Buy Now, Pay Later loans will factor in to Americans' credit scores
FICO plans to launch a suite of credit scores later this year that incorporate BNPL data, providing lenders a window into what's been a big blind spot: consumers' repayment behavior on these increasingly popular installment loans.
BNPL loans can serve as an alternative to credit cards and are used by consumers who are seeking more flexible payment options, who want to overcome a tight financial spot, or who are looking to smooth out some bigger transactions to better meet their budgets.
For some consumers, the inclusion of BNPL data in the company's FICO Score 10 and FICO Score 10 T models could help serve as a credit-builder — or even a credit buster.
'A lot of BNPL users are often young people who don't have long credit histories,' Ted Rossman, chief credit analyst at Bankrate, told CNN in an interview. 'That's the more optimistic use case, that these people could be brought into the credit system. And if they use Buy Now, Pay Later responsibly, it should help them.'
BNPL loans have become more widely available and adoption rates have increased as people of all ages — especially younger adults — have grown more comfortable incorporating them into their shopping habits.
However, BNPL comes with such ease that people can quickly spend well beyond their means — especially if they have multiple installment loans running at the same time. A Bankrate survey conducted in May found that nearly half of all BNPL users experienced at least one problem, and overspending topped the list.
Consumer advocates and economists alike also have expressed concern about how consumers have used BNPL loans, including a recent uptick in installment financing used for everyday purchases such as groceries.
Another question mark with BNPL has been its role in the mushrooming of 'phantom debt.'
By and large, the popular installment loan activity is a gigantic black box. The industry remains largely unregulated, and BNPL providers aren't required to report to credit agencies, lenders or other data-keepers.
And regulations likely aren't coming any time soon: The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, under the Trump administration, dropped planned enforcement of a Biden administration rule that would have treated BNPL providers like credit card companies.
FICO says its FICO Score 10 BNPL and FICO Score 10 T BNPL — set to launch this fall — would be the first credit scores from a leading scoring company to account for Buy Now, Pay Later activity.
Bankrate's Rossman said Monday's 'eye-catching' announcement is a step in the right direction for having a fuller and more accurate representation of consumers' credit activity; however, he noted that the pace of that progress might not be that swift.
'My suspicion is that this may be a slower rollout than one might think at first glance,' he said.
That's because credit tracking, scoring and reporting is a complex business.
For example, FICO scores are the most widely used by lenders (the company touts that its scores are used in 90% of lending decisions); however, not all lenders use the same scoring model.
FICO Score 10 and FICO Score 10 T are among the newest releases, but the most widely used model is FICO Score 8, which was launched in 2009.
'It's kind of like an iPhone, just because they're up to (version) 16 now, some people are still using old ones,' Rossman said. 'Not everybody's using the latest and greatest, just because it's available. Credit scoring has a long sales cycle, lenders are sometimes hesitant to invest in the technology and train all their staff and implement new processes.'
The most widely used versions in mortgage lending are FICO Score versions 2, 4 and 5, according to FICO.
FICO developed a secret sauce for how factors such as payment history, balances and the like feed into its scoring system; however, those ingredients come from what the lenders report to the credit bureaus.
And when it comes to BNPL loans, some of those have only just started hitting credit reports. A select few BNPL lenders, notably industry giant Affirm, have begun reporting activity to agencies such as Experian and TransUnion.
'It's like you've got multiple levels to this,' Rossman said. 'The lenders are the ones furnishing the information, and then they send it to the credit bureaus, and then FICO applies its methodology, and it's kind of hard to get everybody to agree.'
Also, BNPL doesn't behave like traditional credit, and that could complicate how these loans are scored, Rossman said.
'Things like frequent opening and closing of accounts, that would be disastrous for your credit score,' he said. 'With Buy Now, Pay Later, you're doing that every few weeks or even every few days. And then credit utilization, too: Maxing out a credit card is bad, but Buy Now, Pay Later is basically you maxing out a short-term credit line and then paying it down.'
In Monday's announcement, FICO indicated it developed a 'novel' approach to credit scoring that includes aggregating BNPL data when calculating the variables used in the models.
'Our clients tell us that FICO's initiative to include BNPL data in credit scoring is a progressive step that acknowledges the evolving landscape of consumer financing,' Julie May, vice president and general manager of B2B Scores at FICO, said in a statement. 'By capturing a broader view of consumer credit behavior, lenders believe they can make more informed decisions, ultimately benefiting both the industry and consumers.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Insider
23 minutes ago
- Business Insider
They fled cities in the pandemic exodus, seeking a cheaper cost of living, safety, and more. Here's how it's panned out.
It's been roughly five years since America's big-city dwellers were suddenly faced with the opportunity for a major life change: a move to the country. With no commute required, an emphasis on the home, and low interest rates,a wave of millennials and Gen Zers moved to suburban or exurban areas during the pandemic. These rural or metro areas with fewer than 250,000 residents made up the top 10 counties with the highest net percent population increase among this age group between 2020 and 2023, the latest years for which data is available. On the other hand, cities have seen stagnant or declining populations among the 25-44 age group. Of the 10 most populous US counties, five had declines, while two stayed the same. Business Insider interviewed seven Americans who left big cities during the pandemic in search of more space, stability, or a different pace of life. Some moved across the country, while others stayed closer to home, trading New York City, Los Angeles, or Houston for Rockford, Illinois; Wayne, New Jersey; or Palm Desert, California. Now, five years after the pandemic began, life outside big cities hasn't been perfect. It may be cheaper — though not in all cases — but it also can come with longer commutes, less satisfying food and culture, and distance from friends. Here are their stories, in their own words. Their quotes have been edited for length and clarity. Business Insider has heard from hundreds of Americans who have moved in recent years for personal and financial reasons. If you have a story to share, please fill out this quick form. Read more on the topic below: Moving from NYC to Illinois came with career changes and a lower cost of living Andrew Blevins, 35, is an insurance agent who lives in Rockford, Illinois, which has a population of 147,000 and a median home sale price of $175,000. In 2020, my wife and I moved from New York City to Rockford, Illinois, where we bought our first home. We were traveling nationally as part of the Broadway tour of Cats — I was the production stage manager, and she worked in the merchandise department. But we both lost our jobs due to the pandemic. We decided to move to Rockford because we're both from the area and felt comfortable knowing that it would be a safe place to settle down. We appreciated the difference in cost of living and wanted to be closer to our family. The cost to rent our one-bedroom apartment in the Inwood/Washington Heights area of NYC was about the same as the mortgage payment on our three-bedroom home in Rockford. We were thrilled to have the opportunity to buy before the market took off, as we were able to build equity in our home rather quickly. We leveraged that equity into a different home and now reside in something much more comfortable. The move coincided with my career change to an insurance agent. I opened an agency in January 2021 in an effort to help establish our roots in Rockford. I grew up in an insurance family and worked in my father's office during college, even earning some initial licensing at the time. Around the time I lost my job, an insurance recruiter reached out to me. It felt like the right moment to return to something familiar. My wife is the office manager for our agency. We work side by side, building our business together. We have no plans to leave anytime soon. We took this opportunity to rebuild our lives after COVID, and we set out to build a comfortable life. We found that and more in Rockford. Family reasons made moving from LA to New Jersey the right choice Francheska Stone, 36, is the founder of a podcast and consulting platform. She lives in Wayne, New Jersey, which has a population of 53,000 and a median home sale price of $1.5 million. My husband and I relocated from Los Angeles to Wayne, New Jersey, in October 2021. My mother-in-law was diagnosed with dementia, so we wanted to be closer to family support on the East Coast. One month after arriving, I learned I was pregnant with our daughter, which reinforced the decision to stay in New Jersey. I'd never even visited New Jersey before moving, but family ties have made it work. The first year in New Jersey was tough. It was a new state, I was pregnant, and I had to adapt to East Coast winters. But I have no lasting regrets about the move. In Los Angeles, I worked on-site as a paralegal, but the move nudged me into remote legal work with the same law firm and then into entrepreneurship. I eventually launched my podcast and consulting platform business, and earlier this year, I left my full-time job to focus on it full-time. We're rooted here for now and have no immediate plans to move. We love that New York City is a short drive away while we enjoy suburban space. Overall, the cost of living in New Jersey has felt comparable to LA. We're renting for now, but buying a home here is a goal once my business income fully stabilizes. We didn't want to have a family in a big city like Houston, so we moved to suburban Texas Blanka Molnar, 40, is a parenting coach who lives in Sugar Land, Texas, which has a population of 110,000 and a median home sale price of $500,000. My husband and I moved in June 2021 from Houston to Sugar Land, Texas. We were looking to buy a home and start a family, but we were unsure about raising a child in Houston. The area we lived in started to feel dirtier and less safe, we didn't have a backyard, and the schools were not as good as we'd have liked. Overall, we think moving was a great decision. We have much more space, a better school system, and a beautiful neighborhood. There are plenty of green areas and playgrounds, and our daughter enjoys our lovely backyard with her little slide. The downsides are that we drive more than we did in the city, the food scene isn't as good as Houston's, and we live further from the airport. My husband's commute is also about twenty minutes longer. Our housing costs are also higher now. We do not regret buying — we wanted to buy our own home, and we like our purchase — but adding up all the costs and expenses, it's much more than our rent was. After we moved, I resigned and left my corporate life behind due to medical reasons. I now work independently, and I'm happy with my current work situation. Right now, we are satisfied with where we are. Unless my husband changes his job, we are not planning to move in the next three to five years. We couldn't afford a home in the Bay Area, so we moved to Texas Joscelyn Moen, 48, is an executive assistant who lives in Cedar Park, Texas, which has a population of 78,000 and a median home sale price of $491,000. In October 2019, shortly before the pandemic started, we moved from Burlingame, CA — a town in the San Francisco Bay Area — to Cedar Park, Texas. We moved because my husband found a new role with his tech company in Austin. While my husband initially wanted to live in Austin, I insisted on Cedar Park because the housing costs were lower. We would have never been able to purchase a home in our area of California, even though at the time, we both worked at tech companies and made over six figures. We looked at housing, and before leaving California, I made it a goal that if we were going to uproot our family, we would buy a house in Cedar Park, which we did in June 2021 after renting for a while. The cost of living is exponentially cheaper than in the Bay Area, and Texas's lack of state income taxes has made a huge difference. I do miss the Bay Area's Asian food, but it's getting better here in Cedar Park. Texas is also massive, so driving out of state takes forever. Additionally, the beaches are further away, and the culture shock was real. The vibes from Texans are so different from Californians. The move also affected my career. When we moved out here, I quit my job, and I don't have the same career I used to. However, I found I can make good money, have a work-life balance, and still enjoy a comfortable life. Our NYC rent soared, so we moved to Phoenix Maryia Jimenez, 30, is a publicist who lives in Phoenix, which has a population of roughly 1.6 million and a median home sale price of $450,000. I moved in December 2021 from New York City to Phoenix with my boyfriend, now husband. Several factors pushed us to leave, but the decision really began to take shape after we witnessed violence on the subway. It shook me to my core. I no longer felt safe in a city I had once loved. Shortly after, our landlord tried to increase our rent by $700 a month. It felt like a clear signal: we were being priced out, and staying would mean compromising too much. Overall, I don't have any regrets about the move. The home we're renting is more spacious, and it feels like we're actually getting our money's worth. While Phoenix hasn't brought the dramatic cost savings some people might imagine when leaving a major city, it still feels like a financial upgrade. That said, my husband and I miss New York's culture and energy. If the right job opportunity comes up on the East Coast, we might be packing our bags. However, I don't see New York City itself being part of that plan again, at least not for the long haul. We're trying to find the best of both worlds. Ideally, we want to live in a place that's not as crowded as a major city but still offers space, land, and strong job opportunities in our fields. That kind of balance is hard to come by, but we're still searching and hopeful we'll find that happy medium. I realized I didn't need to live in LA to build my business, so I moved to Scottsdale Toni Ferrara is the founder of a PR and talent management business. She's in her 40s and lives in Scottsdale, Arizona, $810,000. I moved in July of 2020 from Beverly Hills, California, to Scottsdale, Arizona. It was one of those life-defining moments. The world was in lockdown, and I found myself sitting alone in my penthouse on my 40th birthday. That night, I realized LA no longer felt like home. The city no longer felt safe or joyful, and I had outgrown the glitz. I now own a three-bedroom, three-bathroom home with a mortgage payment less than the rent on my old one-bedroom apartment in LA. While housing prices have risen with the migration boom, it's still far more affordable than California. My money stretches further, my home is more spacious, and I can still fly into LA anytime I want for business or a quick recharge. It's the best of both worlds. When I first moved, people said I was sabotaging my career. "How can a PR and talent manager not live in LA?" they asked. But I've made it work. I do miss my LA inner circle and the beach — Scottsdale sand doesn't quite compare. But I'm in LA monthly for work, so it's a quick fix. And yes, Arizona's triple-digit heat is no joke, but I'd still choose peace in the desert over chaos in the city any day. I'm not sure I'll stay in Scottsdale forever. I'm a single woman with no kids, which gives me freedom. If 2020 and the lockdown taught me anything, it is that happiness and safety are non-negotiable for me, but for now, I am staying in Scottsdale. There are way too many business opportunities to expand on the horizon. We wanted a change from Hollywood, so we moved to a smaller town Christopher D. Kaufman, 60, is a professor, consultant, and author who lives in Palm Desert, California, which has a population of 53,000 and a median home sale price of $549,000. In March 2020, my wife and I moved from Hollywood to Palm Desert, California. We moved to get more space during the pandemic, and we were having some issues with neighbors having all-night parties. We were also frustrated by how our HOA was run. We're both very happy with the decision to move. The lower housing costs in our area allowed us to buy a home with a pool, build a new bedroom, add solar panels, and install a great new A/C system. Additionally, living in a more walkable town has helped us get healthier. It took a while for me to get professor gigs due to the pandemic, but I was able to once classrooms opened up. After selling our home in Hollywood, we started by renting in Palm Desert. We rented for about a year while looking for a home, and we're very happy with the decision to rent in the new area before buying. We visited and loved the area, but that was a hotel experience. We needed to feel the environment and understand the community and local resources first. So I recommend always renting first and then buying if moving to a new place.
Bloomberg
23 minutes ago
- Bloomberg
Odd Lots: Housing Is a Problem Even in a State With Declining Population
You can kind of understand why it's so hard to build housing in New York City. There isn't much available land. It's already pretty built up. And then, add in the fact that so many people want to live in New York, and you can understand why it's so expensive. But what's the deal with Alaska? There seems to be plenty of land. And population has actually been in a a general state of decline. And yet, housing remains strained, with many of the same affordability problems seen elsewhere in the country. So what are the specific challenging dynamics to be overcome? On this episode, we speak with Jimmy Ord, Daniel Delfino, and Stacy Barnes of the Alaska Housing Finance Corporation to understand the challenges they face, and the work they do to ease the strain. We get into both the specific logistical, political, and financial tools available to reduce pressure.
Yahoo
30 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Make your money work for you by ‘laddering' bonds or CDs
If you have a lot of cash on hand, it should be making money for you. One way to ensure it continuously does that is to set up a ladder of Treasuries or FDIC-insured certificates of deposit with staggered maturities (eg, 1 year, 2 years, 3 years, etc.). When a ladder might make sense A laddering strategy can offer low-risk, predictable returns that will help you keep up with — or beat — inflation, while protecting your money during volatile markets and helping you meet your near- and intermediate-term goals. 'Which ladder works for you depends on your needs,' said Collin Martin, a fixed income strategist at Schwab Center for Financial Research. For example, ladders can be useful if you want to: Preserve purchasing power: A fixed income ladder can help if your main concern for a given sum of money is to protect the principal and not let inflation devalue it. Rhode-Island based certified financial planner Sue Gardiner had a client whose goal was to preserve capital and protect purchasing power of money going to beneficiaries of an inherited IRA that had to be fully distributed within 10 years. 'So we used TIPS (Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities) to hedge inflation, but balanced them with Treasuries and brokered CDs to lock in competitive yields and keep annual liquidity,' she said. 'The ladder was designed so each year's withdrawal is funded by maturing securities.' Pay off debt: If you have credit card debt and can secure a zero-rate balance transfer card — which lets you pay off your debt interest free for up to 21 months — a ladder of CDs or bonds can generate additional income to help clear your balance. Say you have $100,000 from the sale of a house or an inheritance. If you don't already have an emergency fund, set aside some of the money into a high-yield FDIC-insured online savings account or a money market fund. Then split the rest evenly across the number of 'rungs' in the ladder you choose. For instance, a three-month CD or Treasury, another one maturing in six months and a third one maturing in a year. As a CD or Treasury comes due, direct the income it throws off plus some or all of the principal to pay down your 0% credit card debt, Gardiner suggested. Grow savings for a specific end dat e: Or, say you want to have enough money to make a down payment on a home in five years. 'If the goal has a finite date, ladder the strategy so all the money is available for the down payment [on that date],' Gardiner said. Set up a cash flow stream: If you're about to retire but won't claim Social Security for a few years, you might consider a laddered bonds strategy to provide a steady income stream between now and then or even for longer. 'It provides stability and predictability while bridging the gap until larger income sources like Social Security kick in, or to create a predictable foundation while other assets are positioned for growth,' Wade Pfau, founder of the site Retirement Researcher, wrote in an article about bond laddering. 'As one (bond) matures, the principal is returned and can be reinvested or spent, depending on your needs at that time.' Questions to ask To set up a laddering strategy that works for you, consider these questions: How long before I need the money? Be very clear what your liquidity needs will be for the money you're investing. Once a ladder of investments with staggering maturities is set up, if you tap any before they come due, you may have to pay a penalty in the case of CDs that you buy directly from a bank; or you might lose some of your principal if you're selling a bond (or a CD purchased through a brokerage) when you sell it back into the secondary market. 'Make sure you match up maturities of those holdings with what your time horizon is. You don't want to suddenly need all of it and be forced to sell at a loss,' Martin said. Also know that any investment on your ladder that is labeled 'callable' means the issuer can recall it and pay you back your principal before the instrument comes due, plus any income owed up until that point. So ideally, you will only invest in non-callable CDs or bonds, otherwise you might need to reinvest it sooner than you think. Does it make more sense to invest in CDs or bonds? What you'll net after taxes from your investment is a key consideration. The income you earn from a CD is taxable at the federal, state and local level. If you invest in Treasuries, the income is exempt from state and local taxes. So if you live in a high-tax area, they may be a better bet. But if you live in a state with no income tax or very low income taxes and the yield on a CD is better than a bond of similar duration, the CD may be your better bet. Do I want to manage the ladder myself? If you're setting up a ladder of CDs or Treasuries for a one-time, date-certain purpose and your plan is to use the money as it comes due, that might be the simplest thing for you to set up and manage. But if your plan is to use a ladder on an ongoing basis for income, that will mean you have to keep track of everything and be proactive about reinvesting your money whenever it comes due to maximize your income potential. Alternatively, there are now some ETFs that ladder bonds, which can do the work for you if they're structured in a way that meets your goals. If you're building you own ladder, your brokerage may offer model laddering strategies that will help you set one up and then can automatically do the reinvesting for you if you choose. If, however, you're considering laddering municipal bonds for their tax advantages or corporate bonds to maximize yield, you might consult a fixed income adviser or have an investment professional manage your ladder for you because those instruments require a little more research to make sure you're getting the risk-reward trade-off. 'You don't want to blindly invest in those,' Martin said.
