Review launched over reports of delayed response to faulty knee replacement part
Some medics have said they first started noticing issues with a part of a knee replacement made by American medical device company Zimmer Biomet around eight years ago.
A product recall was not issued until December 2022.
A standard total knee replacement has four parts – a femoral component, tibial tray, patellar component and a polyethylene insert.
Concerns were raised about the tibial part – also known as 'NexGen Stemmed Option Tibial Component' – as experts found the implant was linked to higher revision rates compared to other models when it was paired with certain other knee replacement components.
A recall was led by the Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency (MHRA) in December 2022 after analysis of National Joint Registry data.
Leading knee surgeon Professor Leela Biant said action was not taken quickly enough after problems arose.
She told File on 4 that concerns were raised by herself and colleagues around eight years ago – five years before the product recall.
'The issue is their initial reluctance to acknowledge a problem and to not really engage with a process to evaluate these patients until they got to a situation where they had to,' she told the programme.
In June 2022, a study was published in the journal Bone & Joint Open which suggested 'there is a fundamental issue with this NexGen implant design'.
Patients have told the BBC about the impact on their lives.
Debbie Booker, a manager for a company running retirement homes on the south coast, had a knee replacement operation at a local NHS hospital in 2016.
Mrs Booker, from Southampton, described how it initially felt like the operation was a success but a year later she was suddenly 'in agony'.
As a result of the pain she said she had to take powerful pain killers.
'I was on fentanyl and morphine. I was actually addicted to morphine and it took me a long time to actually come off the morphine because I was addicted,' she said.
Medics found the implant had slipped out of place and she needed revision surgery.
Another patient, known only as Diana, described how within three years of her left knee replacement surgery she went from being an active retiree to being sofa-bound.
'Every time I stood up I was standing on a broken leg and it was agony,' she told the programme.
It also impacted surgeons who used the implant during their operations.
One described how they became a surgical 'outlier', with higher revision rates than expected, after using the implant.
File on 4 reported the implant had been used on 10,000 patients.
Local NHS teams are responsible for reviewing and, where clinically necessary, replacing affected implants.
A spokesperson for NHS England said: 'The safety of patients is the absolute priority for the NHS.
'Where issues are identified with any medical device, local NHS teams work swiftly to assess patients and provide replacement treatment where clinically necessary, in accordance with recommendations from the MHRA and device manufacturers.
'NHS England is currently reviewing the case involving Zimmer Biomet NexGen knee implants.'
Zimmer Biomet said in a statement: 'Zimmer Biomet is committed to the highest standards of patient safety, quality, and transparency.
'We issued the Field Safety Notice (FSN) proactively and voluntarily, in consultation with the MHRA, after new UK National Joint Registry (NJR) data indicated the Stemmed Option tibial component was not performing as well when used in combination with two specific femoral components (LPS Flex Option and LPS Flex GSF Option) compared to other combinations of components for which the NJR holds data.
'The vast majority of patients had positive outcomes, and we acted swiftly and responsibly by removing the tibial component from the market to prevent future use in those combinations.
'Zimmer Biomet meets all relevant regulatory requirements and maintains a robust post-market surveillance program.
'All our products are approved in accordance with the relevant regulations, and we continuously monitor the performance of our products once they are available to surgeons.
'Patient safety, transparency, and clinical excellence remain our highest priorities.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The National
27 minutes ago
- The National
Ian Murray's Laffer curve comments point to ignorance of economics
The Laffer Curve epitomises economists' quest for mathematical and scientific rigour and respect. A lot of economic data is collected and presented in the form of graphs from which relationships between variables may be deduced, but often without proper statistical evaluation of the accuracy or significance of the results. But at least there is data on which the calculations and predictions can be based, however unreliable. READ MORE: Meeting details between Ian Murray and Unionist think tank revealed The Laffer Curve purports to plot tax revenue against rate of taxation. It has only two points, one at either end of the baseline (or x-axis). Arthur Laffer postulated that there would be a line between these extremes, but the shape of it is entirely hypothetical. No data has ever been gathered to establish where intermediate points might lie, because to do so would be highly disruptive of the fiscal management of a country's economy. So the Laffer Curve is a figment of the imagination. Ian Murray's quoting of it is a worrying indication of a lack of knowledge or understanding of key economic concepts. Julian Smith Limekilns ANENT my recent observations on our failing NHS (Letters, Aug 9), it pains me to point out further inadequacies. In my previous letter I highlighted a case of a friend where a tissue biopsy was taken during an invasive procedure on January 24 but she still hadn't been informed as to whether the pathology was good or bad news. After great effort and much time spent telephoning hard-to-contact NHS admin staff, she discovered that a pathology report was created on the April 17 yet the correspondence to her on the subject was only generated very recently and was in the post. So my friend is still waiting, six months post-op, to discover whether she has a significant, possibly life-threatening, condition while the tissue sample and the result spent time sitting waiting to be attended to. In the same vein, another friend who is undergoing chemotherapy for a malignancy had a CT scan three weeks ago to monitor progress but has had her review appointment this week rescheduled because the CT scan has yet to be scrutinised by a specialist radiologist. In an ideal world, the CT could be reported on in real time, but for financial reasons everything is on hold – including the patient's state of mind for weeks until the scan is checked by a radiologist who wasn't present when the CT was taken but who could actually be based in Australia doing part-time NHS work. As I stated previously, I support the NHS wholeheartedly but it is underfunded, understaffed and stretching to provide a service to a standard it simply cannot achieve. When things are overstretched they break, and that is what is about to happen with our NHS if the basic problems are not dealt with. We deserve and pay for a first-class NHS but we don't get it. David J Crawford Glasgow CLARE Haughey's excellent but chilling account of the very real peril of creeping privatisation of our NHS (Aug 11) ought to make us all sit up and pay attention. Nothing can be comfortably assumed to be safe. And, on the watch of a soi-disant Labour government? How this ought to sicken us all, the more so when you remember that it was Attlee's post-war Labour administration that brought the NHS into being in the first place. And this precisely because preceding private healthcare simply did not serve people at all. READ MORE: Clare Haughey: If Labour win power in Scotland, what will they do to our NHS? Clare names and hopefully shames the beneficiaries of these obscene donations. This is indeed courageous. Good on you, Clare. I am reminded of two apposite things. Firstly, an acquaintance of mine recently spent some weeks in the USA. He suffered a fall, being knocked down by a cyclist. This required required a hospital visit to outpatients, and 11 stitches to a finger. Relatively minor, you might say, although, of course, unpleasant. For this he received a bill of $650, with a further $60 to be paid for post-treatment care. Luckily for him, his holiday insurance met most, if not all, of this. Secondly, those with a longer memory may recall studies undertaken by the World Health Organisation on at least two occasions that I recall, where the quality of healthcare received was compared over 39 countries. READ MORE: Three new cancer drugs approved for use by NHS Scotland On both occasions, the country offering the best care was France, and number 39 out of 39 was ... yes, you guessed correctly, USA. The UK came in at around half way, at 19. This being the case, why on earth would we wish to emulate a profit-driven broken system which serves none but the insurance companies and their bloated shareholders? Brian York Dumfries
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Pensioner, 77, died during heart surgery when hospital suffered a ten-minute power cut during a crucial stage, inquest hears
A pensioner died during heart surgery at an NHS hospital after the operating theatre she was in suffered a ten-minute-long power cut, an inquest heard. Jean Dye, 77, was at the crucial stage of the procedure when the electricity went down - meaning doctors had to delay the process as they couldn't see vital X rays. Five years after her death, a coroner has now issued a report saying that the delay in restoring power was a 'critical factor in her death'. It was found that an engineer was required to reset the system because it was in another part of the hospital. In a Prevention of Future Deaths Report, Paul Smith, Senior Coroner for Greater Lincolnshire, has now raised concerns about the lack of power controls within the operating theatre and that medical professionals weren't trained in how to understand when electricity has been restored. Mrs Dye, from Grimsby, Lincolnshire, suffered an underlying cardiac disease and attended Scunthorpe General Hospital to have it treated, the inquest was told. At the time of her death in September, 2020, she was having stents implanted to treat narrowed blood vessels. The operation only has a limited window to deploy the devices, the hearing was told. However, at exactly this moment there was a 'sudden and unexpected' power cut, which lasted for 10 minutes. It meant that medics could not see X-rays they needed for the procedure. No clear cause for the power cut has been identified, other than it overrode the back-up electrical supply, Mr Smith said. It was confirmed that power cuts have occasionally happened at hospitals across the country but the staff in Scunthorpe had not had this happen before. There was no manual re-activation of the circuit meaning that an engineer had to come to fix the issue. Once the power had returned, the stenting was completed but Mrs Dye failed to recover and she later passed away, the inquest heard. The hearing concluded that 'on the balance of probabilities, Mrs Dye would have survived but for the loss of electrical power'. It gave her cause of death as an iatrogenic artery dissection during a percutaneous coronary intervention. Mr Smith raised concerns about the lack of an indicator within the lab to confirm that the power had re-activated. There were also issues with the reset button being elsewhere in the hospital. Mr Smith said: 'The delay whilst power was restored was a critical factor in this death. 'The loss of power arose as a result of the Emergency Power Off (EPO) circuit activating. It overrode the emergency power back up system. 'All staff at the scene were unaware of the cause of the loss of power, never having experienced such a situation previously, and an engineer was summoned to attend to reinstate the power, which he did. 'There was no light or other indicator within the lab to confirm to those present that the EPO circuit had activated. Likewise there was no restart button within the lab to permit the EPO circuit to be reset. That lay within the plant room elsewhere within the hospital. 'Had staff been aware of the exact cause of the loss of power on this occasion and had they had the opportunity to reset the circuit without the need to await the arrival of an engineer, who in turn had to attend a separate plant room, the downtime would likely have been significantly reduced. 'Whilst it was not possible to say that the additional time spent on this occasion made a difference between the patient surviving or not, there may well be future cases within which such fine margins are time critical. 'I received evidence that there is no current guidance in relation to the siting of such controls remote from the affected room. I invite review of that guidance and of the need for any consequential training.' Mr Smith sent the report to NHS England and the Health Service Executive, who have until August 28 to respond.
BBC News
an hour ago
- BBC News
Tributes as former Birmingham doctor dies aged 95
Tributes have been paid to a "trailblazer" former doctor who has died at the age of Pauline Manfield became one of the first female consultants in UK paediatrics, helping establish a department at the Good Hope Hospital in Sutton Coldfield, with her colleague, staff nurse Eileen leaving the NHS in her 60s, devout Christian Dr Manfield became a lay reader and chaplain at Birmingham Cathedral where she served until she reached her late Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust said she "leaves behind a legacy defined by compassion, dedication, and an unwavering commitment to service". Dr Manfield was born in Worcester in 1929 and her early years were shaped by World War Two, especially the vivid memories of bombings during her time in Preston as a family eventually settled in Chelmsford where she attended Chelmsford Girls' High an aspiration to become a doctor, she studied medicine at The Royal Free Hospital. She then went on to earn membership of the Royal College of Physicians in the 1960s before joining Good addition to her work with the NHS and Birmingham Cathedral, she was a member of Sutton Sisters, a local multi-faith group promoting understanding and unity. She was involved with a range of local groups, such as the Sutton Coldfield Archaeological and Gardening Societies, and the Lichfield Science and Engineering also ran in the Sutton Coldfield Fun Run, enjoyed photography and travel, and was a regular at ballet shows and Birmingham Symphony Orchestra Manfield also led efforts through the Sutton Coldfield Association of Women Graduates to sponsor young women in Malawi. 'Deep compassion' "Her intelligence and warmth earned her early praise as 'clever, pretty and kind' – a description that would remain true throughout her long life," a spokesperson for the NHS Trust said."Pauline was known not only for her clinical excellence but also for the deep compassion she showed to patients and their families."Her impact was so significant that many former patients contributed to a special birthday book in her honour, filled with notes of gratitude and stories of lives touched by her care."While she never married or had children, the spokesperson said "Pauline nurtured deep friendships and maintained connections with her schoolmates and colleagues"."She was godmother to 12 children, and her home in Sutton Coldfield was a hub of hospitality, known for its garden parties, home-cooked meals, and walls lined with decades of photographs," the spokesperson continued."Pauline will be remembered as a trailblazer, a mentor, and a kind-hearted physician who gave her all to the people and causes she believed in." Follow BBC Birmingham on BBC Sounds, Facebook, X and Instagram.
