Court orders dissolution of Ngwathe Municipality amid service delivery collapse

News24

21-06-2025

The Free State High Court has ordered the dissolution of the Ngwathe Local Municipality, citing gross failures in fulfilling its constitutional, legislative and regulatory responsibilities toward residents in towns such as Parys, Heilbron, Koppies and Vredefort, among others.
The ruling follows a case brought by AfriForum, supported by the Save Ngwathe community group.
The parties successfully acquired an interdict compelling the Free State provincial government to immediately intervene in the municipality's affairs.
Ngwathe becomes the second municipality in the Free State to be placed under administration.
Last month, Matjhabeng Local Municipality was placed under administration following the province's MEC for Cooperative Governance, Traditional Affairs and Human Settlements, Saki Mokoena, finally invoking Section 139 of the Constitution, which outlines the process for provincial intervention in municipalities unable to fulfill its executive obligations.
READ | Matjhabeng Municipality finally under administration as province moves to address governance collapse
Mokoena's actions followed a Bloemfontein High Court judgment, handed down on 23 October 2024, which found financial mismanagement, collapsing infrastructure and poor service delivery.
Ngwathe residents allegedly suffered for years
According to court papers which AfriForum submitted, pertaining to Ngwathe, the lobby group said residents had suffered for years under dire conditions - including persistent water shortages, raw sewage flowing in the streets, crumbling infrastructure and widespread financial mismanagement.
The municipality owes more than R1 billion to Eskom and Rand Water.
In delivering judgment on Friday, Judge Johannes Daffue described the municipality and its council as 'dysfunctional' and criticised the provincial government for its inaction.
He said the case warranted judicial oversight, calling it a 'suitable case where the court should play the role of a watchdog'.
The court order instructed Free State Premier Maqueen Letsoha-Mathae and her executive council to:
Dissolve the municipal council and appoint an administrator;
Develop and implement a recovery plan to restore service delivery and ensure financial stability;
Approve a temporary budget and revenue measures to support the recovery plan; and
Submit written progress reports to the court every three months under oath.
The municipality and eight other respondents, including the premier, were also ordered to pay AfriForum's legal costs.
The judgment comes after a series of public protests in 2024, sparked by water cuts, potholes as well as a catastrophic 11% Blue Drop water quality score.
The crisis worsened when Free State's Provincial Treasury rejected Ngwathe's R2.099 billion draft budget for 2025/26, citing a falsified surplus based on an unrealistic 100% collection rate.
AfriForum's Alta Pretorius called the ruling a 'massive victory' for long-suffering residents.
Pretorius said:
This not only brings justice, but legal grounds for real intervention. The government can no longer look away.
The DA's Carina Serfontein welcomed the judgment, saying it confirmed what residents had known for years.
'We will closely track the premier's progress reports and take further action, if necessary,' she said.
The mayor of Ngwathe, Victoria De-Beer Mthombeni, acknowledged the ruling, stating: 'The executive mayor respects the judgment of the Bloemfontein High Court and is studying the judgment in detail and will communicate in due course on the processes going forward.'