Why Parks Tau backs Sizekhaya Holdings for the national lottery licence
Image: GCIS
The Minister of Trade, Industry and Competition, Parks Tau, has publicly defended the ongoing controversy surrounding the award of the highly anticipated fourth national lottery licence to Sizekhaya Holdings.
Tau was legally obligated to disclose his reasons for selecting the company in an affidavit, doing so in response to two court challenges requesting a review of the award.
Tau has finally disclosed his reasons for awarding the contract to Sizekhaya citing the consortium's well-balanced bid, impressive technology partners, and high projected revenue as the reasons for its selection.
He also commended Sizekhaya's plans to rejuvenate the suite of current lottery games and its broader marketing plans and spend.
Tau's affidavit, filed in the Gauteng High Court in Pretoria, also reveals that Sizekhaya Holdings "pipped the others to the post" due to its impressive bid.
'The bids by Giya Games, Lekalinga, and Umbelelo were ranked the lowest, while those by Bosela, Ithuba Lottery, Ringeta, Sizekhaya, and Wina Njalo were neck and neck,' Tau wrote in the affidavit.
He highlighted Sizekhaya's "strong technology partners" and "high revenue projections" as key factors influencing the decision.
The decision has also been marred by controversy, with allegations of political interference and connections between Sizekhaya's shareholders, the ANC and Deputy President Paul Mashatile.
Tau has been accused of not adequately addressing concerns about Mashatile's alleged connections to Sizekhaya Holdings.
In the affidavit, Tau explained why he launched an investigation into the involvement of politicians, including Mashatile, in the tender awarding process.
Mashatile's sister-in-law, Khutso Bogatsu, reportedly has shares in the company, sparking concerns about potential conflicts of interest.
In response to these allegations, Tau said: 'I have instructed the National Lotteries Commission (NLC) to investigate the alleged connections.
Tau revealed his decision to override his advisory panels, setting aside Ringeta's bid due to its affiliation with the Batho Batho Trust, a known ANC donor.
Ringeta had initially been favored by both the bid evaluation and adjudication committees, but was later flagged by a quality assurance committee (QAC) appointed by Tau.
'My decision was delayed because I was not convinced that the processes and outcomes were correct…This prompted speculation and even accusations that I was trying to favour one or other applicants. Nothing could be further from the truth. I refused to simply rubber stamp recommendations,' Tau said.
The QAC's findings showed that Dr. Sibongiseni Dhlomo, an ANC MP, served as a trustee of the Batho Batho Trust.
This made him an "office bearer," which is prohibited by both the Lotteries Act and the Request for Proposals (RFP) terms.
Tau received legal counsel confirming Dhlomo's direct financial interest through the trust's 70% shareholding in Ringeta.
The awarding of the contract to Sizekhaya Holdings has been met with court challenges from losing bidders, including Lekalinga and Ithuba Lottery.
Tau and other respondents will have to file answering affidavits before trial dates are set.
The DA has criticised Tau for relying on the NLC to investigate, given its failure to flag potential conflicts of interest in the bidding process.
'The DA will continue to seek answers on this clearly flawed process through our PAIA application and by ensuring the Minister accounts to Parliament.
'It is extremely concerning that the NLC evaluation and adjudication committees both failed to flag the glaring conflict of interest of their top candidate for the award of the lotto licence, Ringeta…the conflict of interest in awarding one of the state's largest tenders to a bidder part-owned by an ANC funding vehicle with a sitting ANC MP on its board of trustees is patently obvious,' DA Spokesperson on Trade, Industry & Competition, Toby Chance said.
mashudu.sadike@inl.co.za
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
TimesLIVE
11 hours ago
- TimesLIVE
Paul Mashatile punts new US trade proposal for tariff relief
Deputy President Paul Mashatile said the adoption of a new trade proposal to the US could relieve tariff-related pressures on the automotive manufacturing sector. Mashatile was addressing journalists and delegates on the final day of the 2025 National Association of Automotive Component and Allied Manufacturers (Naacam) Show in Gqeberha this week. "[The proposal] aims not just to settle the 30% tariff but also has ramifications for more than 130 other trading partners who may reroute products into the South African market,' he said. 'The imposed tariffs threaten to disrupt well-established trade flows and weaken the global competitiveness of South Africa's automotive manufacturing ecosystem,' the minister noted, adding that ongoing engagement with the US would yield practical solutions. 'I must highlight that there will be repercussions felt throughout the entire value chain if we do not reach an amicable trade agreement with the White House.' Mashatile encouraged collaboration under the 2018 African Continental Free Trade Area (AfCFTA); whose mandates include reducing trade barriers, fostering regional value chains and harmonising regulations. 'Creating a single continental market for goods and services could potentially lead to increased trade, investment and job creation in Africa.' The deputy president acknowledged the need to protect the automotive sector, which employs about 115,000 people, of whom 80,000 work in the component sector. 'We must never allow the loss of these gains because of external and internal pressures.' He cited Naacam's recording of 12 company closures as worrying, reported to have affected 4,000 individuals. 'What is of more concern are the recently released figures by Stats SA showing that the country's unemployment rate has climbed to 33.2% in the second quarter of 2025, up from 32.9% in the previous quarter.'
The Citizen
12 hours ago
- The Citizen
12 companies close, 4 000 jobs lost as US tariffs and sales slump bite automotive industry
The automotive industry was in big trouble before with a slump in new vehicle sales and this has now intensified with the introduction of the US tariffs. The US tariffs and a slump in new vehicle sales caused 12 companies to close and 4 000 people lose their jobs over the past two years. The erosion of the industrial value of the automotive indsutry is emphasised by recent suspensions at Mercedes-Benz and other Original Equipment Manufacturers. Minister of Trade, Industry and Competition Parks Tau shared this grim news with people who attended the annual National Association of Automotive Component and Allied Manufacturers (NAACAM) show on Thursday. He pointed out that the automotive sector is the cornerstone of South Africa's manufacturing economy, contributing 5.2% to gross domestic product (GDP) and 22.6% of industrial output. 'This industry faces intersecting challenges that demand urgent collaboration but within these challenges lie transformative opportunities to redefine and leverage our global competitiveness.' ALSO READ: Automotive Business Council concerned about Trump's tariffs Automotive industry faces stark reality The automotive industry employs 115 000 South Africans directly, with over 80 000 in component manufacturing alone. However, Tau says, we confront a stark reality that domestic sales of locally produced vehicles plummeted to 515 850 units in 2024, far below the South Africa Automotive Masterplan 2035 target of 784 509. He said it is also important to remember that 64% of vehicles sold in South Africa are imports, eroding local production scales. 'Compounding this, local content remains stagnant at 39%, well short of the 60% target, while US tariffs now significantly affect our R28.7 billion automotive exports. These pressures triggered 12 company closures and over 4 000 job losses in two years.' According to Tau, localisation is not merely policy compliance, but existential. 'A 5% increase in local content would unlock R30 billion in new procurement, dwarfing the R4.4 billion US export market. To achieve this, we must act collectively to address some of the bottlenecks to growth. 'Therefore, we are reviewing the Automotive Production Development Programme (APDP) as a comprehensive way of responding to the challenges the sector face, but also to ensure that we see regular growth in the sector to meet the goals of the Automotive Masterplan. 'Some of these reforms include the incentive structure and shifting duty credits to reward manufacturing instead of assembly credits. 'Our critical minerals and metals strategy will prioritise beneficiating platinum group metals (PGMs), copper and manganese for high-value new energy vehicles components such as fuel cells and batteries. Isondo Precious Metals' fuel cell plant in the OR Tambo SEZ proves this viability.' ALSO READ: South Africa faces 25% tariff on US car imports, Minister Parks Tau voices concern Is innovation the answer for automotive industry? Turning to innovation, Tau said global competitiveness hinges on embracing disruption. 'We have been on a path of developing a new industrial policy which focuses on decarbonisation, digitisation and diversification and we follow the example of players in the auto sector. 'In the area of digitisation, Eastern Cape pioneers like S4 and Jendamark demonstrate how AI and automation can future-proof operations.' In decarbonisation, Tau said Borbet SA's 20-year solar energy commitment and Malben Engineering's green steel pilot project align with global carbon rules reshaping trade. As NAACAM notes, carbon has become 'part of the cost of doing business – and increasingly, part of the value too'. Turning to diversification, Tau said catalytic converter exports, historically our lead sub-sector, are declining due to EV shifts and Chinese competition. 'We must scale new products, such as e-axles and thermal systems as well as markets, particularly under the Africa Continental Free Trade Agreement (AfCFTA).' ALSO READ: Devastating impact of US tariffs on SA automotive sector even before implementation Transformation in the automotive industry 'We walked a long journey with the automotive sector on transformation. Therefore, it goes without saying that inclusion drives growth. The South Africa Automotive Masterplan 2035's target of 130 new black-owned manufacturers is advancing, with 26 black-owned MSMEs exhibiting, supported by the Automotive Industry Transformation Fund and OEM partnerships such as Toyota-Isuzu's supplier development programme. 'As you would agree, the pace does need to be hastened. Therefore, we are hopeful that the industry will support the endeavour of the Transformation Fund that we are pursuing at the dtic with the view to enhance overall transformation through enterprise and supplier development (ESD) funds.' ALSO READ: US tariffs: SA sends new proposal but no changes to laws Tau emphasised that South Africa must accelerate skills development to ensure that we prepare our labour force for the dramatic changes that artificial intelligence will bring into the sector. 'It is therefore critical that we partner with institutions in the country to address this urgently. 'Entrenching supply chain equity through initiatives like linking equity investments to procurement from black-owned tier 2/3 suppliers will create symbiotic growth. As government, we are also working hard to eliminate compliance burdens and reduce red tape which inhibits investment in our country's automotive sector. 'Our policy response is accelerating and we plan on introducing an Omnibus (general laws amendment) Bill to fast-track high-impact investments and projects within 90 days. This is but one of the ambitious plans we have for the medium-term. ALSO READ: 'Open our eyes and ears' – Ramaphosa on how to tackle US tariff hike on SA cars ITAC to look into impact of exports on automotive industry 'We will also, through the International Trade Administration Commission (ITAC), look at the impact of imports into the country and the impact they have on local production. We want to grow the sector and therefore our first option must not be to wield a stick but rather offer a carrot to these companies to attract more investment into the country, increasing the value-add of particularly our component manufacturers.' Tau pointed out that the Eastern Cape produces 46% of South Africa's vehicles and 54% of its exports, epitomising our potential. Therefore, he said, everyone has the responsibility to reignite the collective ambition that drives NAACAM's advocacy. 'With South Africa chairing the G20, our automotive sector can model African industrial resilience rooted in localisation, powered by innovation and fortified by equity.'
The Citizen
13 hours ago
- The Citizen
Mashatile warns of serious consequences if SA can't secure trade deal with US
Government will send another delegation to the US to push for better trade terms. Deputy President Paul Mashatile has warned of the consequences South Africa will face if the country fails to secure a trade a deal with the United States (US), following the imposition of a 30% tariff. Mashatile was speaking at the National Association of Automotive Component and Allied Manufacturers (NAACAM) show in Gqeberha on Thursday. His visit to the Eastern Cape came as negotiations with the US continue. ALSO READ: US tariffs: Here's why talks over trade deal have been 'complex' Earlier this month, US President Donald Trump's administration introduced a 30% tariff on all South African exports. Vehicle and auto component products have separately been subject to a 25% tariff since April. South Africa has since submitted a new trade proposal aimed at reducing these tariff levels. Mashatile warns of US tariffs impact During his speech, Mashatile acknowledged that the automotive and manufacturing sectors, while historically a 'success story', are currently navigating 'tough times'. 'The automotive sector in South Africa is one of the country's most strategically important and internationally linked industries, accounting for 22.6% of manufacturing output and 5.2% of the country's GDP,' he remarked. He highlighted that the automotive industry employs more than 115 000 people, with over 80 000 working in the component sector, which exported R62.5 billion worth of products in 2024. With unemployment at 33.2%, Mashatile warned that the issue remains critical. READ MORE: US tariffs: SA sends new proposal but no changes to laws NAACAM has recorded 12 company closures in the past two years, affecting 4 000 workers. 'We must never allow the loss of these gains because of external and internal pressures. I say this with concern because the employment levels in the sector have been under strain due to ongoing economic pressures and reduced production volumes,' he said. Mashatile stressed the importance of diversifying investment and expanding trade partnerships. 'It is for this reason that the Cabinet has adopted a new trade proposal to the United States that aims not just to settle the 30 percent tariff but also has ramifications for over 130 other trading partners who may reroute products into the South African market.' He reiterated that failure to reach an 'amicable' trade agreement with the US would result in 'repercussions felt throughout the entire value chain'. Watch Mashatile's speech below: This, Mashatile said, could lead to volume cutbacks for South African suppliers serving domestic original equipment manufacturers (OEMs) that export to the US – affecting production planning, employment and investment decisions. 'South African automobiles and components would see a direct rise in the landed cost in the US market. 'Because of this, they would be unable to compete with goods from nations that have continued preferential or zero-duty access, such as those in the United States, Mexico, Canada Agreement.' New delegation headed to the US Mashatile also announced that government will send another delegation to the US to push for better trade terms. 'The imposed tariffs threaten to disrupt well-established trade flows and weaken the global competitiveness of South Africa's automotive manufacturing ecosystem. 'However, South Africa remains resilient and steadfast in its efforts to grow and protect our economy. We will continue to engage with the United States to identify practical solutions. 'The president will once again be sending a delegation to the White House to engage with the US administration on this matter.' A previous delegation – led by President Cyril Ramaphosa and including Cabinet ministers, Cosatu President Zingiswa Losi, businessman Johann Rupert, and professional golfers Ernie Els and Retief Goosen – visited the White House in Washington DC in May in an effort to ease tensions with the Trump administration. NOW READ: Business confidence increases, but will come under pressure from US tariff
