StoneCo Ltd. (STNE): A Bear Case Theory
We came across a bearish thesis on StoneCo Ltd. (STNE) on Quipus Capital's Substack. In this article, we will summarize the bears' thesis on STNE. StoneCo Ltd. (STNE)'s share was trading at $13.51 as of 6th June. STNE's trailing and forward P/E were 11.42 and 9.68 respectively according to Yahoo Finance.
StoneCo Ltd. (STNE), is deeply entrenched in Brazil's payment processing ecosystem, with a business model centered on receivables discounting rather than the processing layer, which has been heavily commoditized. STNE advances funds to merchants on credit card sales, earning high-yield, low-risk returns that are essentially underwritten by card issuers or networks. This model thrives among small businesses with limited credit access, where urgency often trumps cost.
However, STNE's growth potential faces headwinds in the market: a saturated market growing only in line with GDP plus inflation, and a capped receivables base tied to one month's worth of payment volumes. Compounding this is the risk posed by PIX Parcelado, a government-backed initiative allowing installment payments directly via banks, which could disintermediate STNE from the receivables chain.
While STNE has explored traditional credit markets, its previous attempts led to high delinquencies and an eventual retreat. The company lacks the competitive advantage to rival Brazil's full-service digital and incumbent banks. Despite these challenges, STNE remains highly profitable, and management is focused on balance sheet optimization through share buybacks and modest leverage. Assuming stable pricing and spreads, STNE can deliver around 11% from buybacks at a 9x P/E, and add another 5–7% from underlying economic growth.
While the upside from fixed-multiple returns and efficient capital allocation is compelling, it's counterbalanced by the real possibility of margin erosion or disintermediation. For investors, the key question is whether these tailwinds are enough to justify the risk of business model disruption in an evolving payments landscape.
Previously, we summarized a bullish thesis on SoFi Technologies, highlighting its rapid digital bank user growth, expanding product engagement, and forward profitability inflection, framing its 2026 earnings potential as a catalyst for valuation rerating. The stock has appreciated by approximately 4% since the recent coverage. Together, these two theses present a tale of fintech divergence: one banking on digital ecosystem scale and future earnings leverage (SoFi), the other navigating a legacy-dependent niche facing structural headwinds (StoneCo)
StoneCo Ltd. (STNE) is not on our list of the 30 Most Popular Stocks Among Hedge Funds. As per our database, 30 hedge fund portfolios held STNE at the end of the first quarter which was 24 in the previous quarter. While we acknowledge the risk and potential of STNE as an investment, our conviction lies in the belief that some AI stocks hold greater promise for delivering higher returns and have limited downside risk. If you are looking for an extremely cheap AI stock that is also a major beneficiary of Trump tariffs and onshoring, see our free report on the best short-term AI stock.
READ NEXT: 8 Best Wide Moat Stocks to Buy Now and 30 Most Important AI Stocks According to BlackRock.
Disclosure: None. This article was originally published at Insider Monkey.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Forbes
3 hours ago
- Forbes
India's Largest Companies 2025: Big Banks Highlight India's Presence On The Global 2000
India's most profitable private sector bank, HDFC Bank, moved up to No. 53 on this year's Global 2000. India is among the top five countries to be represented on the 2025 Forbes Global 2000 list, ranking the world's largest publicly traded companies. With 70 companies this year it is No. 4 behind the U.S. (612), China/Hong Kong (317) and Japan (180). Indian companies span a range of sectors from banking to telecom to consumer goods and this year their combined profit rose to $126 billion from $120 billion last year. Combined assets grew to $5.5 trillion from $5.08 trillion the previous year and the aggregate market value rose marginally to $2.3 trillion from $2.15 trillion last year. Mumbai-based conglomerate, Reliance Industries, with interests in everything from petrochemicals, oil and gas to retail and telecom, retained the top spot in the country, and moved up four ranks from No.49 to No.45 on the global list. Reliance reported sales of $114 billion, up from $109 billion last year, and was largely insulated from global headwinds with its revenue driven mostly by domestic demand. More than a third of the companies are drawn from the financial services sector spanning banks, insurance companies and consumer lenders. India's most profitable private sector bank, HDFC Bank, moved up 12 spots to No. 53 on the global list. It took over the No. 2 position in India from state-run behemoth State Bank of India which stayed put at No. 55 globally but slipped to the third position in the country. Private lenders ICICI Bank and Axis Bank also feature among the top ten in the country, buoyed by a robust banking sector, which was bolstered by the Reserve Bank of India's interest rate cuts, high net interest margins and robust asset quality. (The NIFTY Bank index grew 14% over the past year.) Seven Indian companies debuted on the Global 2000 this year. Notable among them is Gurgaon-based Eternal, parent of food delivery service Zomato and 10-minute grocery delivery service Blinkit. Among the large Indian conglomerates, the most entries were from the $164 billion (revenue) Tata group conglomerate. Half a dozen Tata companies made the cut, including regulars such as auto behemoth Tata Motors and IT giant Tata Consultancy Services as well as one new entrant to the list, Mumbai-based retailer Trent. Selling everything from apparel to footwear to grocery, the company saw sales jump to $2 billion from $1.5 billion in the past year as profits rose to $231 million from $181 million. The company that climbed up the most in the ranks was Cholamandalam, the financial services arm of the Chennai-based conglomerate the Murugappa Group. Cholamandalam, which has revenues of $3.1 billion, rose 410 ranks to No. 1539, up from No. 1949 last year. Eight companies fell off the list including Varun Beverages, which is one of PepsiCo's biggest bottlers outside the U.S. The Gurgaon-based company is fending off rising competition in the domestic market, specifically from the revival of homegrown beverage brand Campa Cola now owned by Reliance Industries. Steel makers Steel Authority of India and Jindal Steel and Power, part of the O.P Jindal group chaired by India's richest woman, Savitri Jindal, also dropped out, hammered by cheap Chinese imports and lower capacity utilization. But JSW Steel, run by Jindal's son Sajjan Jindal, managed to retain its place in the ranks but fell by 254 places to No. 899–down from No. 645 last year. Forbes
Forbes
5 hours ago
- Forbes
Amid Oil Downturn, Fast Growing Permian Resources Still Shines
An iconic "nodding donkey" pumps in the Permian Basin. It's a tough time to be in the oil business. Prices are down 15% in the past year to $67/bbl as OPEC decided to abandon supply cuts and allow member countries to boost output. Forget drill, baby, drill; at current prices America's drillers have been mothballing rigs at a rapid clip to preserve capital. Among the 93 oil and gas companies in the Forbes Global 2000, more than half dropped in the rankings this year. Saudi Aramco, the biggest of Big Oil, slipped just one spot to no. 4. BP (in the midst of yet another corporate realignment) plunged 374 spots to no. 421. Refiners and chemical producers have felt the pain as well, with PBF Energy, HF Sinclair, Formosa Chemicals and Neste all down hundreds of spots in the rankings. And yet there are bright spots. Argentina's oil champion YPF advanced 478 spots to no. 702 thanks to economic revitalization wrought by President Javier Milei and its work to commercialize the Vaca Muerta gas field via a new JV with Italy's Eni. New entrants to the Forbes Global 2000 include Brazil's biggest independent oil company Prio, chaired by investor Nelson Tanure, which owns stakes in big offshore fields. Also TechnipFMC, which specializes in building out complicated deepwater infrastructure, with big new contracts in Norway, Brazil and Nigeria. Then there's Venture Global, the liquefied natural gas giant with export megaprojects on the Gulf Coast. Venture's IPO early this year minted two new billionaires in co-founders Mike Sabel and Bob Pender. The most inspirational new oil company on the list is Permian Resources, which debuts at no. 1762. Proving that you don't have to be old and grizzled to become an oil tycoon, Permian's co-ceos Will Hickey and James Walter are just 38 and 37 years old. Childhood friends, Hickey worked at Pioneer Natural Resources and EnCap Investments, Walter at BCG and Denham Capital, before they joined forces in 2015 to meld together thousands of acres of private-equity-owned west Texas oilfields to form Colgate Energy. Through Colgate, the duo bought some 180,000 acres for $1 billion through 2022, then merged with Centennial Resources in a $7 billion deal. That led to the $4.5 billion acquisition of Earthstone Energy in 2023, the purchase of some $800 million of assets from Occidental in 2024 and a $600 million buy from the former Apache Corp. earlier this year. After the rollup, Permian Resources is the largest pure-play oil company in the Delaware Basin (straddling the Texas/New Mexico border) with 450,000 net acres and 370,000 barrels per day of output. Despite tough market conditions, Permian Resources generated $1.25 billion in net income on $5 billion of 2024 revenues. When shares tumbled with the market in early April the company bought back $43 million of stock at $10.52 a share. The share price has since bounced back to $14.25, giving Hickey and Walter each a fortune of $150 million.
Yahoo
8 hours ago
- Yahoo
Bank Aston to be first locally licensed Guernsey bank in 30 years
Bank Aston has secured a banking licence from the Guernsey regulator that will make it the first locally licensed bank in the jurisdiction within 30 years. Bank Aston positions itself as a specialist provider for offshore trustees, investment funds, and family offices, which are key sectors in the Channel Islands' financial services industry. The firm is hoping to reinvigorate the offshore sector, which has £800bn in assets under management and £250bn in bank deposits in the Channel Islands alone. Guernsey Financial Services Commission (GFSC) has granted it 'Licensed with Conditions,' which is subject to conditions during Bank Aston's launch phase. The bank will begin accepting institutional deposits and roll out its complete range of services once fully licensed. Guernsey's last locally-based bank ceased trading in 1996. James Bennett, co-founder of Bank Aston, said: 'Banking is becoming a huge problem for offshore institutions. 'They face increasingly slow approvals, poor customer services and eye-watering fees with decisions being taken remotely by legacy banks whose risk appetite is steadily declining.' Bank Aston said it would streamline the onboarding and service delivery process through leveraging advanced technology. The firm added its deep knowledge of the offshore market would allow it to service consumers 'more quickly and competitively than is currently the case'. Brown has 40 years' experience including stints at the Financial Conduct Authority, Payment Systems Regulator and Bank of England. He is also a board member and founding investor of fintechs OneiD and Form3. Co-founder Jay Goss said: 'Few people realise the seriousness of the situation. The difficulties with onboarding and running accounts is starting to impact the whole industry. 'But there is an opportunity as well. We see Bank Aston as a commitment to Guernsey's future and to ensuring the island remains relevant, resilient and ambitious on the global financial map.'
