What to know about Justice Maria Carroccia, the judge who acquitted the five Team Canada players
She used to work as a waitress
Her parents came to Canada from Italy
She worked as a defence lawyer before she was a judge
She has a degree in English language and literature
She once described herself as a lawyer who 'works in the trenches'
She thinks of herself as a plain speaker
Her ruling was criticized but also seen by many as fair and balanced
While there was outrage from some quarters at the acquittal, there were also those who praised the verdict and the
judge's careful work
. Karen Bellehumeur, lawyer for E.M., said as part of her statement after the verdict: 'It's important to understand that this case, the criminal justice system worked the way it's designed to work, to aggressively protect the rights of the accused. It's based on a concept that 10 guilty persons should walk free before one innocent person is wrongly convicted.'
Read the full text of the judge's verdict in the Hockey Canada sex assault trial
In
the questionnaire
Carroccia completed to apply for a federal judicial appointment, she listed under 'non-legal work history' two occupations. From 1980 to 1987, she worked as a part-time pharmacy assistant at Patterson Big V Drug Store, part of a chain that was later
taken over by Shoppers Drug Mart
. And in roughly the same period (1980 to 1986) she was a part-time waitress at Caboto Club of Windsor. Described
on its website
as 'Southwestern Ontario's largest and oldest Italian club,' the Giovanni Caboto Club turns 100 this year.
Carroccia is the oldest child of immigrants from Italy. Her parents did not finish grade school, and when they came to Canada her father became a construction worker, and her mother a homemaker. Their first language was not English and, growing up, Carroccia was often their intermediary when dealing with government agencies and English-speaking people.
'While they encouraged me to further my education, financially, they were not always able to assist, so I worked part time jobs as a student to pay for my education,' she said in her judicial application. 'They taught me the value of hard work. We have a close-knit and loving large family.
She also noted that, as the mother of two children herself, 'I have developed an ability to balance my professional life with my personal life.'
Carroccia's legal work history includes 25 years self-employed as a barrister and solicitor practicing in Windsor, with her practice restricted to criminal defence. Prior to that, she worked for five years for Gordner, Klein, Barristers and Solicitors, practicing criminal law; and two years before that at Gignac, Sutts Barristers and Solicitors, in the same capacity.
Carroccia was
called to the Bar of Ontario
in 1989 after graduating from the University of Windsor's faculty of law two years earlier. In addition to her law degree, she also holds an English language and literature degree from Windsor, earned in 1984.
She was
appointed in June of 2020 as a judge to the Superior Court of Justice of Ontario by then Minister of Justice and Attorney General of Canada David Lametti. This month, Lametti was named Principal Secretary to Prime Minister Mark Carney, after helping
with Carney's transition into office and as an informal advisor.
In her judicial questionnaire,
Carroccia noted that most of her time as a lawyer
was spent as a sole practitioner. 'I do not work in a large firm,' she said. 'I view myself as a trial lawyer who 'works in the trenches.' My contribution to the law is to represent my clients to the best of my ability, whether they are charged with minor offences or the most serious offences.'
'The audience for the decisions of the Superior Court of Justice is the average Canadian citizen,' she once said. 'It is my view that a judge's decision ought to make sense to an ordinary person, not just to lawyers, scholars and other judges. An individual should be able to understand the decision of a judge and the law upon which it is based even if he or she is not well-versed in the law.'
And Meaghan Cunningham, assistant Crown attorney, noted: '
A fair trial is one where decisions are made based on the evidence and the law, not on stereotypes and assumptions, and where the trial process respects the security, equality, and privacy rights of the victim, as well as the accused persons.'
Our website is the place for the latest breaking news, exclusive scoops, longreads and provocative commentary. Please bookmark
nationalpost.com
and sign up for our daily newsletter, Posted,
here
.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Winnipeg Free Press
3 hours ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
A settler accused of killing a Palestinian activist is to be freed. Israel still holds the body
TEL AVIV, Israel (AP) — An Israeli settler accused of killing a prominent Palestinian activist during a confrontation captured on video in the occupied West Bank will be released from house arrest, an Israeli court ruled Friday. The video shot by a Palestinian witness shows Yinon Levi brandishing a pistol and tussling with a group of unarmed Palestinians. He can be seen firing two shots, but the video does not show where the bullets hit. Witnesses said one of the shots killed Awdah Hathaleen, an English teacher and father of three, who was uninvolved and was standing nearby. The Israeli military is still holding Hathaleen's body and says it will only be returned if the family agrees to bury him in a nearby city. It said the measure was being taken to 'prevent public disorder.' The confrontation occurred on Monday in the village of Umm al-Khair, in an area of the West Bank featured in 'No Other Land,' an Oscar-winning documentary about settler violence and life under Israeli military rule. In a court decision obtained by The Associated Press, Judge Havi Toker wrote that there was 'no dispute' that Levi shot his gun in the village that day, but she said he may have been acting in self-defense and that the court could not establish that the shots killed Hathaleen. Israel's military and police did not respond to a request for comment on whether anyone else may have fired shots that day. Multiple calls placed to Levi and his lawyer have not been answered. The judge said Levi did not pose such a danger as to justify his continued house arrest but barred him from contact with the villagers for a month. Levi has been sanctioned by the United States and other Western countries over allegations of past violence toward Palestinians. President Donald Trump lifted the U.S. sanctions on Levi and other radical settlers shortly after returning to office. A total of 18 Palestinians from the village were arrested after the incident. Six remain in detention. Eitay Mack, an Israeli lawyer who has lobbied for sanctions against radical settlers, including Levi, said the court ruling did not come as a surprise. 'Automatically, Palestinian victims are considered suspects, while Jewish suspects are considered victims,' he said. Levi helped establish an settler outpost near Umm al-Khair that anti-settlement activists say is a bastion for violent settlers who have displaced hundreds since the start of the Israel-Hamas war. Palestinians and rights groups have long accused Israeli authorities of turning a blind eye to settler violence, which has surged since the outbreak of the Israel-Hamas war, along with attacks by Palestinians. In a 2024 interview, Levi said he was protecting his own land and denied using violence. Some 70 women in Umm al-Khair said they were beginning a hunger strike on Friday to call for Hathaleen's body to be returned and for the right of his family to bury him in the village. Israel's military said in a statement to the AP that it would return the body if the family agrees to bury him in the 'nearest authorized cemetery.' Hathaleen, 31, had written and spoke out against settler violence, and had helped produce the Oscar-winning film. Supporters have erected murals in his honor in Rome, held vigils in New York and have held signs bearing his name at anti-war protests in Tel Aviv.
National Post
10 hours ago
- National Post
Amy Hamm: On Feucht and Hockey Canada ruling, ignore the angry mobs
Article content This case does not make a strong hill for the 'believe all women' mob to die on. But then again, mobs seldom make sense. They tend to be driven by emotion, not logic. Article content A mob is, at least superficially, motivated by the desire to rectify injustices, stop wrongdoing or protect the vulnerable and innocent. But the examples provided to us by history reveal how angry mobs rarely get things right, and often fail to accomplish justice. They also, naturally, form within a specific cultural context. Article content An illustration: the Salem Witch Trials. Between 1692 and 1693 in Massachusetts, more than 200 mostly female victims were accused by the mob of being witches. Twenty were put to death. Public officials performed the bidding of persons blinded by misogynist, religiously motivated fears. Due process was non-existent, and literal braying mobs influenced judges' verdicts. Article content Today's dominant (but admittedly receding) cultural orthodoxy is one of reactionary rage against all things white, western, colonial, conservative, traditional, religious and male. Article content Article content One look at Feucht, and the exonerated Team Canada players, and it becomes clear that at the centre of both of these very public controversies are persons who can be perfectly vilified within our cultural milieu. And they all have been. Article content Whatever our collective anger is over — Trump's tariffs, a recession or violence against women — Feucht et al. comprise the perfect target for the mob's rage. Article content Politicians, journalists and judges all have a duty to examine the claims of a mob before falling for its proclaimed narrative — and, more critically, before bending to the will of any irate, pitchfork-wielding folks. Article content One of Feucht's songs contains these lyrics: 'There is a name; Who reigns without contention; Whose power can't be questioned or contained; With humble fame; He rules the earth and heavens; His glory knows no measure or refrain; And it's bursting past the border lines of space.' Article content Article content Article content
CBC
12 hours ago
- CBC
Close monitoring of Hockey Canada to continue as condition of federal funding
Social Sharing Canada's secretary of state for sport says the government is keeping Hockey Canada under increased monitoring for the foreseeable future as a condition of federal funding. Adam van Koeverden told CBC News that Canada's national governing body for hockey has made progress addressing its culture, but there is more work to be done. "It's not just a matter of a box-checking exercise," he said in an interview. "We're talking about a massive shift in culture that requires transparency and accountability and a lot of time." That monitoring will continue to be done by Sport Canada and van Koeverden's office, he said. The federal government paused Hockey Canada's funding in 2022 over its handling of a high-profile case. A woman known as E.M. reported a group of 2018 World Junior players sexually assaulted her in a London, Ont., hotel room. A judge recently found the five players not guilty. WATCH | Federal government restores Hockey Canada's funding with conditions: Federal government restores funding to Hockey Canada 2 years ago The federal government says it will restore funding to Hockey Canada following controversy linked to its handling of alleged sexual assault claims. But the government warns this will not be a blank cheque and sets out expectations for the organization going forward. Hockey Canada came under intense public scrutiny three years ago for quietly paying E.M. a settlement. Hockey parents were outraged to learn their registration fees were going into a reserve fund without their knowledge and used to pay out millions of dollars in sexual abuse claims over the years. A parliamentary committee investigated, sponsors paused funding and the head of Hockey Canada and its entire board resigned. The government restored Hockey Canada's funding in 2023 but it came with strings attached. The organization has had to submit quarterly reports to the federal government about its progress addressing recommendations in three independent reports including by a former Supreme Court justice. Hockey Canada confirmed to CBC News it has completed all of the recommendations in those reports. Sport Canada said it's reviewing that progress and as of July the hockey organization has implemented all of the conditions that were part of its enhanced monitoring plan. Hockey Canada completed all recommendations Despite hitting that mark, van Koeverden said there is no date in mind for when Ottawa will drop its extra monitoring. He wants to see "sustained culture change that Canadians are demanding," he said. "We've seen good progress from Hockey Canada in terms of leadership change, in terms of governance changes, in terms of their audits," van Koeverden said. He pointed to mandatory training for all staff, coaches and athletes competing with Team Canada that's now in place covering sexual violence and consent. He said training "is just the bare minimum" and that there is a need to change attitudes and behaviour. E.M. and others' courage in coming forward, van Koeverden said, sparked a national conversation about the change needed in not just hockey, but all sports. 'Abuse isn't endemic to men's hockey' In a statement following last week's ruling, van Koeverden described men's hockey culture as "problematic." Asked by CBC News how he'd describe the culture and what concerns he still has, van Koeverden said he doesn't think the issues he's identified are "endemic" to men's hockey. "I'm concerned with chauvinism, with sexism, treating women as if they're objects or something to be attained rather than one's equal," he said. "I don't think that's unique to hockey, unique to sport. "I think it is an unfortunate reality that exists in other places, in the workplace, in education and it needs to be called out, needs to be recognized and it needs to change." He added "abuse isn't endemic to men's hockey" and that if a national conversation about "how we ought to treat each other starts with hockey, I think that's uniquely Canadian." 'You can't just tick boxes' A Fifth Estate investigation in 2022 found junior hockey players were the subjects of police investigations in at least 15 cases of alleged group sexual assault since 1989 — half of which surfaced in the past decade. Former junior hockey players and those who study the sport say these incidents have grown out of a culture that has included the pursuit of women as a team sport that can result in group sex. Anatomy of a Scandal 3 years ago Hockey Canada is on the defensive over allegations that some members of its gold-medal winning World Junior team in 2018 took part in a group sexual assault, and the organization didn't do enough to hold players accountable. The Fifth Estate examines the national shame inside Canada's game, and the disturbing history that suggests this was not an isolated incident. Laura Robinson, the author of Crossing the Line: Violence and Sexual Assault in Canada's National Sport, said she wants to see Hockey Canada under enhanced monitoring by the federal government until after the Winter Olympics in 2026. She pointed to Hockey Canada's recent announcements about 18 men selected for roles. Hockey Canada appointed an all-male roster to coach its Olympic and World Junior teams. The new general manager and members of the management group for Hockey Canada's Program of Excellence are also male. "You can't just tick boxes and say we've got women involved now," she said. Hockey Canada says 'there is still more work' The Program of Excellence relies on volunteers that come from a pool of Canadian Hockey League employees. The organization said its managers and coaches selected to volunteer have "tremendous experience" working with 15-to-19-year-old male high-performance athletes. It said Chelsea Geldenhuys has been promoted to senior manager of hockey operations for the Program of Excellence. Hockey Canada said as part of its effort to increase the number of women coaching in Canada, it helped launch a new program to employ student athletes as coaches while playing university women's hockey. The hockey organization also sent CBC News a list of 17 changes its made since 2022 to address hockey culture and safety, including achieving gender equity on its board of directors, adopting a universal code of conduct to prevent maltreatment in sport and becoming one of the first organizations to be a full signatory to the Office of the Sport Integrity Commissioner. "While important progress has been made since 2022, there is still more work to be done and we will continue to be transparent and accountable to Canadians as we drive systemic change within our national winter sport," Hockey Canada chief of staff Jeremy Knight said in a statement.
