White crosses in Trump video: ‘Not mass grave' explains KZN farmer who took footage
White crosses in Trump video: 'Not mass grave' explains KZN farmer who took footage
The farming community in KwaZulu-Natal has pushed back against claims that video footage of white crosses — shown during a high-profile meeting between U.S. President Donald Trump and South African President Cyril Ramaphosa — depicted mass graves of murdered Afrikaners.
The Witness reports that farmers have clarified that the images were from a symbolic memorial held in 2020 for victims of farm attacks.
During last week Wednesday's televised meeting at the White House, Trump confronted Ramaphosa with video footage which, he claimed, proved there was a genocide against Afrikaners in South Africa.
The footage showed long rows of white crosses, prompting controversy and international attention.
Farmer who took footage of crosses explains
Farmer Rob Hoatson, who filmed the original video, explained that the footage captured a large memorial event for Glen (63) and Vida Rafferty (60), who were murdered on their Normandien farm, near Newcastle, in 2020.
'I have been personally affected by farm murders in the local community, including those of my neighbours, Glen and Vida Rafferty in 2020, and my close friend Tollie Nell in 2024.'
'But the truth is that all farming communities in South Africa have been profoundly affected by this problem.
'I am grateful that farm murders have risen to international prominence, and I sincerely hope that they receive the attention they deserve,' said Hoatson who clarified the facts around the video in an interview with the BBC.
Crosses laid before memorial of couple killed in farm attack
The Raffertys' deaths sparked widespread grief. The couple was well-known and liked by the community.
In 2022, Doctor Fikane Ngwenya and Sibongiseni Madondo were convicted and sentenced for the murder, while a co-accused, Siyabonga Macu, died before testifying.
'The aerial video showing thousands of people along a twenty-kilometre stretch was taken by me, a farmer in the area myself,' Hoatson said.
'The large spontaneous attendance at this community event bears testament to the scale and seriousness of the problem.'
DA ward 2 councillor Bebsie Cronje also recalled the community's response.
'The entire town attended and paid respects at the crosses which the community laid before their memorial service,' she said.
It was expected that white genocide issue would surface during White House visit
Dr Oscar van Heerden, an expert in diplomacy, suggested that Trump's decision to raise the white genocide issue during the meeting was inevitable.
'He simply had to bring a matter to a conclusion on the white genocide issue and why he brought the refugees to America,' said Van Heerden, referring to the recent granting of refugee status to 49 Afrikaners by the U.S. government.
The meeting has drawn mixed reactions, with some viewing Trump's confrontation as proof that tensions still exist between the two nations.
Police minister says more black than white victims in farm attacks
Meanwhile, South African authorities have rejected the genocide narrative.
Police Minister Senzo Mchunu, presenting the latest crime statistics, said six farm murders occurred in the first quarter of 2025, with only one involving a white farmer.
'The genocide conspiracy is totally unfounded and totally unsubstantiated,' said Mchunu, noting that black farmers and workers have historically been most victims.
Most murder victims in SA are 'poor, unemployed young black males'
Gareth Newham, head of the Justice and Violence Prevention Programme at the Institute for Security Studies, reiterated that farm violence in South Africa was not solely directed at white farmers.
'If there was any evidence of either a genocide or targeted violence taking place against any group based on their ethnicity, the ISS would be among the first to raise alarm and provide the evidence to the world,' said Newham.
He added that most murder victims in South Africa are poor, unemployed young black males.
'Murder victimisation is far more linked to class, gender and location rather than race,' he said.
Read original story on witness.co.za
At Caxton, we employ humans to generate daily fresh news, not AI intervention. Happy reading!
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
44 minutes ago
- The Citizen
DA Limpopo lays charges over GNT pension and medical fund scandal
POLOKWANE – DA provincial spokesperson for Economic Development, Environment and Tourism, Jacques Smalle presented himself at the Polokwane Police Station on Monday morning to lay a criminal complaint against the board and executive management of Great North Transport (GNT) for the non-payment of employee pension fund and medical aid contributions. According to Smalle, the board and executive management of the Limpopo Economic Development Agency (Leda) will also be enjoined in this complaint. You might also want to read: Plans underway to resolve GNT pension fund debacle 'As the sole shareholder of GNT, Leda bears statutory and fiduciary oversight responsibilities for GNT's operations and financial conduct. They too must be held accountable and face consequence management,' Smalle explained. According to Smalle, the shocking extent of this crisis was laid bare during an urgent meeting of Limpopo's Portfolio Committee on Economic Development, Environment and Tourism, convened last Friday evening, following the DA's sustained calls for GNT and Leda to appear before the committee to explain and account. It became apparent at the meeting that unpaid contributions to three pension schemes now total R6.78m, affecting 945 employees. In some cases, employee membership has already been suspended. If a partial payment of R1m is not made by the end of May, all employee memberships will be suspended. If the default continues, employees' risk permanently losing their pension benefits. Regarding medical aid contributions, total unpaid premiums amount to R3.21m, affecting 247 employees. You might also want to read: Unpaid provident fund sparks protest by Great North Transport employees All medical aid coverage for GNT employees has been suspended, meaning employees cannot access healthcare services unless they pay out of pocket. 'While undertakings were made at the portfolio committee, and while MEC Tshitereke Matibe indicated that he wished to address the crisis privately and in confidence to the committee, this never materialised. A subsequent statement issued by MEC Matibe, in which he apologised to GNT employees and set out certain actions including placing GNT under administration, was later withdrawn. It is within this context that our criminal complaint to SAPS will be lodged,' Smalle explained. 'We urgently need resolution to the plight facing GNT's employees, and we need to see real accountability and consequence management. If we don't clean out GNT, no turnaround will succeed,' Smalle reckoned. 'In our complaint to the police we call on law enforcement to investigate the conduct of GNT and Leda officials and their board members for theft, fraud, contraventions of the Pension Funds Act and contraventions of the Medical Schemes Act, all of which constitute criminal offences,' Smalle concluded. At Caxton, we employ humans to generate daily fresh news, not AI intervention. Happy reading!
The Citizen
an hour ago
- The Citizen
MK party wants full disclosure over R9.5bn battery storage projects
Electricity Minister Kgosientso Ramokgopa praised Mulilo Energy as a "great South African success story". The MK party says it wants full disclosure of bid adjudication records after a multi-billion energy tender was awarded to a company headed by former Eskom CEO Andre de Ruyter's right-hand man, Jan Oberholzer. On Friday, Electricity Minister Kgosientso Ramokgopa announced the appointment of five preferred bidders under the Battery Energy Storage Independent Power Producers Procurement Programme (BESIPPPP). De Ruyter's right-hand man Mulilo Energy, chaired by Oberholzer, the Chief Operating Officer of Eskom and Scatec, was awarded five large battery storage projects in the Free State to develop 616 MW / 2,464 MWh of new battery storage capacity for R9.5 billion. Oberholzer was appointed chairperson of Mulilo in September 2023, just two months after leaving Eskom as COO. Out of the five available projects, four were awarded to Mulilo Energy Mulio Energy was founded in 2008 by property developer Johnny Cullum and racing driver Chris Aberdein after a conversation about load shedding. Both remain on Mulilo's board. ALSO READ: Eskom denies reports of 14-hour load shedding next month MK party not happy Ramokgopa praised Mulilo at Friday's announcement as a 'great South African success story' that shows the country can stand tall globally. However, the MK party wants transparency in the bidding process MK party national spokesperson Nhlamulo Ndhlela said they have written to Ramokgopa demanding full disclosure of the bid adjudication records within seven days. 'The uMkhonto weSizwe party is blowing the lid off what appears to be one of the most blatant acts of javelin throwing in post-apartheid public procurement, this time under the green veil of 'renewable' energy. 'Should the Minister fail to comply, the MK party will immediately approach the courts to interdict and suspend these contracts,' Ndhlela said. 'Billions' Ndhlela said 'this is no longer about megawatts. 'This is about the billions being funnelled out of our country under the false flag of progress, and the MK Party will not stand by and watch our state-owned entities being handed over to corrupt white monopoly capital interests'. The Battery Energy Storage Programme is a critical initiative aimed at enhancing South Africa's power system by providing essential ancillary services and increasing grid capacity through energy storage. Projects Other awarded projects located in the Free State will include: Erfdeel BESS (123MW/ 492MWh) Retreat BESS (123MW/ 492MWh) Bloemhoek BESS (124MW/ 496MWh) Vanilla BESS (123MW/ 492MWh) The BESIPPPP Bid Window 3 was launched on 28 March 2024, with bids submitted on 28 November 2024. Ramokgopa said the evaluation process was conducted by an Independent Bid Evaluation Committee 'under strict security measures, took place at the IPP Office.' ALSO READ: Eskom winter outlook: Here's how many days of load shedding to expect in SA
IOL News
2 hours ago
- IOL News
Most South African farmers are black: why Trump got it so wrong
There are more black farmers in South Africa than white farmers,says the authors Image: Karen Sandison/ Independent Newspapers When world leaders engage, the assumption is always that they engage on issues based on verified facts, which their administrative staff are supposed to prepare. Under this assumption, we thought the meeting at the White House on 21 May between South Africa's president, Cyril Ramaphosa, and US president Donald Trump would follow this pattern. Disappointingly, the televised meeting was horrifying to watch as it was based on misrepresenting the reality of life in South Africa. Issues of agriculture, farming and land (and rural crime) were central to the discussions. What is clear to us as agricultural economists is that the skewed views expressed by Trump about these issues originate in South Africa. This includes Trump's statement: 'But Blacks are not farmers.' In our work as agricultural economists, we have, in many pieces and books (our latest titled The Uncomfortable Truth about South Africa's Agriculture), tried to present South Africans with the real facts about the political economy policy reforms and structural dimensions of South African agriculture. Writing on these matters was necessary given that official data – agricultural census 2017, as well as the official land audit of 2017 – all provide an incomplete picture of the real state and structure of South African agriculture. The reason is that the agricultural census, which is supposed to provide a comprehensive and inclusive assessment of the size and structure of the primary agricultural sector, and the land audit, which was supposed to record the ownership of all land in South Africa, are incomplete in their coverage. The incomplete and inaccurate official data provides fertile ground for radical statements by the left and the right – and novices on social media. This is why South Africa has to deal with falsehoods coming from the US. These include Trump's statement that black people are not farmers in South Africa. South Africa is to blame for providing inaccurate data to feed these false narratives. The facts presented here should allow a more nuanced interpretation of South Africa's farm structure. Firstly, there are more black farmers in South Africa than white farmers. And not all white commercial farm operations are 'large-scale', and not all black farmers are 'small-scale', 'subsistence' or 'emerging'. Most farm operations can be classified as micro, or small in scale. This is important so that one doesn't view South Africa's agriculture as mainly white farmers. Indeed, we are a country of two agricultures with black farmers mainly at small scale and accounting for roughly 10% of the commercial agricultural output. Still, this doesn't mean they are not active in the sector. They mainly still require support to expand and increase output, but they are active. The facts In the wake of the circus in the Oval Office, we were amazed by the total silence of the many farmers' organisations in South Africa. We have not seen one coming out to reject all of Trump's claims. The only thing we can deduce from this is that these falsehoods suit the political position of some farmer organisations. But at what cost? Will many of their members be harmed by trade sanctions or tariffs against South Africa? The US is an important market for South Africa's agriculture, accounting for 4% of the $13.7 billion (R247bn) exports in 2024. When Ramaphosa highlighted the fact that crime, and rural crime in particular, has an impact on all South Africans and that more black people than white people are being killed, Trump's response was disturbing, to say the least: 'But Blacks are not farmers'. This requires an immediate fact check. We returned to the text from our chapter in the Handbook on the South African Economy we jointly prepared in 2021. In the extract below, we discuss the real numbers of farmers in South Africa and try to provide a sensible racial classification of farmers to denounce Trump's silly statement. As highlighted earlier, the two latest agricultural censuses (2007 and 2017) are incomplete as they restricted the sample frame to farm businesses registered to pay value added tax. Only firms with a turnover of R1 million qualify for VAT registration. We were able to expand the findings from the censuses with numbers from the 2011 population census and the 2016 community survey to better understand the total number of commercial farming units in South Africa. The Community Survey 2016 is a large-scale survey that happened between Censuses 2011 and 2021. The main objective was to provide population and household statistics at municipal level to government and the private sector, to support planning and decision-making. Data from the 2011 population census (extracted from three agricultural questions included in the census) shows that 2 879 638 households out of South Africa's total population, or 19.9% of all households, were active in agriculture for subsistence or commercial purposes. Only 2% of these active households reported an annual income derived from agriculture above R307 000. This translates into 57 592 households that can be considered commercial farmers, with agriculture as the main or only source of household income. This corresponds in some way with the 40 122 farming businesses that are registered for VAT as noted in the 2017 agricultural census report. If we use the numbers from the agricultural census it is evident almost 90% of all VAT-registered commercial farming businesses could be classified as micro or small-scale enterprises. If the farm businesses excluded from the census are accounted for under the assumption that they are too small for VAT registration, then the fact still stands that the vast majority of all farm enterprises in South Africa are small family farms. Graphic Image: Source: StatsSA There are, however, 2 610 large farms (with turnover exceeding R22.5 million, which are responsible for 67% of farm income and employed more than half the agricultural labour force of 757 000 farm workers in 2017. Graphic Image: Source: StatsSA (2020b) – based on additional analysis of the 2016 Community Survey Another way to get to farm numbers is to use the 2016 Community Survey. Using the shares as shown in Table 2, we estimate there are 242 221 commercial farming households in South Africa, of which only 43 891 (18%) are white commercial farmers. (This is very much in line with the VAT registered farmers but also acknowledging the fact that many white farm businesses are not necessarily registered for VAT.) Let's consider only the agricultural households with agriculture as their main source of income, surveyed in the 2016 community survey. We end up with a total of 132 700 households, of whom 93 000 (70%) are black farmers. This reality is something that policy makers and farm organisations find very difficult to deal with and it seems that Trump also found this too good to be true. We have tried here in a long winded way to deal with farm numbers and how to get to a race classification of farmers in South Africa. In the end we trust that we have managed to show that there are more black farmers in South Africa than white farmers. Their share in total output is smaller than that of their white counterparts. The National Agricultural Marketing Council puts black farmers' share of agricultural production as roughly 10%. But these numbers are also incomplete and largely an undercount. It will always be challenging to get to the real number of black farmers' share of agricultural output as nobody would ever know whether the potato or the cabbage on the shelf came from a farm owned by a black farmer or a white person but operated by a black farmer, for example. As South Africans know, the labour on farms, in pack houses, distribution systems and retail are all black. So, the sweat and hard work of black South African workers are integral to the food supply chain in South Africa. Let's get these facts straight and promote them honestly. The Conversation Image: Supplied
