‘Abysmal waste': Former RBI Governor D Subbarao explains why UPSC urgently needs a reform
'Abysmal waste of productive years'
Age limit and attempt reduction suggested
Live Events
Structured mid-career entry path proposed
Keep youth entry but modernise process
(You can now subscribe to our
(You can now subscribe to our Economic Times WhatsApp channel
Duvvuri Subbarao, former Governor of the Reserve Bank of India, has recommended major changes to the recruitment process for the Indian civil services. In a recent opinion piece in The Times of India, he suggested reducing the upper age limit and number of attempts for the UPSC Civil Services Examination. He also proposed a separate annual entry path into the Indian Administrative Service (IAS) for experienced professionals in their early 40s.Commenting on the recently declared 2024 civil service results, Subbarao congratulated the selected candidates but raised concerns about the large number of aspirants who fail after years of preparation.'The civil service results for 2024 are out. Congratulations to the thousand-odd candidates who have got through what is arguably one of the most competitive exams in the world,' he wrote.He highlighted the toll on those who are unsuccessful. 'For every successful candidate, there are at least ten others who too have invested years in preparation but have failed to make the grade. They are back at square one. An abysmal waste of productive years?'Subbarao criticised the current policy that allows up to six attempts between the ages of 21 and 32. He said many aspirants continue preparing despite repeated failures due to the psychological pressure of sunk costs."After all, they are susceptible to the 'sunk cost fallacy' — 'I've invested so much time, money and effort. All that will go waste if I give up now. Maybe I will succeed this time round,'' he wrote.He said this leads many to spend their most productive years in repeated attempts, and called on the government to limit attempts to three and reduce the upper age to 27. Citing his own experience from the 1970s, he said only two attempts were allowed between ages 21 and 24. He added, 'this levelling has gone too far.'He also argued that allowing six attempts gives an advantage to those who master exam techniques rather than those with inherent merit. 'There is another argument in favour of curtailing the number of allowed attempts. Any examination that allows as many as six chances is likely to privilege mastery of the exam technique over inherent merit,' he wrote, adding that the process is prone to "type I and type II errors."Subbarao's second major suggestion is an alternative annual entry route into the IAS for professionals aged 40–42. This would be a permanent and competitive channel, separate from the current ad-hoc lateral entry system.'They can pursue other careers and take another shot at the exam mid-career,' he wrote.He said mid-career professionals can bring experience and a fresh perspective to governance. 'Tier 2 recruits will make up for these lacunae and make the civil service collectively more relevant and useful, and maybe even more caring.'Subbarao said the current system for young aspirants should remain, but needs reform. 'There is a lot to be said for continuing to recruit young people into the IAS. They bring in youthful spirit, raw enthusiasm and unspoilt enterprise into administration.'In conclusion, he acknowledged improvements over the years but stressed the need for further reform. 'The civil service exam has vastly improved from the time I took it over 50 years ago. But there is still a need to push the envelope.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Economic Times
44 minutes ago
- Economic Times
Stampede aftermath: Deaths have not cast black mark on Govt, says Karnataka CM Siddaramaiah
Live Events NOT AWARE OF DEATHS TILL 5.45 pm (You can now subscribe to our (You can now subscribe to our Economic Times WhatsApp channel Chief Minister Siddaramaiah on Sunday rejected calls for political accountability for the death of 11 persons in a stampede on Wednesday outside of Chinnaswamy stadium insisting that the government had no role in that event and wondering if anyone resigned over deaths during the recent Kumbh Mela in Uttar CM accused the BJP of playing politics over the issue and denied it had left a black mark on the Congress regime as it completed two years in office, while speaking to media persons in Mysuru. The CM also denied suggestions that the Congress high command had sought a report on the government was not embarrassed by the incident as the government committed no mistake, he said, while adding that he was pained over the tragedy that occurred during the RCB IPL victory celebrations, and blamed negligence by the police for the congestion around the rejected the allegations that Police Commissioner B Dayananda had been made a scapegoat, while adding that the government had taken a series of steps including suspension of five police officers, transfer of intelligence chief, and firing of his political secretary K said the subject for permission to hold the felicitation event on the steps of Vidhana Soudha did not come to him for clearance, but he okayed it when the officials informed him about it. The event was not organized by the government, but he attended along with the Governor on an invitation by the organisers. 'I am not responsible for the event organized at the stadium,' the CM said, distancing himself from the celebrations at the first death was recorded at a hospital at 3.50 pm, but he came to know about it only at 5.45 pm, the CM said, expressing his displeasure over the way the police handled the response to a query, he said the government would examine if the cricket stadium could be shifted to a site outside of Bengaluru. The government would look for a suitable location outside.
Economic Times
44 minutes ago
- Economic Times
I-STAR: India's eyes in the sky? IAF set to get Rs 10,000 crore indigenous spy planes
IAF to get Rs 10,000 crore indigenous I-STAR spy planes to help in precision strikes against enemy ground targets India's Defence Ministry is set to review a Rs 10,000 crore project. This project aims to acquire three advanced spy planes. These planes will enhance the Indian Air Force's surveillance capabilities. They will provide detailed air-to-ground intelligence. This will enable precision strikes on enemy targets. The ISTAR system will be indigenously developed by DRDO. Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads High-tech eyes in the sky with indigenous systems Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Precision strikes from afar, round-the-clock The Indian Air Force is set to receive a major capability boost with the government preparing to clear a Rs 10,000 crore project to acquire cutting-edge I-STAR (Intelligence, Surveillance, Target Acquisition and Reconnaissance) high-altitude spy planes will allow the IAF to conduct pinpoint strikes on critical enemy targets such as radar sites, mobile air defence units, and command posts — even from stand-off told ANI that the Defence Ministry is expected to take up the proposal later this month at a high-level meeting, amid the Indian military's ongoing Operation Sindoor against I-STAR project involves procuring three advanced aircraft — likely from international aviation giants like Boeing or Bombardier — which will then be fitted with fully indigenous sensor and electronic systems. These onboard surveillance and targeting systems have already been developed and tested by DRDO's Centre for Airborne Systems (CABS).The Indian-built systems will provide multi-spectral surveillance, enabling forces to detect, locate and track enemy assets with precision — day or night, even in complex terrain. Officials said the integration work would be swift since the tech has already been operational, the aircraft will offer a dynamic, real-time picture of the battlefield, making India one of the few countries in the world with such strategic air-to-ground surveillance and strike coordination capabilities. Only a handful of nations — including the United States, United Kingdom, and Israel — currently operate such I-STAR system combines both airborne and ground-based components, and is designed to operate from stand-off ranges at high altitudes. Its job is to assist the IAF in identifying and engaging high-value ground targets without crossing into hostile airspace — an increasingly critical requirement in modern the ability to carry out intelligence gathering, real-time surveillance, targeting, and reconnaissance (ISR), the aircraft will allow India to limit the scale of conflict while neutralizing threats with surgical said this system will not only strengthen India's deterrence capability, but also help in swift retaliation in conflict scenarios, enhancing national security preparedness across borders.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Stampede aftermath: Deaths have not cast black mark on Govt, says Karnataka CM Siddaramaiah
Live Events NOT AWARE OF DEATHS TILL 5.45 pm (You can now subscribe to our (You can now subscribe to our Economic Times WhatsApp channel Chief Minister Siddaramaiah on Sunday rejected calls for political accountability for the death of 11 persons in a stampede on Wednesday outside of Chinnaswamy stadium insisting that the government had no role in that event and wondering if anyone resigned over deaths during the recent Kumbh Mela in Uttar CM accused the BJP of playing politics over the issue and denied it had left a black mark on the Congress regime as it completed two years in office, while speaking to media persons in Mysuru. The CM also denied suggestions that the Congress high command had sought a report on the government was not embarrassed by the incident as the government committed no mistake, he said, while adding that he was pained over the tragedy that occurred during the RCB IPL victory celebrations, and blamed negligence by the police for the congestion around the rejected the allegations that Police Commissioner B Dayananda had been made a scapegoat, while adding that the government had taken a series of steps including suspension of five police officers, transfer of intelligence chief, and firing of his political secretary K said the subject for permission to hold the felicitation event on the steps of Vidhana Soudha did not come to him for clearance, but he okayed it when the officials informed him about it. The event was not organized by the government, but he attended along with the Governor on an invitation by the organisers. 'I am not responsible for the event organized at the stadium,' the CM said, distancing himself from the celebrations at the first death was recorded at a hospital at 3.50 pm, but he came to know about it only at 5.45 pm, the CM said, expressing his displeasure over the way the police handled the response to a query, he said the government would examine if the cricket stadium could be shifted to a site outside of Bengaluru. The government would look for a suitable location outside.
