Council forced into second homes climbdown after ‘fiery' residents' revolt
North Ayrshire Council is reviewing the impact of the policy on the island of Great Cumbrae after residents complained it would harm their economy, which is reliant on tourism.
The SNP-led authority imposed a 100pc council tax premium on second home owners last month, sparking an opposition movement among its 1,400 residents.
The majority of Scottish authorities introduced similar charges after being given the power to do so in 2024.
More than 200 authorities in England also launched a second homes raid this year – something The Telegraph is campaigning against.
There are 450 second homes on Cumbrae, a small island situated one mile – or a 10-minute ferry – from the Scottish mainland. Its close proximity to the mainland makes it an attractive destination.
One in three properties on Cumbrae are a second home while around a quarter of residents work in tourism-related jobs.
An impact assessment found the council tax raid would strip £500,000 off the island's annual GDP of £12.9m.
Cameron Inglis, the Conservative leader on North Ayrshire Council, said the reaction from residents had been 'fiery'.
He told The Telegraph: 'We are asking second home owners to pay double, get nothing in return, so that we can balance our budget gap.
'The whole thing has been pushed through so that supposedly rich people can plug a budget gap. The whole thing is a sham. It's smoke and mirrors.'
Mr Inglis added that ringfencing 10pc of the additional revenue for affordable housing was the equivalent to £110,000, which would pay for the construction of approximately 20 houses a year, built using council money and government grants.
He said: 'That's not 20 houses for the island. That's 20 houses across the whole county. It's a drop in the water when it comes to the number of houses we need.'
Alex Harvie, chairman of the Cumbrae Community Council, said the premium would force second home owners to sell up, reduce income for the island and could 'start a spiral of decline' as facilities fall into disrepair.
In an appeal to North Ayrshire Council to re-examine the impact on the island, he accused the authority of rushing through the policy before the completion of a three-month review period to allow it to respond to the initial impact assessment.
The council's initial impact assessment found 'concerns' with the economic impact on Great Cumbrae and cast doubt as to whether it would benefit housing availability. It conceded the island 'may not lend itself or be suitable for permanent island living'.
A consultation, of which around 60pc of the respondents were not second home owners, also found widespread opposition to the policy. Only 38pc were in favour of the premium while 59pc were against.
North Ayrshire has now been forced to review its original impact assessment following the pressure applied by the community council.
A public consultation has been opened with the council accepting representations from residents, visitors and businesses until May 20.
A spokesman for North Ayrshire Council said: 'Like other councils across Scotland who have already adopted this measure, we hope to see real long-term benefits to the availability of housing for people in communities across North Ayrshire, and for homes to be occupied for longer periods of time throughout the year.'
Broaden your horizons with award-winning British journalism. Try The Telegraph free for 1 month with unlimited access to our award-winning website, exclusive app, money-saving offers and more.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Epoch Times
2 minutes ago
- Epoch Times
Mississippi to Send National Guard Troops to DC to Back Trump's Crackdown on Crime
Mississippi will send several hundred National Guard troops to Washington to assist President Donald Trump's effort to crack down on crime in the nation's capital, joining several other Republican-led states that have pledged military resources. In a statement posted on social media on Aug. 18, Mississippi Gov. Tate Reeves announced that he's approved the deployment of some 200 National Guard soldiers 'to support President Trump's effort to return law and order to our nation's capital.'
32 minutes ago
Hundreds more National Guard troops expected to arrive in DC
Hundreds more National Guard troops are expected to arrive in Washington, D.C., in the coming days, with at least four Republican-led states offering to send additional soldiers to join the 800 D.C. National Guard troops already activated by President Donald Trump, according to the states' governors. Troops from West Virginia have begun to arrive in the nation's capital, according to a Sunday evening update from the task force overseeing Guard personnel in D.C. The total numbers are expected to grow to more than 1,700 in coming days as more troops arrive from Mississippi, Ohio and South Carolina. During Monday's Oval Office meeting with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy about the Russian war in Ukraine, Trump pivoted to the topic of crime in D.C. The president insisted that he turned the city around in just a few days and claimed Democratic friends called him to personally thank him. The president did not offer evidence that crime incidents had fallen, with many of the troops ordered into the city remaining unarmed and located near tourist areas already heavily patrolled by law enforcement. Troops could be seen over the weekend positioned around the mostly quiet city, standing near armored Humvees and posing for pictures with tourists. In one instance, a member of the National Guard helped a U.S. Park Police officer who had been assaulted while directing traffic, according to the National Guard, which did not provide further details. Officials said Guard personnel are not arresting people, only helping to detain individuals briefly if necessary before handing them off to law enforcement. Under the law, troops are allowed to protect federal property and personnel. They also can defend themselves, but must leave law enforcement duties to the local police. Guard personnel deployed in Washington are currently unarmed, although officials say they expect that to change as more troops arrive. Mississippi on Monday became the latest Republican-led state to call up Guard troops and send them to D.C. Gov. Tate Reeves said he planned to send 200 Guard soldiers. "Crime is out of control there, and it's clear something must be done to combat it," Reeves said in a release. "Americans deserve a safe capital city that we can all be proud of. I know the brave men and women of our National Guard will do an excellent job enhancing public safety and supporting law enforcement." Ohio Gov. Mike DeWine said in a statement he's been asked to send 150 military police from the Ohio National Guard and that they should arrive in the coming days. South Carolina Gov. Henry McMaster said in a statement he's sending 200 Guard personnel. The Pentagon has not responded to a request for comment or said whether it's requested additional personnel from other states. Washington, D.C., saw 137 arrests over the weekend, Attorney General Pamela Bondi said in an X post on Monday morning. Aside from highlighting 21 illegal firearm seizures, Bondi didn't specify the kinds of crimes the arrests were related to, nor did she specify who made the arrests. FBI Director Kash Patel noted in a separate X post that FBI agents were involved in 29 arrests as of Sunday night, with charges including DUI, drug offenses, assault, destruction of property and others. Bondi is ultimately in charge of the military operation in D.C. as well as the takeover of local police as part of an extraordinary reach in federal power for a city that struggles with crime but is not in the throes of a crisis such as Jan. 6, 2021, riots or a large-scale event such as an inauguration. Washington, D.C. Mayor Muriel Bowser on Monday criticized the Trump administration's federal police surge in the nation's capital, calling it politically motivated and disconnected from crime in the city. "This doesn't make sense. The numbers on the ground and the district don't support 1,000 people from other states coming to Washington, D.C.," Bowser said. Violent crime levels have decreased compared to years prior, down 26% since 2024, a 30-year low, according to crime stats released by the city's Metropolitan Police Department. Sen. Chris Van Hollen, D-Md., on Sunday underlined his stance that Trump deploying the Guard to over concerns of high crime and the level of homelessness amounts to an "abuse of power." "It's a manufactured emergency," Van Hollen said in an interview with "This Week" co-anchor Martha Raddatz. "Obviously D.C. can do more to reduce violent crime, as we can across the country. But as you pointed out, crime in D.C. is at a 30-year low and a downward trajectory. So, this is all an opportunity for Donald Trump to play dictator in Washington, D.C."
Boston Globe
3 hours ago
- Boston Globe
Mississippi becomes fourth state to send National Guard troops to D.C. in expanding federal crackdown
Mississippi joins three other states that have pledged to deploy hundreds of National Guard members to the nation's capital to bolster the Republican administration's operation aiming to transform policing in the Democratic-led city through a federal crackdown on crime and homelessness. West Virginia said it was deploying 300 to 400 troops, South Carolina pledged 200 and Ohio said it will send 150 in the coming days, deployments that built on top of President Trump's initial order that 800 National Guard troops deploy as part of the federal intervention. Get Starting Point A guide through the most important stories of the morning, delivered Monday through Friday. Enter Email Sign Up Trump's executive order that launched the federal operation declared a 'crime emergency' in the District of Columbia and initiated a takeover Washington's police department. The administration has ordered local police to cooperate with federal agents on immigration enforcement, orders that would contradict local laws prohibiting such collaboration. Advertisement 'D.C. has been under siege from thugs and killers, but now, D.C. is back under Federal Control where it belongs,' Trump wrote on his social media website a day after issuing his order. 'The White House is in charge. The Military and our Great Police will liberate this City, scrape away the filth, and make it safe, clean, habitable and beautiful once more!' Advertisement During a Monday news conference, D.C. Mayor Muriel Bowser pushed back on Trump's characterization of the city and voiced skepticism about the administration's intentions in flooding the capital with troops and federal agents. 'We don't have any authority over the DC Guard or any other guards, but I think it makes the point that this is not about DC crime,' Bowser said of the administration and states deploying National Guard members onto the streets of the capital. 'The focus should be on violent crime,' Bowser continued. 'Nobody is against focusing on driving down any level of violence. And so if this is really about immigration enforcement the administration should make that plain.' National Guard members in the District of Columbia have been assisting law enforcement with tasks including crowd control and patrolling landmarks such as the National Mall and Union Station. Their role has been limited thus far, and it remains unclear why additional troops would be needed. Federal agents from the Drug Enforcement Administration, Immigration and Customs Enforcement, Federal Bureau of Investigation, Secret Service and other agencies have patrolled high traffic areas around the capital over the last week. ICE officers, who work under the Department of Homeland Security, have made arrests in neighborhoods across the city, dispersed some public gatherings and torn pro-immigrant signs, according to videos published by the administration. The White House has touted various arrests that local police and federal agents have made across the city since Trump's executive order. Federal agents have made 380 arrests in the week since the start of the operation and in some cases issued charges to detained people. The White House has touted the surge of agents on social media and posted pictures of people arrested by local and federal officers. Advertisement 'Washington, DC is getting safer every night thanks to our law enforcement partners,' Attorney General Pam Bondi wrote on social media. 'Just this weekend, 137 arrests were made and 21 illegal firearms were seized. In total, there have been nearly 400 arrests—and we are not slowing down.' Amid the crackdown, the administration has received criticism for the conduct of some federal agents, who in several high-profile incidents have arrested people while wearing masks that hide their identity and declined to identify themselves to media or members of the public when questioned. Bowser said Monday that she had asked D.C. Police Chief Pamela Smith to seek answers from the administration about the use of masked police. 'It's very important to us that agents be identified,' Bowser said. 'There's no reason for a law enforcement official to be masked.' Over the weekend in Washington, protesters pushed back on federal law enforcement and National Guard troops fanning out in the city. Scores of protesters gathered in the city's Dupont Circle on Saturday and marched to the White House. — Associated Press writer Jeff Amy in Atlanta contributed to this report.
