Explainer: What's behind the request for Germany to split its power market?
FRANKFURT, April 29 (Reuters) - Germany has been landed with demands to split its 25 year-old single electricity market into up to five price bidding zones by European power grid lobby ENTSO-E, that wants to stop intra-German price differences leaking to neighbouring countries.
Here are facts and considerations around the issue as a six-month consultation period started on Monday.
Make sense of the latest ESG trends affecting companies and governments with the Reuters Sustainable Switch newsletter. Sign up here.
WHY HAS THE TOPIC COME TO THE FORE?
In its Bidding Zone Review, the European network companies' group argues that dividing Germany's huge market area into a number of zones would bring more efficiency and reduce management costs in Germany and outside.
A scenario modelled on 2019 conditions showed a five-way zonal split could save up to 339 million euros of grid management costs a year, reduce bottlenecks, and help more renewable power to be transmitted, it said.
German grid handling costs ran to 2.8 billion euros ($3.19 billion) in 2024, standing in the way of steering producers' and consumers' behaviour.
WHAT ENTSO-E HOPES TO ACHIEVE
High renewable generation in Germany's north, while industry demand is concentrated in the south, distorts prices in a single zone over a large geography, say some organisations, economists, northern federal states, and Germany's EU partners such as Sweden, which operates a connecting cable.
Northern areas cannot benefit from cheap local power as everyone pays too much when the entire national grid bill is spread around all, they say.
Local zones with realistic prices would encourage better participation in battery storage, electric cars and heat pumps.
WHY GERMANY IS OPPOSED
Germany concedes its network expansion is slow but it has clear targets for building north-south transmission highways to overcome the structural problems. It cannot ditch these now to adopt an entirely new system, say the coalition government, southern states and industries, namely energy, cars and chemicals.
Germany's export-geared industries are struggling with recession and, if burdened with even higher costs in the south, might decamp, withdraw employment.
Meanwhile, transmission companies (TSOs), under the watch of the energy regulator, are clearly making progress with big new transport lines.
POSSIBLE CONSEQUENCES OF AN ESCALATION
If the EU Commission, led by German national Ursula von der Leyen, adopted ENTSO-E's stance and pitted itself against Berlin, the row could rattle the bloc's biggest economy and give rise to right-wing and anti-EU sentiments.
Or, if Germany persisted in its opposition to a reconfiguration, it could face retaliation at a time when it needs good relations with its EU trade partners.
If member states do not agree how to proceed within six months, the Commission has a further six months to decide on a course of action.
HOW THE ISSUE COULD BE SILENTLY REMEDIED
Germany can hope to maintain its unified price zone if it adheres to a long-term requirement under an EU internal energy market regulation for 70% of its border interconnection capacity being ready for tradable power flows by year-end.
TSOs are optimistic they can prove their progress on this target, a bid supported by Germany's power bourse, the European Energy Exchange (DB1Gn.DE), opens new tab.
"Then, there would be no reason to break up this large liquidity pool (Germany's status quo)," said EEX chief executive, Peter Reitz, in a call with reporters on Monday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Reuters
16 minutes ago
- Reuters
South African rand shrugs off weak manufacturing data
JOHANNESBURG, June 10 (Reuters) - The South African rand strengthened on Tuesday despite a sharp contraction in local manufacturing output, as investors waited for more clarity on U.S.-China trade talks. At 1415 GMT, the rand traded at 17.69 against the dollar , about 0.2% stronger than Monday's closing level. South Africa's manufacturing output (ZAMAN=ECI), opens new tab fell 6.3% year on year in April, the sixth consecutive monthly decline, statistics agency data showed on Tuesday. Analysts polled by Reuters had expected a drop of 3.9%. Weakness in the manufacturing sector was one factor behind the first quarter's sluggish growth of just 0.1%(ZAGDPN=ECI), opens new tab, offsetting a strong performance by agriculture. The rand was also supported on Tuesday by a stronger global gold price and by a weaker U.S. dollar . The Johannesburg Stock Exchange's Top-40 index (.JTOPI), opens new tab was last up 0.6%. The benchmark 2035 government bond was stronger, as the yield fell 4 basis points to 10.095%.
The Independent
17 minutes ago
- The Independent
EU seeks to lower a price cap on Russian oil and discourage Nord Stream pipeline investors
The European Union wants to lower a cap on the price of Russian oil to deprive the Kremlin of extra profits to fund its war in Ukraine as part of a new raft of sanctions aimed at forcing Moscow to the negotiating table, senior officials said on Tuesday. EU foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas said the bloc is 'proposing to lower the oil price cap from $60 to $45, which is lower than the market price, and lowering the oil price cap will hit Russia's revenues hard.' Kallas said the EU also wants to impose 'sanctions on the Nord Stream pipelines to prevent Russia generating any revenue in the future. In this way, it sends a clear signal we are not going back to business as usual.' All 27 EU member countries must all agree for the sanctions to enter force. In 2023, Ukraine's Western allies limited sales of Russian oil to $60 per barrel but the price cap was largely symbolic as most of Moscow's crude — its main moneymaker — cost less than that. Still, the cap was there in case oil prices rose. Oil income is the linchpin of Russia's economy, allowing President Vladimir Putin to pour money into the armed forces while avoiding worsening inflation for everyday people and a currency collapse. European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen said she assumed that the price cap would be discussed and agreed among the leaders of the Group of Seven major world economic powers when they meet in Canada on June 15-17. She said the United States and its G7 partners realize 'that the oil price has lowered so much that the effectiveness of the cap is to be questioned, and therefore we all want to lower the oil price from $60 per barrel down to $45 per barrel.' The Nord Stream gas pipelines were built to carry Russian natural gas to Germany but are not in operation. They were sabotaged in 2022, but the source of the underwater explosions has remained a major international mystery. The Commission has said that it wants to impose sanctions on the operating consortium to discourage investors from trying to use the pipelines in future. The blasts happened as Europe attempted to wean itself off Russian energy sources following the Kremlin's full-scale invasion of Ukraine, and contributed to tensions that followed the start of the war. Von der Leyen noted on Tuesday that at the beginning of the war in 2022, 'Russia had 12 billion euros ($14 billion) of energy revenues from fossil fuels" from Europe per month. "And now we're down to 1.8 billion (euros).' The new EU sanctions would also target Russia's banking sector, with the aim of limiting the Kremlin's ability to raise funds or carry out financial transactions. A further 22 Russian banks will be hit with measures, von der Leyen said. An export ban worth some 2.5 billion euros would also be imposed, and the assets frozen of more than 20 Russian and foreign companies alleged to be providing support to the Kremlin's war machine. Von der Leyen said the sanctions are aimed at forcing Russia into serious talks about peace with Ukraine. 'We need a real ceasefire, and Russia has to come to the negotiating table with a serious proposal,' she told reporters. The EU has imposed several rounds of sanctions on Russia since Putin ordered his troops into Ukraine in February 2022. Around 2,400 officials and 'entities' – often government agencies, banks and organizations – have been hit. It's last raft of sanctions, imposed on May 20, targeted almost 200 ships in Russia's sanction-busting shadow fleet of tankers, and tightened trade restrictions to stop produce that could be used for military purposes from reaching Russia's armed forces.
Reuters
31 minutes ago
- Reuters
Romanian president could nominate a prime minister this week
BUCHAREST, June 10 (Reuters) - Romanian President Nicusor Dan said on Tuesday he could nominate a prime minister this week provided pro-European parties reach an agreement on measures needed to lower the European Union's highest budget deficit and prevent a ratings downgrade. Centrist Dan, who won a divisive presidential vote in May that saw the far right gain ground, must form a ruling majority that has until the end of June to approve deficit cutting measures to avoid a downgrade to below investment grade. The European Commission, ratings agencies and analysts have said Romania cannot reduce its shortfall over seven years to the EU's 3% threshold as agreed without hiking taxes, but Dan and the four pro-European parties have proved reluctant to enforce unpopular measures, focusing instead on cuts to state spending. "There is a hierarchy of priorities, first cutting useless state spending, then merging some institutions, rescheduling some investments to 2026 and lastly possible tax hikes," Dan said during a visit to neighbouring Moldova. "I hope we will reach to the tax side as least as possible." Dan said the parties had identified a list of 60-80 possible measures, but had yet to agree on any. The president, who has a semi-executive role, added that pending the talks he could nominate a PM this week. Two sources told Reuters ratings agencies had told a London panel in May they were ready to downgrade Romania from the last rung of investment grade unless they saw convincing measures including tax hikes. The next rating review is in August. Earlier this month the European Commission opened the possibility of freezing some EU funds for Romania next year. Brussels, ratings agencies and the IMF have said hikes to value added tax or changes to Romania's flat 10% tax on income would be the most effective. "It needs to be a solid plan, two big measures that everyone can price are better than 50 that nobody can evaluate," one of the London sources said. "How can anyone trust you that you'll do what's needed in the 7-year adjustment plan?" Claudiu Nasui, a lawmaker from the centre-right Save Romania Union, one of four pro-EU parties engaged in talks, is a strong proponent of state spending cuts inspired by Argentinian President Javier Milei. He told Reuters that he had identified 34 billion lei ($7.73 billion) worth of cuts that could be made in the second half of the year without cutting healthcare, education and defence. However, they included cutting state-funded investment schemes that were easier to tap than EU funds with little oversight, a political instrument for mayors that parties were unlikely to approve cutting. "Any measure to cut the deficit will make parties unpopular, spending cuts or tax hikes, you just need political will," Nasui said. "I often look at a street trash bin outside my office, there are always people rummaging in it. Hiking taxes will not hit us, but it will hit those poor people." ($1 = 4.3977 lei)
