American Idol's Carrie Underwood Was ‘Nervous' About Judging Her First Audition — How Did She Do?
The 30-minute post-Oscars special kicked off with Underwood's 'first day on the other side of the table,' a mere 20 years after she won Idol herself. One of the biggest changes she noticed was the impressive quality of the golden tickets, a considerable upgrade from the 'yellow piece of paper' she recalled being handed back in 2005.
More from TVLine
The Rookie Cliffhanger: What Do You Think Happens Next for Nyla/James? (And Can It Not Be Cringey?)
The Rookie: Season 7's Wiiildest Episode Gave Us an Iconic #Chenford Scene and 3-1/2 Other Big Twists
Grey's Anatomy Enlists Lena Waithe for Multi-Episode Arc - What's Her Connection to Catherine?
Underwood's first-ever contestant arrived in the form of 25-year-old Sonny Tennet, a mustachio'd Ed Sheeran type from the UK. The unassuming singer-songwriter had Underwood melting into her hands within seconds of his smooth, riff-riddled take on the Commodores' 'Easy.' Between this being Underwood's first time at bat, plus Tennet performing a song by fellow judge Lionel Richie, this audition could have gone south really quickly — but ABC wasn't about to kick off the new season with a flop.
Richie was thoroughly impressed by Tennet, praising him for making the song his own before passing the mic to Underwood for her first-ever critiques. 'I felt my heart aflutter,' she said of Tennet's 'joyous' performance, calling it a 'perfect song choice.' Then it was over to Luke Bryan to wrap things up.
So, what did we learn from Underwood's brief first time judging an Idol audition? For starters, she may be replacing Katy Perry, but she's not replacing her energy. Underwood's commentary is insightful, and there's a warm playfulness to her chemistry with both the contestants and her fellow judges, but she's considerably more soft-spoken than her predecessor.
Oscars' Best, Worst and Weirdest Moments
View List
Underwood admitted to having first day jitters ('I don't know why I'm nervous, I'm not auditioning!'), so it's possible that she'll settle into her position as the season progresses. A montage of future audition episodes included several interesting teases, including one contestant being so scared of Underwood that Bryan dubs her 'Scary Carrie.' (To be fair, anyone who isn't at least a little bit afraid of her obviously hasn't seen the music video for 'Before He Cheats.' If she could do all that to a truck, just imagine what she could do to you.)
Sunday's preview introduced a few more memorable contestants, including Thunderstorm Artis, whose original song about his wife made all the judges emotional, and Manhattan musician Amanda Barise, who left Underwood 'possessed' with her impressive take on James Brown's 'It's A Man's Man's Man's World.'
What did you think of Underwood's judging debut? Grade it in our poll below, then drop a comment with your thoughts on all things .
Best of TVLine
Mrs. Maisel Flash-Forward List: All of Season 5's Futuristic Easter Eggs
Yellowjackets Recap: The Morning After
Yellowjackets Recap: The First Supper
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
A 'Home Improvement' reunion is coming to Tim Allen's 'Shifting Gears' season 2 premiere
Patricia Richardson, Richard Karn, and Debbe Dunning will join their former costar in the season 2 episode airing on Oct. 1. It's been 26 years since Home Improvement aired its final episode, and fans are getting a mini reunion on Tim Allen's new sitcom. Home Improvement stars Patricia Richardson, Richard Karn, and Debbe Dunning will make a special guest appearance on the season 2 premiere of ABC's Shifting Gears, airing on Oct. 1, Entertainment Weekly can confirm. Although details on their appearance are under wraps, it has been revealed that their characters will reportedly support Allen's character, Matt Parker, in an unexpected way. Shifting Gears follows Matt as his estranged daughter Riley (Kat Dennings) and her kids move into his home. Matt is a stubborn, widowed owner of a classic car restoration shop, who works alongside Seann William Scott as Gabriel, Daryl Chill Mitchell as Stitch, Maxwell Simkins as Carter, and Barrett Margolis as Georgia. Nancy Travis and Jenna Elfman guest-starred in the show's freshman season and will return as guest stars for the second installment. The series is Allen's third sitcom after he starred on Last Man Standing from 2011 to 2021 as Mike Baxter, an executive at a Denver sporting goods store. But no role has become as much of a household name as Allen's tenure as Home Improvement's Tim Taylor. The stand-up comedian made his mark on TV as TV host and tool- and car-obsessed husband to Jill (Richardson) and father to Brad (Zachery Ty Bryan), Randy (Jonathan Taylor Thomas), and Mark (Taran Noah Smith). The series, which ran for eight seasons and racked up dozens of Golden Globe and Emmy nominations, balanced Tim's life at home with Tool Time, a show within the show about, you guessed it, home improvement. Karn played Al Borland, Tim's friend and the co-host of Tool Time, along with Dunning, who portrayed Heidi, the show within a show's model, from seasons 3 to 8. Allen has been vocal about wanting to reunite with his former costars for a reboot of their sitcom. In 2023, he told the Messenger, "One of the conversations we've had recently is how weird it would be if Home Improvement would be about the kids' kids. Like if all of them had children, and I'm a grandparent. Home Re-Improvement or something like that. It's come up." Others aren't on the same wavelength; a year after Allen's comments, Richardson said she was never approached about a possible reunion and she wouldn't be interested even if she had. "I wrote a big thing on Twitter and said I'm not involved in any series with Jill and I've also never even been asked to do another Home Improvement reunion thing, but I would not want to," she said during an episode of the Back to the Best podcast Richard cited the legal troubles of onscreen son Bryan — who has been arrested on charges related to domestic violence and a DUI — and the passing of Earl Hindman, who played beloved neighbor Wilson, among other roadblocks. "I mean, Zach is now a felon," she said. "Taran [Noah Smith] hasn't acted since he left the show; he's not an actor anymore. And Jonathan's not really interested in acting. He wants to direct and write. And we don't have Wilson."While guest starring on Shifting Gears isn't quite the Home Improvement reboot fans might be hoping for, it's a sweet treat in the meantime. Allen also serves as an executive produce for Shifting Gears alongside Michelle Nader, Marty Adelstein, Becky Clements, Richard Baker, Rick Messina, John Pasquin, Jim Patterson, Bob Daily, and John Amodeo. Dennings is a producer on the ABC series, which is produced by 20th Television. Read the original article on Entertainment Weekly Solve the daily Crossword
Yahoo
4 hours ago
- Yahoo
‘High Potential' Stars Take Fans Behind the Scenes of Season 2 in New Video
High Potential Season 2 is taking shape at ABC as the network gears up for the return of Kaitlin Olson's Morgan and crew, who are tackling new mysteries this fall. In anticipation of the show's arrival, ABC has unveiled a few sneak peeks, the premiere date, and announced some exciting casting for fans to look forward to. As mentioned above, the hit drama is welcoming plenty of new faces to the mix, and several other details have already emerged surrounding the show, including possible directions the story might take. Along with setting the show's fall timeslot, new casting, and more, we're breaking down everything you need to know about what's to come. When is High Potential Season 2 going to premiere? ABC previously teased that High Potential's second season would arrive in the fall of 2025, airing in the 10/9c timeslot on Tuesdays following the network's other hit, Dancing With the Stars, which will air in the 8/7c slot. In the latest update from ABC, High Potential Season 2 will officially return on Tuesday, September 16. Does High Potential Season 2 have a trailer? No, there is no Season 2 trailer for High Potential yet, but stay tuned for first looks as we approach the fall TV season. In the meantime, ABC has shared a fun behind-the-scenes video featuring Olson and costars at the police station. Check it out below: Who will star in High Potential Season 2? There couldn't be High Potential without Kaitlin Olson as Morgan Gillroy, a mom with a high IQ who's been serving as a consultant with the LAPD. Also returning are Daniel Sunjata as Detective Karadec, Judy Reyes as Lieutenant Selena Soto, Javicia Leslie as Daphne, Deniz Akdeniz as Lev 'Oz' Osman, and Amirah J and Matthew Lamb as Morgan's kids, Ava and Elliot. Additionally, Taran Killiam is also likely to be back as Morgan's ex, Ludo. Meanwhile, Deadline has revealed Shameless actor Steve Howey will play a series regular role in Season 2. Howey will portray Jesse Wagner, the LAPD's new precinct captain. Described as a politically savvy person, Jesse knows how to wear an expensive suit and oozes charm. He has a disruptor quality and thinks outside the box like Morgan, and he'll put himself in the middle of the action, whether it's wanted or not. The latest addition to the series is Mekhi Phifer, who will join the show in a recurring guest star capacity, although details surrounding his role remain under wraps, according to Variety, which revealed his casting. Who will make High Potential Season 2? Season 1 of High Potential was created for television by Drew Goddard, who executive produces the series alongside Sarah Esberg. Olson also serves as a producer on the title. High Potential is based on the French series known as Haut Potentiel Intellectuel. What will High Potential Season 2 be about? Only time will tell which storylines will continue to unfold, but we anticipate Season 2 carrying on Morgan's investigations with the LAPD as she teams up with Karadec and crew. Stay tuned to see how it all unfolds, and let us know what you want to see in High Potential's second season when it arrives. High Potential, Season 2 Premiere, Tuesday, September 16, 10/9c, ABC Solve the daily Crossword
Yahoo
4 hours ago
- Yahoo
Shifting Gears Sets Home Improvement and Last Man Standing Reunions for Season 2 — Who's Joining Tim Allen?
Shifting Gears is staging a major Home Improvement reunion: The Tim Allen comedy's Season 2 premiere will reunite Allen with former co-stars Patricia Richardson, Richard Karn and Debbe Dunning. What's more, Last Man Standing's Nancy Travis, who guest-starred in Shifting Gears Season 1 as spirited widow Charlotte, will again reunite with Allen in Season 2. More from TVLine Shifting Gears EP Lays Out Season 2 Plans for Matt and Eve, Riley and Gabe and a M.I.A. Family Member ABC Sets Fall Premiere Dates for 9-1-1: Nashville, High Potential, Grey's and More — Most Scripted Shows Held for October Fallout Season 2 Gets December Premiere Date and Trailer; Episodes Will Roll Out Weekly While character details are being kept under ways, Deadline reports that Richardson, Karn and Dunning — better known to Home Improvement fans as Jill, Al and Heidi — will appear in the Wednesday, Oct. 1 season opener and support Allen's character, Matt Parker, in an 'unexpected way.' Allen has never shied from enlisting his former castmates to appear on his other shows. On Last Man Standing, Richardson guest-starred in two episodes as inconsiderate neighbor Helen Potts; Karn recurred in Season 2 as Bill McKendree, an architect who frequently did business with Mike at Outdoor Man; Jonathan Taylor Thomas appeared in Seasons 2 and 3 as Kristin's boss John, and later made a cameo as Helen's son Randy; and Blake Clark, who played Home Improvement hardware store owner Harry, popped up in a Season 5 episode as coffee house proprietor Clark. Additionally, Shifting Gears Season 1 included a cameo by Last Man recurring player Jay Leno. Shifting Gears Season 2 premieres Wednesday, Oct. 1 at 8/7c on ABC (and streams next day on Hulu). Will you tune in for the big reunion? Last Man Standing Cast Changes View Gallery5 Images Best of TVLine 'Missing' Shows, Found! Get the Latest on Ahsoka, Monarch, P-Valley, Sugar, Anansi Boys and 25+ Others Yellowjackets Mysteries: An Up-to-Date List of the Series' Biggest Questions (and Answers?) The Emmys' Most Memorable Moments: Laughter, Tears, Historical Wins, 'The Big One' and More Solve the daily Crossword
