logo
Mumbai 7/11 acquittals: 17 yrs ago, gaps in probe, question mark over identity of accused

Mumbai 7/11 acquittals: 17 yrs ago, gaps in probe, question mark over identity of accused

Indian Express21-07-2025
The Bombay High Court acquittal of all the 12 accused in the July 11, 2006, serial Mumbai train blasts case comes 17 years after a Mumbai Police Crime Branch probe indicated loopholes in its investigation by the Maharashtra Anti Terrorism Squad (ATS).
At a press conference on September 25, 2008, the Crime Branch announced it had busted a key Indian Mujahideen (IM) module and that it was responsible for several blasts since 2005 – including those in Jaipur, Ahmedabad and Delhi between 2006 and 2008, as well as the July 2006 Mumbai serial train blasts.
The ATS chargesheet had held the banned Students' Islamic Movement of India (SIMI) responsible for the blasts, arresting 13 people and chargesheeting 30, including 'Pakistani nationals'.
But as per the Crime Branch, four of the five IM men it arrested in 2008 were actually the absconding 'Pakistani nationals' mentioned in the 2006 blasts chargesheet filed by the ATS.
At the same time, the Crime Branch never claimed that those arrested for the train blasts by the ATS were innocent, or tried the IM men it had itself held for the Mumbai train blasts. The IM module the Crime Branch busted, led by Sadiq Israr Sheikh and including his associates, were, however, convicted for the July 26, 2008, Ahmedabad blasts and remain on trial in some other cases.
'How could the Crime Branch chargesheet them for a crime in which a sister agency had arrested a different set of accused? It was a job for that sister agency to do,' a Central security establishment officer told The Indian Express, adding he was not surprised by the court's acquittal of the 12 accused for the train blasts on Monday.
In its order, the High Court said: 'Punishing the actual perpetrator of a crime is a concrete and essential step toward curbing criminal activities, upholding the rule of law, and ensuring the safety and security of citizens. But creating a false appearance of having solved a case by presenting that the accused have been brought to justice gives a misleading sense of resolution. This deceptive closure undermines public trust and falsely reassures society, while in reality, the true threat remains at large… Essentially, this is what the case at hand conveys.'
At the press conference in September 2008, when it suggested that its findings regarding the 2006 blasts case differed from the ATS's, then Mumbai Crime Branch chief Rakesh Maria, accompanied by then Additional CP and current Mumbai Police chief Deven Bharti, said: 'The absconding Pakistani nationals mentioned in the 7/11 case as conspirators are actually the men we have arrested. They had not revealed their true identity during the (blasts) operation, and told their associates they were Pakistani nationals. That's why when their associates were quizzed, they told investigators that those absconding were Pakistanis.'
The Crime Branch 'breakthrough' following the arrest of an alleged car thief, Afzal Usmani, by a team led by one of its inspectors, Arun Chavan. Usmani led Chavan's team to Sadiq Israr Sheikh, Arif Badruddin Sheikh, Mohammed Zakir Abdul Sheikh and Mohammed Ansar, who were then arrested.
The Crime Branch said that during interrogation, Sadiq, who headed the UP module of the IM, said it was he along with fellow IM operative Dr Shahnawaz and two others who had executed the July 2006 train blasts.
According to the Crime Branch investigation, also confirmed by Central agency sources to The Indian Express, Sadiq received a year's training in Pakistan in the use of sophisticated weapons and assembling bombs.
He, along with Shahnawaz, who allegedly also received training in Pakistan, later rented a room in the Sewri area of Mumbai. 'They had been supplied with explosives from across the border. In that Sewri room, Sadiq and Shanawaz assembled bombs in pressure cookers. To avoid suspicion, the four pressure cookers in which bombs were assembled were all bought at different periods of time. Before the blasts, they conducted elaborate recces travelling in first-class compartment of Mumbai locals every day to study the feasibility of their plan. On the day of the blasts, they all boarded Mumbai locals at different times and got down at different stations,' an officer who was part of the investigations told The Indian Express.
According to the officer, during interrogation, Sadiq even expressed anger and sadness at the arrest of Ehtesham Siddiqui, one of the 2006 train blasts accused, and others. 'He told the probe team categorically that the ATS had the wrong people and that they had nothing to do with the blasts. He even said that it was because of (the 2006 train blasts) case that the IM began sending emails claiming responsibility for the terror attacks they executed later,' the officer said.
In fact, until the 2008 arrest of the IM module by the Mumbai Crime Branch, the organisation had been a shadowy entity — so much so that even Central agencies such as the Intelligence Bureau (IB) and R&AW (Research and Analysis Wing) had no clue about what it really was.
The chance discovery was made after Maria roped in Inspector Arun Chavan (now retired) following the serial blasts in Ahmedabad on July 26, 2008, to look into the finding that the cars used for it had been stolen from Navi Mumbai.
Chavan, with the help of Constable Pralhad Madne (an expert in car theft cases), managed to catch the two men who had allegedly stolen the vehicles within a month. The two reportedly told Chavan they stole the cars on the instructions of Afzal Usmani. Chavan's team nabbed Usmani from UP's Mau district on August 24 that year.
'Until then, for all practical purposes, we were groping in the dark… If it was not for that inspector from the Mumbai Crime Branch, we would not have known what the IM was really,' a former IB official, who later tracked the new outfit and is now retired, told The Indian Express.
'In fact, in the four years before the Ahmedabad blasts, when a series of blasts were taking place in different parts of the country, we were chasing Pakistan-backed operative Shahid Bilal. Until then, we believed that the IM was just another name for the LeT (Lashkar-e-Toiba), and that Bilal had perpetrated the blasts. This was the information that even R&AW had at that time. But we learnt later that Bilal had already died in Pakistan by then,' the retired official said.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

PM Modi hits out at Opposition for 'chhichorapan': ‘Kya maja le rahe the'
PM Modi hits out at Opposition for 'chhichorapan': ‘Kya maja le rahe the'

Hindustan Times

time28 minutes ago

  • Hindustan Times

PM Modi hits out at Opposition for 'chhichorapan': ‘Kya maja le rahe the'

Prime Minister Narendra Modi, while addressing the Lok Sabha during the ongoing Parliament session, delivered a sharp rebuke to the Opposition, accusing them of indulging in 'chhichorapan' and politicizing national security. His remarks came during a detailed discussion on Operation Sindoor. Prime Minister Narendra Modi speaks during a debate in the Lok Sabha on the Pahalgam terror attack and Operation Sindoor, at the Monsoon session of Parliament, in New Delhi.(Sansad TV) Referring to the April 22 Pahalgam terrorist attack, PM Modi revealed that India's armed forces launched a precision strike within just 22 minutes of receiving clearance. 'Our armed forces avenged April 22 within 22 minutes with precision attacks,' he said, drawing applause from the Treasury benches. 'Right after the attack, Pakistan thought India would react strongly — and we did.' In a bold statement aimed at Pakistan's nuclear posturing, the Prime Minister said, 'India has proved that nuclear blackmailing will not work anymore. Pakistan's airbases and assets have suffered heavy damage. Many of their airbases are still in ICU.' He emphasized that India's resolve and technological edge were critical in neutralizing terror hubs deep within Pakistani territory. According to PM Modi, key terrorist infrastructure in areas like Bahawalpur and Muridke, long considered out of reach, were 'razed to the ground' by Indian forces using Made-in-India weaponry. 'This is the era of technology-based war. If we had not prepared in the last 10 years, the damage could have been unimaginable,' he noted. The Prime Minister underscored that Operation Sindoor was not just a military victory, but a diplomatic one as well. 'India got the support of all the countries,' Modi said, asserting that the international community backed India's right to defend itself. However, he lamented that while the world stood with India, sections of the domestic Opposition chose to oppose the government. Attack on opposition In one of the more fiery moments of his speech, PM Modi questioned the attitude of some Opposition leaders. 'Kya maja le rahe the?' he asked, referring to their behavior during discussions on Operation Sindoor. 'While the entire country, including the broader Opposition, supported the Centre, Saheb comes and makes a mockery of our efforts on the Floor of the House. Is this your idea of leadership?' PM Modi asked. No country called out India: PM PM Modi on Tuesday asserted that no country in the world has stopped India from taking action in its defence against terrorism, but lamented that while the nation got support from the entire world, the Congress could not stand behind the valour of the country's soldiers. Responding to the two-day debate on the Pahalgam attack and Operation Sindoor in the Lok Sabha, the prime minister said Pakistani airbases hit by India "are still in ICU" and the masterminds of the April 22 terror attack are still having sleepless nights. "No country in the world has stopped India from any action in its defence against terrorism. Only three countries spoke in favour of Pakistan at the UN. "India got support from the entire world, but it is unfortunate that the Congress did not support the valour of our soldiers. Congress leaders targeted me for political gains but their frivolous statements ended up discouraging our brave soldiers," he said.

'India Achieved Target...Pakistan Now Knows': PM Modi Shuts Down Opposition Over Op Sindoor Criticism
'India Achieved Target...Pakistan Now Knows': PM Modi Shuts Down Opposition Over Op Sindoor Criticism

News18

time34 minutes ago

  • News18

'India Achieved Target...Pakistan Now Knows': PM Modi Shuts Down Opposition Over Op Sindoor Criticism

PM Narendra Modi said with 'Operation Sindoor', India achieved its target and that was to show any future aggressors that it can go to any extent Responding to opposition leader Rahul Gandhi's remarks on the 'new normal", Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Tuesday said terror masterminds now know that India will attack and Pakistan has realised that its neighbour's response will be tougher than before. Modi said with 'Operation Sindoor', India achieved its target and that was to show any future aggressors that it can go to any extent. His comments came as Gandhi, who spoke before him during the ongoing monsoon session of Parliament, accused the central government of lacking political will to support the Indian armed forces. 'Pakistan now knows that India's response is tougher than before. It realises that in future, India can go to any extent. The situation has changed now. Masterminds of terror know India will come and attack," Modi said during the debate on 'Operation Sindoor', which was a military retaliation to the Pahalgam terror attack that claimed 26 lives on April 22. 'Terrorist bases were destroyed in Pakistan…we achieved what we decided. Some people are interested in wilful amnesia, but India does not forget. We remember from Day 1, it was clear that our target is terrorists and their infrastructure and we did it," he said, adding that India achieved its target '100 percent". He said the military gave a decisive response when Pakistan chose to brazenly back terrorists. 'We ensured that both Pakistan's army and we clearly understood each other's intentions. We, therefore, communicated our objective to them," he added. When Pakistan came out in support of terrorists, India's missiles, drones caused unimaginable loss; forced Pakistan to its knees: PM Modi. PTI SKU SKU KSS KSS . Indian forces showed Pakistan that they had destroyed terror sites within minutes; we made our capabilities clear to them: PM Modi. PTI SKU BJ SKU KSS KSS . On May 7, Indian armed forces stated publicly that they have struck terror sites inside Pakistan: PM Modi on Operation Sindoor. PTI SKU BJ SKU KSS KSS . For Operation Sindoor, India had decided to attack the epicentre of terror that had supported Pahalgam terrorists: PM Modi in Lok Sabha. PTI SKU BJ SKU KSS KSS . New Delhi: Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Tuesday asserted that no country in the world has stopped India from taking action in its defence against terrorism, but lamented that while the nation got support from the entire world, the Congress could not stand behind the valour of the country's soldiers. Responding to the two-day debate on the Pahalgam attack and Operation Sindoor in the Lok Sabha, the prime minister said Pakistani airbases hit by India 'are still in ICU" and the masterminds of the April 22 terror attack are still having sleepless nights. 'No country in the world has stopped India from any action in its defence against terrorism. Only three countries spoke in favour of Pakistan at the UN. 'India got support from the entire world, but it is unfortunate that the Congress did not support the valour of our soldiers. Congress leaders targeted me for political gains but their frivolous statements ended up discouraging our brave soldiers," he said. The prime minister noted that India called out Pakistan's nuclear bluff and showed the world that 'we will not bow down to nuclear blackmail". 'Our operations range from Sindoor to Sindhu (Indus Waters Treaty)… Pakistan knows they have to pay a huge price for any misadventure. Terror attacks were launched earlier and the masterminds of attacks knew nothing would happen, but now they know India will come for them." PM Modi said drones and missiles made in India exposed the capabilities of Pakistani arms and ammunition during the military operation. 'The world saw the strength of self-reliant India during Operation Sindoor. We destroyed terror sites deep inside Pakistan within 22 minutes to avenge the April 22 Pahalgam attack," he said. Modi noted that Pakistan had some inkling of Indian action and had started issuing nuclear threats, but could do nothing when terror targets were hit. 'It (Pahalgam attack) was a conspiracy to instigate riots in India and the country's unity foiled that attempt. When I speak of this Parliament session being a Vijayotsav (celebration of victory), it is of destroying the headquarters of terror," he said. 'I stand here to make a case for India, and to show a mirror to those who do not understand this. I had said that we will teach the terrorists and their masters a befitting lesson which will be beyond their imagination. 'We have complete trust in the capabilities of our armed forces and they were given a free hand to respond. The armed forces taught them such a lesson that the masters of terrorism are still losing their sleep over it," he added. PTI SKU GJS NAB GJS RT RT . About the Author Oindrila Mukherjee Oindrila Mukherjee is a senior sub-editor who works for the rewrite and breaking news desks. Her nine years of experience in print and digital journalism range from editing and reporting to writing impactful More Get breaking news, in-depth analysis, and expert perspectives on everything from politics to crime and society. Stay informed with the latest India news only on News18. Download the News18 App to stay updated! tags : Narendra Modi Operation Sindoor Pahalgam attack Rahul Gandhi view comments Location : New Delhi, India, India First Published: July 29, 2025, 19:37 IST News india 'India Achieved Now Knows': PM Modi Shuts Down Opposition Over Op Sindoor Criticism Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store