How many regulators does it take to completely stifle Ireland's AI innovation?
Much of the talk at the Joint Oireachtas Committee on Artificial Intelligence meeting on Tuesday centred on finding the balance between controlling the risks and harnessing the potential of
AI
within Ireland's regulatory framework.
'We can't afford to stand still,' Patricia Scanlon of the AI Advisory Council told members of the Oireachtas, going on to repeatedly stress the importance of 'implementing serious regulatory reforms' and avoiding having a 'fragmented response' to AI.
The regulatory response to this new technology is critical, the Oireachtas repeatedly heard.
In Leinster House, a building in which phrases such as 'joined-up thinking' and 'co-ordinated response' echo around the halls, it was notable to hear the experts say there are eight separate regulatory bodies over AI in Ireland.
READ MORE
Based on work by the Department of Enterprise on the rollout of the EU-wide Artificial Intelligence Act, there will be a 'complex' web of 'cross-sectoral regulation' due to how vast an area the regulation will cover.
'There are actually going to be eight competent authorities or regulators under the Act,' Prof Deirdre Aherne, law professor at Trinity College Dublin and a member of the AI Advisory Council, told the committee.
Fear not, however, that there may be too many cooks. These regulatory bodies will also co-ordinate with other bodies that have sectoral expertise. Added on top of that 'distributed' regulatory model, the committee heard, will be a 'co-ordinating body' that will look to manage the overlaps between the bodies. Ireland's regulatory framework will then feed into an EU-wide approach to the new technology's adoption.
Furthermore, in its recent paper on digital innovation, the business lobbying group Ibec identified 'at least 30 different State entities and 10 plans that can influence the direction of Ireland's digital and AI ambitions'.
It noted one Cabinet committee, six departments, three Oireachtas committees, 10 departmental plans and 20 agencies that have various responsibilities related to implementing different aspects of the EU digital rule book.
It all begs the question: will eight separate regulators, 30 State agencies and 10 plans be enough to stifle Ireland's AI innovation?
Perhaps the State's response to AI needs more joined-up thinking at the helm, more opportunities for cross-sectoral collaboration and synergistic thinking, and maybe even one more regulatory body.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
13 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
Meet world's most expensive AI girlfriend who can serve coffee & speak 4 languages – but costs same as three-bed house
THE world's most expensive robot girlfriend serves you coffee and can speak four languages. But the silicone lover will cost you an eye-watering £64,700 - the price of a three-bed house in some parts of the UK. 6 The Companion Robot X04-SYNC2 is on sale for an eye-watering £64,700 Credit: Cloud Climax 6 The company selling the world's most expensive AI girlfriend offers hundreds of sex dolls Credit: Cloud Climax 6 The online UK-based sex doll store says there has been a surge in demand for silicone lovers since the pandemic Credit: Cloud Climax The doll - called the Companion Robot X04-SYNC2 - can have "context-aware" chats using AI chatbot ChatGPT, learning from past chats to adapt to future ones. They also come with robotic facial expressions and arms and hands that move to convey expression. And like something from a sci-fi epic, the dolls have micro cameras planted in the eyes to allow them to recognise people by face tracking. Uncanny footage shows the bot flexing its arms, moving its eyes around and winking. More on AI In one clip, the robot even serves up a coffee to men looking on in amazement. So far only three have been sold since they went on sale at the start of 2024. But Cloud Climax, the online UK-based sex doll store, insists there has been a surge in demand for silicone lovers since the pandemic and sees no signs of it slowing up. A spokesperson told The Sun: "Since 2020, we've seen a significant rise in demand for sex dolls and companion robots. Most read in Tech "Increasingly, social interaction has shifted online, making it harder for many people to form genuine, lasting connections in real life . "As AI and robotics have advanced, many are turning to intelligent companions to fulfill emotional and social needs without the complexities of traditional relationships . Weaponized 'AI girlfriends' built with 'malicious' design can steal cash from victims as experts warn over shocking scam "The ability to interact with a responsive, emotionally aware companion at home has made AI-powered robots more appealing than ever." They added: 'Our most advanced model is the Cloud Climax Companion Robot X04-SYNC2. 'This full-bodied robot features expressive facial movements, motorised arms, and customisable aesthetics, including options for ABS plastic or silicone-covered legs. 'It supports multiple languages – English, Chinese, Russian, and Korean – making it suitable for a global user base. 'Powered by advanced AI with ChatGPT integration, the X04-SYNC2 can hold natural, context-aware conversations, learn from past interactions, and respond quickly thanks to its high-speed processor. 'Its modular structure allows for easy maintenance and a plug-and-play setup. 'This robot is ideal for anyone looking for a sophisticated, interactive companion that merges advanced technology with realistic design.' Deep-pocketed customers can choose from thousands of different faces along with skin and eye colour. 6 Doll fanatics seeking a cheaper option will find Emma available at £3,299 Credit: Cloud Climax 6 Users can select a custom-made face for their AI girlfriend Credit: Cloud Climax 6 The website shows a variety of dolls with different hair colours and facial features Credit: Cloud Climax The dolls can be controlled by connecting them to Wi-Fi and using a dedicated app. It is the site's most expensive doll and is thought to be the most expensive of its kind anywhere in the world. Doll fanatics seeking a cheaper option will also find Emma the Sex Robot available at £3,299. This model offers a choice of six faces, seven height preferences, three eye colours and even a choice of feet. Emma has a self-heating mechanism "ideal for cuddling" and uses TPE material for the skin. Like the Companion robot, it holds conversations and learns as it goes along. ChatGPT has become a household name after exploding onto the scene in 2022 as an AI chatbot. AI model dubbed Spain's 'hottest woman' A NEW type of influencer has been taking the internet by storm earning big bucks and racking up a 'phenomenal' 250,000 Instagram followers in just six months. Aitana Lopez is a sight to behold and with her luscious pink locks, snatched waist and flawless skin she is envied by many - but she has one astonishing secret. The 25-year-old - who models for Spanish fashion agency The Clueless - is a state-of-the art AI creation designed to save the company money and time. Despite her computer-generated status being revealed in her Instagram bio, fans of the model still believe she's the real deal and invite her to socialise and spend time with them. Diana Nunez, who co-founded The Clueless with Rubén Cruz, told The Sun how the 'incredibly convincing' influencer was born. "Initially, most of her followers didn't question her authenticity, they genuinely believed in her existence," she said. 'From day one, we received compliments on her beauty, invitations to hang out in the city, and more. 'Even after the media revealed she was an AI creation, many followers still expressed their love for her.' Now, it is used by individuals and businesses to such an extent it has sparked fears entire workforces could be wiped out. Earlier this month, a man told The Sun he'd spent more than £25,000 on a collection of sex dolls to stop himself from cheating on his wife. There have even been suggestions sex robots could one day replace humans as the default relationship preference. For now though, Cloud Climax insists indistinguishable robots are a long way off just yet. The spokesperson added: 'We are still quite far from developing sex dolls or robots that are truly indistinguishable from humans. "While advancements in materials like silicone and TPE have improved the feel and appearance of artificial skin, they still fall short of replicating the complex texture, warmth, and responsiveness of real human tissue. 'Robotic movement is another limitation. "Although facial expressions and basic gestures have improved, achieving natural, fluid body movements and fine motor skills remains a significant challenge. 'On the cognitive side, while AI has advanced in natural language processing, current systems still lack true emotional intelligence, deep contextual understanding, and the ability to adapt seamlessly to social cues. 'Most sex dolls today remain relatively static, with limited interactivity. "Achieving a truly human-like experience in appearance, movement, and behaviour will likely require decades of further innovation across AI, robotics, and materials science ." The Sun has approached ChatGPT.
Irish Times
13 hours ago
- Irish Times
What the new rent rules mean for landlords and tenants
The Government's emergency legislation aimed at making the whole State a Rent Pressure Zones (RPZs) has all the hallmarks of a rushed job. When first announced earlier this month the details seemed vague; renters and landlords were confused as to what it might mean for them; even Government officials called to explain the new measures in interview after interview, struggled. Irish Times consumer affairs correspondent Conor Pope regularly does reader call-outs, testing levels of consumer confusion and frustration. He asked for queries – from tenants and landlords – in relation to the new legislation with the promise that he would take these queries directly to the Department of Housing for clear answers. READ MORE This is what he learned. Presented by Bernice Harrison. Produced by Declan Conlon.
Irish Times
17 hours ago
- Irish Times
Where is the value in increasing the Help-to-Buy scheme threshold?
Pre-budget submissions are all about pleadings. Every special interest group in the State makes a pitch for more resources. They all consider their proposals to be in the wider public and economic interest. Some are worthy, many more are largely self-interested. This year the whole process appears to have kicked off earlier than usual, perhaps on the understanding that the largesse of recent years is unlikely to be repeated this time around. In the first place, there is no election. Worries for the medium-term health of Europe's most open economy in a climate where tariffs, trade wars and an absence of consistency on policy are increasingly the norm also will inevitably push Ministers towards a more cautious approach. And for what money is available, the need is to prioritise investment in infrastructure. Expensive upgrades to electricity, water and sewerage networks that are increasingly being cited by foreign direct investors among factors counting against Ireland Inc are needed. READ MORE An EY survey on Friday found that more than two-thirds of Irish businesses 'are worried about securing enough energy to meet future needs', which is an extraordinary number. Put together, it means more things are going to be a tough ask to get over the line. [ First-time buyers in Dublin now locked out of Help-to-Buy scheme, warns Savills Opens in new window ] It seems a strange time then for estate agent Savills to be picking CSO house price data to press for an increase in the upper threshold for the Help-to-Buy scheme. Savills says first-time buyers in Dublin are paying an average of €515,000 for a home, putting them beyond the €500,000 ceiling for Help-to-Buy. It wants that ceiling increased to at least €621,000 to take account of inflation, it says. First, averages are notoriously prone to manipulation by singular expensive property sales. Second, the more reliable median data from the same CSO note shows that prices exceed €460,000 only in Dún Laoghaire Rathdown among the four Dublin local authority areas. [ Developers are bluffing when they say lower prices would undermine viability of house building Opens in new window ] Then there is the maximum available tax refund under Help-to-Buy, which is €30,000. Ignoring that when calling for a higher ceiling is not making property more affordable for first-time buyers in general, only for the very wealthy. It is worth remembering that while the marketing speaks about providing a helping hand for first-time buyers – with even the scheme's name selected for the same reason – Help-to-Buy was from the start a scheme put together to help developers make the numbers stack up on building starter homes. That's not happening, as supply constraints (and prices rising at their fastest rate in 10 years) attest, so for the State – and those first-time buyers – what is the value of widening the incentive?
