Tensions rise as man refuses to leave Selwyn council meeting
Photo:
Supplied
A Selwyn District Council meeting ground to a halt when a public speaker refused to leave the table.
Peter Schnell fronted the council demanding answers over a pit on his Creyke Road property, near Darfield, in what is a longstanding dispute between his family and the council.
At the meeting, Schnell presented in the public forum but refused to leave his seat until he had an answer from the council.
Mayor Sam Broughton was forced to adjourn the meeting "due to the atmosphere in the room".
Schnell told the meeting there was a legal reserve on his property and claimed someone started an extraction pit in the wrong location 100 years ago.
"I was always promised the titles would be moved," he said.
Schnell alleged the council has allowed all manner of dumping in the pit over the years, which has left the land unproductive without a $30,000 cleanup.
Schnell said the council had offered him a $13,000 compensation package and to "take responsibility for what's been dumped in this pit by the council".
He said he has turned down that offer because he has spent $15,000 on lawyers seeking reparations, and has also sent the council "an account for all the material they have extracted and dumped in there".
Schnell demanded "a realistic conversation of paying my account".
"I want answers. After 50 years, we're starting to get a little frustrated. All you can do is offer me an insult and a compensation package."
He threatened to stop paying his rates until he received a realistic answer or the council took him to court.
"And I would like an answer today, so I'm going to sit here until I get one, or you can have me forcibly removed by the police."
At that point Broughton, who noted that he and chief executive Sharon Mason met with Schnell recently to discuss the matter, said the councillors would not be able to provide that answer at the meeting.
"We are not going to get into a backwards and forwards here."
Schnell then refused to vacate the chair.
Selwyn Mayor Sam Broughton.
Photo:
RNZ / Niva Chittock
Broughton adjourned the meeting as members of the public gallery began to leave the heated confrontation.
"This is not the way we conduct business in this chamber," the mayor said. "We are here to listen to you and we have done that sensibly, and we do not feel that is the right way to go."
As the councillors, staff, and public cleared the room, Schnell rose from the chair, exclaiming "I think I've made my point" as he walked out.
Mason said the council maintained its position that it has no liability, as gravel extraction was originally undertaken over 70 years ago with the consent of Schnell's grandfather.
"Council ceased operations prior to 2003, and Schnell has had full control of the site since then.
"Council has offered two resolution options, both including $13,000 compensation for historic use and a five-year discounted licence. One option involves Schnell purchasing the reserve land via the Department of Conservation."
The offers remain open until September, she said.
"Council remains committed to a fair and lawful resolution," Mason said.
- LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
11 minutes ago
- RNZ News
Invercargill mayor thought brother was 'taking the mickey' with bid for top job
Andrew Clark, who also goes by middle name Maxwell, is standing for mayor at opposite ends of the South Island. Photo: Supplied Invercargill mayoral candidates are questioning the motive behind the current mayor's brother's decision to stand for the city's top job. Not only is Andrew Clark going by two names - he is also running for mayor in two regions. Outgoing Invercargill mayor Nobby Clark's brother is known as Max Clark in Tasman, where he lives and hopes to become mayor. But other candidates seeking the Invercargill mayoral chains are familiar with an Andrew Clark, after he turned up at a code of conduct hearing to discuss Nobby's behaviour last year. During the meeting, he made his way to the council table uninvited, to introduce himself and thank them for their support. Deputy mayor Tom Campbell called the tilt for Invercargill's mayoralty a strange move and said he found Andrew "a slightly strange guy". Councillor Alex Crackett said the real test would be whether the community saw genuine commitment. "I think it's been done to elicit a bit of a response. But the real question is whether it's wanted - and that's up to the community to decide which candidates have shown commitment, and are genuinely in it for the long haul," she said. But Andrew Clark said he was brimming with ideas for Invercargill. "I'm very passionate about the people, the economics and the environment of Invercargill. And that's why I'm standing." Nobby was not convinced : "I thought he was taking the mickey, to be honest." He said he was caught unawares by the move, and he was concerned his brother might be leveraging off the family name - which would not be fair on the other candidates. Andrew Clark said that was not the case and that members of the local business community encouraged him to run - although he would not say who. He said he phoned his brother the night before announcing his bid. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
41 minutes ago
- RNZ News
Parents cautiously optimistic about waving goodbye to NCEA
Education Minister Erica Stanford and Prime Minister Christopher Luxon announce changes to NCEA. Photo: RNZ / Nick Monro A Dunedin mum is hopeful the changes to NCEA will benefit her Year 7 son, but another says she's a "bit scared". The government has pulled the pin on New Zealand's official secondary-school qualification after more than 20 years. The National Certificate of Educational Achievement will be gone by 2030, replaced by a basic literacy and numeracy award at Year 11, and the Certificate of Education and Advanced Certificate of Education at Years 11 and 12. 'Achieved', 'not achieved', 'merit' and 'excellence' will be replaced by marks out of 100 and letter grades A, B, C, D and E. The new certificates would be standards-based, like the NCEA is, meaning every student passes if they demonstrate the required knowledge or skills, but they would have to study at least five complete subjects and pass four of them to get their certificate. A Dunedin mum, who RNZ has agreed not to name to protect the identity of her child, was optimistic about the move . "It will be an advantage to him because it gives that nice, stringent 'I know what I need to head for, I need to study really hard for this'." She called NCEA a "step backwards", saying the change was a return of a more structured way of learning and a focus on core subjects . "As an employer of people coming out of university, I can tell you it kind of sets them up a little bit for failure in real life," she said. "I find that the English levels, the maths levels and science levels coming out for students just isn't quite as good as some of the historical stuff that I've seen coming out of the older styles." Another mum, who has a son just starting university and a daughter in Year 9, said the NCEA system was confusing. "Even I couldn't understand this credit system and achieved system. I always thought 'what is this? Credits? Credits?'. "But one thing I've noticed, if he knows he has got enough credits, then he decides he's not going to work any harder." The new grading system could push them to study harder or discourage them from learning, she said. "As a parent, I am a bit scared, to be honest." She was uncertain how students would respond to the changes, saying it would depend on how they were implemented. A grandmother who lived with her Year 8 grandson said she was on board with the changes if they helped students. "That's what I would be hoping for. Something that makes it easier for the kids to show that they've really, really tried and that they do want to be at school and they want to learn and that they want to get a job when they get away from school, and that they want a better life." But she was worried some students might choose to drop out if they had to pass four of their five subjects to get one of the new certificates. "That does sound a bit tough because if a child or a young adult can't handle exams - to pass four subjects may just be beyond their capability," she said. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
41 minutes ago
- RNZ News
FBI director Kash Patel on Kiwi soil
Photo: supplied Was it a big deal or not? The head of the FBI, Director Kash Patel, was sprung by a Herald journalist lurking in the basement of the Beehive. His appearance came after another reporter twigged that the FBI's plane was sitting on the tarmac at Wellington airport. The avalanche of mumbling 'no comment' from MPs was quickly followed by a release from the US Embassy about exactly why such an exciting guest was here - the FBI hanging its shingle out in the Capital. "Kash Patel being spotted in the Beehive basement felt like the start of a good spy movie," says RNZ political reporter Anneke Smith. But the FBI has long had a presence in New Zealand, and a former spy spoken to by The Detail says it's no big deal. So why did we get so excited about it? Maybe because everyone loves it when a secret gets out. Today on The Detail , Smith tells us how the story unravelled, and a Senior Lecturer in Security Studies at Massey University, Dr Rhys Ball, questions the significance of the event. Patel himself said - through a carefully curated media package and video that was rigged to look like a press conference, though it wasn't - that it was all about transnational crime including countering the narcotics trade, cybercrime, and " countering the CCP ", the Chinese Communist Party. The FBI was "opening up our law enforcement attaché office here in Wellington," he said, to show "the world that the FBI is actually prioritising a permanent presence across all Five Eyes countries, and here in New Zealand we had not had that until this historic moment". The China comment was a very different line to what the New Zealand government took, Smith says. Ministers later that day were reiterating that it was all about cracking down on crime in the Indo-Pacific. Foreign Minister Winston Peters said the issue of China had not come up in their meeting. "Two very different tacks I think taken from New Zealand and the US," says Smith, "the US being quite bolshie in terms of framing this up with the wider context in terms of the geo-political contest in the Indo-Pacific region." China called the FBI director's statements "groundless assertions" and described his comments as part of a "Cold War mentality". And that's why our politicians played that aspect of this visit down. "New Zealand(ers) will be well aware we have an important trade relationship with China, they're our biggest trading partner, they're about a third of our exports, a lot of meat and dairy go to China so a really significant trading relationship there," says Smith. "We walk very much through the centre line of a lot of hefty controversial subjects on that because of our trading relationship. "The US, on the other hand, doesn't hold back." Kash Patel is a controversial figure and a Trump loyalist, who's a conspiracy theorist, supporter of the rioters on the Capitol, an anti-vaxxer and has been accused of perjury. "I don't think any of that came up during his visit to New Zealand last week," says Smith. "That was all about opening the office and signalling it's here in the Indo-Pacific." Dr Rhys Ball says the move isn't really a big deal. "It's part of the usual relationship or engagement that intelligence and security agencies have," he says. "Particularly in the Five Eyes community. The legal attaché role within the FBI is a simple liaison office role, and there's been engagement with Bureau legal attaches for a long time." He says there are New Zealand police liaison agents in other countries around the world, and that's usually a quid-pro-quo situation. The difference now is that where the legal attaché in Canberra used to be responsible for New Zealand, that person is now in Wellington. "One perhaps can speculate that particular role for the Canberra Legat office has got quite big now and the business that needs to be discussed has expanded to the point where the Bureau, and Wellington, feel the need for a permanent presence in Wellington," says Ball. He says cooperation between various international law enforcement agencies has increased in the last five to 10 years, particularly between the United States, Australia and New Zealand. "Things are picking up to the point where there's benefit in a permanent presence in Wellington." Check out how to listen to and follow The Detail here . You can also stay up-to-date by liking us on Facebook or following us on Twitter .
