The changing landscape of rental applications in South Africa
Image: Independent Newspapers.
A detailed risk analysis in the latest PayProp Rental Index highlights a significant challenge for landlords and rental agents: more than a quarter of South African rental applicants were classed as high-risk in Q1 2025.
Based on data from the Tenant Assessment Report, PayProp's market-leading tenant screening tool, 26% of prospective tenants fell into the scoring system's highest risk bracket, up from 25% a year ago.
Landlords are seeing improved returns from healthy rental price growth in 2025, but it's important not to get complacent. Tenant affordability is lower due to the cost of living in many provinces, and with one in four applicants potentially presenting a payment risk, thorough vetting is non-negotiable.
Traditional credit checks offer only part of the picture when it comes to assessing tenant payment reliability, as they score the applicant based on their debt repayment history but often don't take rental payments into account. In contrast, PayProp combines credit scoring with rental payment histories captured from the platform to reveal where tenants fall on the risk spectrum. Analysis by PayProp ahead of a recent training webinar found that it was 94% better at predicting bad tenant behaviour than a traditional credit score when applied to a sample of real tenant data.
In Q1 2025,
● 39.6% of lease applicants were rated minimum-risk
● 20.0% were low-risk
● 14.5% were medium-risk
● 26.0% were high-risk
Video Player is loading.
Play Video
Play
Unmute
Current Time
0:00
/
Duration
-:-
Loaded :
0%
Stream Type LIVE
Seek to live, currently behind live
LIVE
Remaining Time
-
0:00
This is a modal window.
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque
Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps
Reset
restore all settings to the default values Done
Close Modal Dialog
End of dialog window.
Advertisement
Next
Stay
Close ✕
This distribution across the risk spectrum suggests that rental applicants are becoming more concentrated at both ends of the risk scale lately, making careful tenant selection more important than ever.
Income trumps all as a risk predictor
As can be expected, income is the strongest determinant of tenant risk. Among applicants earning R80,000 or more per month, 60.6% were classed as presenting minimum risk and just 12.2% as being high-risk. In the lowest income bracket (R10,000 - R20,000), only 23% qualified as minimum-risk, while 37% were high-risk.
Affordability is one of the first things any agent will check, and this helps demonstrate why. It also means that careful vetting is even more essential for lower-priced properties, as applicants are more likely to fall into lower income brackets. However, there are high-risk and low-risk tenants in every income bracket, and using smarter tools helps agents identify low-income, low-affordability tenants who nevertheless have perfect payment records.
Youth equals uncertainty
Age also plays a clear role. The 20 - 29 age group showed the lowest share of minimum-risk tenants (29.6%), likely due to thinner credit files and shorter rental histories. However, despite being unknown quantities in normal credit scoring terms, this group tends to have more disposable income after debt and rent, making them potentially better prospects than raw scores may suggest.
In contrast, 61.3% of applicants over 60 were classified as presenting minimum risk, and tenant risk declined sharply for all age groups over 50, which indicates a pattern likely linked to more stable financial positions and mature credit profiles.
Debt dynamics by gender
Interestingly, the report finds only slight gender-based differences in tenant risk, despite women earning roughly 80% of what men do, according to Stats SA. 40.1% of men were assessed as minimum-risk, compared to 39.1% of women. One possible explanation is that women spent 3.2% less of their income on debt repayments than men, improving their overall affordability profile.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
31 minutes ago
- The Citizen
Sapref unveils ambitious plans after R1 sale
THE Central Energy Fund (CEF), which bought South Africa's biggest former oil refinery, Sapref, for just R1 last year, said it plans to expand the refinery's capacity as part of a broader energy transition strategy. CEF is a government-owned company under the Department of Mineral Resources. Also read: eThekwini Municipality hopes to see Sapref revived Sapref, located in Prospecton, was previously owned by BP South Africa and Shell South Africa. At its peak before the 2022 floods, it produced 180 000 barrels of fuel per day, about 35% of the country's refining capacity. After it stopped production and shifted to importing fuel, the facility has handled about 70% of South Africa's petroleum fuel supply. Speaking at a recent conference in Cape Town, CEF's acting group CEO, Dr Tshepo Mokoka, said the need to increase capacity comes amid the country's rising demand for fuel. He said CEF aims to increase capacity to between 400 000 and 600 000 barrels per day. 'We want to address demand by processing the hydrocarbons that we have in South Africa as well as those in neighbouring countries,' said Mokoka. Hydrocarbons are organic compounds found in fossil fuels like crude oil, natural gas, and coal. Hydrocarbons are known for their combustibility, making them a primary energy source. Mokoka added that the CEF is striking a balance between renewable energy and hydrocarbons, which aligns government's broader strategy to implement a just energy transition from fossil to renewable energy. A University of South Africa professor, however, has questioned the R1 sale of Sapref to the government, saying it could have been designed for Sapref to evade its social and environmental liabilities. Llewellyn Leonard, of the university's Environmental Science Department, said decommissioning the refinery would have meant that Sapref was liable for the costs of restoring the site to its original state. 'Selling the refinery to the South African government, instead of decommissioning it, suggests that Sapref will not be held accountable for historical environmental liabilities and social injustices,' said Leonard. Over the years, Sapref was at loggerheads with nearby communities over air pollution and oil pipeline leaks. The acquisition of Sapref by CEF was approved by the Competition Commission in September 2024. For more South Coast Sun news, follow us on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram. You can also check out our videos on our YouTube channel or follow us on TikTok. Subscribe to our free weekly newsletter and get news delivered straight to your inbox. Do you have more information pertaining to this story? Feel free to let us know by commenting on our Facebook page or you can contact our newsroom on 031 903 2341 and speak to a journalist. At Caxton, we employ humans to generate daily fresh news, not AI intervention. Happy reading!
IOL News
44 minutes ago
- IOL News
US demands on exemption from South Africa's BEE requirements yet to be addressed with Ramaphosa
The Freedom Front Plus delegation in Washington last week. Image: Facebook/FFPlus FF Plus leader Corné Mulder says he has yet to brief President Cyril Ramaphosa on claims that the Trump administration has demanded that US entities be exempted from all Black Economic Empowerment (BEE) requirements as a precondition for normalising bilateral relations with South Africa. There are more than 600 US companies based in South Africa. Mulder made the claims as a FF Plus delegation returned from the US where they met with senior White House officials. This demand was part of a broader set of conditions that include addressing farm attacks, condemning the "Kill the Boer" chant, and ensuring fair market compensation for land expropriation. According to Mulder, the White House officials expressed concern that these conditions have not been adequately addressed. In May, President Cyril Ramaphosa and his delegation embarked on a working visit to the US to meet with US president Donald Trump to help reset strained relations between the two countries, and secure a favorable trade deal after a fallout over the International Court of Justice (ICJ) case against Israel that had been instituted by South Africa. Mulder, who held a press briefing on yesterday, said the delegation was committed to normalising relations between South Africa and the US and described Ramaphosa's visit with Trump in May as 'premature'. "We have a clear understanding of the US Administration's expectations," Mulder said. "The delegation has undertaken to communicate these pre-conditions to both the South African government and the broader public in the interest of transparency, accountability, and the restoration of strong bilateral ties,' said Mulder. Mulder added that they had not gone to the US to complain. He said that discussions on claimed genocide did not arise and they did not meet with the 50 white Afrikaners who were granted refugee status by the Trump administration. Southern African Agri Initiative chairman Theo de Jager, and National Employers' Association CEO Gerhard Papenfus were also part of the delegation. According to business group Sakeliga's CEO Piet le Roux, this development marks a substantial escalation in international pressure against South Africa's 'race-restrictive economic policies'. "The international backlash against BEE and other race-restrictive policies of the South African government is set to escalate further in the coming months and years," Le Roux said. Le Roux noted that the US demand elevates race-restrictive legislation beyond domestic affairs to the level of international economic and diplomatic relations This could lead to a ratcheting up of US-led bilateral or multilateral pressure opposing restrictive legislation in South Africa. Speaking on BEE, De Jager said there was only one way to avoid economic migrants and that was by improving their livelihoods. "The principle here is that there must be equal citizenship…there must be respective property rights and there must be an environment where we can also do business. 'They (Trump administration) said to us that they had heard us on the BEE matter, that it is a non-trade tariff barrier and they said that they would not restore any trade relationship if these preconditions are not adhered to. 'The biggest war of our generation is poverty and hunger and the only way we can deal with that is to create wealth…So we are gradually losing investment because of the likes of BEE and the threat to expropriate your property without compensation. You cannot invest in a country where you are not safe. 'We need an environment that will safeguard investment whether you are black or white. As Afrikaners we don't have access to production financing anymore. We need that kind of access,' said de Jager. Department of International Relations and Cooperation (DIRCO) spokesperson Chrispin Phiri told IOL that the group was pursuing its "own agenda". "Our experience is that State actors do not use non-state actors as intermediaries; therefore, the Freedom Front Plus' (VF Plus) visit and subsequent pronouncements will be viewed as nothing more than their ambitions," he said. Presidency spokesperson Vincent Magwenya did not respond to questions on how the South African government would react to the US demands. However, Ramaphosa has previously indicated that he would not back down from implementing BEE policies. "BEE is not holding back the economy, but rather the concentrated nature of our economy is," Ramaphosa said. He defended using racial designations as a means to address economic disparities, although he acknowledged that this might not be necessary in the future.
The Citizen
2 hours ago
- The Citizen
What to expect as Huawei and Samsung set to launch new smartphones
Consumers will be watching with bated breath to see what will be launched. Consumers will be watching with bated breath as Samsung and Huawei prepare to launch their new smartphones. On Thursday, tech journalists in South Africa will get a glimpse into Samsung's new smartphone, reportedly the Galaxy Z Fold 7, with the company sharing a teaser for the event, 'Be the first to experience the Ultra Unfold.' Huawei unveiled its Pura 80 series for journalists in Shenzhen, China, last week, with the official launch of the devices expected to take place on July 10th in Dubai. The company shared this teaser: 'Where light meets shadow, a new story begins.' Battlegrounds The battle for a major share of the smartphone market, particularly in South Africa, is simmering as consumers demand devices with the latest innovation but at an affordable price. Sadly, the new flagship smartphones are too often breaking bank balances rather than boundaries. Earlier this year, Huawei unveiled the Mate XT Ultimate Design, which costs a whopping R70,000, while last year's Samsung Galaxy Z Fold 6 retails for about R45,000. The all-new #HUAWEIPura80 Ultra stuns with a glazed gold finish, adopting a dazzling forward symbol design, and a radiant Sunburst Pattern that catches every eye. #HuaweiLaunch — Huawei Mobile SA (@HuaweiZA) June 27, 2025 ALSO READ: [REVIEW] Huawei Mate XT: No tri-fold gimmick smartphone, but it's pricey Money to burn While this is wad of cash to part with for phone which could possibly be the price of a second hand car, mobile operators are heavily subsidizing these smartphones luring consumer into 36-month contracts which is not lucrative as smartphones brands unveil new devices every year leaving customers stuck with devices for three years if they cannot sell old phones to upgrade. As for what Huawei and Samsung have up their sleeves, previous launches have focused strongly on artificial intelligence (AI) technology, with very few cosmetic changes. 💙 Like this post and be the first to witness what's next on GalaxyUnpacked. Something new is unfolding and yes, it's worth the wait 😉 This is the upgrade you've been waiting for. GalaxyAI — Samsung Mobile SA (@SamsungMobileSA) July 1, 2025 Innovation As companies innovate for thinner, foldable smartphones with impressive cameras and advanced AI technology, it's hard to imagine what's coming next. While smartphone prices have soared for flagship devices, many brands are also trying to capture a bigger slice of the mid-range market with affordable devices that offer top-end features, typically found in more expensive phones, at a fraction of the price. As for what Samsung and Huawei have up their sleeves, stay tuned to The Citizen for all the details. ALSO READ: WATCH: Samsung S25 Ultra an AI marvel
