logo
I knew the welfare state was broken — I became an MP to fix It

I knew the welfare state was broken — I became an MP to fix It

The National03-07-2025
At one point in my life, I was classed as long term unemployed. My niece said I was the busiest unemployed person she'd ever met but I just could not get a paid job. So I had that "advantage" over other MPs in that I truly understood what it was like.
Therefore, I was deeply committed to supporting people in those situations and actively went out looking for them. It's important to note that I wasn't doing this on my own. In fact it couldn't have happened at all without the incredible team I had around me.
Everyone in that team played a part in this and, satisfyingly, one of my former caseworkers, Robyn, is now a welfare rights professional.
READ MORE: I've been an MP for 42 years. I've seen Westminster take apart the welfare state
Most of the work we did was with individuals experiencing terrible treatment at the hands of the DWP. Now, I have family and friends who work for the DWP and they care passionately but the system itself can be cruel and yes, like in any workplace, so can a minority of the workers.
Why else, for example, would anyone take the decision to sanction the benefits of a young couple for the first 6 weeks of their newborn's life because the dad went in the ambulance with mum, stayed with her for the birth and completely forgot to sign on?
The system is cruel enough to allow that to happen but the majority of DWP workers would use their discretion. This one chose to remove their income and even their milk tokens. So that's the kind of thing we were dealing with.
And we were VERY good at it.
We made full use of the MP hotline to the DWP which partially bypasses the hoops anyone else has to go through.
But I was always conscious that for every one person who asked me for help, there were many more who suffered in silence.
So we had a three pronged approach:
Advertise the fact that we COULD help as widely as possible
Fight for the people who responded
Fight for policy change so that we could also help all those who didn't reach out
On certain issues we ran full on campaigns.
Pension Credit was one of those. This goes to pensioners on the lowest incomes but you've got to apply. And all organisations advocating for older people eg Age Concern Scotland and Age Scotland will tell you the myriad reasons why so many people don't apply. At one point £7.7million was going unclaimed every year in the constituency of Glasgow NE alone.
So we wrote to thousands of older people in the constituency telling them how to apply.
READ MORE: I claimed Universal Credit – this is what it was like
The letter addressed many of the reservations they might have and for those who thought it was a complicated process we told them to book a slot in the office and we'd do it for them.
The phone rang off the hook and for three full days my office was like a factory with four of my team spending the day sitting with people at 15 minute intervals and doing their applications for them.
Meantime, I set up an All Party Parliamentary Group on Pension Credit and held a debate in Westminster to campaign for the government to put more effort into increasing the number of people who claimed their entitlement.
The following year we found that the constituency had one of the highest take up rates rather than one of the lowest. We can't claim all the credit but it does show that you can make a real difference.
And that leads me onto an important lesson that 3 older working class women in Springburn taught me. I'd been speaking in Mhairi Black's debate on Benefit Sanctions. It was emotional and exhausting.
READ MORE: What it's actually like to apply for DWP disability benefits
I remember coming out of it thinking "what's the point?".
I was banging my head against a brick wall because nothing changed. I felt useless if I'm honest.
Two days later I was at a Christmas fayre when these three women called me over.
They had got together to watch it and loved it apparently, particularly every time a Tory MP intervened on me to demonstrate their complete lack of understanding. I was a bit taken aback and explained how I'd felt I'd wasted my time.
But they taught me that whilst effecting change is the crucial thing, almost as important to them was seeing someone who "gets it" standing up, telling their stories and refusing to back down.
I want to thank those three women in Springburn because I never forgot that and I never again felt what I was saying was pointless.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Nearly £1 in every £10 of Universal Credit was wrongly paid last year with an eye-watering £5.2bn lost to fraud as Labour faces demands to get a grip
Nearly £1 in every £10 of Universal Credit was wrongly paid last year with an eye-watering £5.2bn lost to fraud as Labour faces demands to get a grip

Daily Mail​

timea day ago

  • Daily Mail​

Nearly £1 in every £10 of Universal Credit was wrongly paid last year with an eye-watering £5.2bn lost to fraud as Labour faces demands to get a grip

Nearly £1 in every £10 spent on Universal Credit last year was wrongly paid, official figures have revealed. The Department of Work and Pensions admitted £6.35billion was overpaid in Universal Credit in 2024-25. This was almost 10 per cent of the £65.3billion of total expenditure on Universal Credit in the last financial year. The amount that was wrongly paid in Universal Credit included an eye-watering £5.2billion in overpayments due to fraud. The main cause of fraud overpayments was an under-declaration of income by claimants of Universal Credit, which is paid to those on low incomes or who are out of work. The second largest source of fraud was claimants failing to declare living with a partner, while the third largest fraud reason was an under-declaration of financial assets. The Labour Government is being urged to 'crack down ruthlessly' on those who defraud taxpayers, with the level of fraud and error in the benefits system branded 'a national scandal'. The Department of Work and Pensions admitted £6.35billion was overpaid in Universal Credit in 2024-25. This was almost 10 per cent of the £65.3billion of total expenditure Shimeon Lee, policy analyst of the TaxPayers' Alliance, said: 'The level of fraud and error in the benefits system, particularly Universal Credit, is a national scandal, yet time and again DWP fails to address it. 'The benefits bill would be soaring out of control even if every penny went to the right recipient. 'It is more vital than ever that the Government is cracking down ruthlessly on those that defraud taxpayers while ensuring internal processes are rigorous enough to minimise mistaken payments.' Sir Keir Starmer recently saw his attempt to cut Britain's ballooning benefits bill derailed by a major rebellion among Labour MPs. The Prime Minister was forced to scrap most of his planned welfare changes in the face of a huge Labour revolt. He ditched Labour's proposed restrictions to Personal Independence Payment (PIP), which is the main disability payment in England, until after a review. A humilated Sir Keir was instead left to push through slimmed-down legislation in the House of Commons, now only referred to as the Universal Credit Bill. As part of the Bill, the basic Universal Credit standard allowance will rise at least in line with inflation until 2029-30. But the health part of the benefit will be reduced for new claimants after April 2026, unless they had a severe or terminal condition, and the rate will be frozen until 2030. The Covid pandemic saw a huge increase in fraud and error in benefit payments, as the then Tory government scrambled to protect Britons' incomes as they shut down large parts of the UK economy during lockdown. The latest statistics published by the Department for Work and Pensions showed a total of £9.5billion was overpaid in benefits in 2024-25, at a rate of 3.3 per cent. This compared with £9.7billion and 3.6 per cent in 2023-24. Meanwhile, £1.2billion was underpaid in benefits in 2024-25 at a rate of 0.4 per cent, which was unchanged from 2023-24. In 2024-25, the Universal Credit overpayment rate decreased to 9.7 per cent (£6.35billion) from 12.4 per cent (£6.41billion) in 2023-24. Overpayments due to fraud decreased to 8 per cent (£5.2billion) in 2024-25, from 10.8 per cent (£5.62billion) in 2023-24. The Department for Work and Pensions said these decreasse were 'statistically significant'. Fraud due to under-declaration of income was measured at 2.2 per cent in 2024-5, compared with 2.6 per cent in 2023-24. Fraud due to claimants failing to declare living with a partner was measured at 1.7 per cent in 2024-5, compared with 1.5 per cent in 2023-24. And fraud due to under-declaration of financial assets was measured at 1.3 per cent in 2024-5, compared with 1.9 per cent in 2023-24. Some £610million (0.9 per cent) of Universal Credit was wrongly paid in 2024-25 due to claimant error, compared with £410million (0.8 per cent) in 2023-24. And £540million (0.8 per cent) of Universal Credit was wrongly paid in 2024-25 due to official error, compared with £390million (0.7 per cent) in 2023-24. The proportion of claims overpaid was 21 in 100 claims in 2024-25, compared with 23 in 100 claims in 2023-24. The proportion of claims underpaid increased to 2 in 100 claims in 2024-25, from 1 in 100 claims in 2023-24.

Shropshire army veteran to fight 'inhumane' review after losing Motability
Shropshire army veteran to fight 'inhumane' review after losing Motability

BBC News

timea day ago

  • BBC News

Shropshire army veteran to fight 'inhumane' review after losing Motability

A 56-year-old army veteran has said he will "fight" to keep his Motability car after a review concluded that he no longer qualifies for Motability scheme allows people with a personal independence payment, or Pip, to lease a Tolhurst, who lives in Bicton Heath, who has received his mobility payment for six years, claims that a recent reassessment was not done properly and said his treatment has been "inhumane."A spokesperson for the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) said they are "changing the welfare system so it helps people to live with dignity." Dean Tolhurst served in the army in the 1980s as a driver in the Royal Corps of has had a Motability car for six years, after breaking his back, having three strokes, two hernias, knee reconstructions, and a diagnosis of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD).Mr Tolhurst said he is unable to afford his own vehicle, and so relied on his mobility payments. "I can't used public transport because of my PTSD," he said, adding that he only allows trusted friends to drive him to doctors' appointments and the supermarket. "They've given me one week's notice [before] I lose the vehicle," he said, adding that it has left him "four miles from my nearest cheap supermarket.""They're isolating me - they're taking me away from my daily needs."Mr Tolhurst has been awarded the standard rate for mobility, but to be eligible for the Motability scheme, claimants need to receive the enhanced rate. Pip is paid to 3.7 million people with a long-term physical or mental health condition in England and includes a daily living component and a mobility component, and claimants may be eligible for one or March, the government announced plans to tighten daily living assessments for both current and future after more than 120 Labour MPs threatened to vote against the change, it confirmed that those already receiving Pip would not be affected. To receive Pip, people are asked questions about everyday tasks, with each scored from zero, for no difficulty, to 12, for most Tolhurst said his most recent reassessment by Capita, who carry out Pip assessments on behalf of the DWP in the Midlands and Wales, did not properly take his mobility issues into resulted in him not receiving an extra mobility payment that would allow him to lease a Motability car. The review was carried out via video call, which the grandfather believes is not appropriate."The video call got to 59 minutes and they said they weren't going to do the mobility part of the exam because they ran out of time," he Tolhurst said that he later found out he "failed" the review because he didn't score highly enough in the mobility section."I don't understand how they can fail me for something they didn't do," he said. The 56-year-old grandfather said he is now "doubling" his doses of prescription painkillers - against his doctor's advice - in order to live his life as normal. "Not all disabilities are physical or visible - the government needs to learn that you can't judge a book by its cover," he said."Not everything that is wrong than me you can see, but what you can see is a person that will not give up."I will not stop fighting." In a statement, a spokesperson for the Department for Work and Pensions said they are "changing the welfare system so it helps people to live with dignity."They added that they "have also announced a ministerial review of the PIP assessment process – which puts disabled people at its heart - to make sure it is fit and fair for the future."Capita said they do not comment on individual cases, and confirmed that the company does not make the decision to award Pip payments. Follow BBC Shropshire on BBC Sounds, Facebook, X and Instagram.

Blackwood councillors 'excluded' from meeting with minister
Blackwood councillors 'excluded' from meeting with minister

South Wales Argus

timea day ago

  • South Wales Argus

Blackwood councillors 'excluded' from meeting with minister

I have asked Ruth Jones, MP for Newport West and Islwyn, if she would be kind enough to contact the minister, as I wrote on June 14 and received no response. If an invite had been received, these could have been asked verbally. The questions are: 1 - I certainly welcome the fact to fund local government to deliver the Connect to Work, and I would be most grateful for a little more information about funding, partnership working with DWP, Housing, Communities and councils to make this a success. 2 - I assume there will be joint action plans between local and central government, so the best can be achieved for all residents. 3 - How will other departments feed into this process, please like Education and Health to ensure we are all joined up? 4 - Do you envisage there will be a different formula used for urban and rural communities, and how will the Senedd be involved, please? 5 - I have long been a supporter of Youth Hubs as a previous peer mentor trying to get clients back to work in South Powys. We involved the voluntary organisations in confidence building and positive outcomes and objectives which many clients appreciated. 6 - The European Social Fund was a lifeline then for many. 7 - Will a plan be developed with private sector organisations and employer engagement plans please? 8 - You will be aware of the Senedd Elections next year, so will these plans be in place prior so we can move forward together, and how will councils be involved please, as we are at the forefront of our communities, and will the scheme differ from England please? Always a pleasure to work in partnership Cllr Kevin Etheridge.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store