'Artificial intelligence is not a miracle cure': Nobel laureate raises questions about AI-generated image of black hole spinning at the heart of our galaxy
The monster black hole at the center of our galaxy is spinning at near "top speed," according to a new artificial intelligence (AI) model. The model, trained partially on complex telescope data that was previously considered too noisy to be useful, aims to create the most detailed black hole images ever. However, based on the questionable quality of the data, not all experts are convinced that the AI model is accurate.
"I'm very sympathetic and interested in what they're doing," Reinhard Genzel, an astrophysicist at the Max Planck Institute for Extraterrestrial Physics in Germany and one of the winners of the 2020 Nobel Prize in physics, told Live Science. "But artificial intelligence is not a miracle cure."
For decades, scientists have been trying to observe and characterize Sagittarius A*, the supermassive black hole at the heart of our galaxy. In May 2022, they unveiled the first-ever image of this enormous object, but there were still a number of questions, such as how it behaves.
Now, an international team of scientists has attempted to harness the power of AI to glean more information about Sagittarius A* from data collected by the Event Horizon Telescope (EHT). Unlike some telescopes, the EHT doesn't reside in a single location. Rather, it is composed of several linked instruments scattered across the globe that work in tandem. The EHT uses long electromagnetic waves — up to a millimeter in length — to measure the radius of the photons surrounding a black hole.
However, this technique, known as very long baseline interferometry, is very susceptible to interference from water vapor in Earth's atmosphere. This means it can be tough for researchers to make sense of the information the instruments collect.
"It is very difficult to deal with data from the Event Horizon Telescope," Michael Janssen, an astrophysicist at Radboud University in the Netherlands and co-author of the study, told Live Science. "A neural network is ideally suited to solve this problem."
Related: Astronomers discover most powerful cosmic explosions since the Big Bang
Janssen and his team trained an AI model on EHT data that had been previously discarded for being too noisy. In other words, there was too much atmospheric static to decipher information using classical techniques.
Through this AI technique, they generated a new image of Sagittarius A*'s structure, and their picture revealed some new features. For example, the black hole appears to be spinning at "almost top speed," the researchers said in a statement, and its rotational axis also seems to be pointing toward Earth. Their results were published this month in the journal Astronomy & Astrophysics.
Pinpointing the rotational speed of Sagittarius A* would give scientists clues about how radiation behaves around supermassive black holes and offer insight into the stability of the disk of matter around it.
RELATED STORIES
—Monster black hole jet from the early universe is basking in the 'afterglow' of the Big Bang
—Astronomers discover most powerful cosmic explosions since the Big Bang
—Astronomers simulate a star's final moments as it's swallowed by a black hole: 'Breaks like an egg'
However, not everyone is convinced that the new AI is totally accurate. According to Genzel, the relatively low quality of the data going into the model could have biased it in unexpected ways. As a result, the new image may be somewhat distorted, he said, and shouldn't be taken at face value.
In the future, Janssen and his team plan to apply their technique to the latest EHT data and measure it against real-world results. They hope this analysis will help to refine the model and improve future simulations.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
WIRED
41 minutes ago
- WIRED
Teachers Are Trying to Make AI Work for Them
Aug 18, 2025 6:00 AM Since the start of the AI boom, teachers have been tasked with figuring out if LLMs are helpful tools or a cheat code. This is how they're bringing AI to their curricula. ILLUSTRATION: VIVIENNE SHAO One day last spring, in a high school classroom in Texas, students were arguing about who to kill off first. It was a thought experiment with a sci-fi premise: A global zombie outbreak has decimated major cities. One hundred frozen embryos meant to reboot humanity are safe in a bomb shelter, but the intended adult caretakers never made it. Instead, 12 random civilians stumbled in. There's only enough food and oxygen for seven. The students had to decide who would die and who would live to raise the future of the human race. It wasn't an easy choice. There was Amina, a 26-year-old actress, and Bubak, her husband. Also, a nurse named Marisa, a farmer named Roy, and others. Bubak, who had a criminal record, was a hard sell. So were the useless-yet-likable extras. For years, English teacher Cody Chamberlain had let students debate the ethics and logistics of saving humanity on their own—until he decided to throw AI into the mix. Chamberlain fed the scenario to ChatGPT. It killed Bubak and saved his wife—not because she was useful in other ways but because she could bear children. 'That's so cold,' the students gasped. It was. But for Chamberlain, it offered something new: a dispassionate, algorithmic judgment his students could think about critically. 'ChatGPT said we needed her, like Handmaid's Tale –style,' he says. 'And the kids were like, 'That's ridiculous.' It was weird for ChatGPT to finally not have an answer key but something the kids could push back on.' Teachers have long used technology to personalize lessons, manage workloads, or liven up slideshows. But something shifted after ChatGPT's public launch in 2022. Suddenly, teachers weren't just being tasked with figuring out how to incorporate iPads or interactive whiteboards into their lessons. They had to decipher how to deal with a technology that was already crash-landing into their students' lives, one that could help them study or help them cheat. A quarter of teachers surveyed by Pew in the fall of 2023 said they thought AI provided more harm than benefits; 32 percent thought the tech was a mix of good and bad. Educators faced a choice: Try to fight off AI, or find a way to work with it. This fall, AI will be more embedded in US classrooms than ever. Teachers are deploying large language models to write quizzes, adapt texts to reading levels, generate feedback, and design differentiated instruction. Some districts have issued guidance. Others have thrown up their hands. In the absence of clear policy, teachers are setting the boundaries themselves—one prompt at a time. 'It's just too easy and too alluring,' says Jeff Johnson, an English teacher in California who instructs other teachers on AI incorporation in his district. 'This is going to change everything. But we have to decide what that actually means.' Teaching has long relied on unpaid labor—nights spent googling, planning, adjusting for special education or multilingual learners. For Johnson, AI can provide the kind of assistance that can curb burnout. He uses Brisk to generate short quizzes, Magic School to streamline lesson planning, and Diffit to create worksheets tailored to different skill levels. He doesn't use AI to grade papers or answer student questions. He uses them to prep faster. 'That alone saves me days and weeks,' Johnson says. 'Time that can be better spent interacting with students.' Jennifer Goodnow, who teaches English as a second language in New York, feels similarly. She now plugs complex readings, like essays or book excerpts, into ChatGPT and asks it to create separate versions for advanced and beginner students, with corresponding depth-of-knowledge questions. Amanda Bickerstaff, a former teacher and CEO of AI for Education, an organization that offers training and resources to help educators integrate AI into their classrooms, puts it bluntly: 'Teachers are incorporating AI because they've always needed better planning tools. Now they finally have them.' The same goes for students with individualized education plans, commonly called IEPs—especially those with reading or processing disabilities. If a student struggles with comprehending text, for instance, a teacher might use generative AI to simplify sentence structures, highlight key vocabulary, or break down dense passages into more digestible chunks. Some tools can even reformat materials to include visuals or audio, helping students access the same content in a different way. Chamberlain, Johnson, and Goodnow all teach language arts, subjects where AI can offer benefits—and setbacks—in the classroom. Math teachers, though, tend to be more skeptical. 'Large language models are really bad at computation,' Bickerstaff says. Her team explicitly advises against using tools like ChatGPT to teach math. Instead, some teachers use AI for adjacent tasks—generating slides, reinforcing math vocabulary, or walking students through steps without solving problems outright. But there's something else teachers can use AI for: staying ahead of AI. Nearly three years after ChatGPT became available to the public, teachers can no longer ignore that their kids use it. Johnson recalls one student who was asked to analyze the song 'America' from West Side Story only to turn in a thesis on Simon & Garfunkel's song of same name. 'I was like, 'Dude, did you even read the response?'' he says. Rather than ban the tools, many teachers are designing around them. Johnson has students draft essays step-by-step in a Google Doc with version history enabled, which allows him to track students' writing progress as it appears on the page. Chamberlain requires students to submit their planning documents alongside final work. Goodnow is toying with the idea of having students plug AI-generated essays into assignments and then critique the results. 'Three years ago, I would've thrown the book at them,' Chamberlain says. 'Now it's more like, 'Show me your process. Where were you an agent in this?'' Even so, detecting AI use remains a game of vibes. Plagiarism checkers are notoriously unreliable. Districts have been reluctant to draw hard lines, in part because the tools are moving faster than the rules. But if there's one thing almost everyone agrees on, it's this: Students need AI literacy, and they're not getting it. 'We need to create courses for high school students on AI use, and I don't know that anybody knows the answer to this,' Goodnow says. 'Some sort of ongoing dialog between students and teachers on how to ethically, question mark, use these tools.' Organizations like AI for Education aim to provide that literacy. Founded in 2023, it works with school districts across the US to create AI guidance and training. But even in the most proactive schools, the focus is still on tool use—not critical understanding. Students know how to generate answers. They don't know how to tell whether those answers are inaccurate, biased, or made up. Johnson has begun building lessons around AI hallucinations—like asking ChatGPT how many R's are in the word 'strawberry.' (Spoiler: It often gets it wrong.) 'They need to see that you can't always trust it,' he says. As the tools improve, they're also reaching younger students, raising new concerns about how kids interact with LLMs. Bickerstaff warns that younger children, still learning to distinguish fact from fiction, may be especially vulnerable to over-trusting generative tools. That trust, she says, could have real consequences for their development and sense of reality. Already, some students are using AI not just to complete tasks but to think through them—blurring the line between tool and tutor. Across the board, educators say this fall feels like a turning point. Districts are rolling out new products, students are getting savvier, and teachers are racing to set the norms before the tech sets them itself. 'If we know we're preparing students for the future workforce—and we're hearing from leaders across many different companies that AI is going to be super important—then we need to start now,' Bickerstaff says. That's what teachers like Johnson and Goodnow are doing, one prompt, one student, one weird apocalypse scenario at a time.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Validation of FDA-Regulated Systems Used in Drug Development & Submissions Using AI, Machine Learning & Large Language Models such as ChatGPT - Online Training Course, August 28, 2025
AI, ML, and LLMs present opportunities in the life sciences for improved efficiency and efficacy in drug development and software lifecycle. Key market opportunities include streamlining operations, enhancing compliance with FDA regulations, and fostering innovation through advanced technologies. Dublin, Aug. 18, 2025 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) -- The "Validation of FDA-Regulated Systems Used in Drug Development & Submissions Using Artificial Intelligence (AI), Machine Learning (ML) & Large Language Models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT (ONLINE EVENT: August 28, 2025)" training has been added to safe and effective drugs and other FDA-regulated products is in the best interests of all those involved in the development, manufacturing, testing, and distribution of these products. In training course, you will learn about projects going on in industry and at FDA that take advantage of Artificial Intelligence (AI), Machine Learning (ML) and Large Language Models (LLMs), such as newer technologies such as AI, ML and LLMs in the mix, it means opportunity for greater efficiency and efficacy, but also poses more challenges for companies that develop, test, and support software applications in the life science this webinar, you will learn just how AI, ML and LLMs like ChatGPT can increase efficiency and effectiveness of software development life cycle (SDLC) activities, enabling the delivery and support of computer solutions and new innovative drugs that will drive industry over the coming years. Course Agenda: How AI is being increasingly used in the life sciences industry to enhance drug safety and effectiveness Potential risks and challenges related to AI, ML, and LLMs such as ChatGPT Challenges facing the industry today and how AI technologies can help FDA's adaptation for reviewing AI-enabled software used in drug manufacture and quality testing Understanding how drug products relying on AI are regulated by the FDA Impacts and risks to data, processes, products, and patients Strategies to ensure the benefits of drugs outweigh the risks How FDA, Congress, and industry are collaborating for AI adoption Best practices to improve compliance of AI-enabled drugs Validation, FDA Part 11, and data integrity for AI/ML systems Insights into FDA's CSA guidance and GAMP5, 2nd Edition Software validation and maintenance requirements for AI integration You should attend this webinar if you are responsible for planning, executing or managing the development or implementation of any system governed by FDA regulations, or if you are maintaining or supporting such a system. Learn by reviewing industry best practices and knowing where to gather key information to help you move forward with these technologies quickly and in compliance with Should Attend: Information Technology Analysts Information Technology Developers and Testers QC/QA Managers and Analysts Analytical Chemists Compliance and Audit Managers Laboratory Managers Automation Analysts and Managers Manufacturing Specialists and Managers Supply Chain Specialists and Managers Regulatory Affairs and Submissions Specialists Clinical Data Analysts and Managers Clinical Trial Sponsors Computer System Validation Specialists GMP Training Specialists Business Stakeholders/Subject Matter Experts Business System/Application Testers Vendors and consultants involved in life sciences software validation and compliance For more information about this training visit About is the world's leading source for international market research reports and market data. We provide you with the latest data on international and regional markets, key industries, the top companies, new products and the latest trends. CONTACT: CONTACT: Laura Wood,Senior Press Manager press@ For E.S.T Office Hours Call 1-917-300-0470 For U.S./ CAN Toll Free Call 1-800-526-8630 For GMT Office Hours Call +353-1-416-8900Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
Yahoo
17 hours ago
- Yahoo
Found: The Oldest Black Hole in the Universe
Scientists using the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) have discovered the oldest known black hole in the universe. Nestled within a glowing red galaxy, it dates back 13 billion years and provides a rare glimpse into the universe's earliest moments. The black hole and the galaxy it belongs to are called CAPERS-LRD-z9. It is part of a series of galaxies known as the Little Red Dots. Compared to other galaxies, they are tiny, and they emit red light. Since 2022, scientists have been puzzled by the red spots. Observed in the distant realms of our universe, astronomers thought they were either a cluster of faraway stars or black holes at the center of different galaxies. The fact that they emit so much light suggested that they might be clusters of stars. However, they formed at such an early time that so many stars together was improbable. A new class of galaxy 'We started seeing these objects everywhere,' Anthony Taylor, co-author of the new study, told Science News. It is now generally accepted that the Little Red Dots are a new class of galaxy that formed in the early stages of the universe. The team decided to focus the JWST on one in particular, which seemed to be the oldest. This was CAPERS-LRD-z9. It emitted a huge range of infrared wavelengths. Using spectroscopy to split the light, the team studied the wavelength characteristics, looking for the fingerprint of a black hole. As fast-moving gas is sucked into black holes, it circles and creates a certain pattern of wavelengths of light. The gases moving toward us stretch into red wavelengths, while those moving away compress into blue wavelengths. 'There aren't many other things that create this signature. And this galaxy has it!' exclaimed Taylor in a statement. A blink of time A few even more distant spots could potentially be older black holes, but researchers have yet to see the same spectroscopic signature from them. This means that, at the moment, this is the oldest black hole ever discovered. At 13.3 billion years old, it formed just 500 million years after the Big Bang -- a blink of time in the scale of the universe. 'When looking for black holes, this is about as far back as you can practically go,' said Taylor. "We're really pushing the boundaries of what current technology can detect." Though the galaxies are quite small, the black hole at the center of CAPERS-LRD-z9 is not. It is about 300 million times the mass of our Sun, and roughly 10 times more massive than Sagittarius A*, the black hole at the center of the Milky Way. Even more intriguingly, its mass might represent around half of its galaxy's total stellar mass, a proportion far greater than in younger galaxies. Studying CAPERS-LRD-z9 doesn't just confirm the existence of a black hole. It gives astronomers a crucial testing ground to refine theories of early galaxy and black hole evolution. 'We only ever survey very tiny areas of the sky with the James Webb Space Telescope,' said co-author Steven Finkelstein, 'So, if we find one thing, there's got to be a lot more out there.' Solve the daily Crossword
