'Don't slam DAP but ask if DAP leaves Madani gov't, will Beng Hock's real killers face justice?'
They are the ones holding real power and protecting the culprits behind the death of the political aide to then Selangor executive councillor Ean Yong Hian Wah.
In contrast, DAP lacks power to force this issue. Their only 'trump card' is to threaten to leave the Madani government unless justice is done. Let's call this the 'nuclear war option'.
Like a Chinese kung fu movie, it's emotionally satisfying to overturn the table at Putrajaya and storm the hell out.
Unfortunately, life is not a movie. We have to ask, 'what happens after'? Will Anwar then bring in PAS or Bersatu to bolster his support?
Will we then move into a totally Malay-dominated government that slides towards an Islamic State?
After all, Mr Madani seems more interested in holding on to power rather than pursuing real reforms. And then passing on the reins to his daughter.
In fact, Anwar had admitted in October 2023 that he invited PAS to join his government when it was formed.
Racial battle?
Even if DAP leaves Putrajaya, will the real killers of Teoh then face justice?
I doubt it because the optics will be bad. It will look like Chinese politicians demanding a U-turn from the police and Malay-dominated establishment.
It will become a Chinese vs Malay battle with 'warriors' like Dr Chicken Ham and Holy Hardy taking advantage to score political points.
They will rush to defend the police from the kurang ajar Chinese. We all know how the drama script works.
Take what happened when Tourism Minister Datuk Seri Tiong King Sing did a spot check at KLIA in June 2023 after receiving complaints of Immigration officers allegedly extorting China visitors .
UMNO Youth chief Datuk Dr Muhamad Akmal Saleh then accused him of 'abusing' his power and 'interfering' with Immigration officials. Akmal was also reported to demand that the Bintulu MP be stripped of his citizenshi p.
Can you beat that? Exposing corruption is deemed to be an 'abuse' of power!
This reflects the mindset of the Malay Deep State that disparages an 'uppity' Chinese Minister trying to kacau 'rice bowls', never mind if they were halal or not.
Tiong was brave but no Immigration officer was caught. Instead, the Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission (MACC) pinned the blame for the extortion on a mysterious 'external agent' who had conveniently disappeared.
Tan Sri Nazir Razak, the better and smarter brother of incarcerated former premier Datuk Seri Najib Razak, lamented in October 2022 that a three-headed monster plagues Malaysia.
These are racial politics, over-centralisation of power and corruption that has become like 'stage four cancer '.
Cover up?
Of course, the Attorney-General decision of 'no further action (NFA)' over Beng Hock's case stinks of a cover up.
After all, a 2011 Royal Commission of Inquiry (RCI) ruled that he was driven to suicide by aggressive interrogation.
In 2014, the Court of Appeal ruled his death was caused or by unlawful act s, including by MACC officers.
Democracy watchdog BERSIH has rightly slammed MACC's public apology and offer of compensation for Teoh's death as a whitewash of criminal responsibility .
Yet don't forget lots of other pungent cases remain unsolved including the alleged abductions of Pamela Ling, Pastor Raymond Koh and Shia activist Amri Che Mat.
And of course, we still haven't caught the real masterminds who ordered the Mongolian murder.
Besides these high-profile cases, many have forgotten that 70 people died in police custody between 2021 and 2022?
In addition, Tenaganita revealed that 150 people died in 2022 while locked up by the Immigration Department .
Bowing in sorrow
People have every right to be angry at the dashed promises of reform under the Madani government. But who holds real power in Putrajaya?
DAP knows all this, that's probably why they tried a compromise solution – bowing down to Beng Hock's family and urging them to consider taking MACC's goodwill payment
It was probably the 'best deal' they could negotiate with the unrepentant and unaccountable Deep State.
But they were condemned for 'white-washing' the case they had championed for 16 years. The Teoh family angrily rejected the payment. It looked like a PR stunt that badly backfired.
But later, Beng Hock's parents, sister and members of the Teoh Beng Hock Association for Democratic Advancement solemnly bowed down during a memorial service on July 20 to reciprocate DAP's gesture .
Maybe they recognised that DAP had done what they could, short of leaving Madani?
DAP – Dilemma Action Party
If DAP does walk out of the Madani government, I am sure many will then condemn them for 'betraying' the voters' mandate and 'abandoning' their supporters.
In short, people will always find fault whether the party remains in or out of Putrajaya.
DAP is really a Dilemma Action Party caught between the devil and the deep blue sea.
Its secretary-general Anthony Loke Siew Fook and other DAP leaders don't want confrontation. They want compromise while quietly getting stuff done – like allocations for Chinese schools and funding for the Penang LRT, both from Putrajaya.
You can call all this 'appeasement' or 'sucking up' or use even more foul language. But DAP is still probably the best in work performance of all the Madani Ministers.
However, DAP's 'softly, softly' strategy with the Establishment is not working. They are being slammed left and right as MCA 2.0 for its unwilling to 'rock the boat' while enjoying the cushy perks of Ministers' power.
Yet Anwar is a damaged brand, now forced to buy some popularity with a RM100 payout and extra public holiday on Sept 15 .
As he loses popularity, DAP must be careful not to be too closely associated – and tainted by – the Madani chameleon.
Why stick too tightly to a ship that may sink? Why not establish some distance of 'plausible deniability'? – July 25, 2025
Forner The Star environment section editor Andrew Sia is a semi-retired journalist and columnist for Malaysiakini.
The views expressed are solely of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Focus Malaysia .
Main image credit: Teoh Beng Hock Association for Democratic Advancement/Facebook
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
40 minutes ago
- The Star
Head of China's Shaolin Temple removed over embezzlement claims
BEIJING: The head of the Chinese temple known as the birthplace of kung fu will be disrobed for "extremely" bad behaviour, Beijing's top Buddhist authority said Monday, (July 28) after allegations of embezzlement saw him placed under investigation. The Shaolin Temple said on Sunday that Abbot Shi Yongxin, known as the "CEO monk" for establishing dozens of companies abroad, was suspected of "embezzling project funds and temple assets". The monastery said Shi had "seriously violated Buddhist precepts", including by allegedly engaging in "improper relationships" with multiple women. "Multiple departments" were conducting a joint investigation, it said in a statement on WeChat. In response, the Buddhist Association of China, overseen by the ruling Communist Party, said Monday it would cancel Shi's certificate of ordination. "Shi Yongxin's actions are of an extremely bad nature, seriously undermining the reputation of the Buddhist community, hurting the image of monks," the association said in an online statement. The association "firmly supports the decision to deal with Shi Yongxin in accordance with the law". Shi had previously been accused by former monks of embezzling money from a temple-run company, maintaining a fleet of luxury cars and fathering children with multiple women. China's government exercises authority over the appointment of religious leaders, and "improper" conduct is often grounds for removal from office. A hashtag related to the temple scandal had been viewed more than 560 million times on social media platform Weibo as of Monday morning. The last post to the abbot's personal account on Weibo declared: "when one's own nature is pure, the pure land is here in the present". Shi faced similar allegations in 2015 which the temple called "vicious libel". Shi, 59, took office as abbot in 1999 and in the following decades expanded Shaolin studies and cultural knowledge overseas. He helped the temple establish dozens of companies -- but received backlash for commercialising Buddhism. The temple, established in AD 495, is known as the birthplace of Zen Buddhism and Chinese kung fu. Shi was first elected vice-chairman of the Buddhist Association of China in 2002 and has served as a representative to the National People's Congress, the country's top lawmaking body. - AFP
The Star
40 minutes ago
- The Star
Cambodian and Thai leaders hold ceasefire talks in Malaysia as border violence enters fifth day
Cambodian migrant workers carry their belongings as they returned from Thailand through the Doung International Gate in Battambang province on July 28, 2025. Thailand and Cambodia's leaders are due to meet for peace talks on July 28, as a festering territorial dispute along their shared frontier dragged into a fifth day of open combat. - AFP SURIN, Thailand: Thai and Cambodian leaders are meeting in Malaysia in an urgent effort to resolve deadly border clashes that entered a fifth day despite mounting international calls for peace. Cambodian Prime Minister Hun Manet and Thai Acting Prime Minister Phumtham Wechayachai are scheduled to hold talks Monday afternoon (July 28) at the official residence of Malaysian Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim who is hosting the negotiations as chair of Asean. ALSO READ: US Secretary Rubio briefs Cambodian foreign minister on US support for peaceful resolution The fighting flared last Thursday after a land mine explosion along the border wounded five Thai soldiers. Both sides blamed each other for starting the clashes, that have killed at least 35 people and displaced more than 260,000 people on both sides. Both countries recalled their ambassadors and Thailand shut all border crossings with Cambodia, with an exception for migrant Cambodian workers returning home. Troops from both sides reported ongoing fighting Monday along border areas. Gunfire could be heard as dawn broke in Samrong in Cambodia's Oddar Meanchey province, Associated Press reporters covering the conflict said. Anwar said late Sunday that both sides would present their conditions for peace but "what is important is immediate ceasefire.' "I hope this can work,' Anwar was quoted as saying by Malaysian national news agency Bernama. "Although it's not as bad as many other countries, we have to put a stop (to the violence).' The meeting followed direct pressure from US President Donald Trump, who has warned that the United States may not proceed with trade deals with either country if hostilities continue. Before departing for Kuala Lumpur, Phumtham told reporters in Bangkok that the US and China representatives will also attend as observers. He said the key focus would be on an immediate ceasefire, but noted trust could be an issue as Cambodia has not stopped its strikes. "We have informed that we don't have trust in Cambodia. All they have done reflect that they are not sincere in solving this problem. So they have to show the detail how they will do to prove their sincerity,' he said. The violence marks a rare instance of open military confrontation between Asean member states, a 10-nation regional bloc that has prided itself on non-aggression, peaceful dialogue and economic cooperation. In a statement Monday, Asean foreign ministers reiterated concern over the rising death toll, destruction of public properties and displacement of a large number of people along the disputed border areas. They urged the two countries to resolve their disputes through negotiations and expressed support for efforts to find a middle ground during Monday's talks. The conflict also drew the attention of Pope Leo XIV. At the Vatican on Sunday, the pontiff said he was praying for all those affected by war in the world, including "for those affected by the clashes on the border between Thailand and Cambodia, especially the children and displaced families.' At an evacuation shelter in Cambodia's Siem Reap province far away from the border, Ron Mao, 56, prays for a ceasefire deal during the leaders' meeting Monday. She and her family fled their home a kilometre away from the front line when fighting broke out Thursday. They took refuge in a shelter but moved again to another camp further away after hearing artillery shelling. "I don't want to see this war happen. It's very difficult and I don't want to run around like this,' she said, "When I heard our Prime Minister go to negotiate for peace, I would be very happy if they reached the deal as soon as possible, so that I and my children can return home as soon as possible." The 800-kilometre frontier between Thailand and Cambodia has been disputed for decades, but past confrontations have been limited and brief. The latest tensions erupted in May when a Cambodian soldier was killed in a confrontation that created a diplomatic rift and roiled Thailand's domestic politics. - AP
The Star
2 hours ago
- The Star
Regulating online fraud: Malaysia's OSB vs China's approach
INITIATED in the 2010s, China's Digital Silk Road (DSR) aims to enhance digital connectivity across nations through infrastructure, trade, finance, people-to-people exchanges and policy coordination. It presents new commercial opportunities for Malaysia by fostering collaboration between Chinese and Malaysian businesses, strengthening Malaysia's digital economy ecosystem. The convergence of China's DSR, the Covid-19 pandemic, and the rapid rise in artificial intelligence (AI) have significantly accelerated the adoption of digital technologies in business processes and operations within Malaysia. However, while digitalisation offers numerous benefits, it has unfortunately also led to a significant surge in online criminal activity. A recent report by The Star revealed that nearly RM600mil was lost to online fraud from January to March, according to the Bukit Aman Commercial Crime Investigation Department. The report highlighted that criminals are exploiting technological advancements and modern lifestyles, using fake digital identities, fraudulent websites, chatbots and deepfakes to deceive victims. Recognising the escalating threat posed by these sophisticated methods, regulatory interventions focused on online content have become a prevailing trend. Malaysia, in line with this trend, passed the Online Safety Bill (OSB) 2024 in December. It is awaiting official gazettement, and its effective date will be determined by Communications Minister Datuk Fahmi Fadzil. The new law aims to enhance online safety in Malaysia by regulating harmful content and establishing duties and obligations for application service providers (those who provide network services such as Internet access), content application service providers (those who provide content such as broadcasting and video streaming), and network service providers (those providing cellular mobile services and bandwidth services) operating within and outside Malaysia. According to Minister in the Prime Minister's Department (Law and Institutional Reforms) Datuk Seri Azalina Othman Said, it applies to licensed application and content service providers such as Instagram, WhatsApp, TikTok and YouTube. The Bill regulates two categories of content: 'harmful content' and 'priority harmful content'. Its First Schedule defines the scope of harmful content, which includes content on financial fraud, excluding content that promotes awareness or education related to financial fraud. The content on financial fraud listed in the First Schedule is also classified as 'priority harmful content' in the Second Schedule. Key duties imposed on service providers include the obligation to implement measures to detect and mitigate harmful content (Section 13), issue user guidelines (Section 14), establish mechanisms for handling user reports of potentially harmful content (Sections 16 and 17), and prepare an Online Safety Plan (Section 20). For priority harmful content, such as financial fraud, service providers must take steps to prevent user access (Section 19). Despite Fahmi's assurance that the government's intention in introducing the OSB is to serve as a measure to combat crime, such as financial fraud, and not to restrict freedom of expression, critics remain concerned about its potential to restrict freedom of expression and be used as a censorship tool by the government. These are valid concerns, particularly considering the vague definition of harmful content in the OSB and the vast powers conferred on a commission reporting to the Communications Ministry. This commentary limits its discussion to the Bill's role concerning content on financial fraud. It is undeniable that unregulated content involving financial fraud, such as online scams, can damage business reputations and cause financial losses. Deputy Communications Minister Teo Nie Ching reported that RM1.224bil was lost to online crimes and scams in Malaysia within the first 10 months of last year, with many victims falling prey to sponsored advertisements on social media platforms. Indeed, a duty should be imposed on service providers to prevent these platforms from profiting from sponsored advertisements involving financial scams, for which they receive payment to promote products or services. Nevertheless, the provisions in the OSB are still lacking when viewed from the perspective of curbing online fraud. In China, the government passed the Anti-Telecom and Online Fraud Law ('ATOF Law') in September 2022. This law is more specific, aiming to prevent, deter and punish telecommunications and online fraud, strengthen efforts against such fraud, and protect the rights and interests of citizens and organisations. It imposes responsibilities on key businesses in the telecommunications, financial, and Internet sectors to prevent fraud risks. Among these requirements, the law requires service providers to verify users' identities before providing a range of services, such as web hosting, content and software distribution, livestreaming and advertising (Article 21). The law also imposes a duty of reasonable care on service providers to monitor, identify, and address the use of their services to commit fraud (Article 25). The ATOF Law provides a model regulation for targeted fraud prevention. While Malaysia and China operate within different legal and cultural frameworks, there are valuable lessons to be learned from China's experience in addressing online fraud. China's preventive measures have contributed to a more secure digital environment for businesses and consumers, minimising the impact of online fraud. While the Malaysian government's efforts to ensure a secure online environment and build trust in the digital ecosystem are laudable, more targeted provisions focused on the specific mechanics of online fraud would be more efficient, like China's ATOF Law, instead of a broad content regulation approach. China's ATOF Law, which emphasises user verification and platform monitoring for fraudulent activities, would allow for a more focused approach to content regulation. It is imperative that the Malaysian government review the adequacy of the OSB in achieving its intended purpose of curbing online crime. To enhance its efficacy, the government could consider incorporating more granular provisions that mandate specific actions from service providers and establish clear and enforceable guidelines and penalties. A well-regulated online environment, one that builds trust and security, can attract foreign investment and facilitate DSR-related collaborations, shaping the long-term trajectory of Malaysia's digital economy. Lai Chooi Ling is a lecturer at Tunku Abdul Rahman University of Management and Technology (TAR UMT). The views expressed here are entirely the writer's own. The SEARCH Scholar Series is a social responsibility programme jointly organised by the South-East Asia Research Centre for Humanities (SEARCH) and TAR UMT.
