Tesla on trial in Florida over fatal crash linked to autopilot system
Family members of the woman killed in the crash, Tesla engineers and auto-safety experts are expected to provide testimony in a federal courtroom in Miami during the jury trial, which starts Monday and is set to last three weeks.
Only a handful of Tesla crash cases have gone to trial. The electric vehicle maker has struck confidential accords to resolve several cases that blamed defective technology for deadly accidents.
Musk is under enormous investor pressure after the company's stock has been battered, first by his close affiliation with President Donald Trump, and then by his dramatic falling out with the president. Musk has staked Tesla's future in part on autonomous driving as the company makes a big push to launch a robotaxi business.
In the Miami case, like others before it, Tesla has pinned its defense on 'driver error.' The driver of the Tesla S had engaged the driver-assistance system, but had dropped his mobile phone and wasn't watching the road while reaching for the device on the floorboard. That's when the car went through a T intersection in Key Largo and off the pavement, striking a parked Chevrolet Tahoe whose two occupants were standing outside the vehicle.
Naibel Benavides Leon, 20, was killed in the collision. Her estate sued Tesla, as did Dillon Angulo, who was injured. The lawsuit seeks compensation for medical expenses, wrongful death and pain and suffering, as well as punitive damages for what plaintiffs claim was Tesla's 'reckless disregard for human life.''The evidence clearly shows that this crash had nothing to do with Tesla's Autopilot technology,'' Tesla said in a statement. ''Instead, like so many unfortunate accidents since cell phones were invented, this was caused by a distracted driver. To his credit, he took responsibility for his actions because he was searching for his dropped cell phone while also pressing the accelerator, speeding and overriding the car's system at the time of the crash. In 2019 when this occurred, no crash avoidance technology existed that could have prevented this tragic accident.'
At issue is whether alleged design defects with Tesla's Autopilot system resulted in a failure to detect and respond to obstacles in the vehicle's path, including the end of the roadway. The lawsuit also argues that Tesla failed to provide adequate warning about the dangers of using Autopilot.
Michael Brooks, executive director of the Center for Auto Safety, a consumer advocacy group, said the case would be the first to test these legal theories of liability against Tesla.
'This case has the potential to set a marker in the sand about just how far juries are willing to go one way or the other,' Brooks said in an interview. 'The interesting part of this case will be seeing how much blame the jury places on the driver, but also how much blame they want to place on Tesla.'
In June, US District Judge Beth Bloom dismissed claims of defective manufacturing and negligent misrepresentation. The lawsuit had argued that Tesla falsely advertised its Autopilot capabilities beyond what the vehicle actually possessed. Bloom sided with Tesla and said there was no basis for such a claim.
George McGee, the driver of the Tesla, is expected to testify at trial. In court filings, attorneys for the plaintiffs argue he was overly reliant on his vehicle's Autopilot system because Tesla fails to adequately inform drivers about its limitations.
Jurors are also slated to hear expert testimony from Mary 'Missy' Cummings, a George Mason University professor who has been critical of Tesla's automated-driving systems. When she was appointed to serve as senior safety adviser at the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration in 2021, Musk called her 'extremely biased against Tesla' and Tesla fans signed a petition against her.
Cummings has served as an expert witness in at least two other lawsuits against Tesla related to the Autopilot system, according to court filings.
The automaker won two previous trials in California after juries found that accidents blamed on Autopilot — one fatal and one not — were due to driver error rather than the company's technology. In 2022, the company was found just 1 per cent responsible for the death of an 18-year-old whose Model S slammed into a concrete wall in Fort Lauderdale, Florida, while he was speeding. The jury said the teen and his father were 99 per cent at fault for the crash.
The company's near-perfect record in court carries the risk that any adverse verdict could be seen as undermining Musk's oft-repeated claim that his electric vehicles are the safest ever made.
Tesla faces three more trials over fatal Autopilot crashes in the next nine months in California. It's also scheduled to go to trial in Houston over a case brought on behalf of five police officers badly injured on the side of a freeway when a Tesla on Autopilot plowed into a parked squad car at 70 miles (113 kilometers) per hour.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


India.com
14 minutes ago
- India.com
Bad news for NASA employees as Trump administration forced 3870 workers to...
New Delhi: Washington: 3,870 employees will lose their jobs from the US space agency National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA). These employees are going to resign under the Voluntary Resignation Program. Why did these employees resign? US President Donald Trump's administration has launched a programme to reduce the number of employees to cut the budget. Under this, employees have been asked to resign on their own instead of being fired from NASA. To comply with the Trump administration's goal of reducing the federal workforce, space agency NASA officials are taking the path of resignation to avoid layoffs. NASA is world's most prominent space agency. What did NASA say about resignations? At present, 3,870 employees have resigned from NASA. However, NASA has said in its statement on Friday, July 25, that this number may change after reviewing the applications. NASA has given employees two separate opportunities to leave the job in 2025. After both resignation programmes and about 500 people leaving their jobs in general, NASA will be left with about 14,000 employees. This is the second round of resignations The first round of resignations at NASA came in the early part of the Trump administration. This effort was driven by the government efficiency department DOGE led by Elon Musk. NASA launched its second round of deferred resignations in early June, giving a chance to join it till July 25. The agency said that 3,000 employees accepted it, which is 16.4 percent of the total workforce. NASA issues statement NASA has said in its statement that safety is our top priority. Along with becoming a more efficient organization, we are also ensuring that our capabilities for missions like Moon and Mars remain fully intact. However, experts believe that such a huge reduction in the number of employees may harm NASA's future missions and technical expertise.


Time of India
32 minutes ago
- Time of India
Japan tariff deal to include $550bn investment: Trump
WASHINGTON: President Donald Trump said Japan has given him, as part of a new trade framework, $550 billion to invest in the United States. "Japan is putting up $550 billion in order to lower their tariffs a little bit," Trump said Thursday. "They put up, as you could call it, seed money." He said 90% of any profits from the money invested would go to the US even if Japan had put up the funds. "It's not a loan or anything, it's a signing bonus," the Republican president said, on the trade framework that lowered his threatened tariff from 25% to 15%, including on autos. A White House official said the terms are being negotiated and nothing has been formalised in writing. The sum is significant: It would represent more than 10% of Japan's entire gross domestic product . The Japan External Trade Organisation estimates that direct investment into the US economy topped $780 billion in 2023.


Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Trump recalls India-Pak conflict as he speaks to leaders of Thailand and Cambodia
US President Donald Trump Saturday said he spoke to the leaders of Cambodia and Thailand amid escalating tensions between the two neighbours, as he recalled, yet again, the conflict between India and Pakistan that was "brought to a successful halt." On Saturday, in a post on social media, Trump said he had spoken with Prime Minister of Cambodia Hun Manet "relative to stopping the War with Thailand." Explore courses from Top Institutes in Please select course: Select a Course Category Data Science Degree Management Public Policy Cybersecurity Product Management Others PGDM Technology Data Science Artificial Intelligence healthcare Project Management Leadership Finance MBA Data Analytics MCA Operations Management others Design Thinking Healthcare Digital Marketing CXO Skills you'll gain: Data Analysis & Interpretation Programming Proficiency Problem-Solving Skills Machine Learning & Artificial Intelligence Duration: 24 Months Vellore Institute of Technology VIT MSc in Data Science Starts on Aug 14, 2024 Get Details Skills you'll gain: Strategic Data-Analysis, including Data Mining & Preparation Predictive Modeling & Advanced Clustering Techniques Machine Learning Concepts & Regression Analysis Cutting-edge applications of AI, like NLP & Generative AI Duration: 8 Months IIM Kozhikode Professional Certificate in Data Science and Artificial Intelligence Starts on Jun 26, 2024 Get Details Trump said he also spoke with Thailand's acting Prime Minister Phumtham Wechayachai to "likewise request a Ceasefire, and END to the War, which is currently raging." by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Freedom Holding Corp Joins FXO ETF Alongside Berkshire Hathaway and Citigroup TechBullion Undo Trump described the conversation with Wechayachai as "very good" and said, "Thailand, like Cambodia, wants to have an immediate ceasefire, and peace." "After speaking to both Parties, Ceasefire, Peace, and Prosperity seems to be a natural. We will soon see!" Live Events Thailand and Cambodia have for the third consecutive day witnessed clashes at the border that left over 30 dead and more than 1,50,000 displaced. "I am trying to simplify a complex situation! Many people are being killed in this war, but it very much reminds me of the conflict between Pakistan and India, which was brought to a successful halt," Trump said. "We happen to be, by coincidence, currently dealing on Trade with both Countries, but do not want to make any Deal, with either Country, if they are fighting - And I have told them so!" Trump posted on social media. He said that after talking to the Thai leadership, a call could be made again to Cambodia "regarding War stoppage and Ceasefire based on what Thailand has to say." India launched Operation Sindoor on May 7, targeting terror infrastructure in Pakistan and Pakistan-occupied Kashmir in retaliation for the April 22 Pahalgam attack that killed 26 civilians. India and Pakistan reached an understanding on May 10 to end the conflict after four days of intense cross-border drone and missile strikes. Trump has repeatedly claimed that he stopped the conflict between India and Pakistan. However, India has been consistently maintaining that the understanding on cessation of hostilities with Pakistan was reached following direct talks between the Directors General of Military Operations (DGMOs) of the two militaries.