On-screen warnings on Bob Vylan set ‘not good enough' says minister
On-screen warnings issued by the BBC about discriminatory language during Bob Vylan's Glastonbury set were 'not good enough,' a minister has said.
The BBC is facing questions after rapper Bobby Vylan – of the rap punk duo – led crowds at the festival's West Holts Stage in chants of: 'Free, free Palestine' and: 'Death, death to the IDF (Israel Defence Forces)' on Saturday.
Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer has said there is 'no excuse' for the chanting, and the corporation said it showed a warning during the set's stream about the 'very strong and discriminatory language'.
The Bob Vylan set was shown live on an iPlayer stream.
Baroness Jacqui Smith was asked on Times Radio whether she thought the BBC has a bias.
She told the station: 'I don't think the BBC has a bias, but I think it made a mistake here.
View this post on Instagram
A post shared by Bob Vylan (@bobbyvylan)
'It's not good enough simply to say on screen that, you know, 'this is dodgy language'.
'It was far beyond that, and it shouldn't have been broadcast live. And I think it would have been possible for the BBC to stop that.'
The education minister also told Sky that she was 'surprised' that the BBC continued broadcasting the set.
Over the weekend, the BBC said that viewers would not be able to access the performance on demand.
A spokesperson for the broadcaster said: 'Some of the comments made during Bob Vylan's set were deeply offensive.
'During this live stream on iPlayer, which reflected what was happening on stage, a warning was issued on screen about the very strong and discriminatory language.'
A former BBC editor has said that the broadcaster should have the ability to 'cut the feed' whenever there 'is a hint of hate speech'.
Sir Craig Oliver – who also served as director of communications for Lord David Cameron in Downing Street – told Radio 4's Today programme: 'I suspect at next year's Glastonbury there's going to have to be a senior editorial figure who does understand the sensitivities and is going to cut the feed.'
Sir Keir Starmer led the criticism from across the political spectrum over the weekend, and also referenced Belfast rap trip Kneecap, who had faced calls to be cut from the festival after a member was charged with a terror offence.
Responding to the chants from Bob Vylan, the Prime Minister said: 'There is no excuse for this kind of appalling hate speech.
'I said that Kneecap should not be given a platform and that goes for any other performers making threats or inciting violence.
'The BBC needs to explain how these scenes came to be broadcast.'
Bob Vylan, who formed in Ipswich in 2017, have released four albums addressing issues to do with racism, masculinity and class.
Bobby Vylan's real name is Pascal Robinson-Foster, 34, according to reports.
In a statement posted to Instagram, Vylan said: 'Teaching our children to speak up for the change they want and need is the only way that we make this world a better place.
'As we grow older and our fire starts to possibly dim under the suffocation of adult life and all its responsibilities, it is incredibly important that we encourage and inspire future generations to pick up the torch that was passed to us.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scottish Sun
37 minutes ago
- Scottish Sun
I paid a hypnotist £950 to ‘cure' me of my addiction to bad boys – but still ran back to my red flag ex after a 2am text
Find out why she hasn't been in a proper relationship for ten years UNDER A SPELL I paid a hypnotist £950 to 'cure' me of my addiction to bad boys – but still ran back to my red flag ex after a 2am text Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) A DECADE ago, Jana Hocking hit rock bottom. She woke up with sickening shame at the memory of crying at her ex-boyfriend's front door, begging him to come out and talk to her. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 2 Heartbroken and humiliated, Jana called her mother after her ex told her to 'f**k off' Credit: Instagram /@jana_hocking 2 In total, she forked out over £900 to 'cure' her addiction to bad boys Credit: INSTAGRAM/Jana Hocking They had just broken up - again. Their four-year relationship had been like watching soap opera - explosive arguments galore, passionate reconciliations, cheating, two stints in prison (him, not her), and several family-led interventions begging Jana to leave. But despite all the anger issues and insane jealousy, she loved him - madly. However, that night was different, the Daily Mail columnist recently revealed. Up until them, the couple's ''usual pattern was fight, sulk, then make-up sex''. read more on dating SWIPE RIGHT I'm the most liked man on Hinge but I've still not found The One But when she showed up to his house to repeat the same routine - one they had followed so many times - he didn't come to the door. Instead, she got a muffled ''f**k off'' through the glass, before his mate emerged to break the news that it was officially over. Heartbroken and humiliated, Jana called her mother, who came over and slept next to her, as she sobbed for hours on end. While she was relieved the relationship had come to an end, she was worried for her daughter. ''The next morning, she handed me a book on limerence (an unhealthy, involuntary obsession with another person) and gently suggested I see a therapist.'' She read the book and saw the therapist - but the pain didn't go away and she longed to see her ex-partner. I paid £20 for Tinder and can't stand little-known loophole desperate guys use So when a pal mentioned a hypnotist who had just moved into her office building, Jana didn't think twice. ''Surely this woman could rewire my brain to stop going for bad boys (spoiler alert: this wasn't my first rodeo) and finally make me fall for the elusive 'nice guy'?'' she wondered. 15 Relationship red flags to look out for Red flags are warning signs that indicate unhealthy or manipulative behaviour. When you encounter relationship red flags, it's a good time to pause and reflect on the dynamic you really share with that person. Overly controlling behaviour Lack of trust Feeling low self-esteem Physical, emotional, or mental abuse Substance abuse Narcissism Anger management issues Codependency Inability to resolve conflict Constant jealousy Gaslighting Lack of emotional intelligence Negatively affecting your relationship with family and friends Inability to communicate openly Lack of social connection or friends For more advice and support, Relate is available: "Whether it's your relationship with a partner, a child, a family member or anyone else - we help everyone to build better relationships." In total, the hypnotist reckoned Jana would need four sessions minimum, each one setting her back almost £240. She was a broke junior producer living off instant noodles, but she was desperate. Jana raided her savings and paid the hefty £950 upfront. For the next month, she 'put Jana under' once a week, and dug through childhood memories, whilst reframing thought patterns, and implanting healthy boundaries in her brain. But there was a plot twist - the hypnotist set the boundaries so high, that it's now been a decade since Jana has had ''a proper boyfriend''. Before this, she might have overlooked a few red flags. Now, one tiny whiff of toxic traits is enough for Jana to run away as fast as she can. ''I've become maddeningly picky. My mother calls it 'too picky'. I call it finally having standards.'' Sadly, the hypnotist didn't cure Jana of her attraction to bad boys - but while they still get her going, the singleton no longer dates them. 'You up?' Fast-forward to six months after the brutal break-up, Jana received an unexpected text from her ex-boyfriend at 2am. ''You up?'' read the text to which Jana tried her hardest to ignore. ''Did the hypnotist fix you yet? Nice guys are fun lol,'' he messaged almost 15 minutes later. ''Come over. I'll behave if you do.'' Like a moth to a flame, Jana booked an Uber and drove straight to his house for one last hurrah. But when the red flag ex suggested getting back together the following morning, Jana didn't feel anything - ''just closure''. While the hypnotist may not have stopped the singleton from hopping into bed with her ''bad boy ex'' she did at least stop her from committing to men like him. However, there's a small problem - she may have accidentally stopped her dating full-stop. More therapy, soul-searching and even a psychic or two - Jana has since tried everything. But a decade later, it feels like her ''forever man'' is not coming after all. ''It turns out there are no quick fixes for heartbreak. No magic wands. ''Just hard lessons, a lot of unsexy self-work, and hopefully one day… a nice guy who still manages to make me feel just the right kind of dangerous.''
Daily Mirror
38 minutes ago
- Daily Mirror
Christine McGuinness says she's 'scared' of dating apps as she teases over exes
Former Celebs Go Dating participant Christine McGuinness has shared that she has never used a dating app, with her opening up about her concerns on her Situationships podcast Podcast host Christine McGuinness has shared her thoughts on dating apps after revealing that she's never used one. She's revealed that she's concerned over one aspect, which she said she would be "petrified" of. Christine, 37, has spoken about dating in the years since it was announced that she had split from Paddy McGuinness in 2022. She even briefly took part in the new series of Celebs Go Dating, which is yet to air on E4, and is expected to return in the finale. She's now giving fans an insight into her personal life on the new BBC podcast Situationships with Sophie and Christine, which launched earlier this month. Christine co-hosts the newly launched podcast with author Sophie Gravia. A discussion about dating apps in the first episode saw Christine open up about her concerns. It came after the mention of 'catfishing' and Sophie recalling a date with someone who was "not all all" how she had expected them to look based on the photos that had been on his profile. Christine, who revealed that she's "never been on a dating app," asked: "Do you not think to like FaceTime or check that the person is who they say they are?" Sophie, who's now in a relationship, replied by saying that she would "never do it" and that she hasn't been on dating apps for years. Her co-host Christine then shared: "I would be petrified of who could turn up and who am I talking to and yeah ... no, it scares me." Sophie went on to tell her: "I think they are gonna go out of fashion. I think everyone's getting fed up." Sharing her thoughts, Christine added: "I think it should come with like ... almost like a TripAdvisor ... like a review thing. Maybe like reviews from people's exes or something." After discussing the idea together, Christine said: "Imagine what people's exes would say about them." She teased: "I mean, mine, obviously, would all be five stars reviews." Sophie however admitted that she's treated some potential partners differently to her boyfriend. She said: "How I've acted in the past to certain people because I don't necessarily like them isn't a true representation of how I would act, for instance, to my boyfriend, who I like." Christine said on the podcast: "It's part of the problem. I mean, for me, it's something I've really struggled with is ... the idea of dating and not going well, then how do you get out of it? Cause I wouldn't want to upset somebody." Earlier in the episode, Christine had spoken about dating in the aftermath of her split from Paddy, which was announced three years ago. She told her co-host Sophie: "It took me a while to even think about dating." Christine said she fell into some "situationships" where "friendships had blurred the lines" and then had her first date with someone who she had briefly first met out. She said that they then spoke for months on social media before going on a date. She said: "My first proper date ever, ever in my life, with somebody that I didn't actually know. But I took those months of messaging to feel comfortable." The podcast Situationships with Sophie and Christine is available through BBC iPlayer and BBC Sounds.
Daily Mail
39 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Charli XCX crowns Gracie Abrams as her 'Apple girl' as she performs headline slot at Glastonbury
Charli XCX crowned Gracie Abrams as her 'Apple girl' during her Glastonbury headline slot on Saturday. The Dance The Night hitmaker, 32, has made it a tradition to have a special surprise guest perform the viral TikTok dance to her track Apple. While performing on The Other Stage, Charli clutched a glass of white wine as she said: 'You know what time it is, now who the f**k is going to be 'Apple girl' at Glastonbury? 'Who did you find out there? Someone cute?' The camera then panned to singer Gracie, 25 - the daughter of director J. J. Abrams - who was quick to showcase the dance that made the 'under-appreciated' song on Charli's 2024 album Brat a viral sensation. Created by TikTok star Kelley Heyer, the simple dance features several moves including, famously, pretending to hold an apple. Gracie threw herself into the challenge, playfully performing the moves and miming along to the track. The That's So True hitmaker previously took to the Glastonbury stage herself on Friday night as a headliner at The West Holts Stage, with Charli in attendance in the crowd. Previous 'Apple girls' have included Chappell Roan, Charli's fiancé The 1975 drummer George Daniel, Rosé from Blackpink and Chicken Shop Date podcaster Amelia Dimoldenberg. Reactions to Charli's choice of Apple girl at this weekend's festival were mixed on social media, with one commentator even making a viral meme to imply that Gracie's director father had paid for her to get the position. Others remarked: 'GRACIE ABRAMS WAS THE APPLE GIRL AT GLASTONBURY OH MY F**KING GOD SHES INSANE.'; 'I wasn't Charli xcx's Apple girl at Glastonbury so I blocked Gracie Abrams #glastonbury.' But many had positive reactions such as: 'gracie as the apple girl shut up this is everything to me.'; 'U WERE LEGENDARY TY FOR BEING APPLE GIRL TOO BTW MADE MY NIGHT [sic].' Reactions to Charli's choice of an Apple girl were mixed - one commentator even made a viral meme implying that Gracie's director father had paid for her to get the position Many had positive reactions such as: 'gracie as the apple girl shut up this is everything to me' Following the performance, Charli hit back on social media at claims she is a 'fraud' after being criticised for her headline Glastonbury set. The singer performed to a packed crowd at Worthy Farm but came under fire after many said they were convinced she was miming or using autotune. Taking to X, formerly known as Twitter, Charli referenced the 'boomer vibe' comments as she hit back at claims. She wrote: 'Like the idea that singing with deliberate autotune makes you a fraud or that not having a traditional band suddenly means you must not be a 'real artist' is like, the most boring take ever. yawn sorry just fell asleep xx 'But to be honest… I enjoy the discourse. imo the best art is divisive and confrontational and often evolves into truly interesting culture rather than being like kind of ok, easily understood and sort of forgettable.' She added: 'Really enjoying these boomer vibe comments on my Glastonbury performance. It's super fascinating to me,' before thanking those who gave her five star reviews. It comes after viewers called the energetic performance 'truly terrible' and claimed she was the 'worst headline act' at the festival. Taking to X, formerly known as Twitter, Charli referenced the 'boomer vibe' comments as she hit back at claims It comes after viewers called the energetic performance 'truly terrible' and claimed she was the 'worst headline act' at the festival They wrote: 'Can't be just me? Charlie xcx is truly truly terrible? This is not actual music is it? Who is listening to this on a playlist seriously it's torture sounds. Gotta be one of the worst headline acts ever at Glastonbury'; 'This Charlie xcx thing is the worst headline act in Glastonbury history. There may be headliners that you don't like. 'But at least they try and fkn sing. Her fee should be withheld, as tbh, you could have put a stripper on stage with a Spotify speaker and got the same results'; 'This Glastonbury set by Charli XCX is one of the worst things I've ever seen in my life. Barely singing, autotune in the rare moments she does sing a bit and horrendous dancing. Be fuming if you spent ages getting into that crowd only to see that'. During her performance, Charli put on a very racy display showing off her toned figure in tiny black leather hot pants and a mesh skull crop top. Charli accessorised with a floaty Alexander McQueen scarf, and hid her eyes behind oversized dark sunglasses. As well as playing Apple, the crowd went wild as she performed hits including Party 4 U, Speed Drive, Sympathy Is a Knife, and 360.
