New season, same strife between the sticks for Manchester United
Arsenal are good at set pieces; United are vulnerable to inswinging deliveries. In December last year Arsenal beat United 2-0 at the Emirates Stadium, both goals the result of corners. United had André Onana in goal for that one, but Tottenham had taken notice of the susceptibility to balls arced into the goalmouth, the way United struggled to protect their keeper.
Two weeks later, Spurs played United in the Carabao Cup. Altay Bayindir was in goal for that one and endured the indignity of being beaten direct from a corner by Son Heung-min.
United don't like inswingers and Bayindir really doesn't like inswingers. Declan Rice is good at taking inswingers. And so there was a certain inevitability to what happened after 13 minutes. United had looked vaguely threatening. Arsenal had been rattled enough to commit four fouls in that period. Then Arsenal won a corner from their left. Rice whipped it in, Bayindir flapped and would have scored an own-goal had Riccardo Calafiori not nodded the ball in the line from the goal-line.
Read More
Workmanlike Arsenal dig in to cloud new Manchester United dawn
Fundamentally, with more decisive goalkeeping any potential foul wouldn't have been an issue. David Raya's assertive punch to clear an inswinging free-kick from Bruno Fernandes early in the second half, cuffing Matthijs de Ligt out of the way, showed the way to do it.
Maybe the analogy was never entirely apt. Maybe building from the foundations up doesn't necessarily mean getting the defence right.
Maybe as football increasingly becomes about content production there is some sort of commercial logic in prioritising the goalscorers and the creators, the players who will look good clipped up or, to continue the metaphor, the spire, the ornamentation on the roof. But on the other hand, it doesn't much matter if you've spent £200m on forwards if you're going to concede goals like that. Particularly if you don't then actually score yourself.
There were positive signs from both Bryan Mbeumo and Matheus Cunha but the most incisive United player, yet again, was Amad Diallo, who came off the bench to play at right wing-back 10 minutes into the second half.
To point out that United drew this fixture last season and that they're therefore doing worse this season is on one level meaningless. But equally this is a manager whose win percentage is 37.2%, the worst in half a century – and if United fail to win at Fulham next week, he will drop below both Frank O'Farrell and Wilf McGuinness to have the worst win percentage of any United manager since Herbert Bamlett, who was sacked in 1931. Context matters.
There was plenty of mitigation. But it won't take many more bad results for faith in Amorim to wane. When form has been so bad, it's only natural to catastrophise: if they don't win at Craven Cottage, the next home match, against newly-promoted Burnley, takes on a ghastly aspect: not merely a game they should win, but a game they have to win.
This season is not discrete from the last. Poor results are a problem not only in themselves but for the impact they have on games to come: time present and time past are both perhaps present in time future.
Guardian
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Daily Mirror
15 minutes ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
‘Silky' - No surprise at the Irishman who makes Aston Villa legend's all-time XI
Aston Villa legend Tony Daley spent over nine years as a first-team regular at the Birmingham-based club - so he has seen plenty of teammates come and go. So when he was asked by Villa to name his all-time club XI, only the best made the cut. During his time at Aston Villa, Daley played with five Ireland internationals, but only one of those has made his dream team. Tony Cascarino, Steve Staunton, Ray Houghton and Andy Townsend all lined out in the claret and blue during his time there, but they didn't make the cut. However, Daley did have a place in his XI for Paul McGrath, who joined Villa from Manchester United in August 1989 and played there until 1996. During his time at Villa Park, McGrath won two League Cups, in 1993/94 and 1995/96, as well as a host of individual awards. Paul McGrath of Aston Villa (Image: Mark Leech/Offside via Getty Images) Discussing his pick, Daley told the Villa website: 'I had the pleasure of playing with McGrath for four years and he was an outstanding player. 'What I really love about him is we talk about his ability, how silky he was in defence, how he'd come out with the ball and how great he passes the ball, but when he had to put it in row Z, it went into row Z.' As for the rest of Daley's all-time XI, he went for World Cup winner Emi Martinez in goal, and Allan Evans alongside McGrath, describing the former Scotland international as 'so gentle off the field.' On it, however, Daley said: 'He'd kick his own granny, a completely different character – aggressive, wanting to win the ball. In training, he'd boot you up in the air and then pick you up.' The full-backs are Colin Gibson and Earl Barrett, with Gordon Cowans, David Platt and Stilyan Petrov in midfield. And up front is Dwight Yorke, flanked by Mark Walters and Tony Morley. Get the latest sports headlines straight to your inbox by signing up for free email .
The Irish Sun
2 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
Alejandro Garnacho's Chelsea transfer is being held up by Blues' Christopher Nkunku stance as Man Utd set out demands
GARNA WAIT Alejandro Garnacho's Chelsea transfer is being held up by Blues' Christopher Nkunku stance as Man Utd set out demands CHELSEA'S pursuit of Manchester United's Alejandro Garnacho has been stalled by the West London club's steep valuation of Christopher Nkunku. The Blues have rejected a loan bid from Bayern Munich for Nkunku, 27, preferring a £50million sale to raise the funds to buy Garnacho for the same price. 2 Chelsea are yet to meet Alejandro Garnacho's asking price Credit: Shutterstock Editorial 2 The Blues rejected Bayern Munich's loan offer for Christopher Nkunku Credit: Getty Advertisement United are braced for an offer from Stamford Bridge chiefs for the Argentina international, but are determined not to let the young winger leave on the cheap. The Red Devils want at least £50m for the 21-year-old winger. It's understood that Garnacho only wants Chelsea, which is the main reason why he is still at Carrington nearly three months after boss Ruben Amorim told him to find a new club. The relationship between the two sides has completely broken down and on Sunday a mural of Garnacho close to Old Trafford was defaced by fans. Advertisement READ MORE ON MAN UTD SAVE US Neville and Rooney tells Man Utd to sign one of two players after Arsenal defeat As an academy graduate, the money raised will have a huge impact on United's Profit and Sustainability checks as his sale will be marked as pure profit. But, the negotiations - which must be completed before the close of the summer window in 14 days time - will be a major test for United chiefs. The Red Devils know Chelsea will attempt to drive the price down for Garnacho, who has been training alone with the 'Bomb Squad' after being iced out. Insiders at Old Trafford note the Blues' reluctance to sell one of their unwanted forwards Nkunku for less than £50m. Advertisement BEST FREE BETS AND BETTING SIGN UP OFFERS Nkunku's hefty price tag is guiding Chelsea's moves for Garnacho and RB Leipzig star Xavi Simons. Garnacho's exit would open the door for United to bag a new goalkeeper with Andre Onana and second stopper Altay Bayindir not up to scratch. Wayne Rooney and Gary Neville both make transfer plea to Man Utd after Arsenal clash Bayindir deputised for the injured Onana for United's 1-0 defeat to Arsenal in their Premier League opener on Sunday. The Turk, 27, was at fault for the goal after he flapped at Declan Rice's inswinging corner, which was headed in by Riccardo Calafiori in the 13th minute. Advertisement SunSport exclusively revealed that United have made discreet checks over a remarkable return for club legend David de Gea from Fiorentina. Amorim's side were tipped off that the Spaniard, 34, has a clause in his deal at Fiorentina — allowing him to leave for a relatively small sum. Gianluigi Donnarumma has also been linked with both United and Manchester City after being relegated to No.2 at Paris Saint-Germain with one year left on his deal. Italy stopper Donnarumma, 26, is set to demand a bumper 50 per cent rise on his current £210,000 per week salary.
Irish Daily Mirror
2 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
'My life is on hold. It has been a kick in the balls' - Colin Hawkins opens up
His day began in a waiting room, a real-life purgatory. The clock ticked past nine when he took his seat. He recalls the noise of the water cooler; the rise and fall in volume as people passed along the corridor. Otherwise there was silence, which is not an uncommon thing on the seventh floor of the Mater Hospital, where cancer patients get their treatment. Read more: AZ Almaar manager's snappy response to question about Troy Parrott's future Read more: Shock report suggests Manchester United and Liverpool are eyeing up Ireland star And on this sunny Friday morning, this was where Colin Hawkins, one of only 20 Irish footballers to win a medal at an official World Cup event, went to discover if the cancer drug they'd given him would save his life. The clock ticked on. It was just after ten when he left his chair to take in the view from the seventh floor window; Croke Park to the right, Dalymount Park to the left. It was Dayler where Hawkins played when he was 25-years-old and considered the best defender in the League of Ireland. 'You felt invincible,' he says of his days as a professional footballer. But no one ever is. Still, at that stage of his life, the midpoint of a professional career, it is no exaggeration to say he was among the country's healthy elite. Now, as a 47-year-old man, his feelings of invincibility are over. So he sat back down for his appointment and waited, every second feeling like a minute, every minute an hour. Time passed. Time didn't heal. He thought about his upbringing. He was one of ten children, the only one of his siblings to become a professional athlete, a four-times winner of the League of Ireland, later a player with Coventry City in England's Championship, Europe's fifth best attended league. 'I probably took my health for granted,' he says. 'Put it this way, it was a big shock to my nine siblings that I was the one who got so ill. 'It can't be you, you are the sports guy', they said.' But it was him because cancer is a democratic illness. Anyone can be diagnosed with it. A King of England died from it. It doesn't discriminate against rich or poor. 'It is two-and-a-half years since I was first diagnosed,' Hawkins says. 'And the thing you learn about this life is that you don't know when your time is (up). 'I don't feel punished or whatever. It is just unlucky. Still, if you ever want a wake-up call about why you should enjoy every day of your life, go into the Mater every Friday. 'Walk to the seventh floor. Go into the waiting room where you receive your treatment. You are handed a number. A person sits to your left, another to your right. 'I keep asking, 'how is this place so busy? Are more and more people getting cancer than ever before?' Their answer is actually reaffirming. 'No,' they tell me, 'more and more people are surviving.' Colin Hawkins is drawing the positives from life. (Image: ©INPHO/Donall Farmer) By now it was 11am. He still had the ticket in his hand. It resembled a small raffle ticket, a beige colour. He waited and thought back to 2023 when he started to feel unwell. By the time he discovered he had cancer in his blood, the pain became practically unbearable. He subsequently needed surgery on his neck and his back. 'When the myeloma is alive and active, that is when your bones break,' he says matter of factly. 'When it is gone and under control, all that pain is gone.' Good news came. He received stem cell treatment and entered remission. Then terrible news followed. His wife, Elaine, was diagnosed with breast cancer. Telling their three children this news was the hardest day of their lives. Better days came after that. Elaine's treatment worked. She, thankfully, is in remission. Life returned to normal for a while until his old pains resurfaced. He visited Dr O'Gorman in the Mater to review a new drug he had been on for six weeks. 'Your numbers have gone through the roof and your myeloma has gone crazy again,' he was told. 'We need to take you off this drug and get you on a new one.' That was three months ago. He had to check into the hospital that night and ended up staying for a month to see if he could deal with the side-effects of the drug. He got pancreatitis. There is pain and then there is pain. Pancreatitis was hell. But this feeling he had on that Friday morning was way worse, sitting on a blue chair, holding a beige-coloured ticket, staring at the clock, waiting and wondering. If the news was good, if he was told the drug was working, then life would go on. He'd return to work 'to CPM, the best employers in the world who have looked after me while I have been ill'. But if this drug wasn't working, what then? Was there a fifth drug they could try? He hadn't asked. 'Sitting in that room, waiting for that news was the first time I was seriously worried. Three treatments had failed. 'I had my bloods taken the day before. I had scans. As the clock ticked towards noon. I was waiting to be told if my numbers had improved or got worse. 'I have always fought it (his cancer) head on. This was the first time when I realised this was a trial drug; so if this doesn't work then what the hell is the next treatment?' The stem cell transplant he had received was supposed to give him ten years in remission. 'For the cancer to come back after 18 months was kind of unheard of for my age. I was obviously nervous waiting for the result.' Nervous waiting for a result! He remembers the first time he issued those words, back in 1998. He was a St Pat's player then. They won that year's League of Ireland title on the last day of the season, beating Kilkenny City away. But to become champions, they needed Dundalk to defeat their rivals, Shelbourne. So they waited for a result from Oriel Park. They got the news they wanted. The following year something similar happened, Pat's beating Bray on the final day of the season to win back-to-back titles. Consumed by the game, he worked to make the most of what he had, reaching an incredibly high level, representing his country at underage level, winning bronze at the 1997 Under 20 World Cup. And when he spent a month in the Mater Hospital over Easter, all those players from all those teams came in to visit. Brian Kerr, his Ireland manager in 1997, checks in at least once a week. Brian Kerr, the former St Pat's and Ireland manager, is still a regular at Saints games (Image: ©INPHO/Tom Maher) 'Brian has been incredible,' Hawkins says. 'He has such a big heart. Football people, they're great. They don't forget. They remember the big nights, you being there for them on the pitch. "This time they were there for me. All these years later and the dressing room spirit is still strong. It's why football is special.' Yet now all those characteristics which made him such a winner were being put to the test. He says: 'My life is on hold. Thursday I get the bloods done, Friday my treatment. It has been a kick in the balls. That is where my life is at the moment. 'I am not working because I don't have the energy. My immune system is really low. I kind of feel I have a permanent flu or a chest infection.' Yet he isn't feeling sorry for himself because he has spoken to people in the chair next to him in that waiting room, swiftly realising if they have no hope. And on this Friday morning three and a half hours elapsed before Dr O'Gorman called. And that was when the man who played in a World Cup U20 semi-final for Ireland, got up off the blue chair and walked into a doctor's office. In those steps, the fact he had been a champion footballer on four different occasions ceased to matter. He was just another number, waiting to hear if his cancer drug was helping. 'It is,' said Professor O'Gorman. 'You are responding well.' That was eight weeks ago. Today Colin Hawkins is in remission. This champion football player has just won the biggest prize of his life. Get the latest sports headlines straight to your inbox by signing up for free email .
