Councillors refuse Coupar Angus solar farm on prime agricultural land
Perth and Kinross councillors have refused an application for a solar farm on prime agricultural land near Coupar Angus.
The plans - which went before the Planning and Placemaking Committee on Wednesday, July 9 - had been recommended for approval by council officers.
It was refused by a single vote after objectors raised fears about going from living in open countryside to being in the middle of an industrial site.
Elected members in the SNP administration - who voted to approve the application - were outnumbered by opposition councillors who voted for refusal.
Milton Keynes-based Greentech Invest UK (9) submitted plans to develop a 22MW solar farm on 46 hectares of land 320m north-west of Peattie Farm, Kinnochtry near Coupar Angus. The solar panels themselves would occupy around 24 hectares of the site.
PKC received 44 letters of objection to the application and just one letter of support.
Kettins Parish Community Council and Burrelton And District Community Council both objected to the proposal.
Campmuir resident Dave Ritchie, addressed the council on behalf of local residents opposed to the proposal.
He said: "While we all recognise the requirements to produce green energy, the use of prime agricultural land is a real concern, particularly in light of the recent political and economical uncertainties when arguments for food security are stronger than ever.
"There's only eight per cent of Scotland that's prime agricultural land, so there must be plenty more room on other land to put these solar farms on. We've got brownfield sites, rooftops and plenty of unproductive sites."
He highlighted concern about the swathe of renewable energy developments in the Coupar Angus area.
Mr Ritchie said: "There's a gathering pace of solar development - all on prime agricultural land.
"Of particular concern to residents is the prospect of being sandwiched between two separate developments - one which is at Markethill, 250 acres, (which is awaiting a decision from Scottish Ministers) and this one here at Peattie which is 110 acres.
"Before long, we'll no longer be living in the countryside but on a solar farm."
He told councillors the arable land was used every year to grow crops such as potatoes, barley, carrots and turnips.
Objector Polly Jones' home neighbours the site.
Addressing councillors, she said: "My concern, I believe, is shared by all of my neighbours and many of the residents of Campmuir.
"We were actually really shocked to hear this was being considered for approval, given the size of it and the impact it's going to have on all of us.
"Currently, we look at a wide open expanse of beautiful agricultural land. We bought our properties due to their location, at a price which reflected that setting and we pay our council tax to reflect that value and setting.
"If this proposal is allowed I and my neighbours will be faced directly with a minimum six-metre wall of solar panels."
With the application site opposite her home being on a slope she explained they were "very sceptical the screening will have any effect and even once the screening is fully grown, we're still going to be dwarfed by the panels that are visible higher up the hill".
She added: "As developments - like these - crowd in and around the substation there is a risk in Coupar Angus (with multiple developments proposed) that if they go ahead we won't be living in the countryside any more but in an industrial site.
"I feel, in Scotland, we don't have to have the trade-off between energy and food because we have a lot of land that is not prime agricultural land."
Greentech senior planning manager James Jenkins told councillors: "We estimate the project will deliver over £4.5 million of construction work that can be delivered by local contractors and specialists."
He said rent paid to the landowner would "ensure they could continue investing in their farming enterprise and maintain it as a viable operation" and the community would benefit from around £500 per MW (£11,000).
When councillors questioned the use of prime agricultural land, PKC's Major Applications and Enforcement team leader Sean Panton told councillors: "The loss of prime agricultural land is regrettable but national planning policy does allow it."
National Planning Framework 4 permits development on prime agricultural land for "essential infrastructure and there is a specific locational need and no other suitable site".
Blairgowrie and Glens councillor Bob Brawn moved to refuse the application.
The Conservative councillor said: "This part of the world, Coupar Angus, has already lost prime agricultural land to battery storage at Pleasance Road; last month we, as consultees, agreed to battery storage at Kettins on prime agricultural land; Markethill is still in abeyance and could happen (but we can't use that as a justification); there's also a solar farm development at Keithick.
"The exception for the use of prime agricultural land is for essential renewable energy. I would argue that Coupar Angus has done its bit for renewable energy already and I don't believe this is now classed as essential in this area.
"I feel the need for prime agricultural land outweighs the need for renewable energy in this area."
Conservative councillor Ian James seconded the motion for refusal.
SNP councillor Ken Harvey moved to approve the plans and claimed the land was "in a poor state and doesn't appear to have been used for anything other than silage the past few years".
Following a brief recess, he corrected himself and said: "I said it was getting used for silage. Obviously not, there are potatoes and what looked like turnips being grown."
He added: "The loss of prime agricultural land is outweighed by the benefit of solar energy we're getting. We are constrained by where the substations are for such developments and we need to take due cognisance of that going forward with the other developments but I think this development is reasonable."
It was seconded by Bailie Mike Williamson.
Six Conservative, Independent and Liberal Democrat councillors voted to refuse the application and the five SNP councillors on the committee voted to approve the application. It was refused by one vote.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Leader Live
18 minutes ago
- Leader Live
Energy giant SSE sees UK dry spell hit water power generation
The Perth-based energy giant reported a 4% decrease in output in May and June, compared with the same period last year. This was due to 'unfavourable weather conditions' affecting its hydro power stations, which work by harnessing the power of moving water to generate electricity. SSE's hydro generation dropped by about 40% in the three months to June, compared with the same period a year ago. Scotland has experienced a lack of rainfall, with regions in the east seeing the driest spring since 1964, according to the Scottish Environment Protection Agency. SSE told investors that the dry conditions offset strong operational availability across its renewable power plants. Meanwhile, the company welcomed 'clarity' from the Government's decision not to split the country into different energy pricing zones. Energy Secretary Ed Miliband confirmed earlier this month that the UK would retain a single national wholesale price for electricity but reform the current system. SSE said in a statement to investors that the decision brings 'welcome clarity for both investors and consumers whilst sending a strong investment signal that reaffirms the UK as a world-leading renewables market'. The form said its financial outlook for the year continues to be subject to weather, market conditions and plant availability, with the key winter months still to come.
Daily Record
18 minutes ago
- Daily Record
'Fairytale' Scottish castle beside beautiful loch on sale for £2.6million
The castle, now listed with Knight Frank, has five bedrooms and luxury features like a gym, sauna, and glass-walled dining room A historic Scottish castle by a beautiful loch with a story stretching back more than 800 years has hit the market. The "fairytale" Couston Castle is up for sale for a cool £2.65 million. The restored 16th Century castle near Aberdour in Fife sits on 5.37 acres of landscaped grounds overlooking the tranquil Otterston Loch. The striking property combines centuries of history with exceptional modern upgrades Offering a rare blend of heritage, privacy and luxury less than an hour from Edinburgh, Couston Castle is described by estate agent Knight Frank as an 'outstanding fairytale castle' that has been 'maintained to the highest standard'. Inside, it features five bedrooms and a wide array of bespoke features, including a gym suite with sauna and wet room, a vaulted sitting room with a rescued fireplace, and a stunning glass-walled dining and living space finished with Caithness stone flooring. The state-of-the-art kitchen is fitted with Gaggenau appliances and dual islands, ideal for entertaining or family life. Additional highlights include an office, cinema room, oak-panelled drawing room and a luxurious principal suite with a copper bath. There is also a bunk room, multiple en suites and a guest or staff flat above a triple garage. Outside, the beautifully maintained grounds include an orchard, a play area, outdoor kitchen, dog kennels, a gardener's compound and a two-storey barn with modern utilities. A stone and gravel courtyard connects the buildings, all thoughtfully integrated into the historical fabric of the estate. The castle's story begins in the late 12th century, when Robert de London, the illegitimate son of King William the Lion, granted Couston and other lands to Roger Frebern. By the 16th century, a fortified castle stood on the site, equipped with artillery. In the following century, King James V issued a charter to James Logan of Couston, during whose tenure the building was remodelled into a form close to its present-day layout. In the 1660s, the castle was home to Reverend Robert Blair, a professor at Glasgow University and former tutor to King Charles I. Exiled from St Andrews due to his covenanting views, Blair lived out his final years at Couston, dying there in 1666. Over time, the castle fell into disrepair. Much of it was dismantled in the 1840s for farm building materials, leaving behind only partial ruins, including a 17th-century stair base and doorway. It remained largely forgotten until the 1980s, when businessman Alastair Harper bought the site and commissioned architect Ian Begg to restore it. Using original stone from Otterston Loch and salvaged rubble, they painstakingly rebuilt the structure, preserving the historic layout. Their work was recognised with a Saltire Society Award in 1988. The current owners have since added further refinements, including contemporary bathrooms, a modern kitchen and luxurious high-end finishes throughout. These developments have transformed Couston Castle into a unique, multi-level family home that is both rooted in the past and designed for modern living.
Glasgow Times
23 minutes ago
- Glasgow Times
Shoppers flock to sweet treats inspired by US trends, Mr Kipling owner says
The St Albans-based owner of brands including Mr Kipling and Bisto said there were signs of shoppers switching back to brands. Branded sales across the group grew by 1.2% to £216 million over the 13 weeks to June 28, compared with the same period a year ago. This was driven by an 11.34% jump in sales of its sweet treat branded products including Mr Kipling and Cadbury cakes. Mr Kipling birthday cake tarts, inspired by snack trends in the US, and newly launched 'lunchbox' cake slices helped draw in new shoppers, the company said. Chief executive Alex Whitehouse said the uptick in branded sales was 'driven by the strength of our innovation programme with new product ranges such as Mr Kipling birthday cake tarts performing very strongly, as we brought to Britain a trend that is particularly popular in the US'. 'We expect branded revenue growth to build through the year, as we launch further new products, such as Fuel10K yoghurt and granola pots,' he added. However, revenues from its grocery products declined by 2.7% over the latest period. Demand for items such as gravy, stock and soup were impacted by warmer-than-usual temperatures, Premier Foods said. Premier Foods said it was attracting new customers to its Mr Kipling birthday cake tarts (Premier Foods/PA) It pointed to new product launches such as The Spice Tailor rolling out Mexican kits and Bisto bringing out peri-peri gravy to attract more younger consumers. Meanwhile, non-branded grocery revenues declined by 8.8% year-on-year, which Premier Foods said partly reflected consumers switching to brands. Premier Foods said it was expecting sales growth from its portfolio of brands to build throughout the financial year. It is also continuing to target cost-cutting across the business in a bid to bolster profits. Shares in the company were down by nearly 4% on Thursday following the update.
