heard it was Harry on the phone there was stony silence: Peerless Royal expert RICHARD KAY sensationally tells for first time exactly how Prince and Meghan 'blew' relationship with his grandmother
Just the other day, a former Buckingham Palace switchboard operator was reminiscing about working for the late Queen Elizabeth. One afternoon, a call had come through from Prince Harry in the US and he wanted to speak to his grandmother. The procedure was to ring the Queen's private number and let her know who was on the line. 'She would always thank you and then you would connect the call and leave them to their conversation,' the operator recalled.
