FBR procurement plan: IHC-ordered automated IT refund system missing
The court's directive aimed to facilitate taxpayers and minimise interaction with tax functionaries when there is an issue of returning taxpayer money in the shape of refund, but the FBR has failed to take concrete steps in this regard. It is reliably learnt that a landmark order issued by IHC remained unimplemented by the FBR despite lapse of considerable time.
Automated income tax refund system: FBR has failed to enforce IHC's directive
When contacted tax lawyer Waheed Shahzad Butt who has argued the case before IHC told Business Recorder that a report titled 'Findings and Recommendations of Committee for Effective Enforcement of Section 170A' was submitted to the IHC, outlining comprehensive recommendations for implementation. However, despite assurances from Member (Policy) FBR that these recommendations would be implemented, no progress has been made till date.
Waheed Butt further added that FBR's inaction is particularly surprising given the government's efforts to digitize tax processes. The failure to implement the automated refund system as directed by the IHC raises concerns about the FBR's commitment to transparency and efficiency. The FBR's lack of progress on this front is a missed opportunity to streamline tax processes and improve the overall taxpayer experience.
This will not only enhance transparency and efficiency but also demonstrate the FBR's commitment to upholding the rule of law and respecting the directives of the judiciary, Waheed added.
IHC order states: 'The FBR has submitted a report. The report and recommendations appear fairly comprehensive, and the Member (Policy) FBR appearing today has stated that these recommendations will be implemented in accordance with the USD 25 million loan from an international donor agency.' The objective of this petition seems to have been achieved. The petition is accordingly disposed of, leaving it open for the petitioner to approach the Court again if the recommendations are not implemented, the IHC ordered.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
an hour ago
- Express Tribune
TCP clarifies bids for sugar import accepted under PPRA Rules
The Trading Corporation of Pakistan (TCP) clarified on Sunday that the three bids accepted for the import of sugar were accepted following "the requirements contained in PPRA Rules, 2004". Earlier, it was reported in error that the TCP raised objections to documents submitted by two companies and consequently rejected their bids, despite them offering lower prices in their tenders for importing 200,000 metric tons of sugar. 'The lowest bidder's (M/S ED&F Man Sugar Limited, London) offer was to supply/import of 50,000 MT, and not 100,000 MT as incorrectly reported in the news item, and the same has been accepted at quoted price of USD 539/MT. Accordingly, bid acceptance letter has been issued which has also been accepted by the firm,' TCP said in a statement. It clarified that only one bidder (M/S Bare Syndicate FZCO) was rejected for failing to provide the mandatory bid security document, rendering its bid non-responsive. 'Thus, all three bids were accepted following the requirements contained in PPRA Rules, 2004. Accordingly, bid acceptance letters have been issued to all three bidders for import/supply of 105,000 MT of sugar,' the statement added.
Business Recorder
18 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Risk mispriced, lessons ignored
EDITORIAL: The rising tide of natural catastrophe losses is no longer a distant warning; it is a direct cost and a growing one. The USD 135 billion in global economic losses recorded in the first half of 2025, as reported by Swiss Re, underscores a world where climate volatility is fast outpacing institutional readiness. Of that total, $80 billion were insured losses, almost double the ten-year average when adjusted for inflation. The insurance industry, typically built around precision modelling and disciplined risk pricing, appears to have misjudged both the pace and scale of the threat. A large portion of this year's insured hit came from a single event, the Los Angeles wildfires in January, with losses estimated at USD 40 billion. Swiss Re notes that this is the largest insured wildfire loss event on record, driven by a combination of extreme wind conditions, prolonged drought, and a high concentration of high-value residential properties in vulnerable areas. While climate change is undoubtedly amplifying the frequency and severity of such disasters, the scale of insured losses raises uncomfortable questions about whether insurers themselves priced this risk appropriately. That is where the insurance industry cannot be absolved of all responsibility. For years, insurers have issued policies in high-risk regions, particularly in California, without raising premiums sufficiently to reflect the accelerating climate exposure. Competitive pressure and short-term market share considerations may have played a role, but the result was the same: mispriced risk and under-prepared balance sheets. This is not merely a case of insurers getting caught off guard, it is a failure to act in their own self-interest. According to Swiss Re, wildfire-related insured losses now make up 7 percent of global natural catastrophe claims, up from just 1 percent before 2015. That increase did not happen overnight. Yet insurers continued to offer cover, often at rates that did not factor in the new baseline of prolonged dry seasons, shifting rainfall patterns, and growing suburban development in fire-prone areas. The consequences were predictable and, in hindsight, preventable. It is also telling that severe thunderstorms accounted for USD 31 billion in insured losses in just the first six months of the year. The second half typically carries even more risk due to the North Atlantic hurricane season. If current loss trends hold, global insured losses in 2025 could exceed Swiss Re's projection of USD 150 billion, a figure that would put even the best-capitalised reinsurers under pressure. This is not just a market problem. The knock-on effect of repeated, outsized claims is that premiums will eventually rise sharply, coverage will become more selective, and vulnerable communities, especially in developing countries, will be left even more exposed. The gap between insured and uninsured losses will widen, and without proactive mitigation measures, the financial burden will shift further onto governments and the public. Swiss Re's own recommendation is unequivocal. The strongest lever for long-term resilience is investment in mitigation and adaptation. Dykes, floodgates, firebreaks, and stricter zoning rules are not luxuries; they are cost-saving mechanisms. Research suggests such interventions can be up to ten times more cost-effective than rebuilding after disaster strikes. Developing countries, including Pakistan, should take particular note. Flooding, heat waves, and urban sprawl into hazard-prone zones are recurring features of the local climate and planning landscape. Yet, disaster management continues to rely heavily on response rather than prevention. Insurance penetration remains low, and climate-related risk is largely absent from urban development decisions. If the private insurance sector, with all its modelling sophistication, can misprice such risk, the implications for public infrastructure and fiscal planning are even more serious. The Swiss Re report should be a wake-up call, not only to the global insurance industry, but also to policymakers tasked with safeguarding national resilience. The data is clear. The losses are real. The window to adjust is narrowing. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
18 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Biometric verification of registered persons: LTBA urges FBR, Nadra to bring in secure mobile app
ISLAMABAD: The Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) and the National Database and Registration Authority (Nadra) should jointly implement a secure mobile application for biometric verification of sales tax registered persons. According to a letter of the Lahore Tax Bar Association (LTBA) to the FBR Chairman, the association highlighted major challenges faced by certain sales taxpayers under the current biometric verification system and proposed a digital solution aligned with FBR's commitment to facilitation and innovation. Presently, biometric verification for sales tax registration and annually bio metric which required in terms of SRO 350(1)/2024 is conducted exclusively through Nadra's physical infrastructure. While this may suffice for most residents, it poses considerable challenges for the following categories of taxpayers: (I); Individuals temporarily residing or travelling abroad. (2); Taxpayers located in remote or underdeveloped areas. (3); Elderly or physically challenged individuals who cannot easily access the Nadra facilities. Due to the unavailability of a remote verification mechanism, these taxpayers are unable to complete their sales tax registration and annually biometric which required in tarns of SRO 350(1)/2024 dated 07.03.2025, despite their willingness to comply with legal requirements. This creates unnecessary delays, hampers business operations, filing of sales tax returns and discourages potential entrants into the tax system. Key challenges included no Remote Option for Overseas Taxpayers and delays in Registration Activation and filing of sales tax returns. He LTBA proposed the FBR should consider in coordination with Nadra, the development and deployment of a secure mobile application for biometric verification. This solution may include facial recognition or fingerprint scanning wing smartphone technology and secure integration between the FBR and the Nadra. The expected benefits included enhanced taxpayer's facilitation particularly for overseas Pakistanis and remote areas residents, improved compliance rate with quicker registration and fewer delays; expanded lax base and alignment with FBR's digital transformation and automation goals. The association is confident that this initiative would greatly enhance the accessibility, efficiency, compliance and Inclusivity of FBR's taxpayers' registration system and ease filing of sales tax returns and enhance the revenue collection, it added. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
