The Inefficiencies of the Grammar-Translation Method in Teaching English as a Foreign Language..By:Altaf Ahmad
The Inefficiencies of the Grammar-Translation Method in Teaching English as a Foreign Language
Altaf Ahmad
The Grammar-Translation Method (GTM) has been a predominant approach in language education for many years, particularly in contexts where resources are limited and standardized testing is emphasized. Despite its historical significance, GTM proves inadequate in developing the practical language skills necessary for effective communication in English. This article examines the inefficiencies of GTM in teaching English as a foreign language, drawing on various studies and expert perspectives.
Emphasis on Grammar and Translation
GTM prioritizes the meticulous study of grammatical rules and the translation of texts between English and the students' native language. While this method facilitates the understanding of grammatical structures and enhances reading comprehension, it neglects crucial aspects of language acquisition such as speaking and listening skills. According to Milawati (2019), GTM's rigid structure often leads to rote memorization rather than genuine language understanding, resulting in students who can recite grammar rules but struggle to hold a basic conversation in English (Milawati, 2019).
Deficiency in Communicative Competence
A significant drawback of GTM is its failure to develop communicative competence.
Language is inherently a social tool, and effective communication involves more than just grammatical accuracy. Research by Ma et al. (2024) indicates that students trained with GTM often lack the ability to use English in real-life situations, as the method does not provide opportunities for meaningful interaction and practical language use (Ma, Xiao, & Liu, 2024). Without exposure to authentic conversational contexts, students may become proficient in. written translation but remain incapable of expressing themselves verbally.
Decreased Student Engagement and Motivation
The repetitive nature of GTM can also lead to decreased student engagement and motivation. Fang (2010) highlights that the method's focus on translation and grammar drills often results in monotonous and uninspiring lessons, which can demotivate students and reduce their interest in learning English (Fang, 2010). In contrast, more dynamic methods such as Communicative Language Teaching (CLT) and Task-Based Language Teaching (TBLT) encourage active participation and contextual learning, fostering a more engaging and enjoyable language learning experience.
Incompatibility with Modern Language Learning Theories
Modern language acquisition theories, such as Krashen's Input Hypothesis and Vygotsky's Sociocultural Theory, emphasize the importance of comprehensible input and social interaction in language learning. GTM, however, does not align with these theories as it prioritizes written language and grammatical accuracy over interactive communication. Krashen (1982) posits that language acquisition is most effective when learners are exposed to comprehensible input in meaningful contexts, something that GTM inherently lacks. (Krashen, 1982).
Resource and Training Limitations.
Despite its inefficiencies, GTM is often employed in economically disadvantaged areas due to its simplicity and minimal resource requirements. Hu (2007) notes that rural schools with limited access to teaching materials and trained educators may rely on GTM because it is easier to implement with the available resources (Hu, 2007). However, this reliance on GTM perpetuates the cycle of inadequate language education, leaving students ill-prepared for real-world communication and global opportunities.
Conclusion
In conclusion, while the Grammar-Translation Method has historically played a role in language education, it is insufficient for teaching English as a foreign language. Its emphasis on grammar and translation, lack of communicative competence, decreased student engagement, and incompatibility with modern language learning theories render it ineffective
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Arab Times
11-05-2025
- Arab Times
Intermittent fasting made easier: Low-carb diet shows promising results
NEW YORK, May 11: Intermittent fasting has proven to be an effective tool for weight loss and offers significant benefits for metabolic health, even independent of weight loss. However, some individuals find the more extreme forms of intermittent fasting, such as the 5:2 diet, challenging due to the severe calorie restriction required on fasting days. New research suggests that you don't need to drastically cut calories to experience the metabolic benefits of intermittent fasting. In fact, restricting carbohydrate intake twice a week may be enough to see improvements in metabolic health. Intermittent fasting enhances health by impacting metabolism in key ways. After eating, the body enters the postprandial state, where it uses carbohydrates for immediate energy while storing some for later use. However, during periods of fasting, the body shifts to burning fat for energy, enhancing metabolic flexibility. This balance between carbohydrate and fat usage leads to better cardiometabolic health, reducing the risk of conditions like cardiovascular disease, insulin resistance, and type 2 diabetes. Previous studies by my team have shown how fasting influences fat burning. For example, following a day of fasting or severe calorie restriction (around 25% of daily calorie requirements), participants were able to more effectively burn fat after consuming a high-fat meal, such as a full English breakfast. This shift from using carbs to burning fat was observed both during the fast and the following day. In other research, we compared intermittent fasting with a calorie-restricted diet where participants lost 5% of their body weight. Despite the same weight loss results, the intermittent fasting group exhibited better improvements in metabolic health. This was a consistent finding in several studies on intermittent fasting and its positive effects on metabolism. However, why exactly is intermittent fasting beneficial for metabolic health? This is a question I explored in my latest study. On typical fasting days, especially for those following the 5:2 method, calorie intake is very low, resulting in a drastic reduction in carbohydrate consumption. Since the postprandial state is governed by carbohydrate availability, it raised the question: Is it the calorie restriction, or is it the carbohydrate restriction that drives the metabolic changes seen with intermittent fasting? To answer this, we recruited 12 overweight and obese participants. They were given a very low-carb diet on one day and a severely calorie-restricted diet (about 75% fewer calories than usual) on another day. After each fasting day, they were given a high-fat, high-sugar meal, like an English breakfast, to observe how their bodies burned fat. Our results showed that both the low-carb day and the calorie-restricted fasting day resulted in similar improvements in fat burning and fat handling. This suggests that restricting carbs could trigger the same favorable metabolic effects as fasting. While our findings are promising, further studies with a larger sample size are needed to confirm these results. If this approach proves effective, it could help address some of the practical challenges people face with intermittent fasting and low-carb diets. For example, severe calorie restriction during fasting days can lead to nutritional deficiencies and trigger disordered eating behaviors. Similarly, long-term carb restriction can be hard to stick to and may create an unhealthy fear of carbohydrates. Moreover, both intermittent fasting and continuous carb restriction are likely to result in weight loss, which may not be desirable for those looking to improve health without losing weight or for those aiming to maintain their weight. We are now exploring the potential of a modified intermittent fasting approach: intermittent carb restriction. Instead of severely restricting calories, participants would limit carb intake two days a week. If this approach proves effective, it would allow people to benefit from fasting's metabolic advantages without the need to cut calories on fasting days.
Arab Times
16-04-2025
- Arab Times
Tech-proof no more: AI targets doctors and teachers, says Gates
NEW YORK, April 16: Bill Gates believes that artificial intelligence could soon help eliminate the long-standing shortages of doctors and teachers across the globe. 'AI will come in and provide medical IQ, and there won't be a shortage,' Gates said during an episode of the People by WTF podcast, published Friday. Gates, who has long focused on public health through his philanthropic work, noted that countries such as India and those across Africa continue to face significant shortages of medical professionals. The United States is also grappling with this issue. A 2023 report by the Association of American Medical Colleges projected that the U.S. could face a shortfall of up to 86,000 physicians — including both specialists and primary care doctors — by 2036. Michael Dill, director of workforce studies at the organization, told Business Insider last year that the country would need hundreds of thousands of doctors to provide equitable care for all, including underserved communities, the uninsured, and rural populations. The shortage is especially concerning in geriatric care, where the number of specialists continues to decline even as the population ages. Medical professionals warned Business Insider in March that this growing demand from older patients could trigger a crisis in the quality of care. To help alleviate burnout in the industry, healthcare-focused AI startups have raised billions of dollars by positioning themselves as a potential solution. Startups such as Suki, Zephyr AI, and Tennr aim to reduce workloads by automating repetitive tasks like billing and note-taking, while also improving diagnostic accuracy and identifying candidates for new treatments, according to a Business Insider report from December. Consulting firm McKinsey estimates that generative AI could increase productivity in healthcare and pharmaceuticals by as much as $370 billion. Gates noted that the same transformation is underway in education. According to federal data released in 2023, 86% of K–12 U.S. public schools reported difficulty in hiring teachers for the 2023–24 academic year, with about 45% of schools saying they were understaffed. In the U.K., one London high school is piloting the use of AI to supplement teaching. David Game College implemented a program in which 20 students used tools like ChatGPT to help prepare for exams in core subjects including English, math, biology, and computer science, Business Insider reported. Despite growing concerns about students using AI to cheat, many educators remain optimistic. Teachers told BI they believe generative AI has the potential to save time and improve learning outcomes, especially as teacher shortages persist. But Gates wasn't just referring to doctors and teachers. He also believes AI will soon impact workers in physically demanding jobs — including factory workers, construction crews, and hotel staff. 'The hands have to be awfully good to do those things. We'll achieve that,' he said. Tech giants like Nvidia are investing heavily in humanoid robots capable of performing manual tasks, from picking items in warehouses to scrubbing floors. These robots aim to reduce labor costs and boost overall efficiency. Gates suggested that society may be headed toward a future where work is drastically reduced or redefined altogether. 'You can retire early, you can work shorter workweeks,' he said. 'It's going to require almost a philosophical rethink about, 'Okay, how should time be spent?'' He admitted that this shift is difficult to fully grasp, even for him. 'It's hard for those of us — in my case, spending almost 70 years in a world of shortage — even to adjust my mind,' Gates said. In 1930, economist John Maynard Keynes famously predicted that advancements in technology could reduce the workweek to just 15 hours. Yet nearly a century later, most people still work around 40 hours a week. 'I don't have to work,' Gates added. 'I choose to work. Because? Because it's fun.'
Arab Times
01-04-2025
- Arab Times
India's CBSE unveils new syllabus for Classes 10 and 12 for 2025-2026: Key changes explained
NEW DELHI, India, April 1: The Central Board of Secondary Education (CBSE) of India has unveiled its updated syllabus for Classes 10 and 12 for the 2025-2026 academic session. This overhaul includes significant changes in exam schedules, grading systems, passing criteria, and the introduction of new skill-based subjects aimed at enhancing the educational experience for students. Key changes in the new CBSE syllabus: Two board exams for Class 10 students For the first time, Class 10 students will have the opportunity to appear for two board exams annually—one in February and another in April. This initiative, which is currently in draft form, will offer students a second chance to improve their scores within the same academic year. However, the final approval of this policy is still pending. In contrast, the Class 12 board exams will remain an annual event, with the 2026 exams scheduled to start on February 17. The revised grading system for Classes 10 and 12 CBSE has transitioned to a new 9-point grading system for both Class 10 and Class 12. The grading system replaces the previous five-point scale and aims to provide a more detailed and accurate assessment of students' performance. The new system will convert marks into grades more effectively, offering a clearer picture of students' capabilities and understanding. Passing criteria for Class 10 To pass the Class 10 board exams, students must secure at least 33% in each subject. A notable change is that if a student fails in a core subject such as Science, Mathematics, Social Science, or a language paper but passes a skill-based or optional language subject, the failed subject can be substituted with the passed skill-based subject for result calculation. For example, if a student does not achieve the required marks in Mathematics but passes a skill-based subject, the grade from the skill-based subject will replace that of Mathematics. Introduction of skill-based subjects in Class 10 CBSE is placing greater emphasis on practical, skill-based education by introducing subjects like Computer Applications, Information Technology, and Artificial Intelligence for Class 10 students. Additionally, students must choose either English or Hindi as one of their languages during Classes 9 and 10. New skill electives for Class 12 In an effort to align the curriculum with industry demands, CBSE has introduced four new skill electives for Class 12 students: 1. Land transportation associate 2. Electronics and hardware 3. Physical activity trainer 4. Design thinking and innovation These subjects are designed to equip students with practical skills that are highly relevant to various industries. Use of calculators in Class 12 Accountancy exams In response to feedback, CBSE will now allow the use of basic, non-programmable calculators during Class 12 Accountancy exams starting from the 2025-2026 academic session. This change aims to assist students with complex financial calculations. Shift towards real-world learning and competency-based assessments CBSE is also promoting new teaching methods that focus on real-world skills, including: Project-based learning: Students will engage with real-life problems, moving beyond textbook learning. Inquiry-driven education: Instead of rote memorization, students will be encouraged to explore and ask questions. Tech-enabled learning: AI tools, digital resources, and online platforms will play a bigger role in classroom teaching. Collaborative lesson planning: Teachers will adapt their teaching methods dynamically based on student needs. In addition to these changes in teaching, CBSE has revamped its assessment system to focus on: Critical thinking Analytical skills Conceptual clarity Practical application of knowledge This shift aims to prepare students better for higher education and future careers. Accessing the new syllabus The detailed syllabi for Classes 9 to 12 are now available on the CBSE academic website. Students, parents, and educators are encouraged to review the updated curriculum and assessment frameworks to stay informed about the upcoming changes. These updates reflect CBSE's ongoing commitment to providing a comprehensive, skill-oriented education system that prepares students for academic success and professional growth.
