Dangers Of Excessive Spending Highlighted
Treasury's latest report highlights the dangers of excessive government spending, Finance Minister Nicola Willis says.
The Treasury's Long-term Insights Briefing released today explores the role of fiscal policy in economic shocks and crises including the way government finances were used during and after the Covid-19 pandemic.
It says the response, which wound up costing $66 billion, about twice the cost of the Canterbury earthquakes (as a proportion of GDP) also shows the challenges of using big spending measures to respond to one-off shocks.
'Treasury's language is spare and polite, but its conclusions are damning,' Nicola Willis says.
'The report makes clear significant errors were made in the fiscal response to Covid. Treasury is urging policy makers not to repeat those mistakes. Our Government will not.
'The briefing notes that the COVID-19 Response and Recovery Fund was established in May 2020 to 'support a timely economic response and public confidence' but as the economy recovered, the then-government was advised against further stimulating in favour of more targeted support.
'Unfortunately, the Labour government ignored that advice. The consequence was undisciplined spending that pushed up inflation, eroded New Zealand's previously low public debt position, and fuelled a cost-of-living crisis.
'The briefing makes particular mention of programmes 'not tied to the shock (that) had a lagged impact on the economy and proved difficult to unwind in later years'.
'That is a very diplomatic way of saying New Zealanders are still paying the price of the previous government extending a big-spending approach initially intended for a pandemic response.
'The lesson from Labour's mishandling of the Covid response is that while there are times when governments have to increase spending in response to major events the fiscal guardrails should be restored as soon as possible.
'Kiwis can take confidence from the current Government's commitment to strong and responsible fiscal and economic management.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
25 minutes ago
- NZ Herald
Letters: We should hang our heads in shame at the state of Auckland's CBD
Complex problems can take time to solve but we could be exploring immediate, relatively cheap short-term options. Figuratively speaking, one or two fewer road speedbumps would go a long way towards restoring a sense of civic pride and economic wellbeing. Perhaps it is time for the famed and under-utilised creatives of New Zealand to play a part. Vacant shop windows could be brimming with hired paintings and sculptures. Ugly external walls – think globally, think Italy and Singapore – could be plant-adorned hanging gardens. Street art could be part of the mix. Think nooks of pavement planters – Dublin-style multi-layered planters of riotously coloured cascading blooms. Think No 8 wire mentality! But also think of putting it out there to the Auckland community – some of whom may want to financially contribute to this essential CBD recovery. And we are the ratepayers – let's insist to our council through the upcoming elections that it has to do better. Angela Yatri, Oratia. Luxon's turnaround job Warren Cossey's letter (August 6) defending Christopher Luxon from the criticism of him and his coalition is timely, given that the previous Government spent six years destroying the economy and causing social division that has only worsened. During those six years we were constantly told to be kind to one another as if we were children in need of some sort of patronising reminder on how to be an adult. Then, when Labour ministers were asked about particular pressing issues, such as migrant exploitation and ram raids, a lot of the time their inevitable response was a rather lame, 'we're looking into it'. At least Luxon and his team appear to be far more forthright and proactive in what they are doing rather than acting like a possum caught in the headlights. Bernard Walker, Mt Maunganui. Razor needs to find innovation Not long ago when the scribes got together to pick their top 15 rugby players for the year, it was dominated by All Blacks. If they were to pick a squad this year, not many All Blacks would be in the running. Ardie Savea and Tamaiti Williams might get a look-in for the forwards and maybe Cam Roigard and Will Jordan in the backs. The All Blacks have certainly gone backwards, and our new coach is struggling to improve the situation. Razor needs to be a bit more innovative like Rassie if he is going to improve. The next few weeks will show if he is on the right track. Jock MacVicar, Hauraki. Tunnels to nowhere? It must be particularly painful and galling for our older residents who have been waiting for years for urgent surgery to observe how $5.5 billion of public money has been squandered on the rail tunnels to nowhere? It is patently obvious that this emerald-plated project has had no independent fiscal scrutiny or cost-benefit analysis. This has allowed a phalanx of assorted consultants and contractors to have a field day paid from the public purse. The pigs-in-the-trough syndrome still appears to be alive and well in Aotearoa. For example, how much has been paid to Mana Whenua in consultancy and other fees? Bruce Tubb, Devonport. Alternative to butter Unlike Wendy Galloway (letters, August 3), I have no qualms about using an alternative to butter to make a white sauce. Indeed, my granddaughter once announced, to her mother's chagrin, that I made the best cheese sauce in the world. Mind you, she was only 4, and hasn't repeated that in the 20 years since, so maybe her palate has become more refined. Or perhaps she was simply currying favour. Peter Jackson, Kaitaia. Not all doom and gloom What a balanced and thoughtful piece by Liam Dann (August 3). In particular it was interesting to learn that Paul Bloxham, HSBC Australia-New Zealand chief economist, while negative about Australian growth, is one of the most positive economists about New Zealand growth. As we continue to consider our economic, political, social, cultural and environmental future, we always need to be mindful of the way in which social and other media distorts the picture of where we are heading. Dann's piece shows the important role of the media in political reporting. As Sir Geoffrey Palmer wrote, 'The media plays a vital role in sending communications from the governors to the governed.' Glennys Adams, Oneroa.
NZ Herald
25 minutes ago
- NZ Herald
Simon Bridges is right, Auckland's economic blues require special attention
Bridges' public call for fresh government policies – including more fiscal stimulus – was remarkable coming from a former leader of the National Party. It was a sign of some desperation. Bridges is head of the Auckland Business Chamber and is acutely aware of how bad things are looking for many retailers and hospitality businesses in the city. He has a different hat on these days, of course, and it is his job to lobby for Auckland business, but anybody who has spent time in downtown Auckland recently can see he's not exaggerating the problem. Let's face it, Auckland's CBD is a dismal place to be in the rain-sodden winter of 2025. Around the country, I can hear the tiny violins playing. New Zealand's largest city is often perceived as a brash and arrogant place, but with nearly a third of the country's total population within its regional boundaries, it's a bit hard to ignore. Politicians ignore it at their peril – as Labour found out after putting the city through a long and unpopular extended lockdown. I know the long-awaited Central Rail Link is supposed to turn things around, and I see the Prime Minister went for an advance spin on it last week. It looks great, and I look forward to it opening. But we haven't got a date yet, and it may well be later next year before it opens to the public. That means potentially another winter of waiting for struggling inner-city retailers. And perhaps a bigger worry than the timing is the risk that, if it opens in anything like the current CBD malaise, people will come to the city once, be disappointed by what they see and won't come back again. The same issues apply to SkyCity's long-awaited New Zealand International Convention Centre, and as Bridges points out, relying on these two developments to fix Auckland's woes won't be enough. But the central Government doesn't have a lot of money. So what to do? Bridges' suggestion of corporate tax cuts is fine in theory. But I don't think we can afford fiscal stimulus on that scale right now. And it's also not clear that it is needed right across the country. If you just looked at the economy in aggregate, it is flat but recovering – not too bad. I was pleasantly surprised to see the official unemployment rate land better than expected at 5.2% this week. My gut feeling was that it would be worse than that. When I saw the Auckland number, it all made sense. Auckland's unemployment rate has hit 6.1%. Of course, if you're taking your anecdotal evidence from business people in Auckland, you'd assume the economic recovery has stalled. For better or for worse, Auckland's economy is driven by population growth and its service sector. It thrives on rising numbers of tourists and immigrants (international and from around New Zealand). The population growth drives property and construction. Building booms and property prices rise. Confident in the extra zeros on their house prices, Aucklanders go out and spend. The shops, bars and restaurants thrive, and Auckland is a fun place to be. That creates jobs and opportunities and attracts more tourists and more immigrants. That circle of economic growth has completely broken down. Meanwhile, in Otago, the June quarter data showed the unemployment rate had dropped to 2.9%. Christchurch is also, by all accounts, humming along right now. I've written before about the stark regional divide that appears to be opening up as the returns from high export commodity prices bolster rural regions and the cities that support them. It doesn't seem like a great idea to be stimulating flush southern economies with either fiscal or monetary stimulus right now. Economists are currently making the case for one or two more cuts to the Official Cash Rate (OCR). If the Reserve Bank just looked at the South Island, it might not see a need to cut again at all. If it just looked at Auckland and Wellington, it might see a need to cut much further. But monetary policy doesn't work like that. That's where fiscal policy comes in. I think any fresh spending on Auckland would need to be very well-targeted. The Government doesn't have spare billions, but it might be able to find spare millions for projects that could make an outsize difference to the grim Auckland mood. We have a trifecta of dead buildings in the crucial mid-town intersection around Aotea Square. The remains of the St James Theatre have looked like a demolition site for years. Across the road, the old Smith & Caughey building is now empty and just up Queen St, the Sky World Indoor Entertainment is increasingly empty and run-down. There are plans in place for all of these buildings (the Government has already allocated funds for restoring the St James), but no signs of anything happening quickly. It might be time for the Government to look at getting involved – either with cash, some of that fast-track regulatory magic it has sprinkled around the regions (and, to be fair, on plans for Port of Auckland expansion). Bringing these buildings back to life would deliver a much-needed boost to a key area of the central city. It would also double as fiscal stimulus for Auckland's construction sector, keeping skilled workers employed while we wait for the broader economic cycle to turn. And perhaps most importantly, they'd deliver a morale boost, providing another reason to believe that Auckland can and will find its mojo again. I'm not necessarily wedded to any of these ideas; there might be better ones. Let's hear them. The point that Bridges is making is that things are now so grim that we can't afford to just wait for a recovery that might still be another year away. By then, it might be too late. Liam Dann is business editor at large for the New Zealand Herald. He is a senior writer and columnist, as well as presenting and producing videos and podcasts. He joined the Herald in 2003.
Otago Daily Times
an hour ago
- Otago Daily Times
Govt ‘double-counted' council spending figure
A rationalisation of Waitaki District Council teams and services, such as moving its service desk to the public library, has led to an 8.9% reduction in FTE staff, the largest drop in more than 20 years, chief executive Alex Parmley says. ALLIED MEDIA FILES The Waitaki District Council has largely welcomed a new government ranking system for council performance, but points out some "double counting" in the newly-released key metrics. "Key metrics published today show how much councils are spending and what they are spending it on, which has a direct impact on your rates," Local Government Minister Simon Watts said. "Some ratepayers are getting more and more fed up with rising rates hitting pockets harder than ever. This isn't fair during a cost-of-living crisis where many Kiwis are doing it tough. It is important that ratepayers can see how their council is performing and what it is delivering for their community. "That's why the government is putting clear facts and figures directly into the hands of ratepayers. When ratepayers know more about how their council is performing and where their money is going, they can engage more effectively and ask the tough questions." The government measurements rank Waitaki around the median score, when compared with similar smaller, rural councils on most metrics. However, WDC's annual operating expenditure of $84.78m is $30.25m more than the group median. It also employs more people, 207 fulltime equivalents (FTEs), compared with the median of 87. Personnel costs are also $10.63m higher than the median. WDC's forecast total capital expenditure for 2025 to 2027, $147.78m, is double that of the median. However, WDC chief executive Alex Parmley said that figure is wrong. "In 2025, council deferred around $20million of budgeted work to the following year. That has been double-counted by the government. Our budgeted capital expenditure over the period is around $128m "Waitaki District Council is currently undertaking three separate once-in-a-generation infrastructure projects. The Network Waitaki Events Centre, the Kakanui Bridge replacement and the Forrester Gallery extension. "These projects are all funded externally by the community, the NZTA and the Ministry of Culture and Heritage, with the council's funding a minority of each. "We are also undertaking vital infrastructure upgrades for our waters network, as well as maintaining our roads, parks, reserves and property as a responsible council. "While figures are pegged to the median, Waitaki District has almost double the median population and double the land area of councils it is classed as similar to. "This has an impact on the requirement for capital investment, even without the major infrastructure projects at the Forrester Gallery, in Kakanui and at Centennial Park, Oamaru." Regarding personnel, Mr Parmley said a rationalisation of council teams and services, such as moving its service desk to the public library, has led to an 8.9% reduction in FTE staff, the largest drop in more than 20 years. "Our new approach is helping us to improve customer service access and levels whilst using resources more efficiently." Visit to view the performance tables on the DIA website.
