Red shoe rivalry: How papal footwear signalled deep divide between Pope Benedict and Pope Francis
Where Benedict leaned into tradition and visual grandeur with fur-lined vestments, gem-encrusted rings, and pectoral crosses, Francis opted for simplicity and humility—choices that reflect deeper divides within the modern Catholic Church. With both popes now deceased, their contrasting legacies continue to shape debates over the Church's future direction.
Pope Benedict often used clothing as a statement of continuity. His red shoe, historically worn by popes as a sign of martyrdom and ecclesiastical authority reflected his vision of a Church grounded in heritage and doctrine, especially at a time when global faith was facing deep scrutiny over scandal and secularisation.
Photo: Corbis
In contrast, Pope Francis, elected in 2013, immediately shifted the Church's visual tone. Rejecting opulence, he maintained his simple white cassock and shoes, setting aside many of the traditional trappings.
Photo: Vatican Pool
This choice aligned with his broader mission: a more inclusive and humble Catholicism. Francis focused on outreach to the poor, addressing climate change, and revising pastoral attitudes on issues like divorce and LGBTQ+ inclusion.
Despite efforts to present a united front, tensions surfaced publicly, notably when Benedict published a 2019 letter attributing the clerical abuse crisis to societal changes rather than institutional failures. Francis had already placed blame squarely on systemic power imbalances within the Church.
Following Benedict's resignation in 2013—the first by a pope in nearly 600 years—and his death in 2022, Pope Francis carried on the reforms. His passing, announced Monday, marks the end of an era shaped by their parallel influences.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
04-08-2025
- Express Tribune
Pope's 'Jubilee of Youth' ends with mass for 1m pilgrims
Pope Leo XIV presiding over the mass outside Rome on Sunday, a highlight of the Catholic Church's Jubilee year. Photo AFP Pope Leo XIV presided over a final mass in Rome for over one million young people on Sunday, the culmination of a pilgrimage that has drawn Catholics from across the world. "Aspire to great things, to holiness, wherever you are. Do not settle for less," Pope Leo told the crowd. The week-long "Jubilee of Youth" — a highlight of the Jubilee holy year — was an enormous undertaking for the Vatican, with a half a million young pilgrims in Rome for most of the week. On Saturday night, before a twilight vigil led by the pope, organisers said there were 800,000 people in the vast, open-air space on Rome's eastern outskirts, and on Sunday the Vatican said that number had grown to one million. Most of them spent the night in tents, in sleeping bags or on mats in anticipation of Sunday's mass. Among them was New Yorker Christofer Delano, who said he was "so happy to see Pope Leo" but stunned by the crowds. "I didn't expect to see all these people. I knew there was going to be a lot of people — I didn't know it was going to be this many," he told AFP. In his homily, the first US pope and former missionary encouraged the gathered youth to "spread your enthusiasm and the witness of your faith to everyone you meet!" The Vatican has sought to highlight pilgrims who travelled to Rome from war-torn regions, and Leo said in his Angelus prayer: "We are closer than ever to young people who suffer the most serious evils which are caused by other human beings." "We are with the young people of Gaza. We are with the young people of Ukraine, with those of every land bloodied by war," said the 69-year-old pontiff. "My young brothers and sisters, you are the sign that a different world is possible, a world of fraternity and friendship where conflicts are not resolved with weapons but with dialogue." The colourful event was accompanied by music from a choir, and about 450 bishops and 700 priests, all in green robes. A towering cross dominated the massive golden arch covering the stage where the pope led mass. Italian pilgrim Tommaso Benedetti said the pope had passed his "first test" in the eyes of young people during the youth jubilee. "We feel quite satisfied. There were many references to peace, which is a theme that is very close to our hearts as young people," Benedetti told AFP. The young pilgrims -- from 146 different countries, according to the Vatican -- have filled Rome's streets since Monday, chanting, singing and waving flags of their countries. The festive atmosphere reached a peak Saturday ahead of the vigil presided over by Leo, with Italian broadcaster Rai dubbing it a Catholic "Woodstock". Hundreds of thousands camped out at the dusty venue, strumming guitars or singing, as music blasted from the stage where a series of religious bands entertained the crowds. Leo was greeted with deafening screams and applause after his arrival by helicopter and as he toured the grounds in his popemobile, with many people running to catch a better glimpse of the new pope. Roads leading to the Tor Vegata venue, about a 40 minute drive from the centre of Rome, were packed, making Leo's choice of helicopter transportation on both Saturday and Sunday more efficient. At over 500,000 square metres (125 acres), the grounds were the size of around 70 football fields. British student Andy Hewellyn sat in front of a huge video screen — a prime spot, as he could not even see the stage far away. "I'm so happy to be here, even if I'm a bit far from the pope. I knew what to expect!" he told AFP. "The main thing is that we're all together." The youth pilgrimage came about three months after the start of Leo's papacy and 25 years after John Paul II organised the last such youth gathering in Rome. It was announced by Pope Francis during World Youth Day in Lisbon in 2023. The Church planned a series of events for the young pilgrims over the course of the week, including turning the Circus Maximus -- where chariot races were held in ancient Rome -- into an open-air confessional.
Business Recorder
17-07-2025
- Business Recorder
Israeli strikes kill 27 in Gaza, three die in church late pope often spoke to
CAIRO/OCCUPIED JERUSALEM: Israeli forces killed at least 27 people in attacks in the Gaza Strip on Thursday, including three people who died in a strike on a church that late Pope Francis used to speak to regularly, medics and church officials said. Eight men tasked with protecting aid trucks were reported among the dead in airstrikes that were carried out while mediators continued ceasefire talks in Doha. A U.S. official said this week the talks were going well but two officials from the Palestinian group Hamas told Reuters there had been no breakthrough as the Israeli military continued to pummel Gaza. Two women and one man died and several people were wounded in a strike by the Israeli army on Gaza's Holy Family Church, said the Latin Patriarchate of Jerusalem, which oversees the small parish. 'The Latin Patriarchate strongly condemns this tragedy and this targeting of innocent civilians and of a sacred place,' a statement by the Patriarchate said, adding that the victims had turned to the church compound as a safe haven 'after their homes, possessions, and dignity had already been stripped away'. 'This horrific war must come to a complete end,' it said. Photos released by the church showed its roof had been hit close to the main cross, scorching the stone facade, and that windows had been broken. Hamas says Israel wants to keep military control of Gaza Father Gabriele Romanelli, an Argentine who used to regularly update the late Pope Francis about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, was lightly injured in the attack. TV footage showed him sitting receiving treatment at Al-Ahly Hospital in Gaza, with a bandage around his lower right leg. Pope Leo said in a statement that he was 'deeply saddened' by the loss of life and renewed his appeal for an immediate ceasefire, while Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni said attacks on civilians were unacceptable. The Israeli military said it was looking into the incident. Israel's foreign ministry said in a statement on X that the results of the investigation would be published. It also said the country did not target churches or religious sites and regretted harm to them or civilians. Israel has been trying to eradicate Hamas in Gaza in a military campaign. Palestinian medics said one airstrike on Thursday had killed a man, his wife and their five children in Jabalia in northern Gaza, and that another in the north had killed eight men who had been handed responsibility for protecting aid trucks. Gaza Humanitarian Foundation says 20 people killed in an incident in Khan Younis Three people were killed in an airstrike in central Gaza and four in Zeitoun in eastern Gaza, medics said. Ceasefire talks Arab mediators Qatar and Egypt, backed by the United States, have hosted more than 10 days of talks on a proposed U.S. 60-day truce. As part of the potential deal, 10 hostages held in Gaza would be returned along with the bodies of 18 others, spread out over 60 days. In exchange, Israel would release detained Palestinians. The exact number is not clear. A Hamas source with knowledge of the matter said Israel had presented new maps to the mediators, pledging to pull the army further back than had previously been offered. The source said this partially met Hamas' demands, but was still insufficient. Disputes also remain over aid delivery mechanisms into Gaza, and guarantees that any eventual truce would lead to ending the war, said the two other Hamas officials who spoke to Reuters. Israel has told the mediators it is willing to drop its demand to maintain a military presence along the so-called Morag Corridor in southern Gaza during a ceasefire and is prepared to show flexibility regarding the size of the security buffer it would retain near the Israeli border, Israeli media reported. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's office did not immediately comment on the reports. On Wednesday, U.S. President Donald Trump's Middle East envoy, Steve Witkoff, said that negotiations for a ceasefire in Gaza were going well. A Palestinian official close to the talks said such optimistic comments were 'empty of substance.' Israel's campaign in Gaza has killed more than 58,000 Palestinians, according to Gaza health authorities.
Express Tribune
03-07-2025
- Express Tribune
Real fertility crisis in Pakistan
Listen to article The United Nations Population Fund (UNFPA) launched the State of World Population report 2025 on June 12 in Nairobi. This year's theme focuses on 'The Real Fertility Crisis: The Pursuit of Reproductive Agency in a Changing World'. While the report does not present new insights into the skewed fertility trends that have divided the globe, it provides a novel perspective on addressing what many politicians consider an existential threat. In some developing nations such as Pakistan, population growth and size are often seen as primary barriers to development and economic prosperity. Conversely, while a significant decline in total fertility rates poses a challenge to economic stability in various developed countries — such as China, Japan, and the rapidly advancing economies of Southeast Asia — other nations have managed to maintain population growth despite low fertility. Countries like Australia, Canada, France, Luxembourg, New Zealand, Sweden, the UK and the US have consistently recorded fertility rates below replacement level of 2.1 yet are expected to continue growing beyond 2054 largely due to sustained immigration policies. Therefore, the concerns about fertility as an existential threat are largely overstated. The socioeconomic, geopolitical and environmental ramifications of both high and low fertility rates are considerable, necessitating a thorough examination of their underlying factors. In the short term, socioeconomic elements, particularly urbanisation and evolving childbearing practices, significantly influence fertility trends. Since fertility rates are associated with the demographic transition — a seemingly widespread phenomenon - the potential public health consequences are quite detrimental. Changes in fertility patterns have intensified concerns related to birth rates, prompting governments to explore various policy options concerning childbirth and family planning. To effectively address the challenge around fertility rates, it is essential to first dispel the common misconceptions. The foremost misconception is that the global fertility rate is so low that humanity faces the threat of extinction. The current world fertility rate is estimated to exceed 2.2, indicating that the world population is still growing. Another pervasive misconception about fertility is that religion is the primary driver of rapid population growth. Although religious organisations, such as the Catholic Church and Islamic Shariah courts, may officially oppose artificial birth control, there is mostly a notable gap between the official stances of religious leaders and the actual behaviours of their followers. A compelling example is the Islamic Republic of Iran, which implemented one of the most successful family planning initiatives in history, leading to a remarkable decrease in the country's fertility rate from 6.5 to 1.6. A third major myth is the assumption that slower or faster population growth inherently harms the economy. Economic wellbeing depends more on the human capital and quality of skills than on population size or growth — especially in the era of artificial intelligence. UNFPA conducted a survey of approximately 14,000 individuals across 14 countries, which together represent over 37% of the world's population. Most respondents expressed a desire to have two or more children. Notably, one in five individuals under the age of 50 fear they will not reach their ideal family size, while one in ten anticipate having fewer children than they would prefer — compared to only 7% who expect to have more. Among respondents over the age of 50, more than 40% reported not having the number of children they would ideally have, with 31% having fewer and 12% having more. More than half of all respondents identified economic challenges — such as financial insecurity, job insecurity, the cost of housing and childcare — as barriers to having the number of children they desire. Almost one in five reported having experienced a situation where they were unable to access medical or health services related to contraception or reproductive health. These findings suggest that the real question is not about the attitude of the people but the policies and incentives that shape or limit their reproductive choices. This report is the first-ever UN document that examines the reasons behind the declining birth rates. UNFPA supports nations in building demographic resilience by taking a comprehensive approach to their population dynamics, thereby alleviating adverse impacts and seizing opportunities presented by demographic shifts. Almost half of all pregnancies globally are unplanned. Furthermore, in the European Union, the number of childless single-person households surged by 21% from 2013 to 2023. Considering growing concerns about a potential 'depopulation crisis', recent findings reveal that while most individuals desire to have children, many encounter overwhelming obstacles. Women and young individuals are often criticised for supposedly 'rejecting' parenthood, but surveys indicate that most people across various countries aspire to have two or more children. New statistics demonstrate that both women and men experience significant restrictions on their reproductive choices. The report reveals that two in three women in Pakistan cannot make decision about their reproductive health. In addition, the family planning needs of 16% of women across Pakistan remain unmet. The quest of ensuring reproductive agency of people, especially women, demands recognition of their reproductive rights. Apart from economic and policy factors, social factors such as gender-based violence and child marriage limit the autonomy and reproductive agency of women and girls. The challenges that hinder individuals from preventing unintended pregnancies frequently overlap with those that restrict their ability to achieve their desired family size, including economic marginalisation, gender inequality, inadequate access to healthcare and a pervasive sense of hopelessness about the future. I believe the key issue is recognising the significance of reproductive rights, which encompasses the quest for reproductive agency. It is well-recognised that the realisation of women's reproductive rights is intrinsically linked to gender equality and women's empowerment. Gender-based violence significantly undermines women's ability to make informed decisions about their reproductive health and heightens their risk of experiencing adverse reproductive health outcomes.
