
Italian lawyers warn of rights violations against Palestinians facing terror charges
The three men, Anan Kamal Afif Yaeesh, Mansour Doghmosh and Ali Irar, were living in the central Italian city, northeast of Rome, when they were arrested.
They are accused of setting up a cell linked to Al-Aqsa Martyrs' Brigades, an armed group associated with the Palestinian Authority's ruling Fatah party.
Authorities claim they were planning attacks "against civilian and military targets on foreign territory".
Al-Aqsa Martyrs' Brigades is considered a terrorist group by Israel, the EU and the US and the charges the trio face carry sentences of up to 15 years imprisonment.
New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch
Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters
But the men's lawyers say the preliminary hearing, which in Italy determines which evidence is admissible, included serious violations of due process.
They reported that the court refused their request to exclude transcripts of interrogations of Palestinian prisoners conducted by Israeli intelligence agency Shin Bet as evidence.
Majority of Israelis want censorship of social media posts sympathetic to Palestinians in Gaza Read More »
That was despite the transcripts previously being deemed inadmissible by another judge.
The defence said in a press release that the move constitutes a violation of the men's right to defence, as the witnesses could not be cross examined by the defence.
Article 111 of the Italian constitution stipulates that: "The defendant shall have the right to cross-examine or to have cross-examined before a judge the persons making accusations and to summon and examine persons for the defence in the same conditions as the prosecution."
The lawyers further highlighted that Palestinian detainees are subjected to multiple abuses during interrogations by Israeli forces, including torture and denial of legal access, in violation of Italian law.
"The court has pretended there are no problems," lawyer Flavio Rossi Albertini told Middle East Eye.
"The judges have shown that they do not want anything to emerge from the trial that would lead to unfavourable judgements against Israel".
Witnesses rejected
The court also rejected 46 out of 49 witnesses proposed by the defence, including UN Special Rapporteur Francesca Albanese, international humanitarian law experts, aid workers and volunteers involved in projects in the occupied West Bank.
The only three witnesses admitted by the court were all drawn from the list relating to a single defendant, including an Italian volunteer, the defendant's wife and a linguistic consultant, denying any possibility of defence to the other two defendants.
Defence lawyers highlighted that the only testimony about the situation in the occupied West Bank is being provided by Italy's state police anti-terrorism unit, Digos.
Israel-Palestine war: Egyptian writer banned from speaking in Italy for calling Netanyahu 'serial killer' Read More »
According to Albertini, this will obscure crucial context about the nature of Israeli occupation in the occupied West Bank, where settlers often conduct attacks against Palestinians under military protection.
Israeli settlements are illegal under international law, however, Israeli civilians living in unlawful settlements in the occupied territory do not lose their civilian protections under the laws of war.
When settlers actively take part in hostilities, however, they lose their immunity from attack and become legitimate military targets.
"The court thinks it can judge Palestinians for acts committed in the West Bank, through testimonies provided by the Italian police," he said.
"We are talking about a small town in Abruzzo, 100km from Rome in the middle of the mountains. According to the judges, the local police are the only ones able to describe what is happening in the West Bank".
Albertini said the court's decisions were unprecedented in his legal experience.
"I haven't seen a court reject the evidence presented by the defence before, nor have I seen a court admit evidence produced in another country," he said.
According to Albertini, it is unlikely the men will face extradition if charged.
In March, an Italian appeals court rejected an Israel extradition request for one of the defendants, Yaeesh, arguing that he would face "acts constituting a violation of human rights" if the request were granted.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Gulf Today
an hour ago
- Gulf Today
UAE to resume Gaza aid airdrops immediately, says Sheikh Abdullah
Gulf Today, Staff Reporter The United Arab Emirates will resume aid drops over Gaza at once, its foreign minister said on Saturday, citing the "critical" humanitarian situation in the blockaded territory, where aid groups have warned of mass starvation. Sheikh Abdullah Bin Zayed Al Nahyan, Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Foreign Affairs, 'The humanitarian situation in Gaza has reached a critical and unprecedented level. In a post today on his account on the social media platform "X," Sheikh Abdullah said: "We will continue delivering relief support to those most in need - by land, air, and sea," reaffirming the immediate resumption of airdrop operations for humanitarian aid. Sheikh Abdullah stressed that the UAE's commitment to alleviating suffering and supporting the Palestinian people is resolute and unwavering. The United Arab Emirates remains at the forefront of efforts to deliver life-saving assistance to the Palestinian people. We will ensure essential aid reaches those most in need, whether through land, air or sea. These remarks come as the UAE continues, through various humanitarian initiatives, to send urgent relief and medical aid to the Gaza Strip in an effort to alleviate the humanitarian crisis faced by its residents. The UAE is among the leading nations that responded quickly at the outset of the crisis by establishing both air and sea bridges to aid those affected. This includes the launch of the "Birds of Goodness" operation, during which dozens of airdrops of food and relief supplies have been conducted over the Strip.


Middle East Eye
an hour ago
- Middle East Eye
Unrwa chief says Israel spread false aid theft claims to control relief
The head of the UN agency for Palestinian refugees (Unrwa) has accused Israel of fabricating claims that Hamas was stealing large amounts of aid, saying the allegations were designed to push out humanitarian groups and tighten Israeli control over food distribution in Gaza. 'No proof of aid diversion in Gaza,' Unrwa Commissioner-General Philippe Lazzarini wrote on social media. He said the accusations were part of a deliberate effort to damage the reputation of international relief agencies. 'Claims were only aimed at tarnishing the reputation of the humanitarian community & attempting to replace it with a diabolic and politically motivated distribution scheme,' he added. 'It's time for principled and at scale humanitarian response including through Unrwa.'


Middle East Eye
an hour ago
- Middle East Eye
US envoy blames UN, media and Hamas for Gaza chaos and failed truce
US Ambassador to Israel Mike Huckabee has accused the United Nations, The New York Times, and Hamas of spreading 'lies and propaganda' to undermine aid operations and destabilise Gaza. Huckabee, a staunch supporter of Israel and an evangelical preacher, made the remarks in response to footage showing desperate Palestinians climbing onto an aid truck. 'Is the UN, NY Times, and Hamas all happy now?' he asked in a social media post. 'I'm sure Hamas is. Their lies and propaganda destroyed the ceasefire deal, tried to discredit safe and functioning GHF effort, emboldened Hamas and will result in this complete balagan [chaos]! Most sad for hostage families—grief prolonged.' His comments come as international experts continue to blame Israel's near-total blockade of food and supplies for the collapse of civil order and widespread hunger in Gaza.