Economist calls for budget ‘prudence', as Central Bank governor suggests rethink is needed
Budget 2026
, while there is a case for postponing recurrent spending and
tax
cuts until there is 'greater clarity' on the negative implications of the
EU-US trade deal
, a prominent economist has said.
Dan O'Brien, the chief economist of the
Institute of International and European Affairs
, made the remarks while responding to comments from the
Central Bank
governor
Gabriel Makhlouf
suggesting the Government should rethink its approach to the October budget.
In its
summer economic statement
last month the Government said a €9.4 billion tax and spending package will form the foundation of the upcoming budget.
However, the Coalition warned at the time it may have to 'recalibrate' its strategy and reduce the size of the overall package if there is a 'deterioration in the
tariff
landscape' over the coming months.
READ MORE
The
European Union
has since struck a trade deal with the
United States
which sees EU goods, including those from Ireland, hit with 15 per cent tariffs by the US.
The Business Post reported on Sunday that Mr Makhlouf said Minister for Finance
Paschal Donohoe
now has 'more certainly' for planning the budget with the level of tariffs on EU goods known.
'Hopefully the summer economic statement is not the budget, and hopefully, by the time he (Mr Donohoe) gets there, he will have reflected again on what the trade situation is telling us,' Mr Makhlouf said.
He added: 'For an economy operating at full employment, we're adding more stimulus to the economy than it needs – and I would look again at what we're planning to do.'
Mr Makhlouf also told the paper: 'I think at the moment there's a risk that we're in the wrong place.'
[
What did the summer economic statement really tell us about Budget 2026?
Opens in new window
]
A spokeswoman for Mr Donohoe declined to comment on Mr Makhlouf's remarks.
During an interview on Newstalk radio on Sunday, Mr O'Brien was asked if he agrees Mr Donohoe needs to rethink the budget.
He said this suggestion is 'largely' correct, as 'we're facing a lot of uncertainty'.
Mr O'Brien added: 'I think the Government needs to manage expectations around this. There's been a lot of giveaways [in recent budgets]. Clearly we had a general election last year.'
He said there has been a 'big uptick in inflation' but this has 'come right back down again' and 'there isn't the justification for Government to be intervening to deal with every problem'.
Mr O'Brien said the implications of the trade situation for the pharmaceutical sector are uncertain, relying on the 'whims of the US president who may just decide he doesn't like the pharmaceutical sector in Europe selling stuff to the US and he may do something more radical'.
He added: 'So there's a lot of uncertainty here, and I think we need a lot of prudence in this budget.'
Asked about potential tax choices in the budget, Mr O'Brien argued there is 'no economic justification' for the Government's intention to reduce the
VAT
rate for the hospitality sector.
'One might strongly make the case that both recurrent spending and tax cuts maybe need to be postponed until we get greater clarity as to the negative implications of the trade deal and the extent to which it effects particularly the pharmaceutical sector and how that feeds into corporation tax revenues,' Mr O'Brien added.
'We just don't know how big a hit that could impose on the public finances if we get a change in pharmaceuticals sales to the US and that results in a reduction in
corporation tax
profits.'
Did the EU have its hands tied before striking a trade deal with the US?
Listen |
23:32
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
4 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Venture capital funding environment for Irish AI start-ups 'challenging'
Despite venture capital investing heavily in generative AI during the first half of the year, Irish AI start-ups are finding the funding environment 'challenging', a new report from consultancy company EY has found. Between January and June, global venture capital investment in generative AI surged to $49.2bn (€42.5bn), outpacing the total for all of 2024 at $44.2bn, according to EY Ireland's latest Generative AI Key Deals and Market Insights study. The company said the sharp rise comes as venture capital firms concentrate on more mature, revenue-generating AI companies, resulting in fewer but significantly larger deals. Average transaction size for late-stage deals more than tripled to more than $1.55bn, up from $481m in 2024. EY Ireland's technology, media and telecoms lead Grit Young said this investment momentum was expected to continue to build into the second half of this year with the launch of new generative AI platforms. However, the report noted while Ireland had emerged as a strong adopter of AI among start-ups, many are struggling with access to capital and infrastructure. 'In Ireland, the appetite for AI adoption is strong, and we are working with many indigenous and international companies who are already well established on their AI journey,' Ms Young said. 'However, for AI start-ups, the funding environment remains challenging, particularly in the €1m to €10m funding space.' She added many start-ups with high potential were finding themselves in a difficult middle ground where they are 'too advanced for early-stage support, yet not quite large enough to attract global venture capital attention'. 'However Ireland has a deep and well-established pool of talented entrepreneurs, and with increased collaboration between businesses, founders, academic institutions and policymakers, there are plenty of opportunities to be seized,' she said.
Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
Jones Engineering targets €1.5bn turnover as overseas business expands
Irish construction firm Jones Engineering says it expects turnover to surpass €1.5 billion this year as it continues to expand overseas. According to recently filed accounts, the contractor, which specialises in large-scale industrial projects for the life sciences sector, saw turnover increase by almost 25 per cent to €1.28 billion last year. The company, which employs 4,500 staff across 19 countries, reported a profit of €75.5 million, up from €70.8 million the previous year. 'Our increased turnover in 2024 reflects the ambitious growth trajectory and long-term vision of Jones Engineering,' chief executive Stephen McCabe said. READ MORE 'We expect this momentum to continue, with turnover projected to surpass €1.5 billion in 2025. While we remain the market leader in our sector in Ireland, our strongest growth has come from our expanding overseas operations. 'Looking ahead, 2025 is set to be another strong year for the company with a robust pipeline of work extending into 2026 and beyond,' he said. Increased levels of business saw the company recruit almost 1,000 additional staff in 2024, including more than 240 hires at graduate, internship and apprenticeship levels and about 494 in engineering, craft and support roles. Jones said its baseline headcount grew by 431 (18 per cent) in 2024, which it described as 'significant growth'. The company recently dropped a legal case taken against trade union Unite and three of its officials arising from a strike two years ago. The builder had claimed it suffered financial damage as a consequence of the industrial dispute. Jones's lawsuit prompted Unite and global trade union federation, Building and Woodworkers International (BWI), to file a complaint against the company and its owner, US-based Cathexis, with the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development. Founded in the 1890s, Jones Engineering was acquired by Cathexis Holdings in 2022 for an undisclosed sum. The company said it generates turnover from the supply of mechanical and electrical engineering services and fire protection services. The latest results showed the directors declared and paid a dividend of €63 million during the year, down from €73 million in 2023.
Irish Times
7 hours ago
- Irish Times
The Irish Times view on policing: domestic violence must be a key focus
Two days after Deputy Commissioner Justin Kelly was confirmed as successor to Garda Commissioner Drew Harris a fresh policing controversy erupted. A review of roads policing found a significant minority of frontline gardaí were uninterested in performing their duties. Indeed, they had a 'blatant disregard' for their jobs, often to the point of hostility. The report is yet to be published, but when the detail of the poor performance and belligerence of the problematic gardaí is laid bare, the controversy will only intensify. The episode is a timely lesson for Kelly as he prepares to take over as Garda commissioner on September 1st, when Harris resigns after seven years. Policing is complex, often problematic, and the next controversy is never too far away. Even if the vast majority of Garda members are committed and hardworking, things will go wrong. Docile, even corrupt, gardaí will create significant problems with the capacity to undermine the force in the eyes of the public. Shocking as the new roads policing revelations are, they have emerged because Garda Headquarters commissioned consultants to carry out a review after receiving claims in an anonymous letter from a Garda whistleblower. It is reassuring that Garda Headquarters was willing to unearth that incompetence and poor service, even if the details are stark. The continuation of that approach, being willing to proactively address problem areas in the force, must be one of Kelly's top priorities. This is a cultural approach he must lead and be seen to lead. READ MORE The Dubliner seems like a formidable policeman, with an impressive record from frontline uniform duties in some very challenging parts of Dublin to leading teams of specialist sex crime investigators. He also has experience leading some of the Garda's special units and was head of the organised and serious crime branch of the force. Though the fight against the gangs must continue, there is evidence from several sources – academia, NGOs and the Garda itself – that domestic and sexual violence is being perpetrated in the Republic at a scale we are only beginning to face up to. Victims, mostly women, are being beaten and terrorised in their homes by controlling men. Harris said this week that violent pornography had become so 'normalised' that sexual offenders were mimicking extreme behaviour in their attacks. As he comes to the job, Kelly is best known for his high profile senior management role in tackling the crime gangs and cartels that run Irish organised crime. This work must go on. However, with the gun feuds having dissipated over the last decade, the Garda must also refocus. Tackling the physical, sexual and psychological violence being inflicted on vulnerable victims across Irish society – most of it waged by men on women – must be a key part of this.
