Inside rural Pennsylvania where Bryan Kohberger became a killer

Daily Mail​

23-07-2025

Carolyn Dale happened to glance outside when she noticed something unusual unfolding in front of her home. It was late on December 29, 2022, in Indian Mountain Lake - a quiet, gated community nestled in the Pocono Mountains of Pennsylvania. In the darkness, she saw police cars lining the road with their lights out. Curious, Dale asked her husband to check what was going on. He was quickly ushered back into the house. 'Then all this [expletive] happened,' Dale told the Daily Mail from her front porch.
Moments later, a Pennsylvania State Police SWAT team set off flash-bangs and broke down the windows and doors of a two-story home a few houses down. Inside, 28-year-old Bryan Kohberger was surrounded by officers with guns drawn. The tranquility of the neighborhood, where residents largely kept to themselves, had suddenly been shattered by the murders of four students 2,500 miles away in Moscow, Idaho. Six weeks earlier, on November 13, 2022, Kohberger broke into an off-campus University of Idaho home and slaughtered best friends Kaylee Goncalves and Madison Mogen, both 21, and couple Xana Kernodle and Ethan Chapin, both 20.
While Moscow locals had feared that the killer was still among them, the people of Albrightsville were celebrating - unaware that he was already back home in their own community. No one there could have predicted the murders that hit headlines nationwide would lead back to their own doorsteps. Now, more than two-and-a-half years on, the broken glass and debris from the raid that dramatic night have long been cleared up. But the memories - and gossip - remain. When the Daily Mail spoke to neighbors and workers inside the community on a quiet, sweltering afternoon in late June, few wanted to speak about that gruesome day or the local man who committed the crime. One worker, who declined to give his name, said he had never believed that Kohberger could be guilty, saying that he was 'too calm' and speaking sympathetically of his 'suffering' parents Michael and MaryAnn.
He claimed that Kohberger's 70-year-old father had told him only recently that he just wanted 'to know the truth'. He would not have to wait long. That afternoon, the Kohberger home was silent, except for the sound of a dog barking at the doorbell. Michael and MaryAnn were perhaps already en route to Idaho, given that it had emerged their son was finally going to own up to his crimes. Less than 48 hours later, on July 2, 2025, they sat in the Ada County Courthouse in Boise, their faces ashen, as they watched their only son change his plea to guilty. As part of the deal, Kohberger avoided the death penalty but will spend the rest of his life in prison without the possibility of parole, and has waived all rights to appeal. For his family, the question lingers: how did their youngest child grow up to become a mass murderer ? They are not the only ones.
The Daily Mail spoke to several people from his community about their memories of Kohberger, now 30. They paint a picture of a socially awkward, quiet child and teenager who struggled with weight, addictions and interactions with others - but whose interest in crime and law enforcement grew more intense with age. But, while troubled, those who knew him said there was nothing particularly remarkable about his past life or any major red flags to indicate what was to come. Before the family moved to the private community in Albrightsville, Kohberger lived in Effort, a peaceful area of the Poconos with low crime and above-average incomes. His parents worked for the local Pleasant Valley School District, Michael as a maintenance worker and MaryAnn a special needs paraprofessional. Kohberger grew up with his older sisters, Amanda and Melissa, in a two-story home surrounded by trees and grazing deer.
Natori Green, 29, who lived four houses down and was in Kohberger's year at school remembers riding the same bus from 4th grade through high school. In elementary school, she told the Daily Mail, he would sit alone at the front. 'He was very sunk into himself until around middle or high school when he began to socialize a bit more,' she said, adding that there was nothing 'off-putting' about the way he interacted with other children. At school, Kohberger was bullied over his weight and Green recalled noticing an 'unrecognizable' change in his appearance during his teens. High school yearbook photos show a drastic transformation between sophomore and senior years. By that point, Kohberger had begun boxing almost daily after school. Jesse Harris, known as 'Coach' to the kids he trained, recalled Michael Kohberger bringing his son to the boxing gym around the age of 15. Over the years, Harris has seen many troubled kids and worried parents come through his doors.
While Kohberger was not the most outgoing, sociable teen - and it was obvious that Michael was seeking help in handling him - Harris said nothing alarming stood out at the time. '[Michael] was having some discipline issues with him, and he was overweight, so he had a lack of confidence,' Harris told the Daily Mail. 'His dad needed support guiding him.' It was around this time, between 2009 and 2012, that Kohberger began posting in an online forum about anxiety, depression, [self-murder] thoughts, a 'lack of emotion or remorse' and a condition called 'visual snow' - in which a person sees static-like interference. 'I feel like an organic sack of meat with no self worth,' he wrote in 2011, aged 16. 'As I hug my family, I look into their faces, I see nothing, it is like I am looking at a video game, but less.' Over time, Kohberger's posts became more optimistic. At the gym, he gained confidence and trained more with others. 'I saw a little change in his personality when he lost the weight,' Harris said. He was proud of himself.'
Friends told the Idaho Statesman that he developed a severe eating disorder, resulting in hospitalization, and underwent a tummy tuck after losing half his body weight. He also became a strict vegan. But more troubling than his weight issues was his drug use. Kohberger developed a heroin addiction, reportedly stealing from his family to feed the habit. In 2014, his father, Michael, called police after Kohberger, then 19, stole and sold his sister's $400 cell phone to buy drugs, according to court records seen by ABC News. Local Veteran Mark Baylis said that Kohberger was friends with his son Jack and nephew Brandon and the three boys used to hang out at his home in rural Saylorsburg. Starting in 2013, there were several break-ins at his home, he told the Daily Mail. 'Somebody was coming into my house when nobody was home and taking weird things,' he said, including military gear, coins, jewelry and knives similar to the one used years later to murder the students in Idaho. It was only after Kohberger's arrest that Baylis connected the dots. 'Now I know who it was,' he said.
Opioid addiction was widespread in the area. Driving from Stroudsburg to Albrightsville, billboards advertise websites to help tackle the fentanyl crisis, and safe needle disposal bins are installed in restrooms of local coffee shops. 'It's sad because a lot of people within our school year were affected by drugs,' Green said. 'Some passed away or went through very traumatic experiences that have set them back in life.' One of Kohberger's closest friends, Jeremy Saba, died of a fentanyl overdose in March 2021 - a year before the murders. The Kohbergers tried to help their troubled son with his addiction, including several stints in rehab. Eventually, after years of drug abuse, it seems that he turned his attention to education. During high school, he had shown an interest in a police or military career - taking part in a law enforcement program at the Monroe Career & Technical Institute. In an early, troubling glimpse into his behavior toward women, he was kicked out of the program following complaints from female students, former school administrator Tanya Carmella-Beers told 'The Idaho Massacre' podcast. So when Kohberger returned to his studies, he focused on criminology. He graduated from Northampton Community College with a major in psychology in 2018, then earned a bachelor's degree and a Master's in criminal justice at DeSales University.
He worked part time as a security officer for Pleasant Valley School District while he studied. Josh Ferraro, a fellow student at DeSales , told the Daily Mail that Kohberger very much kept to himself. Ferraro teamed up with him on many projects, including one involving testing for DNA on objects including a keyboard, keys and a student ID. He said he found Kohberger a 'pleasure to work with' but reluctant to get to know his classmates. He would speak to his professors but not his peers, Ferraro said. 'The only times we ever really hung out were for school. It was never personal. I never really got to know him,' he said. Ferraro said he sometimes invited Kohberger to college parties but he always declined. One other thing that he noticed was Kohberger always wore long sleeves, no matter the weather. 'I'll never forget it because I was like: 'Man, it's hot', and this dude's always in a leather jacket or a long-sleeve button-down. That was odd, so I always kept a mental note of it,' he said.
He had no idea about his quiet classmate's past drug abuse. But, at the time, Kohberger's social awkwardness was not unusual. After all, he was a 'commuter' - living at home with his parents, and traveling to and from college, rather than living on campus. Fellow classmate Brittany Slaven described him as 'shy' with students but very confident when it came to the subject matter in class room. Slaven found him smart and educated and admitted to once copying his test paper. 'He came across as a normal student. He was interested in the coursework and, maybe looking back, more interested than most students but, then again, that was our curriculum,' she said. 'I never got any red flags, nothing really stood out about him. He was just another student. But now I look back, it's so scary to think about.' As part of the program, students were taught by serial killer expert Dr Katherine Ramsland. They analyzed crime scenes, learned investigative techniques and studied the criminal minds of prolific killers including Ted Bundy and Elliot Rodger. Some classmates now wonder if the coursework might have inspired Kohberger to carry out his own crimes.
It was after graduating from DeSales in 2022 that Kohberger enrolled at Washington State University - a decision that saw him move to Pullman, just 10 miles from Moscow. When he formulated his plot to kill, what his motive was and how and why he chose his victims only he knows. During his six-months in Washington, Kohberger's professional performance was dismal, his behavior towards female students was concerning and he was ultimately fired as a teaching assistant at the end of the semester, sources told the Daily Mail. On December 30, 2022, he was arrested. In the Effort neighborhood where he grew up, Green said she felt 'ambushed' by the news that she had gone to school with the killer. 'When it's someone in your backyard, it makes it a reality for you,' she said.
But, while she was shocked, she said others who grew up in the area were not. 'A lot of people were alarmed, and then there were a lot of people that weren't,' Green said. 'It was 50-50.' Kohberger returns to court in Ada County, Idaho, on July 23 for sentencing, when the victims' families are expected to deliver impact statements at the hearing. He faces four consecutive life terms without the possibility of parole. As part of the plea agreement, he has waived all rights to appeal.