Families brand decision to stop autism and ADHD diagnoses as 'dangerous'
Last month, the health board announced that it would no longer accept referrals through Child and Adolescent Mental Health Services due to long waiting lists.
Young people with a pre-existing mental health condition would still be able to access assessments for autism and ADHD through the health board.
Families looking for support would be directed to online groups and other services.
Donna Ploatner's youngest son was diagnosed with autism when he was five years old – he was on the waiting list for an ADHD assessment.
While he's supported for his autism, she's worried he might not be able to get the support he needs for his ADHD. STV News Donna Ploatner and Ruth Alexander
She added: 'I think it's more probably going to be around supports for medication that he will really struggle to access without us going down the private route.
'I know many parents who are down that private route and have got shared care with medication, but many don't, and that again is an individual thing down to surgeries or GPs, even.
'So even having a private diagnosis doesn't guarantee the NHS will pay for your medication.'
Ruth Alexander spent more than £4,000 on a private diagnosis for her daughter – an expense she knows not all families can afford.
She's concerned by NHS Tayside only taking referrals for children who have a pre-existing mental health condition.
She told STV News: 'The general feeling is it's just a short-sighted move, and it's storing up problems for the future, and it's not going to help anything in the long run because young people who did not have pre-existing mental health conditions will develop them as a direct result of this, and that feels really foolish. It's dangerous.' STV News Angie Ferguson, Perth Autism Support
Since referrals were closed, charities have been busier than ever with parents seeking help.
Angie Ferguson, of Perth Autism Support, said: 'None of us are disputing the fact the neurodevelopmental pathway is not mental health and doesn't necessarily sit very neatly within a CAHMS service, but the feeling has definitely been there could have been an alternative or plans for how that's going to be offered in a different way before the announcement was made, before parents recieved letters through the post advising them their referals wouldn't be accepted.'
NHS Tayside previously told STV News that they are still accepting referrals but have 'refined' the criteria for the neurodevelopmental pathway.
Adding that their teams have spent the last 12 months changing the focus from diagnosis to needs-based support.
But for many families across Tayside, they're concerned about getting the right support without a diagnosis.
NHS Tayside has said the changes will mean that the highest risk children and young people with mental health conditions will be seen in a 'responsive, effective service in a timely way'.
Meanwhile, children and young people who do not have a mental health condition will be able to access other forms of support and intervention.
A spokesperson for NHS Tayside said: 'It is accepted that this change may cause distress and concern for some families.
'We are very keen that all our partners and families of children and young people are involved in taking forward care models which offer the best options and outcomes for everyone.
'We accept that not all our partners were fully engaged in our change plans before a communication was sent out and we apologise for that.
'We are fully committed to working more closely with our partners, children and young people and their families, as well as Scottish Government, in the future as we look at further pathways of care for neurodevelopmental needs.
'A short life working group has been established to take this forward and a meeting has been arranged in early May with colleagues in local authorities, education services and children's services. Scottish Government colleagues will also be attending.'
Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News
Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
10 hours ago
- The Guardian
Woman with ADHD who slept in sauna on team-building trip wins UK case
An executive with ADHD who was sacked after spending the night sleeping in a sauna when she lost her room keys during a team-building event has won a disability discrimination case. Shannon Burns had been drinking and her bosses told her that confidence in her had been eroded and she needed to set an example. But she won her case after arguing the software company she worked for had not done enough to help her perform well taking into account her attention deficit hyperactivity disorder. She is in line for compensation after the tribunal accepted that while she had been drinking before going to sleep in the sauna, her ADHD contributed to her lack of organisation and the loss of her keys. The tribunal in Birmingham heard that Burns previously worked in Silicon Valley and was a member of organisations that help women into the tech industry. But her ADHD meant she was forgetful and often lost her phone and keys. She was recruited by the company Gitpod as a vice-president of engineering on a salary of £220,000 with £78,000 bonus per annum. Shortly after arriving, Burns asked Gitpod for a coach to help her with ADHD as she was feeling 'deeply overwhelmed' at her workload but was not referred to occupational therapy, the tribunal heard. She attended a Gitpod off-site team building event in Austria and on the final night, was said to be 'slurring her words' after drinking alcohol, the tribunal heard. Burns went back to her room and found it was locked and she had no key. There was no receptionist on duty and her roommate had fallen asleep and was not answering her phone. Eventually Burns gave up and went to sleep in the sauna. She later received a message from a senior executive saying she had to stay in control and was given a deadline for improvement but was dismissed two months after the sauna incident. The tribunal said her employer should have done more to investigate and assess her ADHD. On the reasons for her spending the night in the sauna, the tribunal concluded: 'This was likely in part to be as a result of the combination of her alcohol consumption and her forgetfulness, which is a something arising from her ADHD.' A hearing will be set to decide on the amount of compensation Burns will receive.
STV News
11 hours ago
- STV News
GP practices to receive £15m funding boost in bid to improve services
The health secretary has announced £15m in funding for GP practices in Scotland in a bid to improve services. The funding will aim to support staff and ensure more roles are recruited, while allowing practices to build up capacity and support the day-to-day running of services. Neil Gray said: 'We have been listening carefully to the views of Scotland's GPs and as a result, I am pleased to confirm an initial additional investment of £15m for the current financial year.' The funding announcement comes after discussions with the sector about the sustainability of GP services. The Scottish Government said negotiations will continue around further support to 'help shift care from acute to community'. 'This new funding will help support capacity and ensure GPs and services in the community have the resources they need for their essential role in our health system', Gray added. 'We remain in negotiations with the sector on the provision of further support in the future, but this initial instalment demonstrates this Government's commitment to supporting primary care and alleviating current pressures on the system. 'We want to make it easier for people to see their GP and to achieve this we are working towards ensuring a greater proportion of new NHS funding goes to primary and community care. 'Funding gap remains' BMA Scotland welcomed the news – but said a near-£300m funding gap remains and that GPs are still facing a considerable funding shortfall. Dr Iain Morrison, chairman of BMA Scotland's GP committee, said: 'We welcome this immediate investment to help alleviate some of the recruitment and retention issues plaguing GP practices and harming patients' access to healthcare. 'We see this as a positive move by Government to acknowledge the issues we have described in our ongoing negotiations to rescue general practice. 'Our negotiations continue with a view to stabilising and then improving GP services across the nation. 'General practice in Scotland has seen funding erosion and cost pressures generate a funding gap of £290m, which we must see restored. 'It is only by closing this substantial gap that patients will see long term, sustainable improvements in access to GPs and the care we are able to provide to them. 'On that basis, we urge the Scottish Government to build on this and come forward with a substantial offer of new long-term funding that will put general practice in Scotland on a more sustainable footing. 'General practice can offer so much more that it is able to currently. Only with substantial investment can we realise the potential and give the people of Scotland the service they deserve.' Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
STV News
12 hours ago
- STV News
District nurses hold rally outside NHS offices over pay dispute
District nurses have protested over pay at demonstrations outside the offices of NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde. Dozens of protesters attended the event led by GMB Scotland on Thursday, holding banners and flags. It comes after district nurses, who are currently on Band 6 of the Agenda for Change pay scale, voiced overwhelming support for industrial action over delayed job evaluations. They believe the health board has failed to follow the nationally agreed-upon job evaluation process despite the trade unions and the employer agreeing on a new job description. GMB organiser in NHS Scotland, Karen Leonard, said the row was because the 'skills, qualifications and responsibilities' of the nurses justify a higher grade. STV News The protest was organised by GMB Scotland She said: 'Our members fully engaged with the process of job evaluation in good faith, but that faith has not been justified. 'Their skills, qualifications and responsibilities have increased over the last decade to meet the complex needs of patients now living in our communities and only want their changing role to be properly recognised and fairly rewarded. 'This process has dragged on for year after year, when consensus on the way forward has been reached on a number of occasions, only for the goalposts to be moved. 'After so many false starts and needless delays, the nurses' patience has been stretched to breaking point. 'They only want to nurse but are being driven towards industrial action by a needlessly protracted process that has left them demoralised but determined to resolve this issue.' STV News A ballot of members revealed 100% support for industrial action Last week, GMB's consultative ballot of members revealed 100% support for industrial action if there is 'no swift resolution'. An NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde spokesperson said they 'accept the review process has gone on for too long'. 'We greatly value the work of our district nurses and fully support the modernisation of roles', a spokesperson said. 'We fully accept that the process of review has gone on for far too long at NHSGGC and we recognise how important it is for us to resolve this matter as quickly as possible. 'We have set out a potential way forward which would align the new job description, once evaluated, to those staff with the required qualifications and who are undertaking the role. We believe this would show fair recognition for the training and responsibilities undertaken by staff. 'We are disappointed that we have not yet been able to reach an agreement with trade unions, however, we are keen to meet again with our trade union colleagues to find a way forward for our staff and for our services.' Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
