Oregon adoption policy on LGBTQ acceptance violates free speech rights, court says
A divided three-judge panel of the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals reversed a lower court ruling blocking Jessica Bates from adopting because of the Oregon Department of Human Services' policy.
The majority agreed with Bates, a devout Christian who said her beliefs prevent her from following the policy, finding that it violates Bates' rights to free speech and free exercise of religion under the First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution.
Circuit Judge Daniel Bress, who was appointed by Republican President Donald Trump in his first term, joined with Circuit Judge Michael Hawkins, an appointee of Democratic President Bill Clinton, in finding that the policy is unconstitutional.
Oregon hasn't explained why other ways to protect LGBTQ children in foster care — instead of a policy that broadly bans Bates from adopting — aren't feasible, Bress wrote in the opinion.
'A state's general conception of the child's best interest does not create a force field against the valid operation of other constitutional rights,' he wrote.
Bates was represented by lawyers from Alliance Defending Freedom, a conservative Christian group that is routinely involved in high-profile court cases involving religious liberties.
'The 9th Circuit was right to remind Oregon that the foster and adoption system is supposed to serve the best interests of children, not the state's ideological crusade,' ADF Senior Counsel and Vice President of Litigation Strategy Jonathan Scruggs said in a statement after the ruling.
A spokesperson for Democratic Oregon Attorney General Dan Rayfield, whose office defended the policy, said in a statement they are reviewing the ruling to determine their next steps.
Bates filed the lawsuit in 2023 after her application to adopt a pair of siblings was denied when she told an administrator that she couldn't support the behavior of a hypothetical child whose preferred pronouns and identity don't match their biological sex.
The district court rejected Bates' bid for an injunction against the policy, finding that Oregon has a strong interest in protecting the rights of LGBTQ children and the policy's regulation of free speech was precise enough.
Circuit Judge Richard Clifton, an appointee of former President George W. Bush, dissented, saying that the policy regulates parental actions and does not impact speech beyond what is necessary.
The case is Bates v. Pakseresht, case number 23-4169 in the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.
For Bates: Jonathan Scruggs, James Campbell, Johannes Widmalm-Delphonse, John Bursch of the Alliance Defending Freedom and Rebekah Schultheiss of the Freedom Foundation
For Oregon: Philip Thoennes, Denise Fjordbeck, Benjamin Gutman, Ellen Rosenblum of the Oregon Department of Justice
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
a few seconds ago
- Daily Mail
Awkward moment Kamala Harris waffles when pressed about who is the leader of the Democrats
Former Vice President Kamala Harris wouldn't give a name when asked who the current leader is of the Democratic Party. Harris appeared Thursday night on the Late Show With Stephen Colbert following last month's shock announcement that CBS was cancelling the program next spring. The previous Democratic presidential nominee announced this week that she had penned a book about her failed 2024 campaign experience entitled 107 Days, which will be released next month. Harris also revealed that she won't be running for California governor in 2026, teeing up speculation she's planning to mount another presidential bid in 2028 instead. Colbert was quick to press her on who the real leader of the Democrats is now, as other potential 2028 hopefuls - including Gov. Gavin Newsom, Pete Buttigieg and Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez - wait in the wings. 'Who's leading the Democratic Party? I'm just curious,' Colbert prodded. Harris briefly paused. 'There are lots of leaders,' she responded. Colbert didn't buy it. 'There's generally a leader of the Democratic Party,' the liberal comedian continued, cuing laughs. 'Who comes to mind?' Harris, again, didn't name names. 'I think there are a lot of - I'm not going to go through names because I'm going to leave somebody out and then I'm going to hear about it,' the former VP answered. Party leaders tend to be former presidents and former presidential nominees. But former Vice President Kamala Harris (left) didn't volunteer her name or that of former President Joe Biden (right) when Stephen Colbert asked who is the leader of the Democratic Party 'But let me say this,' she continued. 'I think it is a mistake for us who want to figure out how to get out and through this, and get out of it, to put it on the shoulders of any one person. It's really on all of our shoulders. It really is,' Harris added. Typically a former president or the party's most recent presidential nominee would be considered the party leader - but Harris didn't volunteer herself nor former President Joe Biden. She also announced this week that she would not seek the job of California governor. After leaving Washington in January for Los Angeles, Harris was reportedly mulling a run. She had previously served as a U.S. senator from California and the state's attorney general, before being sworn-in as vice president in 2021. Colbert asked Harris why she had decided to sit this one out - and if she planned to run for a different office, alluding to another presidential run in 2028. 'No, no, no,' she answered. 'It's more, perhaps, basic then that,' Harris continued. 'I am a devout public servant. I have spent my entire career in service of the people and I thought a lot about running for governor. I love my state, I love California.' She then told Colbert she wanted to be 'very candid with you.' 'For now, I don't want to go back in the system, I think it's broken,' Harris said. 'I want to travel the country, I want to listen to people, I want to talk to people and I don't want it to be transactional where I'm asking for their vote.' President Donald Trump, who beat Harris in November's election, was asked Thursday about his former rival's decision not to run for California governor. 'Well, she can't speak,' Trump replied. 'She can't talk. She can't do an interview.' 'I thought it was a very strange campaign that we had,' the president added.
Daily Mail
a few seconds ago
- Daily Mail
The View likened to 'insane asylum' by critic for 'booking 102 liberal guests and NO conservatives'
Fox News ' Guy Benson slammed 'The View' as an 'insane asylum' after a study from Media Research Center's NewsBusters determined the show has welcomed 102 left-leaning guests this year. The study, which looked at episodes from January 6 through July 25, also said 'zero conservatives ' appeared on the daytime opinion show. Arnold Schwarzenegger, an anti-Trump Republican, appeared last month. The former Golden State governor was discounted due to voting for Kamala Harris, NewsBusters editors said. Benson, a Fox News contributor, reacted live to the results on Friday's 'Fox & Friends.' There, host Ainsley Earhardt joked: 'So "The View" only has one view?' Co-host Brian Kilmeade similarly lamented: 'They used to be somewhat balanced,' recalling how Barbara Walters started the show in 1997 'to get some political points of view – no script – and just get a conversation going and let us know what women talk about when they're together. 'Then what happened? It ends up being an angry Democratic show,' he asserted, pacing the way for Benson. 'I am actually surprised by this because 102 seems a little low,' he began, eventually proclaiming, 'It's an insane asylum now.' 'The left talked for years about bringing back the fairness doctrine,' he told Kilmeade, Earhardt, and Lawrence Jones. 'This was an obsession of theirs to try to clamp down on the success of [conservative] talk radio. 'If they had succeeded and had gotten the fairness doctrine, " The View" would be out of business for that reason alone,' Benson argued. '[The show] would be basically illegal.' Jones then chimed to accuse the show's co-hosts - Whoopi Goldberg, Ana Navarro, lone Republican Alyssa Farrah Griffin, Joy Behar, Sara Haines, and Sunny Hostin - of being hostile toward right-leaning guests they have had on in the past. Kilmeade, meanwhile, called the discrepancy the 'least surprising stat ever.' Daily Mail has contacted ABC, which broadcasts The View, for comment. A source pushed back on claims the program does not welcome conservative talking points. 'Without going into detail about the show's booking process, there is wide outreach across the aisle,' the insider told Daily Mail. Guests this year, meanwhile, have included the likes of former President Joe Biden, rising Congressional Democrat Jasmine Crockett, House Democratic Leader Hakeem Jeffries, and Democratic Senators Chuck Schumer and Elissa Slotkin. John Fetterman, Pennsylvania 's centrist Democrat senator, appeared on the program on January 27. Goldberg, Haines, Navarro, and Hostin went on to pepper him with questions about his relationship with Donald Trump, whom Fetterman defended. A slew of left-leaning stars have appeared since, including famed feminist Gloria Steinem, MSNBC's Molly Jong-Fast and Javier Bardem. Stars like Mariska Hargitay and Republican Kelsey Grammer were not counted, however, due to the study not including stars whose segments did not touch on politics, the media analyst who did the research, Nick Fondacaro, said. 'The View has undergone some major changes since last year which proves it has gotten more extreme,' he told Daily Mail Friday. 'Prior to their winter break, the cast would defend and praise their reliance on legal notes, only to abandon the practice altogether in the latter half of the season. 'Meanwhile, they've gotten more comfortable with making wild, unsubstantiated actuations in the early months of the second Trump administration, which seem to not ruffle feathers in ABC's Standards and Practices division.' He added how longtime Executive Producer Brian Teta has repeatedly 'defended the show's biases and legal notes by arguing it functions like the editorial pages of a newspaper. 'But even newspapers have editorial standards that keep them from saying some of the unhinged things that The View has said this year,' he claimed. T he Media Research Center, meanwhile, is a conservative watchdog group started in 1987.
Reuters
a few seconds ago
- Reuters
Lesotho textiles to struggle even with lower 15% Trump tariff, minister says
JOHANNESBURG, Aug 1 (Reuters) - Lesotho's modified tariff rate of 15% may still not be enough to save its textiles industry, its trade minister said on Friday, a day after U.S. President Donald Trump lowered it from a devastating 50% rate he had threatened to implement earlier. In an executive order, Trump modified reciprocal tariff rates for dozens of countries, including Lesotho, which had been under threat of a 50% rate since April, the highest of any U.S. trading partner. "It's a mixed feeling," Lesotho Trade Minister Mokhethi Shelile told Reuters by telephone. "The sad part is that it is still not good enough ... this will lead to job losses." Lesotho's textiles sector is its leading export industry, and it was heavily dependent upon the Africa Growth and Opportunities Act (AGOA), a U.S. trade initiative that offers qualifying African nations duty-free access to the U.S. market. On the back of that preferential tariff, textiles were the tiny mountain kingdom's biggest private employer, with some 40,000 jobs and accounted for roughly 90% of manufacturing exports, according to Oxford Economics. Under the tariff threat, many U.S. importers canceled orders of Lesotho-produced textiles, leading to mass layoffs. Shelile indicated that the new tariff would be unlikely to reverse the carnage. "Fifteen percent for the textile industry is as good as 50%, because there's still no chance that our textiles will compete with Kenya or Eswatini, who have 10%," he said. "Those are our direct competition". The Trump administration has defended its tariffs, stating that Lesotho charged 99% tariffs on U.S. goods. Lesotho officials say they have no idea how the White House arrived at that figure. After firing off a salvo of tariffs in April, the administration paused implementation to give countries time to negotiate. Textiles factories have in recent months indicated they were searching for new markets. Shelile said his government would continue to engage with U.S. counterparts in hope of having the rate lowered.
