‘Hardship' for West Cork communities over protected nature sites
At this week's meeting of Cork County Council, Councillors Finbarr Harrington and John Michael Foley called on the Council to write to the government to seek permission from the European Union to carry out an urgent review of Cork's designated Natura 2000 sites.
'In my own West Cork, working harbours, piers and slips were taken into SACs and these are causing unbelievable amounts of difficulties for ourselves as a local authority to do repairs to these piers because we must carry out all kinds of EIAs [Environmental Impact Assessment] before we get to do it,' Cllr Harrington said.
'In relation to rural planning, where you have young couples that are just applying for planning permission for a normal family home to live in it, our planners are obliged to notify them that they're building in an SAC or an SPA or an NHA [Natural Heritage Area] and they must go off and do EIAs, which is costing them thousands and thousands of euros,' he added.
Cllr Harrington cited the Garnish slipway at the tip of the Beara Peninsula, which is used by recreational sailors, fishermen and the Coast Guard. Sand builds up at the tip of the slipway over the winter but because it's in the Kenmare SAC, ministerial permission has to be sought to remove the sand.
Many of the designations were mapped decades ago and have not kept pace with updated ecological knowledge or with the practical realities faced by rural communities, according to Cllr Foley.
'Right now in County Cork, homeowners struggle to get planning permission for modest homes. Farmers are restricted in their ability to work their land. Local councils find critical infrastructure projects delayed or blocked entirely in many coastal areas. Renewable energy and rural development projects, crucial for meeting Ireland and Europe's climate goals, are held back,' he said.
'We're not asking to dismantle conservation efforts, but we need to be able to complete coastal erosion problems where farms are falling into the sea, roads are falling into the sea. We need to be able to work on things, we need to be able to work on essential works like working harbours. We're not asking for a dismantling of the SECs, they're great, but we are asking for a common-sense approach where we can work,' said Cllr Foley.
The Council agreed to write to the government to ask for a review of the Natura 2000 mapping.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
8 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Cork schoolchildren play part in bringing forgotten graveyard back to life
Ballynamona Graveyard, located near Mourneabbey, had been left to grow wild following the decommissioning of the nearby church in 1978. Gravestones were lost and inaccessible to the families and friends of those buried on the site, following decades of neglect. However, in April of last year, a voluntary group was formed to finally get the graveyard back into shape and restore the rightful respect for those buried in the area, with the group focused on removing all the wild overgrowth of saplings and weeds. Meeting every Tuesday evening, the volunteers made huge inroads in clearing and cleaning the graveyard, while also receiving grants from both Cork County Council and the National Heritage Council, working with council archaeologists and conservation officers. The group also thanked Councillor Liam Madden for his guidance and support. In November 2024, prayers at the graveyard were said by the local Church of Ireland minister, Rev. Meurig Williams, who joined with Rev. Fr. Anthony Sheehan in the ceremony. One lady who was present was the last child to have been baptised in Ballynamona Church, 40 years on from its decommissioning. Now, the next generation will be rewarded for their part in the project. Having made presentations to the local national schools on the heritage associated with the church and graveyard, the group organised an art competition as part of the presentation, with the theme of 'Keeping Memories Alive'. To celebrate National Heritage Week, two children from both schools were selected to place a stone in a wall currently being reconstructed on Monday (August 11), under the stewardship of the stonemason. While in a busy week, the group will also be hosting an information morning at Mourneabbey Community Centre on Saturday, 16 August, from 11am to 1pm. A presentation and display of the work and achievements to date will take place, while prizes for the art competition will also be presented. The group say they hope their work will allow local people to 'enjoy the opportunity to continue their own unique relationship with Ballynamona Graveyard and make a renewed connection with preserving it for future generations'.
Irish Independent
6 days ago
- Irish Independent
Pressure mounts on Galway City Council to address pedestrian safety in one of city's busiest areas
Galway West TD John Connolly has called on Galway City Council to create such a scheme following representations from Shantalla residents who highlighted 'significant concerns' over the issue. Residents highlighted the issue of speeding cars passing through the area, as well as the number of vehicles parking there to access local public facilities and the city centre. Active Travel schemes promote walking and cycling, while also focusing on improving infrastructure and accessibility through safety improvement works. Deputy Connolly wrote to the Active Travel and Sustainable Transport department of Galway City Council, calling for such a scheme to be implemented in Shantalla. The Fianna Fáil TD also highlighted that the local school, Scoil Bhríde, had not yet been included in the Safe Routes to School Scheme, and called for this to be rectified. On Tuesday, August 5, Deputy Connolly was informed by the council that the Active Travel Section is currently progressing priority projects, as per the Galway Transport Strategy and in line with National Transport Authority guidance. The priority projects are identified as the Western Distributor Road, Bóthar Stiofáin, the Salmon Weir Pedestrian Crossing, and the Ballybane Road/Castlepark Road Cycle Network. However, Deputy Connolly says that the council has taken note of the concerns regarding traffic speed and other issues along Shantalla Road and says that funding has been received for the early development of safety improvement works in the area. Galway City Council says that it will be meeting with residents, additional key stakeholders, and representatives of Scoil Bhríde, and that this engagement will inform the future development of any possible scheme. 'An Active Travel scheme for Shantalla is sorely required to make motorists more conscious of the needs of people within the community. I am pleased that the work will commence with consultation with the community,' DeputyConnolly said. 'I am pleased that funding is available and that the Council is aware of the issues there, but I would call on the Council to also treat this issue as a priority, especially as Shantalla Road has essentially become one of the main routes into the city centre and so is already prone to experiencing high traffic.'
Agriland
31-07-2025
- Agriland
Icos Co Op Chairs to Travel to Brussels Amid Nitrates Frustration
The Irish Co-operative Organisation Society (ICOS) has said that it is "deeply concerned and frustrated" by news this week that Ireland would potentially be required to demonstrate added compliance with the Habitats Directive, as part of its application for a nitrates derogation. The Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine (DAFM) revealed on Monday, July 7, that the European Commission has told Ireland it 'must demonstrate compliance' with the Habitats Directive when granting farmers a nitrates derogation. There are 600 sites in Ireland designated under the Habitats Directive and the Birds Directive. Sites range in size from 1ha up to 76,000ha. These sites are designated as either Special Conservation Areas (SAC) and or Special Protection Areas (SPA) and are generally referred to as Natura 2000 sites. Under the Habitats Directive any plan or project 'likely to have a significant effect on a designated site or species' must be subject to Appropriate Assessment of its implications for the site. The European Court of Justice has ruled that the 'grazing of cattle and or the application of fertilisers on the surface of land or below its surface' in the vicinity of Natura 2000 sites may be classified as a project. ICOS has outlined its concern in a letter sent today (Friday, July 11) to Jessika Roswall, EU Commissioner for Environment, Water Resilience and a Competitive Circular Economy. Addressing Commissioner Roswall on behalf of Irish dairy cooperatives and their farmer members, ICOS president Edward Carr stated: 'This is a very significant and unexpected departure that adds a new and potentially onerous layer of compliance to the nitrates derogation that was never envisaged when the Nitrates Directive and Habitats Directive came into force in Ireland in the early 1990s. 'Farmers and their cooperatives have embraced their responsibilities in terms of adopting environmental best practice. "We have seen very positive outcomes with nitrate concentrations in Irish rivers declining significantly in 2024. "This new development related to the Habitats Directive is deeply frustrating given the ongoing national movement to improve water quality led by farmers, dairy co-ops, the meat and tillage sectors, Teagasc and LAWPRO [Local Authority Waters Programme]," he added. The Irish Government is currently preparing a response to the European Commission. However, ICOS maintains that before any process is agreed to with the commission, the implications for farm families and the food industry need to be outlined. ICOS has confirmed that a delegation of co-op chairpersons will travel to Brussels on July 15-16 to meet with Irish MEPs and the European Commission on the matter, including Commissioner Roswall's head of cabinet, Paulina Dejmek Hack. Edward Carr commented: 'We will strongly impress on the European Commission our deep concerns that this development will have for business certainty at farm and processing level and for generational renewal in the sector. 'We will use the opportunity to reinforce to the commission the benefits of Ireland's unique grass-based system and the strong momentum building in Ireland on water quality and the verifiable improvement in water quality, as well as other environmental metrics such as climate and ammonia. 'The dairy co-op sector has a strong track record of delivering pioneering initiatives on sustainability to support our members and family farms and a strong track record of collaboration and working together. "We will continue with these efforts to protect the environment and to ensure the future of Ireland's grass-based system of production that depends on a workable nitrates derogation,' Carr added.
