
If the draft fake news Bill is the cure for misinformation, Karnataka may have to ban irony next
The Karnataka legislature recently released the Karnataka Mis-information and Fake News (Prohibition) Bill, 2025. Broadly, the Bill attempts to criminalise the spread of fake news and misinformation within Karnataka. The mechanism for enforcing this prohibition is a 'fake news on social media regulatory authority' comprising the Minister for Kannada and Culture, members of the Karnataka Legislative Assembly and council, representatives of social media platforms, and an IAS officer. If any social media users are found guilty by this authority of spreading fake news, they could be imprisoned for up to seven years.
The sweeping provisions of the Karnataka Bill have sparked concern about its potential chilling effect on free speech. The Bill defines 'misinformation' as any willful or reckless false or inaccurate expression of a statement of fact. The definition also excludes 'opinions, religious or philosophical sermons, satire, comedy or parody or any other form of artistic expression', provided a 'reasonable man' would not misconstrue it as a statement of fact.
A reasonable man (or person) is a hypothetical individual whose behaviour and level of care in any given situation are judged according to commonly accepted standards of good judgement and societal norms. In the context of speech, the standard is typically used in cases regarding defamation or harassment, as a means of objectively understanding whether any given speech qualifies as an offending one. Yet, 'reasonableness' is an inherently vague and subjective standard, one that shifts with socio-cultural expectations. In the context of the Karnataka fake news Bill, the reasonableness standard will also possibly be informed by politics, given that half the members of the regulatory authority, including its head, are politicians. In effect, by hinging exemptions on whether a 'reasonable man' might misinterpret them as fact, the Bill leaves all expression vulnerable to being labelled fake news.
It creates a potent risk for satire as people (even reasonable ones) are often fooled into believing it is true. In 2012, the satirical news website The Onion released a story stating that North Korea's Kim Jong Un was the 'Sexiest Man Alive' for that year. The story was taken seriously by China's People's Daily Online, the digital version of the official newspaper of the Central Committee of the Chinese Communist Party, which reprinted it in full as a legitimate event. The Onion went on to claim, in jest, that the People's Daily was their subsidiary. Under the Karnataka Bill, The Onion's story as well as its subsequent joke could be treated as an offense.
Fortunately, the Karnataka fake news Bill is not even remotely constitutionally tenable. There is a wealth of constitutional precedent surrounding false information and what can and cannot be policed in its name. The courts are clear on the fact that restrictions on speech must be clear, narrowly tailored, and fall within the permissible bounds on speech, recognised under Article 19(2) of the Constitution. These include grounds like sovereignty, national security, diplomatic relations, public order, morality, decency, contempt of court, defamation, or the incitement of an offense. In Kaushal Kishor vs State of Uttar Pradesh, the Supreme Court held that these restrictions were comprehensive enough to account for any attack on an individual, groups, society, the judiciary, the state or the country. And it was not open to the state to add to these restrictions. Thus, speech cannot be restricted purely on the grounds that it is fake.
In addition, any law seeking to restrict speech must be proportional. The test of proportionality ensures that there are sufficient guardrails in place to keep any restriction on a fundamental right from overstepping its bounds. Here again, the Karnataka Bill fails because it opens many forms of speech up to subjective attacks from the state.
The Karnataka fake news Bill is an egregious document, not only for its constitutional failings but also the clumsy way it has been put together. Part of its Statement of Objects and Reasons, which is a part of a law that sets out the rationale for why the Bill is needed, was borrowed verbatim from the Prohibition of Fake News on Social Media Bill, 2022. Indeed, the borrowing was so faithful that even the title of the 2022 Bill was copy-pasted without correction. Adding insult to injury is the fact that it also attempts to open opinion up to scrutiny, which, at its very essence, is meant to be separate from statements of fact. The whole exercise makes a mockery of the pressing problem created by the spread of malicious falsities that are wrecking the fabric of human society, not only in India, but across the world.
The problem of fake news is complex. No law offers a silver bullet, especially because any law targeting speech can be weaponised. It demands thoughtful consideration and a focus on evidence-based solutions that have been shown to protect the public from the harmful effects of deliberate misinformation. Most of all, however, it requires leaders to cast expedience aside in favour of principle. That said, if the Karnataka government believes that its fake news Bill is the cure for misinformation, it may have to ban irony next.
The writer is the director of the Esya Centre, a tech policy focussed think tank based in New Delhi. Views are personal
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


NDTV
2 hours ago
- NDTV
Centre Notifies Rules On Portal, Database Of Waqf Properties
New Delhi: The Centre has notified the Unified Waqf Management, Empowerment, Efficiency and Development Rules, 2025 that deal with issues such as the portal and database of Waqf properties, the manner of their registration, conduct of audit and maintenance of accounts. The rules were notified on Thursday in exercise of powers under Section 108B of the 1995 Act, which was inserted through the Waqf (Amendment) Act 2025, which came into effect from April 8, 2025. According to the rules, a portal and database is set up for the purposes of filing of details of Waqf, uploading the list of auqaf, registration of new Waqf, maintenance of register of auqaf and maintenance and submission of accounts of mutawalli of a Waqf, publication of audit report and proceedings and order board under Section 48 of the Act. The joint secretary to the Government of India in the Ministry of Minority Affairs in-charge of the Waqf division shall be responsible for the supervision and control of the portal and database, the rules notified said. The portal and database shall contain the details and fields referred to in the Act, monitoring and management of Waqf properties and related data, court cases, resolution of disputes and such other details and fields as are necessary for the filing of details of the Waqf and the property dedicated to it on the portal and database. Every state government shall appoint an officer not below the rank of a joint secretary to that government as the nodal officer and shall establish a centralised support unit, in consultation with the central government for providing assistance in streamlining uploading of details of Waqf and properties thereof, registration, maintenance of accounts, audit and other related activities of the Waqf and the board, the rules stated. The portal and database shall include features for real-time monitoring of registration of new Waqf and filing details of the Waqf and properties dedicated to the Waqf, institutional governance, court cases and dispute resolution, financial oversight and resource management, and for surveys and development thereof, the rules stated. Every mutawalli shall enrol on the portal and database by using his mobile number and e-mail address through authentication by one-time password (OTP) received from the portal and database and thereafter be able to access the portal and database and file details of his Waqf and property dedicated to the Waqf. After enrolment, the mutawalli shall be able to login the portal and database by using his mobile number and e-mail ID with OTP for future use of the portal and database in respect of his Waqf. A mutawalli is the manager or administrator of a Waqf property, which is an Islamic charitable endowment. Every user of the portal and database, including board, collector, designated officer under Section 3C of the Act, and other officers of the central government and state government dealing with Waqf shall also have access to the portal and database under this rule. Central Waqf Council shall have access to the information uploaded on the portal and database.


Economic Times
8 hours ago
- Economic Times
UP government grants permission for 2 new private universities
Live Events (You can now subscribe to our (You can now subscribe to our Economic Times WhatsApp channel In a move aimed at strengthening the higher-education landscape in Uttar Pradesh, the state government has granted permission for the establishment of the Maharishi Mahesh Yogi Ramayan University in Ayodhya and issued a letter of intent for the creation of the Ajay Kumar Garg University in establishment of the Ramayan University in Ayodhya and an engineering-focussed university in an industrial city like Ghaziabad is a clear indication that the "New Uttar Pradesh" is rapidly moving toward becoming a frontrunner in the field of higher education, the government said in a statement on the leadership of Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath , the government is putting in efforts to make education more accessible, inclusive and modern, the statement Higher Education Minister Yogendra Upadhyay said the government is encouraging innovation and infrastructure development in higher education through private-sector the coming years, Uttar Pradesh is set to become a leading state in the field of education, the minister order to improve the quality of education and provide youngsters with access to higher-education institutions at the local level, both university proposals were approved through a time-bound process, he minister informed that the Maharishi Mahesh Yogi Ramayan University has been officially notified and granted permission under the Uttar Pradesh Private Universities (Amendment) Act, 2025. The university will now be able to operate formally in accordance with the set conditions and official the Ajay Kumar Garg University, proposed by the Indian Institute of Management and Engineering Society, Ghaziabad, has been issued a letter of intent under Section 6 of the Uttar Pradesh Private Universities Act, establish a university, an institution must meet certain requirements, including a minimum endowment fund of Rs 5 crore, 20 acres of land in an urban area and at least 24,000 square metres of academic of State for Higher Education Rajni Tiwari, Principal Secretary of Higher Education M P Agrawal, Special Secretary Nidhi Srivastava and other departmental officials were present on the occasion, the statement added.


New Indian Express
10 hours ago
- New Indian Express
UPITS 2025 roadshow held in New Delhi
NEW DELHI: The Government of Uttar Pradesh, in collaboration with India Exposition Mart Ltd (IEML), held a roadshow in New Delhi on Friday to promote the third edition of the UP International Trade Show (UPITS) 2025. This event follows the curtain-raiser held in Lucknow on June 27, which was launched by Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath. The New Delhi roadshow marked a key milestone in the run-up to UPITS 2025, which is scheduled to take place from September 25 to 29 at the India Expo Centre & Mart in Greater Noida. Themed 'Ultimate Sourcing Begins Here', the upcoming edition aims to enhance exports across vital sectors in the state, including MSMEs, electronics, IT, handloom and textiles, ODOP, Khadi and village industries, sericulture, food processing, automobiles, EVs, renewable energy, and traditional crafts. The roadshow was presided over by Rakesh Sachan, Cabinet Minister for MSME, Khadi and Village Industries, Sericulture, Handloom & Textile, Government of Uttar Pradesh. He was joined by Alok Kumar, Principal Secretary, MSME & Export Promotion, Government of Uttar Pradesh; Dr. Rakesh Kumar, Chairman, India Exposition Mart Ltd; Dr. Ajay Sahai, Director General & CEO, Federation of Indian Export Organisations (FIEO); Dr. Neeraj Khanna, Chairman, Export Promotion Council for Handicrafts; Shailendra Bhatia, OSD, Yamuna Expressway Industrial Development Authority; and other senior officials. The event witnessed participation from representatives of foreign embassies, including those of Austria, Canada, Vietnam, Norway, and Singapore. A diverse group of trade associations, sourcing consultants, sectoral leaders, and industry stakeholders from across North India also attended. Speaking at the roadshow, Minister Rakesh Sachan said, 'Uttar Pradesh has emerged as a promising hub of opportunity, driven by a strong focus on development, entrepreneurship, and global engagement.' He emphasized that UPITS is more than a trade exhibition—it is a platform to showcase the strength of Uttar Pradesh's industries, artisans, MSMEs, and entrepreneurs on a global stage. Improved infrastructure and law and order have allowed industries and MSMEs to thrive in the state. From handlooms and ODOP products to electronics, food processing, and renewable energy, UPITS reflects a powerful fusion of heritage and modern enterprise under one roof. He further added that with exports rising from all 75 districts and increasing international interest, Uttar Pradesh is developing strong linkages across key sectors. 'UPITS is helping transform local excellence into global reach. It offers a space where buyers, investors, innovators, and producers can come together to build lasting partnerships. Under the leadership of Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath, the Government of Uttar Pradesh is fostering a business-friendly environment through improved governance, equal opportunities, and industry-forward policies. UPITS 2025 is not just a trade event—it is a vision to connect the potential of Uttar Pradesh with the world,' Sachan said. Alok Kumar, Principal Secretary, MSME & Export Promotion, added, 'Uttar Pradesh seems like a giant awakening. It is growing rapidly and now has the UP International Trade Show to showcase its industrial and cultural strengths. This is an export gateway for our MSMEs, artisans, and entrepreneurs. With each edition, UPITS builds bridges from local businesses to global markets, reinforcing our commitment to achieving the vision of a trillion-dollar economy.' Dr. Rakesh Kumar, Chairman of India Exposition Mart Ltd and co-organiser of UPITS, highlighted the diverse sectors and high-performing products from Uttar Pradesh that will be featured at the event. He said, 'UPITS is a perfect sourcing platform that brings together all the products and services from the state in one place.' Dr. Ajay Sahai, Director General & CEO of FIEO, spoke about the overseas buyers program and the financial support being extended with the help of the state government. 'FIEO is bringing together international buyers to explore the full manufacturing and creative potential of the state. UPITS is becoming an unmatched sourcing destination for domestic and global buyers across all product and service categories,' he noted. The roadshow also offered a preview of UPITS 2025's expanded features, including new exhibitor categories, focused B2B meetings, curated buyer delegations, ODOP showcases, and dedicated export promotion zones. It serves as a strategic platform to attract wide industry participation and ensure strong buyer turnout from both regional and international markets. This roadshow is part of a nationwide series designed to generate awareness and engagement for UPITS 2025. The Delhi edition specifically aimed to build stronger connections with sourcing consultants, institutional buyers, exporters, and industry associations from the capital and nearby regions. Upcoming roadshows are planned for Hyderabad, Bengaluru, Mumbai, and Ahmedabad as part of the promotional campaign. Building on the success of its previous editions—which attracted lakhs of visitors and buyers and generated business enquiries worth thousands of crores—UPITS 2025 is poised to be even more ambitious in scale and impact. (Disclaimer: This is a press release issued by UP International Trade Show)