Govandi residents accuse MPCB of undervaluing environmental violations by biomedical waste facility
MUMBAI: Residents of Govandi have accused the Maharashtra Pollution Control Board (MPCB) of grossly underreporting and mishandling environmental violations by SMS Envoclean Pvt. Ltd., which operates a biomedical waste treatment facility in the area.
A biomedical waste treatment facility is a specialised center that handles, processes, and disposes of hazardous waste from healthcare and research facilities, such as used syringes, bandages, surgical instruments, pathological waste, pharmaceuticals, and materials contaminated with blood, bodily fluids, or infectious agents.
In a fresh application filed before the National Green Tribunal (NGT), a specialised judicial body in India established to address environmental disputes, on June 2, the Govandi New Sangam Welfare Society alleged that MPCB failed to impose appropriate environmental penalties on the facility, despite repeated violations of the Bio-Medical Waste Management Rules, 2016 (BMWM Rules).
The Society claims that the MPCB ignored key violations such as untreated effluent discharge, improper handling of biomedical waste, and manipulation of emissions data while calculating Environmental Damage Compensation (EDC). Citing the Polluter Pays and Precautionary Principles, which requires polluters to bear the costs of pollution prevention, control, and restoration, the petition demands a new, legally sound assessment of the environmental damage and seeks personal accountability of MPCB officials for allegedly suppressing evidence and failing to perform their statutory duties.
The society pointed to several complaints it had made in the past, flagging serious concerns over toxic emissions and adverse health impacts from the plant. Following inspections, the MPCB issued closure directions in July 2019, confirming violations of the BMWM Rules. However, despite this, the board imposed no penalty and calculated a compensation of just ₹14.22 lakh—an amount the petitioners say grossly favours the polluter. Dissatisfied with the inaction, the society initially filed a public interest litigation in the Bombay High Court. On September 11, 2023, the High Court directed the petitioners to approach the NGT for suitable remedies.
In its plea, the society accused the MPCB of deliberately excluding crucial evidence of non-compliance, including failure to meet treated wastewater standards and delays in disposing of biomedical waste within the mandated 48-hour period. 'MPCB chose to disregard these key violations for reasons best known to them,' the petition stated.The closure notice issued by MPCB itself, dated July 6, 2019, documented several infractions- failure to segregate waste as per the 2016 Rules, poor maintenance of biomedical waste records, unwashed transport vehicles at the site, and transportation vehicles lacking mandatory biohazard symbols. 'Despite these glaring lapses, MPCB has under-calculated the compensation and misled the tribunal,' the petition alleged.
The residents further invoked the Central Pollution Control Board's 2019 guidelines, which require enhanced penalties for repeat violations—guidelines that MPCB allegedly failed to apply. This, the petition claims, has made such violations economically viable for offending firms.Additionally, the society alleged that MPCB excluded 267 days during the COVID-19 pandemic and another 395 days in 2020–21 from its compensation calculation—periods during which violations had occurred.
Calling for the application of the strict and absolute liability principle under environmental law, the society urged the NGT to direct MPCB to reassess and impose a fair and accurate EDC on the polluter.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
17 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
Govandi residents accuse MPCB of undervaluing environmental violations by biomedical waste facility
MUMBAI: Residents of Govandi have accused the Maharashtra Pollution Control Board (MPCB) of grossly underreporting and mishandling environmental violations by SMS Envoclean Pvt. Ltd., which operates a biomedical waste treatment facility in the area. A biomedical waste treatment facility is a specialised center that handles, processes, and disposes of hazardous waste from healthcare and research facilities, such as used syringes, bandages, surgical instruments, pathological waste, pharmaceuticals, and materials contaminated with blood, bodily fluids, or infectious agents. In a fresh application filed before the National Green Tribunal (NGT), a specialised judicial body in India established to address environmental disputes, on June 2, the Govandi New Sangam Welfare Society alleged that MPCB failed to impose appropriate environmental penalties on the facility, despite repeated violations of the Bio-Medical Waste Management Rules, 2016 (BMWM Rules). The Society claims that the MPCB ignored key violations such as untreated effluent discharge, improper handling of biomedical waste, and manipulation of emissions data while calculating Environmental Damage Compensation (EDC). Citing the Polluter Pays and Precautionary Principles, which requires polluters to bear the costs of pollution prevention, control, and restoration, the petition demands a new, legally sound assessment of the environmental damage and seeks personal accountability of MPCB officials for allegedly suppressing evidence and failing to perform their statutory duties. The society pointed to several complaints it had made in the past, flagging serious concerns over toxic emissions and adverse health impacts from the plant. Following inspections, the MPCB issued closure directions in July 2019, confirming violations of the BMWM Rules. However, despite this, the board imposed no penalty and calculated a compensation of just ₹14.22 lakh—an amount the petitioners say grossly favours the polluter. Dissatisfied with the inaction, the society initially filed a public interest litigation in the Bombay High Court. On September 11, 2023, the High Court directed the petitioners to approach the NGT for suitable remedies. In its plea, the society accused the MPCB of deliberately excluding crucial evidence of non-compliance, including failure to meet treated wastewater standards and delays in disposing of biomedical waste within the mandated 48-hour period. 'MPCB chose to disregard these key violations for reasons best known to them,' the petition closure notice issued by MPCB itself, dated July 6, 2019, documented several infractions- failure to segregate waste as per the 2016 Rules, poor maintenance of biomedical waste records, unwashed transport vehicles at the site, and transportation vehicles lacking mandatory biohazard symbols. 'Despite these glaring lapses, MPCB has under-calculated the compensation and misled the tribunal,' the petition alleged. The residents further invoked the Central Pollution Control Board's 2019 guidelines, which require enhanced penalties for repeat violations—guidelines that MPCB allegedly failed to apply. This, the petition claims, has made such violations economically viable for offending the society alleged that MPCB excluded 267 days during the COVID-19 pandemic and another 395 days in 2020–21 from its compensation calculation—periods during which violations had occurred. Calling for the application of the strict and absolute liability principle under environmental law, the society urged the NGT to direct MPCB to reassess and impose a fair and accurate EDC on the polluter.
Hindustan Times
19 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
Delhi Jal Board to lay down new water, sewer lines in Janakpuri
The Delhi Jal Board (DJB) has told the National Green Tribunal (NGT) that it will fix the issue of sewage water entering the drinking water supply in Janakpuri, a month after a study found that 30% of water samples tested in Janakpuri's A block were contaminated with E. coli and faecal coliform. In an undertaking, the water agency, however, said an examination of the area revealed that water and sewer pipelines in and around the block were nearly 40 years' old and have corroded. This, it claimed, was leading to contamination and mixing. Replacing the drinking water and sewer lines will solve the issue, it said. Last month, the Central Pollution Control Board study studied water samples in the area following a plea filed by the Residents' Welfare Association complaining of foul smell and visibly contaminated drinking water in the area. In the last hearing, NGT had pulled up DJB for inaction, observing that even after three months of deliberation, the water utility has failed to take meaningful remedial measures. In a submission dated June 4, filed on behalf of the chief engineer, DJB told the tribunal that repair work on peripheral sewer lines is already underway and will be completed by June 30. 'It will be ensured that none of the residents receives a supply of water containing E. coli and faecal coliform,' the undertaking said. 'For a permanent solution, the existing more than 40-year-old water and sewer lines in the affected area, which have outlived their lives, will be replaced,' the submission said. The submission added that tenders will be floated once budgetary approvals are secured under the current action plan, and replacement work will take around six months which will begin after the monsoon season. The tribunal had also ordered fresh sampling to be carried out on June 30, with a report due ahead of the next hearing on July 16. Action will be taken against DJB if contamination is observed again, it had warned.
Hindustan Times
3 days ago
- Hindustan Times
NGT raps Delhi Jal Board over continued water contamination in Janakpuri
New Delhi After 30% of water samples tested in Janakpuri's A Block were found contaminated with E. coli and faecal coliform, the National Green Tribunal (NGT) pulled up the Delhi Jal Board (DJB) for inaction, observing that even after three months of deliberation, the water utility has failed to take meaningful remedial measures. The NGT directed that clean drinking water be supplied to residents of A1 Block through alternate sources until the issue is fully addressed. The tribunal also ordered fresh sampling to be carried out on June 30, with a report due ahead of the next hearing on July 16. NGT issued the directions while hearing a plea filed by the residents' welfare association (RWA) of Janakpuri's A1 Block, which alleged that households have been receiving drinking water mixed with untreated sewage. The residents claimed a choked sewer line has corroded drinking water pipelines, leading to widespread contamination in the area. A Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) report submitted last week found total coliform and E. coli in water samples taken from six of 20 houses in the area, raising red flags about faecal contamination. According to CPCB norms, these indicators should be absent in potable water. 'It is unfortunate that the matter is pending before the Tribunal for more than three months, and such a serious complaint concerning the supply of sewage mixed water where a presence of total coliform and has been noticed, has not been remediated till now by the DJB. This reflects that the Officers of the DJB are taking the matter in a very casual manner. They need to be sensitive to the problem being faced by the residents of that area for want of supply of clean drinking water,' the tribunal said in its order dated May 30. The tribunal noted that DJB chief engineer Mukesh Kumar Jindal agreed to file an undertaking assuring of remedial steps, and that no resident would continue to receive contaminated water. The NGT made it clear that any failure to adhere to the undertaking would lead to personal liability.
