
What we learned from Sandie Peggie employment tribunal
Here is what we learned from day 11 of the tribunal.
Sandie Peggie cleared
The most significant revelation came hours before the tribunal had even began.
Maragret Gribbon, the solicitor for Ms Peggie, revealed her client had been cleared all four allegations of gross misconduct against her.
She was suspended in January 2024 following a row with Dr Upton over the trans medic's use of female only changing rooms.
Further allegations emerged, including that the nurse 'walked out of a resuscitation unit when Dr Upton entered, leaving a patient unseen'.
Another allegation, alleged to have occurred on December 18, 2023, claimed a patient was triaged and left the hospital without being seen.
In a statement, NHS Fife concluded there had been 'insufficient evidence' to support any misconduct claims.
Read more:
The ramifications for this are significant and it is unlikely that this will be the end of this.
First Minister John Swinney is also facing criticism after he said he had 'confidence' in the board of NHS Fife despite the misconduct allegations being cleared.
NHS Fife's 'secret' trans policy
NHS Fife did not have a trans inclusion policy at the time of the incident in 2023.
We were told by Ms Bumba that the health board "soft launched" a policy for feedback in October 2024.
We learned that the health board launched its policy in February.
Prior to that, Ms Bumba told the tribunal that she relied on the guidance used by other health boards, particularly in Lanarkshire, Greater Glasgow and Clyde and Highland.
Ms Bumba also said she would have been "Googling" to find out other policies from around the country.
These policies generally said that trans individuals should be treated in accordance with their "self-declared gender".
Workplace regulations were not consulted
In a crucial piece of evidence, Ms Bumba said she did give consideration to the Workplace (Health, Safety and Welfare) Regulations 1992.
However, she admitted that in hindsight she probably would consider it because of the evolving nature of the issue.
She is, of course, referring to the Supreme Court judgment, which ruled that the definition of a woman is linked to biological sex.
Why is this important? The Workplace Regulations state that there must be separate facilities for men and women where necessary.
Excluding Dr Upton could be 'discriminatory'
Dr Bumba told the tribunal she issued the guidance because restricting Dr Upton's access to female changing facilities could "be deemed discriminatory".
She said: Ms Bumba said: "I said it could be deemed discriminatory to not allow a trans person access to facilities that aligned with their gender. But I recommended that it might be worthwhile having a conversation with the person directly, if they'd been open about their trans status, to see where they would feel most comfortable."
Ms Bumba said she was given very limited information relating to the incident between Ms Peggie and Dr Upton.
While she was told it related to a "protected characteristic", Ms Bumba maintains she did not know who the people concerned were.
Based on this information, she advised that it could be "discriminatory" towards Dr Upton as it concerned comments about the doctor's trans status.
"It sounded like it was comments that were being made specifically about this person's trans status.
'It sounded quite unpleasant based on what was written," she said.
But crucially, Ms Bumba also said she advised that Ms Peggie's gender critical views must be respected.
The idea of Dr Upton being discriminated against became a key issue of contention when Ms Bumba was quizzed by Naomi Cunningham, a barrister representing Ms Upton.
The barrister asked whether women like Ms Peggie would have been disadvantaged by the decisions taken.
Ms Bumba said there was "no reason" for her to think that women might be concerned about being exposed to sexual harassment.
Harm caused by trans people vs men
Another significant issue of contention related to Ms Cunningham's question which asked whether a trans person using a single-sex space would "put women at significant risk".
Ms Bumba argued that the prospect of harm from a trans woman was "significantly less" that the danger posed by men.
She also said it could have been potentially isolating for Dr Upton to have been instructed to use a "private space" to change away from women.
This was a solution offered to Ms Peggie - but importantly not by Ms Bumba.
Bumba denies being biased towards trans community
The tribunal heard that Ms Bumba signs off her work emails with the statement 'LGBT ally'.
Lawyers acting on behalf of Ms Peggie questioned whether this meant the equality lead was "positioned on one side of the debate" and whether she believed gender reassignment and sexual orientation were the most important protected characteristics.
Ms Bumba said her signature did not suggest these were her main priorities.
"I'm an ally to trans people yes, but that doesn't mean I am not an ally to women," she said.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Daily Mail
26 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
X Factor star reveals 'devastating' diagnosis after years of suffering physical pain and mental anguish as famous friends rush to offer support
X Factor star Ella Henderson has revealed she's been diagnosed with endometriosis, which she claimed was both 'devastating' yet 'validating' after finally discovering the route of her chronic pain. The songstress, 29, who found fame on the show in 2012, took to her Instagram on Wednesday as she bravely opened up about the mental toll the condition had also taken and left fearing she was making up her symptoms. Endometriosis occurs when cells in the lining of the uterus are found elsewhere in the body. Symptoms include pain, heavy periods and fatigue, as well as a higher risk of infertility, and bowel and bladder problems. In a clip the Ghost hitmaker said: 'The last few years have been a bit of a rollercoaster to say the least, behind the scenes and I've really really been struggling,' 'With not only stomach bloating and physical pain and mental health, because at one point I thought all this pain was in y head and I wasn't really believed'. Later writing in a statement: 'After years of struggling with confusing and challenging health problems including stomach bloating, bowel pain and heavy periods. 'Plus countless GP appointments leading to scans, tests and the feeling that maybe the pain was all in my head, I was officially diagnosed with Endometriosis in January this year. Ella continued: 'The revelation came after a laparoscopy, which found severe endometriosis behind my uterus and scar tissue affecting my bladder and bowel. 'For those who are unfamiliar with this condition (just like I was only months ago) - endometriosis occurs when cells similar to the ones in the lining of the womb are found elsewhere in the body'. "The diagnosis was a difficult one to swallow but on the other hand it feels validating and empowering. It meant I wasn't imagining things after all, and 1 could finally find a way forward and take control of my body'. 'My long journey to an endometriosis diagnosis is not unique. It takes on average up to 9 years in the UK, which for many like me, can put an immense mental and physical toll on you. "Living in chronic pain, not being believed, and constant misdiagnosis led to periods of depression, isolation and anxiety. If health practitioners had recognised my endometriosis symptoms sooner, I might all that have been spared'. "Although it took a long time (like many women out there) to finally get a definitive diagnosis, it has allowed me to receive appropriate and life-changing support. "Which, in my case, was surgery, that so far helped to significantly reduce my symptoms. Unfortunately, there is no actual cure for endometriosis,' Later writing in a statement: 'After years of struggling with confusing and challenging health problems including stomach bloating, bowel pain and heavy periods' 'So ongoing management will likely be part of my life, whether that's through lifestyle changes, pain management, or other treatments'. Ella's fans and famous friends alike were quick to rush to the comment and offer her their support. TV's Gabby Roslin shared a slew of love heart emojis while broadcaster Miranda Burns said: 'Worst club with the best members. thank you for sharing Ella. Sending lots of love'. Following her appearance on the X Factor, where she became the eighth contestant eliminated, Ella has gone on to release hit single Ghost, Glow and Yours. WHAT IS ENDOMETRIOSIS? Endometriosis occurs when cells in the lining of the uterus are found elsewhere in the body. Each month, these cells react in the same way as those in the uterus; building up, breaking down and bleeding. Yet, the blood has no way to escape the body. Symptoms include pain, heavy periods and fatigue, as well as a higher risk of infertility, and bowel and bladder problems. Its cause is unknown but may be genetic, related to problems with the immune system or exposure to chemicals. Treatment focuses on pain relief and improving quality of life, which may include surgery or hormone treatment.


Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
The science-backed workout that makes men TALLER in just two months - and you can really see the difference
When Sydney estate lawyer Oliver Morrisey realised his job was starting to take both a physical and emotional toll, he knew he had to change up his fitness regimen. 'Years of courtrooms and being bent over a desk had pulled my shoulders down and smushed my back together,' Oliver says.


Daily Mirror
2 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
DWP issues update as 630,000 households owed up to £12,000 after PIP error
PIP is a benefit that is awarded to people who may need extra help with day-to-day activities due to an illness, disability or mental health condition Personal Independence Payment (PIP) benefit claimants could still be owed cash from the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) following a major payment error. PIP is a benefit that is awarded to people who may need extra help with day-to-day activities due to an illness, disability or mental health condition. It comes in two parts - the daily living rate, and the mobility rate - and you can be entitled to both or just one of these, depending on how your condition affects your life. Most people must undertake a health assessment where a point system is used to determine how much PIP you are eligible for. However, a Supreme Court ruling in July 2019 - known as the MM judgement - changed the way the DWP defines "social support" in relation to one of the daily living questions. Following the ruling, the DWP had to change how it assesses the need for social support when engaging with other people face to face, as part of the PIP assessment. It means hundreds of thousands of PIP claimants were due additional points for this activity. The DWP launched an administrative exercise back in 2021 - but in a new update, it has been revealed that hundreds of thousands of cases still need to be reviewed. An estimated 633,338 households receiving PIP are thought to have been affected. Of this figure, the DWP has reviewed 527,745 cases and paid out £250million. This means there are still 105,593 cases waiting to be reviewed. The average payout is £5,285 each - however, some payments will be higher, and some lower. One claimant was entitled to a £12,000 back payment. There are other PIP errors also being corrected by the DWP. This includes PIP claimants who did not have their claim processed because they didn't have a National Insurance – despite an NI number not being needed for a claim. Some 455 cases of this were reviewed in the last year with £500,000 paid out. The DWP has also paid out £13million to Scottish PIP claimants who mistakenly saw a "loss of entitlement" when they tried moving over to the Adult Disability Payment (ADP). Almost 4,700 records of this have been reviewed, with another 176 cases still to be looked at. The daily living rate of PIP is worth £73.90 a week if you're awarded the lower rate, or £110.40 a week for the higher rate. The mobility rate is worth £29.20 a week for the lower rate, or £77.05 a week for the higher rate. PIP is paid every four weeks, so if you're awarded the maximum rates for both the daily living and mobility elements, then you would get £749.80 every four weeks.