Ex-49er Dana Stubblefield freed from prison after rape conviction overturned
The Sixth Court of Appeals overturned the conviction of the Stubblefield, who is Black, after determining that prosecutors had made racially discriminatory statements during his trial. However, Stubblefield remained in prison because a lower court judge said he didn't have the jurisdiction to grant bail or release.
After the state attorney general's office and the appeals court weighed in, Santa Clara Superior Court Judge Hector Ramon granted Stubblefield's release Friday from the state prison where he has served close to four years of a 15-year sentence.
'Finally, an innocent man is no longer sitting in a cage away from his family,' said Stubblefield's defense attorney Kenneth Rosenfeld in a statement.
Stubblefield was sentenced to 15 years to life in prison in October 2020 after being convicted of raping a woman in 2015 who prosecutors said he lured to his home with the promise of a babysitting job. Defense attorneys argued that no rape occurred, and Stubblefield said the woman consented to sex in exchange for money.
Deputy District Attorney Tim McInerny objected to Stubblefield's release at Friday's hearing and said his office plans to re-file charges, The Mercury News reported.
'A jury unanimously found Mr. Stubblefield guilty of raping a woman at gunpoint, he was given an appropriate sentence, and we felt that justice had been served,' Assistant District Attorney Terry Harman said in a statement. 'That justice has been interrupted and although we are disappointed that the judge released Mr. Stubblefield from custody while we await a decision from the California Supreme Court, we remain focused on the sexual assault that occurred, the victim, and the need for accountability and community safety.'
The Sixth Court of Appeals found that prosecutors violated the California Racial Justice Act of 2020, a law passed during a summer of protest over the police killing of George Floyd. The measure bars prosecutors from seeking a criminal conviction or imposing a sentence on the basis of race.
The appeals court said prosecutors used 'racially discriminatory language' that required them to overturn Stubblefield's conviction.
'The entire trial was infected with error and bias from the start,' Rosenfeld said. 'This was a consensual, transactional encounter, and (Stubblefield) lost years of his life due to a flagrantly biased trial that blocked critical evidence and allowed prejudice and racial bias into the courtroom.'
Rosenfeld said prosecutors used 'prejudicial racial tropes' and called Stubblefield a 'large Black man' in front of the jury during his trial.
The terms of his supervised release include wearing an ankle monitor, not possessing firearms, and being barred from contacting the reported rape victim.
Stubblefield began his 11-year lineman career in the NFL with the 49ers in 1993 as the league's defensive rookie of the year. He later won the NFL Defensive Player of the Year honors in 1997 before leaving the team to play for Washington. He returned to the Bay Area to finish his career, playing with the 49ers in 2000-01 and the Raiders in 2003.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
American Press
2 hours ago
- American Press
Things to know about the indictment against the New Orleans mayor
Months before New Orleans Mayor LaToya Cantrell was set to leave office because of term limits, she has been indicted in what prosecutors allege was a yearslong scheme to conceal a romantic relationship with her bodyguard. Prosecutors say bodyguard Jeffrey Vappie was being paid as if he was working when he and Cantrell were really alone in apartments and visiting vineyards, hiding their communication by sending encrypted messages through WhatsApp and then deleting them. Although the pair have said their relationship was strictly professional, the indictment described it as 'personal and intimate.' The first female mayor in New Orleans' 300-year history has been charged with conspiracy, fraud and obstruction. Vappie was already facing charges of wire fraud and making false statements. He has pleaded not guilty. A grand jury returned an 18-count indictment Friday that added Cantrell to the case. The City of New Orleans said in a statement that it was aware of the indictment and that the mayor's attorney was reviewing it. Cantrell hasn't sent out a message on her official social media feed on X since July 15, when she said the city was experiencing historic declines in crime. She and her remaining allies have said that she has been unfairly targeted as a Black woman and held to a different standard than male officials. Here are things to know about the mayor and the indictment: Vineyard trips and alone time with bodyguard The indictment paints a detailed picture of Cantrell and her bodyguard traveling to vineyards and spending time alone in apartments at the same time it says Vappie was being paid as if he was working. Vappie reminisced in a WhatsApp exchange cited in the indictment about joining Cantrell in Scotland in October 2021, saying that was 'where it all started.' Cantrell had told local reporters she needed a security detail 'due to COVID,' saying her travel accommodations were 'a matter of safety, not of luxury.' The following year, instead of Cantrell attending a conference in Miami, authorities said the pair rendezvoused on Martha's Vineyard. Vappie's travel to the island was covered by the city to attend a separate conference. 'The times when we are truly (traveling) is what spoils me the most,' the mayor wrote to him that month. That same year, they also visited several California wineries, according to the indictment. After a 'trusted staff member' posted a photo of the three of them on social media, one of Cantrell's associates asked them to remove it. They met in an apartment while Vappie claimed to be on duty, and Cantrell arranged for him to attend 14 trips, Acting U.S. Attorney Michael Simpson said. The trips, he added, were described by her as times 'when they were truly alone.' In all, New Orleans taxpayers paid more than $70,000 for Vappie's travel, Simpson said. The pair used WhatsApp for more than 15,000 messages, including efforts to delete evidence, make false statements to FBI agents, 'and ultimately to commit perjury before a federal grand jury,' he said. A turbulent second term as mayor Cantrell, a Democrat, won a historic election in 2017 by portraying herself as a candidate for the people and not of the city's political class. Her mayoral tenure started strong with her securing tens of millions of dollars for city infrastructure improvements and taking decisive steps during the pandemic. There wasn't strong opposition to her 2021 election for a second term. But it was around that time that the wheels started to come off her administration. After Hurricane Ida pounded south Louisiana in 2021, residents were left without trash collection for weeks, while crime rates were surging.
2 hours ago
Semenyo thanks soccer community for support after alleged racial abuse at Anfield
LIVERPOOL, England -- Bournemouth forward Antoine Semenyo thanked his teammates, Liverpool's players and the soccer community as a whole for the 'overwhelming messages of support' he received after reporting he was racially abused by a spectator at Anfield. Merseyside Police said on Saturday that a 47-year-old man from Liverpool was arrested on suspicion of a racially aggravated public order offense. He was taken into custody to be interviewed. Police launched a hate crime investigation after ejecting a 47-year-old spectator from Anfield for his alleged racial abuse of Semenyo, who is Black, on Friday during the Premier League opener. 'Last night at Anfield will stay with me forever — not because of one person's words, but because of how the entire football family stood together,' Semenyo posted on Saturday on his social media. 'The overwhelming messages of support from across the football world remind me why I love this sport. We keep moving forward, together.' The incident occurred when Semenyo reported abuse to referee Anthony Taylor in the first half with the score at 0-0. Play was briefly stopped while Taylor spoke to both coaches and captains. 'To my (Bournemouth) teammates who supported me in that moment, to the (Liverpool) players and fans who showed their true character, to the (Premier League) officials who handled it professionally — thank you,' Semenyo wrote. 'Football showed its best side when it mattered most.' The 25-year-old Ghana international scored both of Bournemouth's goals in the 4-2 loss. 'Scoring those two goals felt like speaking the only language that truly matters on the pitch,' he wrote. 'This is why I play — for moments like these, for my teammates, for everyone who believes in what this beautiful game can be.' The spectator's identity was confirmed and he was removed from the stadium, police said. 'Merseyside Police will not tolerate hate crime of any form," said Chief Inspector Kev Chatterton, the match commander. 'We take incidents like this very seriously, and in cases like this we will be proactively seeking football banning orders, with the club, against those responsible." Shortly after the game, Semenyo posted further racial abuse that he received online and added: 'When will it stop..." Bournemouth players consoled Semenyo and an anti-discrimination message was read out to the crowd after the halftime whistle. The Premier League also said it will investigate the incident and 'offer our full support to the player and both clubs.' In a statement late Friday, Liverpool said it condemned 'racism and discrimination in all forms. The club is unable to comment further as tonight's alleged incident is the subject of an ongoing police investigation, which we will support fully.'
The Hill
2 hours ago
- The Hill
Judge expands Paxton restraining order against O'Rourke over Texas Dems fundraising
A judge on Saturday expanded Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton's (R) restraining order against former Rep. Beto O'Rourke (D-Texas) and his political organization, Powered by People, over its fundraising for state Democratic lawmakers who fled Texas amid the redistricting battle. A Tarrant County judge ruled that O'Rourke and his political group are barred from sending money out of the Lone Star State, coming after Paxton sought to revoke the charter of O'Rourke's organization, accusing it of committing bribery. 'The Court finds that harm is imminent to the State, and if the Court does not issue this order, the State will be irreparably injured. Specifically, Defendants' fundraising conduct constitutes false, misleading, or deceptive acts under the Texas Deceptive Trade Practices Act, because Defendants are raising and utilizing political contributions from Texas consumers to pay for the personal expenses of Texas legislators, in violation of Texas law,' 348th District Court Judge Megan Fahey said in a four-page Saturday order. Fahey said that financial institutions and political fundraising platforms, like ActBlue, are barred from transferring O'Rourke's or Powered by People's, a leadership political action committee, donations 'outside of Texas in support of the unlawful scheme.' O'Rourke has been in Paxton's crosshairs as his PAC has been raising money for Texas state legislators who left the Lone Star State for nearly two weeks to prevent the new, GOP-friendly congressional maps from passing. On Friday afternoon, Texas Republicans gaveled in a second special session. Democrats are expected to return to Texas soon. Last week, a Texas judge granted a temporary restraining order against O'Rourke, a former presidential candidate, and his political organization after the Texas attorney general claimed that the PAC was misleading donors. O'Rourke said Saturday morning that Powered by People gave over $1 million to Texas Democrats during a special session, including to the Texas Legislative Black Caucus, the Texas House Democratic Caucus and the Mexican American Legislative Caucus. Paxton celebrated the judge's decision, saying that in Texas, 'lawless actions have consequences, and Beto's finding that out the hard way.' 'His fraudulent attempt to pad the pockets of the rogue cowards abandoning Texas has been stopped, and now the court has rightly frozen his ability to continue to send money outside of Texas,' Paxton said in a statement. 'The cabal of Democrats who have colluded together to scam Texans and derail our Legislature will face the full force of the law, starting with Robert Francis O'Rourke.'
