Fears Air Corps may have to cut down on night flights due to lack of air traffic controllers
IT IS FEARED the Irish Air Corps could face having to shut down its flight operations at night because it is losing air traffic controllers to high paid civilian jobs,
The Journal
has learned.
Air traffic control for the Air Corps is managed from Casement Aerodrome at Baldonnel in southwest Co Dublin.
The base has its own air traffic controllers who manage the airspace around the airfield, which can include night operations by military helicopters, Garda aircraft and fixed wing Defence Forces aircraft such as those used to monitor maritime activities off the coast.
The jobs are staffed by trained military members, and the air traffic control personnel is made up of both commissioned and non-commissioned officers.
According to multiple sources we spoke to, air traffic control tower personnel are leaving their State jobs for jobs elsewhere, where they can take up roles that have a starting wage of €80,000.
Specialist military personnel have left for jobs at companies such as Aer Lingus and at AirNav Ireland, which employs over 200 controllers at Dublin, Shannon and Cork airports.
A senior source in the Irish Air Corps also noted the growth of Weston Airport near Leixlip, on the border of Dublin and Kildare, where there has been extensive recruitment efforts to bring in experienced personnel from the Irish military.
'The Defence Forces don't take direct entry from the civilian world to fill gaps as they arise,' the source said.
'If someone with a key skill, like an air traffic controller leaves, we have to employ from within to fill that gap.
'So we have to take people in and start them from stage one of their military training and then start the process of getting them qualified to ATC level – that can take up to five years to achieve.'
Compounding the issue, sources said, is the fact that it's usually more experienced controllers who carry out the on-the-job training in Baldonnel of newly qualified members.
Advertisement
Sources have said that a delay in offering the non-commissioned ranks promotions to become officers was key to them leaving.
'It would have stopped them leaving – but it just didn't happen in time,' one source said.
Cathal Berry, a former TD and army officer, said that the issue had been flagged a number of years ago but the Government failed to act to implement incentives to retain the specialists.
'This is the perfect example of a single point of failure – this has the potential to cause the entire operation to end.
'It has been bubbling under surface for a long time but it is a real pity we don't get ahead – they could have been a small stitch years ago to solve it but now there has to be a mad scramble.
'They are going to a job that is less secure and they do not get the same job satisfaction but there are push factors sending them to the private sector.
'A report was written a number of years ago highlighting this crisis and the recommendations were never implemented,' the former TD said.
Berry explained that the Officer Commanding the Air Corps is not given the autonomy to fix the problem.
'He has no budget control to fix this – there is no CEO in the world that does not have the power to allocate resources – this is at the political level and no action has beentaken.
'The consequences are very severe for national security, maritime patrol and even in the case of the emergency transfer of organs. There needs a ministerial intervention – officials don't have directions to act and the military have no powers,' he added.
The Garda Air Support Unit (GASU) is also based at Baldonnel, in addition to military operations. The unit includes helicopters, and the force is also due to take delivery of a new fixed-wing surveillance aircraft.
There's concern among sources we spoke to that An Garda Síochána may leave Baldonnel due to the air traffic control issue.
Statements have been requested from the Department of Defence and the Irish Defence Forces.
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
3 hours ago
- Irish Independent
‘It's absolutely the best time to highlight the benefits of emigration to the US – Trump says he is all for legal immigration'
Thousands who got Morrison visas in the 1990s are showing their gratitude to the politician who made it happen, says businesswoman Elaine Brennan Today at 21:30 Elaine Brennan was in London in 1994 when her mother phoned to say she'd won the lottery. Not the Lotto, you understand, although almost as lucrative and life-changing. It was the lottery for Morrison visas, which allowed about 45,000 Irish people to live and work in the United States at a time when the economy here was ailing. 'There was almost 20pc unemployment,' Brennan recalls. 'I remember looking at job applications, and the only one I could get an interview for was washing dishes in a hotel in Ennis, and that was with a science degree.'
Irish Independent
3 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Holland & Barrett enjoys healthy revenues on back of store network expansion
Today at 21:30 Pre-tax profits at the Irish unit of health and wellness retailer Holland & Barrett decreased by 37pc to €2.65m last year due to expansion costs. Accounts filed by Holland & Barrett Ltd show profits decreased as revenues rose by 17pc from €56.29m to €66.36m in the 12 months to the end of September last. Register for free to read this story Register and create a profile to get access to our free stories. You'll also unlock more free stories each week.
Irish Independent
3 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Almost one in four Irish earners is paying no income tax, says Revenue
While the number of taxpayer units earning enough to be liable for the standard rate will be just over 2.2 million, an estimated 1.06 million of these, or 30pc, will not pay anything because their liability is fully covered by their tax credits. Another 256,600 taxpayer units, or 7pc of the total, are exempt from income tax. The statistics, contained in an answer by Finance Minister Paschal Donohoe to a Dáil question, means 37pc of earners will pay no income tax this year. In an annual report on the Irish economy, published yesterday, the European Commission emphasised the need to reduce the risks created by the high concentration of tax revenue among a relatively small number of payers. Ireland should broaden its tax base, given the reliance on relatively few foreign-owned multinationals, and there is particular scope for expanding the local property charge, the commission says. 'Ireland's labour-tax system is highly progressive, but it relies on a narrow tax base,' according to the report, which says the top 10pc of taxpayers accounted for approximately 60pc of the tax yield in 2022. This concentration of revenue means the tax base is vulnerable to economic shifts. Ireland's labour-tax revenues are well below the EU average, and 'to cope with high projected budget expenses, diversification in Ireland's public revenue structure is warranted', the report says. Ireland's share of labour taxes as a proportion of GDP is not even half the EU average, and remains below the EU average when adjusted to GNI*, a measure of economic activity that takes out the distorting effect of multinationals. There is also scope to expand the local property charge, since the revenue collected – which was 1.8pc of GNI* in 2022 – is also below the EU average, which was 2.1pc that year. On the spending side, the European Commission calls on Ireland to 'reinforce' defence spending in line with decisions reached by the European Council in March. The report points out that spending on defence in Ireland remained stable at 0.2pc of GDP between 2021 and 2023. According to its forecast, it will remain at this level for both last year and this year. This means there has been no change in four years. ADVERTISEMENT As the healthcare system is overly reliant on costly hospital care, exacerbated by the lack of universal primary care coverage, there is scope for reform to alleviate the strain on hospitals The commission says there are still concerns about the impact that spending by the healthcare system is having on fiscal sustainability. The ageing of the population is going to mean an increase in health spending of 1.5pc of GDP by 2070, while across the EU the average increase is projected to be 0.4pc. 'As the healthcare system is overly reliant on costly hospital care, exacerbated by the lack of universal primary care coverage, there is scope for reform to alleviate the strain on hospitals,' the report says. Given the heightened political uncertainty, Ireland's dependence on foreign multinationals needs to be looked at, and the European Commission warns there is an 'urgent need' to build a more resilient, innovation-driven domestic economy. It points out that spending on research and development (R&D) in Ireland is at one of the lowest rates in the EU, accounting for just 0.4pc of GNI*. This has led to a noticeable technology innovation gap between Irish SMEs and their counterparts in comparable European countries. 'Boosting R&D expenditure and providing targeted Research and Innovation (R&I) support could help boost SME productivity,' it says.
