BBC response to Bob Vylan's IDF chants at Glastonbury ‘not good enough', says minister
The BBC is facing questions after the musician Bobby Vylan – of the punk-rap duo Bob Vylan – led crowds at the festival's West Holts stage in chants of 'Free, free Palestine' and 'Death, death to the IDF [Israel Defense Forces]' on Saturday.
Keir Starmer has said there is 'no excuse' for the chanting, and the corporation said it showed a warning during the set's stream about the 'very strong and discriminatory language'.
The Bob Vylan set was shown live on an iPlayer stream but the footage has since been removed from the BBC's streaming services.
The equalities minister, Jacqui Smith, said that, while she did not believe the BBC was biased on the war in Gaza, a line had been crossed during its Glastonbury coverage.
'These were clearly comments that overstepped the mark. I'm surprised that the BBC carried on broadcasting them live when it was obvious what was happening. I think the BBC also have questions to answer about how they continued to broadcast this for the time that they did,' she told Sky News on Monday.
Bob Vylan, whose two members go by Bobby Vylan and Bobbie Vylan, played immediately before Kneecap on Saturday. The BBC had decided not to broadcast the latter's set live amid controversy over the band's support for Gaza at previous gigs.
Describing himself as a 'violent punk', Bobby Vylan said on stage: 'Sometimes we have to get our message across with violence because that's the only language some people speak, unfortunately.'
The BBC's warnings were 'not good enough', Smith said on Monday. She told Times Radio: 'I think it [the BBC] made a mistake here. It's not good enough simply to say on screen that, you know, this is dodgy language. It was far beyond that and it shouldn't have been broadcast live. And I think it would have been possible for the BBC to stop that.'
Smith added that she thought there would be 'lots of people' at the festival who 'were also remembering the music festival in Israel on the 7 October 2023, where young people got grabbed from that music festival, kidnapped and murdered, and will want to reflect on that as well'.
A former head of news and current affairs at Channel 4, Dorothy Byrne, said that, had the BBC wanted to act more decisively on the broadcast, it would have been technically possible.
She told BBC Radio 4's Today programme there were questions to answer about the research it had done into Bob Vylan, adding: 'They should really have had a politics producer in the gallery ready to advise them when and if something went wrong.
'I would have expected them to have an alternative feed available anyway because things can go wrong and there were lots of other acts on at the time. I'm surprised they just left it on with a warning rather than cut away because it's wrong to call for anyone to be killed.'
She said the Glastonbury coverage should not be held to the same standard on impartiality expected of news programming. But she added that the BBC's coverage meant it was the focus of controversy 'when we should be discussing events in Gaza'.
Bobby Vylan stood by his actions, posting on Sunday on Instagram: 'I said what I said' and calling for a 'change in foreign policy'.
He added: 'As we grow older and our fire possibly starts to dim under the suffocation of adult life and all its responsibilities, it is incredibly important that we encourage and inspire future generations to pick up the torch that was passed to us.
'Let us display to them loudly and visibly the right thing to do when we want and need change. Let them see us marching in the streets, campaigning on ground level, organising online and shouting about it on any and every stage that we are offered.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time Out
38 minutes ago
- Time Out
The 2025 Maho Rasop Series lineup has landed
It's strange to think of November in Bangkok without Maho Rasop. The annual gathering – once a shorthand for discovering music you didn't yet know you loved – has been a fixture in the city's cultural calendar, a rare blend of precision and chaos, polish and grit. Last year, it was Air who drifted into the skyline, their set suspended somewhere between nostalgia and dream. I remember it not just as a performance, but as a collective hallucination; a crowd swaying in a rare moment of perfect weather. This year, though, the festival is on pause. In its place comes something that feels at once smaller and more deliberate: Maho Rasop Series, a chain of standalone concerts unfolding across November and December 2025. Less sprawling field, more curated rooms. The same people – HAVE YOU HEARD?, Seen Scene Space, Fungjai – but now playing with intimacy as their headline act. The absence of the festival was not a creative decision alone. The press release didn't dress it up. The global economy is fragile. Artist fees keep climbing. Audiences are cautious with their spending. The regional circuit has grown more crowded, each city trying to host its own miniature Glastonbury. And so, Maho Rasop – usually a sprawling, weekend-long escape – is sitting this one out. It's a sobering reminder that 'support your local scene and festival' isn't just a nice slogan to print on a tote. Without audiences, without sponsors who understand the worth of these events, without the often-invisible crews who make them happen, even the most beloved gatherings can vanish. And yet, from that pause comes a pivot. Maho Rasop Series promises to keep the spirit intact – introducing listeners to acts they might not stumble upon otherwise, making each show its own world of light, sound, and atmosphere. Three names are already on the poster. Let's have a closer look at them. Black Country, New Road The first to be revealed, announced in July. They arrive on December 13 at Search Studio, Ramkhamhaeng 81. Black Country, New Road (BC,NR) are not a band you half-listen to. Their sound spills across experimental rock, touching post-punk's nervous edges and the wistfulness of klezmer. Their debut, For the First Time (2021), landed like a thesis statement. The follow-up, Ants From Up There (2022), was heavier with emotion – and also the last with vocalist Isaac Wood. Their debut, For the First Time (2021), sounded like six people running in different directions but somehow keeping pace – jagged saxophone, angular guitar, lyrics you weren't sure you'd understood but couldn't stop replaying. Then came Ants From Up There (2022), warmer, more melodic, and bittersweet, now considered one of the defining records of the decade's early years. When frontman Isaac Wood stepped away in 2022, many thought it might be the end. Instead, they dissolved the idea of a single frontperson altogether. Forever Howlong, their latest, feels both lighter and more fragile – all shared vocals, quiet pastoral interludes, and words that cling like half-forgotten dreams. Live, this shift has given them an almost theatrical fluidity, with members swapping instruments and roles mid-set. Tickets are available now via Ticketmelon right here. Regular price B2,200 or B2,400 at the door. Suchmos Next, the Japanese rock collective with a taste for groove. Formed in 2013 in Kanagawa Prefecture, Suchmos pull from African-American genres – rock, jazz, hip-hop – and their name nods to Louis Armstrong's nickname, 'Satchmo'. Catch them live on November 30 at Ambience Space. Their debut THE BAY (2015) gave us 'YMM', all funk and disco lift, and won them Apple Music's Best New Artist of that year. THE KIDS (2017) leaned further into rock and hip-hop, with 'STAY TUNE' sending the album to the top of Billboard Japan's charts. In Thailand, they became familiar faces after their Big Mountain Music Festival slot in 2018, just as THE ASHTRAY brought a '70s haze to their catalogue. THE ANYMAL (2019) – part Beatles homage, part experiment – proved they could keep evolving without losing their rhythm-first DNA. Tickets are now available on Ticketmelon – grab yours here. Zone A: B2,400, Zone B: B1,800. L'Impératrice Presented by Seen Scene Space on November 27 at The Street Hall. The Parisian group weave electropop, funk, and nu-disco into something lush and cinematic. Members Charles de Boisseguin (keyboard), Hagni Gwan (keyboard), Achille Trocellier (guitar), David Gaugué (bass), Tom Daveau (drums) and vocalist Flore Benguigui build songs that glide – silk basslines under disco name means 'The Empress', a nod to transformation and quiet authority. Flore's presence is both magnetic and political: she writes about sexism in the industry, about being second-guessed as an artist because she is a woman, about resisting any attempt to reshape her identity. On stage, those politics become euphoria. Albums like Matahari (2019) and Tako Tsubo (2021) show their range – the former a cascade of glittering dancefloor anthems, the latter dipping into more introspective textures without losing groove. Live, they're masters of atmosphere: coloured lights curling like smoke, bass lines you feel in your ribs, and an audience that inevitably starts to sway by the second will be on sale via Ticketmelon here, with early bird pricing at B1,900 from August 16-22, and regular tickets at B2,200 starting August 23. What's being offered here isn't a consolation prize. It's a reminder that live music doesn't always have to be a sprawling field and a weekend lost to mud. Sometimes it's a single night in a small room, the air thick with anticipation, where the distance between audience and artist is short enough to see every detail. Maho Rasop Festival will be missed this year, but Maho Rasop Series might give us something else entirely – a season stitched together from singular moments, each one designed to be unrepeatable.
Daily Mail
3 hours ago
- Daily Mail
ANDREW PIERCE: Londoners have the Tube, Sadiq Khan has a gravy train
London may be riddled with crime, soaring prices and poor-quality transport – but at least Mayor Sadiq Khan and his officials can enjoy the finer things in life. Latest figures reveal City Hall racked up a £2billion expenses bill in the past financial year. This includes a jaw-dropping £4.6million on printing, £805,000 on hotel accommodation and £57,000 on photography. Then there's the £48,000 spent on postage and another £31,000 for European and domestic flights. The Mayor himself also received tickets worth almost £8,000 to football matches and Taylor Swift concerts (he was last month cleared of wrongdoing in relation to the gifts). And, not to be outdone, his aides have cashed in to the tune of £11,000 with tickets to Glastonbury, the Brit Awards and the UEFA Champions League football finals. Nice work if you can get it... In the Spring Statement, Rachel Reeves announced the formation of the Defence Growth Board to oversee investment in our Armed Forces. Five months later, how many times has it met? Not once. Yet more window-dressing from a Chancellor woefully out of her depth. Cotswolds locals weren't the only Britons amazed by Mr Vance's 24-vehicle entourage during his trip to Britain. BBC grandee John Simpson tells how the late Queen Elizabeth would travel around Britain by train. 'She and her companions would have four seats in a first-class carriage, plus two more for her detectives, leaving the rest of the carriage for the public,' he notes. '[They] were always stunned to see her with so little security.' All eyes will be on London's Guildhall on October 13 when Tory big beasts gather for the tenth anniversary dinner of the Margaret Thatcher Centre – dedicated to the legacy of Britain's greatest post-war leader. But there'll be one notable absence – that of party leader Kemi Badenoch, who will be attending a fundraising event elsewhere on the same night. Lammy's angling is rather fishy... It seems that David Lammy has never held a fishing rod in his life, to judge from his laughably unconvincing fishing pose with US Vice-President JD Vance. The Foreign Secretary, whose Tottenham constituency borders the favourite spot of many London anglers, the Walthamstow Wetlands, could have made more of an effort. I doubt his photo opportunity will have hooked their votes. If Keir Starmer needs advice, he might try Tory MP Esther McVey's words of wisdom. ''Never-here Keir' has clocked up a massive 100,000 air miles in just over a year – more than any prime minister this century – while suffering the steepest drop in approval ratings for any recent election-winning leader,' she says. 'Maybe if Keir spent more time in the UK he might improve his ratings!' Police minister Dame Diana Johnson advised victims of crime to dial 999 if they're in trouble or '111' for less serious issues. She ought to know 111 is for NHS matters. The police are on 101. Labour MP Afzal Khan, fired as trade envoy to Turkey, once overdid the henna while dying his hair, giving him alarmingly ginger roots. From the Press seats above, he looked like Rita Hayworth.
Daily Mail
3 hours ago
- Daily Mail
EastEnders star Michelle Ryan shares glam Zoe Slater transformation pics amid her return to the BBC soap
EastEnders star Michelle Ryan has shared before and after glam transformation snaps amid her return to the BBC soap. The actress, 41, briefly reprised her role as Zoe Slater back in June after 20 years away from Albert Square. Michelle is set to make a full time return as Zoe this summer where she'll come face-to-face with her estranged mother Kat Slater (Jessie Wallace) in explosive scenes. And amid filming for her scenes, Michelle gave fans a glimpse into how she gets into character as Zoe as she snapped selfies in the make-up chair. The soap star initially showed off a bare-faced look without a scrap of make-up, before a follow-up picture showed her with eye-liner and sleeker hair. Subsequent images followed showing Michelle looking glam with a sweep of bold red lipstick, while her raven locks were styled in glam waves. Set to Modjo's 2001 track Lady (Hear Me Tonight), Michelle captioned her post writing: 'Make up transformation today in the chair. Grateful to costume and make up for helping me find the role of Zoe again over the past couple of months. 'When I first played Zoe early 2000's this song was a huge hit and played all the time.' It comes after Jessie revealed she 'burst out crying' after reuniting with her on screen daughter Michelle amid her return to the soap. During her time on the show, Michelle was involved in one of the soap's biggest storylines when it was revealed that Kat Slater (Jessie) was in fact Zoe's mother and not her sister, with explosive scenes seeing her yell: 'You ain't my mother!', only for Kat to reply: 'Yes I am!' And now, after returning to Albert Square two decades after her dramatic exit, Jessie, 53, revealed she was overcome with emotion at the news. Speaking in an interview with the Radio Times she confessed that they reunited at a secret dinner date with the executive producers. 'I burst out I saw Michelle, I cried – we were all very emotional. It was nostalgic and lovely.' While it isn't uncommon for roles to be recast in the soap world, Jessie was also determined that if Zoe returned it could only be Michelle. Michelle captioned her post writing: 'Make up transformation today in the chair. Grateful to costume and make up for helping me find the role of Zoe again over the past couple of months' 'I said to Ben [executive producer], "It has to be Michelle. It won't feel right if Zoe is recast." I wouldn't be able to give my best performance. The audience would feel completely conned.' She added: 'I love Michelle and have always been protective over her, perhaps that's natural having played her mum. I'm a mother myself now, which I wasn't when we worked together before, and I'm very protective over my daughter.' Michelle had been asked to return to the soap before but had always declined. However this time she felt the time was right after she was moved after seeing the comments on social media following EastEnders' 40th anniversary. After reminiscing on her time on the soap with colleagues she mentioned to her agent that she would go back and as coincidence would have it EastEnders had already been on the phone. Back in June Zoe made a bombshell return to the BBC soap, after her return was kept under wraps. Viewers then saw Zoe in two further episodes that week but she will now be back full-time this summer. Speaking previously on her return to the BBC soap, Michelle said: 'It feels like coming home. After doing my first few scenes, it was like I'd never been away. It all happened at the right time. 'I'd already been thinking about a return because I'd met up with Kacey Ainsworth (Little Mo) and Kim Medcalf (Sam Mitchell) and we were reminiscing our fond memories of the show, and I'd also joined social media and saw that there was still a lot of love for the character. 'It just so happened that at the same time, EastEnders had announced a new Exec who was keen to explore the potential of a return as he was such a massive fan of Zoe and the Slaters, so both of our worlds aligned at the right time, and I'm so excited to be back.
