SC adjourns ‘urgent' TCP case as Goa says counsel unavailable
Panaji:
on Friday adjourned to July 21, state govt's special leave petition challenging the high court's verdict in the Section 17(2) matter after state informed SC that its counsel was not available.
Tired of too many ads? go ad free now
State govt filed the SLP challenging the HC's reading down of the Town and Country Planning Act's Section 17(2). When the appeal was called out on Friday before the SC's vacation bench, state informed the court that their counsel was not available, and the SC adjourned the case to July 21.
State govt had specifically sought an urgent hearing before SC. The letter from the office of senior counsel Mukul Rohatgi on May 28 to the registrar seeking an urgent hearing said that the state would suffer irreparable harm and irreversible consequences if Section 17(2) is not implemented in accordance with the legislative framework, especially as the impugned decision directly affects the exercise of statutory powers and ongoing planning processes.
'Moreover, it is pertinent to mention that several cases pertaining to Section 17(2) are currently pending before the HC, and the impugned judgment will impact the outcome of those cases,' the letter said.
State, in its petition before SC, said that the HC transgressed the power of the legislature by reading down Section 17(2) of the TCP Act, which restricts govt mechanisms to undo past errors in the regional plan efficiently.
The petition filed in SC two months after the high court's order states that the constitutional validity of a provision cannot be decided on the basis of factual considerations.
It said that the high court failed to appreciate that the challenge to the constitutional validity of the act and rules needed to be decided separately from the factual challenges contained in the PILs. The high court struck down the rules and guidelines of Section 17(2) on March 13 in 'public interest', but stayed the order for six weeks. The bench rejected the plea to declare Section 17(2) as unconstitutional, but made it clear that no applications for approvals under the section shall be considered.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
15 minutes ago
- Time of India
Banke Bihari temple priests threaten to 'relocate Thakurji' over corridor redevelopment plan
AGRA: Priests of the centuries-old Banke Bihari temple in Mathura, who are opposed to the proposed 'redevelopment plan for the Banke Bihari corridor in Vrindavan', alleged on Monday, that if govt does not heed their concerns, they will relocate the Banke Bihari deity to another site. The latest development came after a series of protests by the Goswami community members and locals against the proposed corridor and the creation of the Banke Bihari temple trust by the state govt. Ghanshyam Goswami, 60, a member of the management committee, said, "The problem is that the govt wants to turn this place of faith into a picnic spot. The Banke Bihari Trust was formed without consulting us. We're open to suggestions for improving the management of the temple but if this situation continues, we'll not hesitate to move Thakurji out of the temple. This temple was founded by our forefathers, and the customs and traditions here date back to the 19th century. " The Supreme Court, in its May 15 verdict, permitted the UP govt to continue with the 'Rs 500 cr redevelopment plan for the Shri Banke Bihari temple corridor in Vrindavan'. The project, approved by the bench of Justice Bela M Trivedi and Justice SC Sharma, enables the state to utilise temple funds to acquire about 5 acres of land near the shrine. Calls for redevelopment intensified after a stampede-like incident took place during the Janmashtami celebrations in 2022, which resulted in two fatalities. In Sept 2023, Allahabad high court directed the state govt to implement a corridor plan to manage crowds and ensure safety. Although the state said it engaged with all stakeholders, Shebaits and local residents have claimed they were excluded from discussions. On Monday, Agra's divisional commissioner Shailendra Kumar Singh, Mathura DM Chandra Prakesh Singh, Agra range DIG Shailesh Kumar Pandey and additional officials held a meeting with the stakeholders to seek a resolution. Shailendra Kumar Singh said, "The proposed corridor has been cleared by the SC. The locals have raised some issues, and we have reached out to them. In the issues related to the temple, we ensured that no change will be there to the customs and traditions of the temple. Shopkeepers had doubts related to compensation, and we cleared them. The streets in and around the temple are narrow and unsuitable for the influx of people who visit the temple daily, so this corridor will be beneficial for all the stakeholders. "
Hindustan Times
2 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
Caste discrimination allegation: BSP demands FIR against Ludhiana MC official
The Bahujan Samaj Party (BSP) on Monday launched a protest outside the Ludhiana municipal corporation's (MC's) Zone-A office, calling for immediate registration of an FIR against a senior MC official under the SC/ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act. The protest, organised under the party's ongoing 'Punjab Sambhalo' campaign, highlighted what BSP leaders described as institutionalised caste-based discrimination and exploitation within the municipal administration. The party also called for a complete roll back of the contract system for sanitation and Class IV workers, terming it a form of systemic injustice against Dalits. BSP leaders alleged that on May 26, official, while sitting on a constitutional post, physically assaulted Class IV workers including sanitation staff, sewer men, and beldars. According to the party, he kicked them, hurled casteist slurs, used filthy language, and publicly humiliated the workers. The BSP demanded his immediate suspension and legal action under the SC/ST Act, stating that such behaviour not only violates constitutional values but also reaffirms the oppressive treatment meted out to Dalit workers in government institutions. The protest also targeted the Aam Aadmi Party-led Punjab government and the BJP-led central government, accusing both of turning a blind eye to the plight of sanitation workers across the state. 'Despite repeated appeals, the government has failed to address our basic demands. There is growing anger among the Valmiki Samaj and the entire community of sanitation workers,' the memorandum submitted by the party read. Among the key demands raised during the protest were registration of an FIR against MC official and his immediate suspension; a complete rollback of the outsourcing policy for sanitation workers, sewer men, gardeners, and beldars; issuance of appointment letters to overage employees; deployment of one supervisor (lambardar) in each of the 95 municipal wards; and the clearance of retirement benefits within 24 hours of an employee's retirement. The BSP further demanded an inquiry against councillors from AAP, BJP, and Congress, accusing them of supporting private garbage collection tenders that, according to the protestors, have robbed poor workers of their livelihood. The party alleged that private contracts are benefiting select contractors while sidelining Dalit workers who earlier collected garbage from door to door. It sought a halt to this 'anti-poor and anti-Dalit' privatisation drive and urged the civic body to regularise these workers through a house resolution. Other demands included installation of compactors in all 95 wards, action against the so-called 'garbage mafia' allegedly collecting ₹1,000 to ₹2,000 per month from households through staff deployed on compactors, and the permanent appointment of a deputy chief financial advisor (DCFA) in the Ludhiana MC. The BSP has warned that if its demands are not met, the agitation will intensify across the state.
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
New Andhra Pradesh SC commission chairman vows to safeguard rights of SCs
Vijayawada: Andhra Pradesh SC commission chairman KS Jawahar has assured that he will strive to protect the rights of Scheduled Castes in the state. The former minister and senior TDP leader assumed charge as the state SC commission chairman on Monday. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now Speaking to the media, Jawahar said he had instructed state officials to ensure that no person from the Scheduled Castes is targeted, tortured, or victimized for any reason. He emphasized the need for officials to act with honesty to render justice to SCs. The Commission, Jawahar said, would not spare anyone who deliberately causes injustice to SCs. Jawahar expressed gratitude to chief minister Chandrababu Naidu, IT minister Nara Lokesh, and deputy chief minister Pawan Kalyan for giving him the opportunity to serve as Chairman. He stated that he will work for the welfare and development of SCs in the state. He noted that the coalition govt is working in an unprecedented manner and that all SCs in the state are particularly happy with Naidu-led govt. He pointed out that the govt has initiated several welfare schemes for the welfare of the SCs. He alleged that SC/ST atrocity cases increased in the state during the previous YSRCP regime. "The Commission will function beyond politics. We will restore faith in the system which collapsed during the previous regime. The commission will ensure that all the SCs will get justice as per the law," said Jawahar. Former APSRTC chairman and TDP politburo member Varla Ramaiah said that the appointment of KS Jawahar as SC commission chairman is a matter of joy for all the SCs. After assuming office, MLAs Nakka Anand Babu, MMS Raju, Burla Ramanjaneyulu, and MLC Alapati Rajendraprasad congratulated Jawahar. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now The program was attended by state SC commission deputy director Bathula Jeevaputra Kumar and other senior officials. Minister Vasamsetti Subhash, MLAs Bandaru Satyanandaravu, Tangirala Soumya, Vegulla Jogeswara Rao, Pitani Satyanarayana, SC Mala welfare cooperative finance corporation chairman Pedapudi Vijayakumar, SAAP chairman Animini Ravi Naidu, and a large number of supporters participated at the felicitation programme organized at Tummalapalli Kala Kshetram later in the day.
