Should a supercomputer be a top priority amid a housing crisis?
At a very rough and admittedly simplistic calculation – and assuming you could build a decent flat for, say, £100,000 – the almost £1 billion price tag for the supercomputer could have been used to build around 10,000 homes. Politics is all about priorities and supercomputers seem these days to come before homes for our nation's homeless weans. More than 10,000 of them languish in so-call temporary accommodation today and will continue to do so every day for the foreseeable future.
READ MORE: 5 things Scots should know from Rachel Reeves' spending review
After the announcement I watched a TV interview with a suitably enthusiastic academic from the university who singularly failed to explain the actual (not theoretical) benefits of the supercomputer. In the meantime, Peter Mathieson, principal and vice-chancellor of the University of Edinburgh, took to the press to say the supercomputer investment will have a 'transformative impact on the UK'. He went on to say 'This significant investment will have a profoundly positive impact on the UK's global standing'. Is this whole project primarily about 'the UK's global academic standing'?
I am reminded of The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy, a comedy science-fiction franchise created by Douglas Adams. The number 42 is especially significant to its many fans because that number is the answer given by a supercomputer called Deep Thought which takes 7.5 million years to finally answer the ultimate question of life, the universe, and everything.
Perhaps The National could devote some column inches to an article from the university to inform us of the real – not theoretical – benefits of this massively expensive project and explain why it is at the top of the political agenda. Will it be obsolete before it is even switched on?
READ MORE: Scottish Government 'short-changed by £1bn by Rachel Reeves'
I am sure the academics of Edinburgh University will enjoy their new toy when it eventually does come online. The homeless of weans of Scotland less so.
In sharp contrast, on March 28 2021 the then education secretary John Swinney said: 'If we are re-elected in May, the SNP will roll out a new programme to deliver into the hands of every school child in Scotland a laptop, Chromebook or tablet to use in school and at home. It will come with a free internet connection and full technical support. It will be updated when necessary, replaced when needed and upgraded as technology improves. As a child moves through their school life, it will change with them, going from the simpler devices needed at P1 to the more advanced in the senior phase of secondary'.
That pledge has since fallen by the political wayside. So it's a supercomputer for academics but no laptops for our school children.
Sandra West
Dundee
TRUMP'S false charge of race discrimination by the South African government against white farmers and offering them refuge in the US is an act of hostility against South Africa.
Since South Africa took Israel to the International Court of Justice charging it with genocide, the US has ramped up its actions against South Africa.
Trump's presidential order 'Addressing the Egregious Actions of South Africa' promoted the re-settlement of Afrikaners in the US and stated that South Africa had taken aggressive positions towards the United States including 'accusing Israel of genocide'.
READ MORE: David Pratt: Donald Trump is reshaping democracy for authoritarians
It added, 'The United States cannot support the government of South Africa in its undermining United States foreign policy which poses national security threats to our nation … and our interests.' It concluded that 'the United States shall not provide aid or assistance to South Africa.'
It could not be made clearer that if you disagree with US support for Israel's actions then you will be punished.
In South Africa's colonial and apartheid past, land distribution was grossly unequal on the basis of race. This remains the case. Whites own 70% of the land while being only 7% of the population. South Africa in addressing this issue passed the Land Expropriation Act. Land can be expropriated without compensation only in strictly defined circumstances.
READ MORE: Donald Trump ambushes South African president with false 'white genocide' claims
The United States intervention, making false claims about the act and what is happening to white farmers, whilst offering fast-tracked refuge to Afrikaners, is a disruptive interference in the affairs of a sovereign country.
The US actions seem designed to destabilise South Africa and stop its support for the Palestinians.
South Africa should be applauded for its humanitarian stance in support of the Palestinians and should also be assisted in its journey to overcome 300 years of colonialism and apartheid.
Brian Filling
Chair, Action for Southern Africa (ACTSA) Scotland
(successor organisation of the Anti-Apartheid Movement)
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scottish Sun
an hour ago
- Scottish Sun
Famous family-run NC500 hotel with panoramic views of stunning Scottish coastline sold after three decades
The seafront property was first opened in the late 19th century END OF AN ERA Famous family-run NC500 hotel with panoramic views of stunning Scottish coastline sold after three decades Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) A FAMOUS family-run hotel on Scotland's North Coast 500 route has been sold after three decades. The Lochalsh Hotel boasts 47 en-suite bedrooms, a spacious restaurant, a lounge bar as well as breathtaking panoramic views of the Isle of Skye. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 2 The Lochalsh Hotel in Kyle of Lochalsh has 47 ensuite bedrooms Credit: 2 It boasts spectacular views over the sea to the Isle of Skye and Loch Alsh Credit: The seafront property, in Kyle of Lochalsh, was opened in the late 19th century by the Highland Railway Company. Its prime spot on the 516-mile NC500 stretch has made it a magnet for tourists and locals alike, proving the perfect base for exploring the Isle of Skye. Selling agent CCL Property hailed the hotel as a "renowned landmark location." The hotel has been under the ownership of the Macrae family for nearly thirty years. Murdo Macrae said: "It has been a privilege to serve guests from around the world and to be part of the local community. "We believe that under new ownership, the Lochalsh Hotel will continue to thrive as a cherished Highland destination." But Edinburgh Portobello Hotels Ltd has now taken the reins - promising to uphold the Macrae family's incredible legacy with a planned refurbishment. Sonia Patel, Director of CJ Highlands Hotels Limited, said: "We are excited to welcome the Lochalsh Hotel into our portfolio. "Its unique setting and storied past present significant opportunities, and we are committed to honouring the MacRae family's legacy with a planned refurbishment that will enhance the guest experience while upholding Highland traditions." David Pickering, Director of CCL Property, added: "This successful sale underscores the resilience of the Highland hospitality sector and the enduring appeal of the Lochalsh Hotel. Escape to Glen Clova Hotel The stunning hidden gem nestled in the heart of Scots mountains is the perfect place for a weekend of relaxation "Our tailored marketing approach ensured the property reached the right audience, and we are delighted to have brokered a deal that benefits all parties involved." We previously told how a five-star former Victorian hunting lodge has been named Scotland's hotel of the year.
Daily Mirror
an hour ago
- Daily Mirror
Kemi Badenoch bills taxpayers for nearly £3,000 worth of electricity bills
The Tory leader claimed £1,800 worth of bills in February 2024, followed by another £1,000 a month later - both for her second home which is only just far enough away from London to claim expenses Kemi Badenoch claimed nearly £3,000 of taxpayers cash to pay the electricity bills at her second home - months after her government scrapped assistance for struggling households. The last government's Energy Bills Assistance scheme came to an end in June 2023. But the following February, Ms Badenoch billed taxpayers for more than £1,800 worth of electricity bills. And in March, she submitted a second claim for another £1,000. Government records suggest it's the first time Ms Badenoch has claimed for energy bills since moving into her Kent country pile, which she shares with her banker husband Hamish. The couple share a huge grade II listed farmhouse with six bedrooms - with rent paid for on expenses. Her banker husband subsidises the rent - as it is over the limit for the amount she can claim - but the Mirror revealed earlier this year that Mrs Badenoch has landed the taxpayer with the full council tax bill. The Mirror revealed earlier this year that Ms Badenoch claims the maximum level of Council Tax for her property - nearly £4,000 last year - despite it being just a stone's throw away from London. Ms Badenoch made the 23rd highest accommodation claim out of 664 MPs last year and yet her Essex constituency borders the 'London area' where MPs are not allowed to claim any second home expenses at all. The claims are within the rules but raises awkward questions for the outspoken right-winger, who says she wants a "smaller state" and champions lower Government spending. At the time the electricity bill claims were submitted, Ms Badenoch was business and trade secretary, earning almost £160,000 a year - more than four times the national average salary. Ms Badenoch's spokesman did not respond to a request for comment. Ms Badenoch came under fire this week after calling for measures to drive down energy bills to be scrapped. The Tory leader demanded an end to the windfall tax on oil and gas firms and for a ban on new licences in the North Sea to be lifted. She was accused of being "on the side of oil and gas giants rather than working Scots". The energy levy was brought in when Rishi Sunak was in power when profits exploded following Russia's invasion of Ukraine. But in a speech to Scottish Tories Ms Badenoch claimed the windfall is "long gone" and claimed Labour is "killing this industry".
Glasgow Times
2 hours ago
- Glasgow Times
Tories ‘got it wrong' when they backed 2045 net zero target, Findlay says
Tory MSPs had voted for legislation in 2019 which commits Scotland to achieving net zero by that date. But Mr Findlay now says they had been 'wrong' to do so. 🗣️ @RussellFindlay1: "The only just transition is an affordable transition – one that protects North Sea jobs and cuts energy bills for families and businesses. "We would scrap the SNP's 2045 net zero target. "It is unaffordable and unachievable."#SCC25 — Scottish Conservatives (@ScotTories) June 14, 2025 His comments came as a new policy paper published by the party said reaching this target would result in 'unaffordable costs for struggling families across Scotland and put at risk our oil and gas industry and farmers' businesses'. UK Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch has already said the UK target of reaching net zero by 2050 – five years later than the Scottish date – is 'impossible'. While Scottish Tories had previously backed the 2045 date, Mr Findlay told the PA news agency: 'I think yes, we did get it wrong'. When Conservative MSPs at Holyrood supported the 2045 date, he said they had done so 'so on the basis of what was known in those moments'. But he added: 'The situation has become clearer, it is evident to everybody watching this, to everybody in the Scottish Parliament, if they were being honest. 'Both Labour, the SNP and the rest of them would admit that the 2045 target isn't just unaffordable it's unachievable – that's the reality. 'So we're telling the truth to the Scottish public.' The Tories want to give local communities new legal powers to oppose 'mega-pylons' (Ben Birchall/PA) Mr Findlay continued: 'We want to reach net zero fairly and quickly. We understand the climate crisis emergency but we cannot harm our own economy and force householders who are already struggling to pay the bills with yet more great costs. 'Whether it be ripping out their gas boilers and putting in costly heat pumps, or forcing them to get rid of their cars and buying very expensive electric alternatives. 'This has got to be about the balance between ensuring we reach net zero properly and speedily, but recognising that it cannot come at a crippling cost to those people out there who are having to pay for it.' Asked later by journalists if his party was pandering to climate sceptics, Mr Findlay said they were 'absolutely not', adding the Tories were the only party 'telling the truth' on the issue. His comments came as the Scottish Conservatives promised to give every household in Scotland a £100 discount on their energy bills – with this to be funded from money accrued from the ScotWind auction, where areas of the seabed were leased for offshore wind power projects. The paper also said the Tories would make pylons 'an option of last resort for energy infrastructure projects' – with the party promising legislation to give people 'greater decision-making authority over local infrastructure projects' by abolishing the Scottish Government's existing energy consents union. Speaking about the changes as he addressed the Scottish Conservative conference in Edinburgh, Mr Findlay said: 'We would scrap the SNP's 2045 net zero target. It is unaffordable and unachievable.' He added that instead of spending money on 'SNP eco-projects', the Tories would 'use it to protect oil and gas workers' livelihoods'. Mr Findlay continued: 'We would take £100 off every household energy bill in Scotland from the proceeds of leasing our waters to wind farms. 'We will also give residents new legal powers to oppose mega-pylons.'
