Auckland's Covid lockdown cut Northland off from rest of country, Royal Commission of Inquiry told
Photo:
RNZ / Luka Forman
Northland's business community says Auckland was one of the region's biggest obstacles during the Covid-19 pandemic.
The region's chamber of commerce was questioned as part of the Royal Commission of Inquiry into
New Zealand's pandemic response
.
When the country went into a two-month lockdown in March of 2020, businesses like those owned by NorthChamber president Tim Robinson
took it on the chin
.
Speaking to the Royal Commission of Inquiry on Monday, Robinson said Northland's business community accepted the lockdown was necessary.
"Because of the nature of our business, there was nothing we could do until we came out of lockdown. We just had to sort of just accept that and just kind of, you know, carry on," he said.
"All in all, I think all of us just sort of thought, yep, we're dealing with something brand new. The response was absolutely appropriate. It gave us a chance to sort of stop and then think, well, what's going to happen next and where are we going to head to next?"
But when a second nationwide lockdown started in August of 2021, NorthChamber chief executive Leah McKerrow said the sentiment shifted.
"A lot of fear existed. And fear is one of those core emotions that permeates through, and unless you can actually address that fear, then it is very difficult to help people shift," she said.
"In that second lockdown, some of that fear was starting to be replaced with anger."
That was compounded by a vaccine mandate that a number of New Zealanders found a step too far, she said.
"It comes back to human beings and emotion. The fear that is driven through people who didn't want to be vaccinated and it started to, I think, unravel some of that community cohesion."
Tim Robinson said the unrest made it difficult to do business.
"You just never knew who was going to pop their hand up and say, 'this is ridiculous, I'm not going to buy into that. I'm never going to get vaccinated'. And somebody walking in the shop thinking, oh, yep, they're a kind, rational person, and next thing they're ranting and raving," he said.
"And you've got to somehow deal with that and try and be polite and say, well, actually, those are the rules. I didn't make them."
Robinson said Northland also faced unexpected challenges during Auckland's own citywide lockdowns.
He said the supercity became a wall separating his region from the rest of the country.
"A lot of companies started to make decisions based around 'how easy is it to transact in and out of Northland?' The overwhelming perception became, well, it's bloody hard," he said.
"So many companies still see us as being very hard to do business with. You know, we had Covid, then we had the year of rain and the cyclones and the road closures, and people just going, 'you know what, it's just so hard'."
Leah McKerrow agreed.
"I think, for me, the biggest challenge for Northland was Auckland," she laughed.
"But, you know, quite seriously, the fact is we have to drive through this place. And so
finding a solution
to that so that if Auckland, you know, does have some sort of disease in the future that we can at least drive through."
She said maintaining road access to Northland should be a key lesson for the Royal Commission.
The hearing continues.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
21 minutes ago
- RNZ News
Slinging match as dirty politics engulfs Wellington mayoral race
Wellington City Councillor Ray Chung says and email he wrote to three fellow councillors in 2023 about an alleged sex encounter involving Mayor Tory Whanau has been released to discredit his mayoral campaign. Photo: RNZ / Samuel Rillstone Wellington mayoral candidate Ray Chung says he regrets writing an email with third-hand claims about incumbent Mayor Tory Whanau, but believes the email's release was an attempt to discredit him and his campaign. Chung sent an email, seen by RNZ, to three fellow councillors in early 2023 recounting a story he'd been told by his neighbour about the neighbour's son allegedly having a sexual encounter with the mayor. The email surfaced last week. Whanau rejected the contents of the email and said it was false and contained a "malicious and sexist" rumour. In a video statement on social media Chung said the email was released deliberately to discredit him. "This attack on me and our Independent Together candidates is designed to undermine our campaign," he said. Chung had previously indicated he would be apologising to the mayor in the video. He had told Morning Report on Friday he wouldn't object to apologising. But in his Sunday statement he said, "I regret writing it and I regret sharing it with people whom I thought trustworthy". Chung said since the email's contents had surfaced he had encountered abuse in public. High-profile donor and philanthropist Sir Mark Dunajtschik had also withdrawn his support for Chung saying he did not support his behaviour. Chung said the email's release was a "blatant political attack". "I have not and will not conduct personal attacks against other candidates in the selection," he said. "I will play the ball, not the person." "Dirty politics will not be tolerated. I will call it out," he said. Wellington Mayor Tory Whanau has slammed Ray Chung's campaign as being characterised dirty politics. Photo: RNZ / Samuel Rillstone Tory Whanau said Chung's campaign was characterised by "unethical and dirty politics". "Ray Chung's recent actions and public statements reflect a significant lack of accountability and a disregard for basic decency," she said in a statement. Whanau said the city deserved elected members who upheld the highest standards of respect, honesty, and integrity. "It is also important to emphasise that this poor behaviour has not occurred in isolation; it has been enabled by some councillors, lobby groups, mayoral candidates, and a few members of the media," she said. "I hope they also take this moment to reflect on their respective roles and consider how we can collectively create a respectful environment. "Those who wish to stand for public office, particularly women and Māori, deserve this. Our constituents deserve this too." Other media report that Whanau released the email. RNZ has sought clarification from the Mayor's office about who gave the email to the New Zealand Herald , which first reported the story. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
27 minutes ago
- RNZ News
A radical tax plan to avoid an economic 'car crash'
Photo: RNZ Have you ever wished the tax you paid on your income was going into savings, rather than to the government? That's the idea behind a plan developed by former Finance Minister Sir Roger Douglas and University of Auckland economics professor Robert MacCulloch. They first developed the proposal in 2016 but have updated it for 2025. "Back in 2016, the original version said we're going to struggle with paying the welfare bills and there are going to be budgetary problems due to the aging population, from health to pension spending and we have to work out how to protect the welfare state so there are not cuts to those services," MacCulloch said. "At the time, Bill English had an economic advisory group that I used to go to in the Beehive and… he didn't have any interest whatsoever. I remember him saying, 'look that's for future governments to deal with and people will have to adapt'." But MacCulloch said the governments since then had done nothing to address the issue. Treasury and Inland Revenue have both raised questions in the past year about how the government will collect enough revenue to fund the increasing cost of NZ Super and healthcare. Sir Roger Douglas. Photo: Celebrity Speakers By 2060, 26 percent of New Zealanders will be over 65, up from 16 percent in 2021. MacCulloch and Sir Roger said that income tax on earnings up to $60,000 a year should instead be redirected into individual savings accounts to fund each person's healthcare pension and risk cover. That would replace much of the current public system with private provision. People who did not have enough in their individual accounts could still be helped by the public system, which would be funded on taxes collected on income over $60,000 a year. This would mean larger numbers of middle- and higher-income people paying for their themselves, while the system helped lower-income people. "It retains that wealth redistribution - so is not at all like the US system which leaves many low income people without proper healthcare. It's more like France where everyone is covered and everyone can choose whether they go public or private." Finance Minister Nicola Willis has been approached for comment. MacCulloch said that would mean government costs were reduced, the quality of outcomes increased and the plight of low-income earners improved. He said too many low-income people had no savings in KiwiSaver . This model would help to address that. According to the model, an individual could save around $21,000 annually: $9450 into a health account, $7350 for superannuation, and $4200 for risk cover. A drop in corporate taxes would help fund employer contributions. "Our savings-not-taxation reform offers scope for efficiency gains in healthcare. It does so by opening up choice for individuals," MacCulloch said. "Rather than the government dictating where to go, people can choose their preferred public or private supplier." They would keep the pension but raise the age of eligibility to 70 over a 20-year period, Subsidies and interest-free loans for tertiary students would be means tested. They would scrap grants to the movie industry, winter energy subsidies to wealthy households, favourable tax treatment for owners of rental housing, and allowances to sectors such as forestry, fishing, and bloodstock. The money saved from these changes would be directed towards helping low earners build savings and cover the welfare needs of those who are chronically unwell. "Perhaps more than any other feature of our reform, it's the 'miracle of compound interest' that governments like New Zealand's are not taking proper advantage of," MacCulloch said. "If we can do this, it'll help our financial situation." He said the problem the government now had was that it was not set to return to surplus in any meaningful way. "What the government calls a return to surplus is a projection [of] a tiny surplus in 2029 and then [the deficit] blows out again with health and pension spending." He said many countries around the world were having to make changes because of similar pressures. But he said there was still limited political interest. "What I can tell you is by not going down this road, what they're not telling you is a slow motion car crash crisis is enveloping New Zealand and it's not my job to save the country with this. "I did the proposal. They have no interest. I've given up on them. But you know what? Without doing something like this, they're gradually descending into a situation where our entire health system is going to become rundown." He said New Zealand had missed a chance to require compulsory retirement savings. "The average KiwiSaver balance is $30,000. A mandatory retirement scheme was set up by Keating around 2000 in Australia and the average balance in the Aussie system scheme is $300,000." He said the power of compound interest meant that large balances grew much faster, which meant New Zealand was being left increasingly behind. But his plan would allow New Zealanders to take advantage of that. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
34 minutes ago
- RNZ News
Tax plan to avoid looming economic 'car crash'
Photo: RNZ Have you ever wished the tax you paid on your income was going into savings, rather than to the government? That's the idea behind a plan developed by former Finance Minister Sir Roger Douglas and University of Auckland economics professor Robert MacCulloch. They first developed the proposal in 2016 but have updated it for 2025. "Back in 2016, the original version said we're going to struggle with paying the welfare bills and there are going to be budgetary problems due to the aging population, from health to pension spending and we have to work out how to protect the welfare state so there are not cuts to those services," MacCulloch said. "At the time, Bill English had an economic advisory group that I used to go to in the Beehive and… he didn't have any interest whatsoever. I remember him saying, 'look that's for future governments to deal with and people will have to adapt'." But MacCulloch said the governments since then had done nothing to address the issue. Treasury and Inland Revenue have both raised questions in the past year about how the government will collect enough revenue to fund the increasing cost of NZ Super and healthcare. Sir Roger Douglas. Photo: Celebrity Speakers By 2060, 26 percent of New Zealanders will be over 65, up from 16 percent in 2021. MacCulloch and Sir Roger said that income tax on earnings up to $60,000 a year should instead be redirected into individual savings accounts to fund each person's healthcare pension and risk cover. That would replace much of the current public system with private provision. People who did not have enough in their individual accounts could still be helped by the public system, which would be funded on taxes collected on income over $60,000 a year. This would mean larger numbers of middle- and higher-income people paying for their themselves, while the system helped lower-income people. "It retains that wealth redistribution - so is not at all like the US system which leaves many low income people without proper healthcare. It's more like France where everyone is covered and everyone can choose whether they go public or private." Finance Minister Nicola Willis has been approached for comment. MacCulloch said that would mean government costs were reduced, the quality of outcomes increased and the plight of low-income earners improved. He said too many low-income people had no savings in [ KiwiSaver. This model would help to address that. According to the model, an individual could save around $21,000 annually: $9450 into a health account, $7350 for superannuation, and $4200 for risk cover. A drop in corporate taxes would help fund employer contributions. "Our savings-not-taxation reform offers scope for efficiency gains in healthcare. It does so by opening up choice for individuals," MacCulloch said. "Rather than the government dictating where to go, people can choose their preferred public or private supplier." They would keep the pension but raise the age of eligibility to 70 over a 20-year period, Subsidies and interest-free loans for tertiary students would be means tested. They would scrap grants to the movie industry, winter energy subsidies to wealthy households, favourable tax treatment for owners of rental housing, and allowances to sectors such as forestry, fishing, and bloodstock. The money saved from these changes would be directed towards helping low earners build savings and cover the welfare needs of those who are chronically unwell. "Perhaps more than any other feature of our reform, it's the 'miracle of compound interest' that governments like New Zealand's are not taking proper advantage of," MacCulloch said. "If we can do this, it'll help our financial situation." He said the problem the government now had was that it was not set to return to surplus in any meaningful way. "What the government calls a return to surplus is a projection [of] a tiny surplus in 2029 and then [the deficit] blows out again with health and pension spending." He said many countries around the world were having to make changes because of similar pressures. But he said there was still limited political interest. "What I can tell you is by not going down this road, what they're not telling you is a slow motion car crash crisis is enveloping New Zealand and it's not my job to save the country with this. "I did the proposal. They have no interest. I've given up on them. But you know what? Without doing something like this, they're gradually descending into a situation where our entire health system is going to become rundown." He said New Zealand had missed a chance to require compulsory retirement savings. "The average KiwiSaver balance is $30,000. A mandatory retirement scheme was set up by Keating around 2000 in Australia and the average balance in the Aussie system scheme is $300,000." He said the power of compound interest meant that large balances grew much faster, which meant New Zealand was being left increasingly behind. But his plan would allow New Zealanders to take advantage of that. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
