There are more than 20,000 unfinished RDP houses in the Free State
Theirs is one of more than 20,000 Breaking New Ground (BNG, formerly known as RDP) houses in the province that are incomplete, says Zimasa Mbewu, spokesperson for the Free State Department of Human Settlements. These projects are 'blocked' mainly because contractors failed to complete the work they have been paid for.
Toloko Mofokeng and his wife Monyaduwe Tshabalala were allocated an RDP house in 2011, to be built on a piece of land where they lived. A contractor arrived the same year but left without doing anything. A second contractor left after levelling the ground. A third contractor put in a concrete slab before also abandoning the project.
Fourteen years later, the couple live in a shack next to the slab. The shack leaks when it rains and will need to be rebuilt soon. Mofokeng, tired of waiting, says he is considering building his own mud hut on the concrete foundation.
Mbewu says the department has scrapped contractors who left work undone and 'blocked' housing projects, including Mofokeng's home, will be completed over the next two years. She declined to name the contractors responsible for Mofokeng's incomplete house, as disputes over payment were still taking place.
LONG HISTORY OF HOUSING FAILURES
The Zondo Commission found that between 2010 and 2011, under former Premier Ace Magashule, about R1-billion was spent on housing projects in the Free State, many of which were never completed.
In 2014, the province entered into a R255-million corrupt tender for the removal of asbestos roofs. That trial is continuing.
In 2021, the Auditor General wrote that for three years, the housing department had spent most of the grants received for housing but had delivered 'significantly fewer houses than the target', with no consequences for contractors who failed to meet their targets.
In 2024, the Auditor General commended the department on improving internal controls, but the department only reported completing 50 Breaking New Ground houses against a target of 2,065.
The Auditor General found there was insufficient evidence that even 50 houses had been built. 'I could not determine the actual achievement, but I estimated it to be materially less than reported,' the Auditor General wrote.
This article first appeared on GroundUp. Read the original article here.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
eNCA
5 hours ago
- eNCA
Gupta Compound in Saxonworld sold for over R30 million
JOHANNESBURG - The notorious Gupta compound in Saxonwold has been sold. Business Rescue Practitioners accepted an offer of R34 million. This sale follows just three weeks after the compound went under the hammer with one of the houses selling at significantly lower price. The house, known as Property 3, which once served as staff quarters, sold for just R3.3-million which was a decrease from its original amount of R5-million. The Gupta brothers, Rajesh, Atul and Ajay who once called the compound home, were identified as central figures in South Africa's state capture. They remain fugitives after fleeing the country in 2016.
The Citizen
a day ago
- The Citizen
Civil wife vs ‘customary wife': Widow's legal fight over late husband's R1.6m pension hits another delay
Tshifhiwa Shembry Mutsila has been embroiled in a legal battle with the Municipal Gratuity Fund for 10 years. After a decade-long legal battle, a widow will have to wait at least another three months to find out whether she is entitled to her late husband's full R1.6 million pension. Tshifhiwa Shembry Mutsila has been in and out of court since 2015, after another woman, Dipuo Masete, claimed she was also married to the deceased under customary law and financially dependent on him. Husband's death sparks battle over R1.6 million pension Mutsila married Takalani Emmanuel Mutsila in December 2003 in a civil marriage. The couple had five children. Takalani, who worked for the Ba Phalaborwa Municipality in Limpopo, died in December 2012 in a workplace accident. His dependants were entitled to R1 614 434.86 under Section 37C of the Pension Funds Act. However, Masete lodged a claim with the Municipal Gratuity Fund (MGF), saying she and her two children had been named beneficiaries in the deceased's life policy and that he made regular payments into her bank account. ALSO READ: Councils take pension billions Although Mutsila disputed the claim, the MGF board in April 2014 decided to split the death benefit -awarding Mutsila and her five children 47.5%, and Masete and her two children 52.5%. A private investigator hired by Mutsila later found that Masete was married to Malema Joseph Mphafudi under customary law and that he was the biological father of her two children. This revelation sparked a custody battle brought by Mphafudi against Masete in the Limpopo High Court. Masete did not dispute these findings. Adjudicator's ruling In May 2014, Mutsila challenged the MGF's decision with the Pension Funds Adjudicator. While the adjudicator invited both the fund and Masete to respond, the MGF requested a delay until the custody matter was finalised. The adjudicator subsequently found that the MGF had not properly identified the deceased's dependants and set aside the decision in September 2014. The fund was instructed to conduct a proper investigation and make an equitable distribution of the death benefit within three weeks of the custody case's conclusion. READ MORE: Thousands denied pensions as employers fail to pay The MGF, however, approached the Gauteng High Court in Pretoria in April 2015 to overturn the adjudicator's decision. That application was dismissed in June 2018, and its appeal was rejected in November 2021. The high court found that the fund had distributed the pension before properly identifying dependants. SCA reversal Despite the earlier losses, the MGF was granted a special appeal to the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA). It argued that the adjudicator lacked jurisdiction and that Mutsila should have lodged her complaint directly with the fund under section 30A(1) of the Pension Funds Act before approaching the adjudicator. The MGF also contended it had not been heard before the adjudicator made a determination. In July 2023, the SCA ruled in favour of the fund, finding the adjudicator had not given it the opportunity to respond to Mutsila's complaint. The court also highlighted that Masete's factual dependency had not been challenged. ConCourt judgment Mutsila then escalated the matter to the Constitutional Court (ConCourt), where the appeal was heard in November 2024. Former MGF CEO Marthinus Jacobsohn argued before the apex court that the finding that Masete and her two children had been supported by the deceased was 'both rational and sound'. Judge Leona Theron, however, pointed out that the fund did not know about Masete's marriage to Mphafudi at the time of its decision and had failed to conduct a proper investigation within the 12-month period from the death of a member. 'The fund was not aware that he was the biological father of her children, that he was still alive, and that he could support the children financially. 'The only fact mentioned in the fund's founding affidavit filed in the high court and annexures attached thereto is that Ms Masete declared dependency on the deceased in the amount of R2 000. 'There is no evidence that the fund carried out any investigations to determine for itself or confirm this declared dependency. 'There is no allegation in the documents attached by the fund to its founding affidavit to the effect that the deceased either maintained Ms Masete's children, paid for their school fees and clothing, or provided them with shelter,' the judgment, delivered on 8 August 2025, reads. Theron also pointed out that Mutsila had not demonstrated exceptional circumstances warranting the ConCourt to replace the fund's decision with a new order. She, therefore, ruled that the case be sent back to the MGF for a new investigation as the dispute stemmed from their 'flawed decision'. 'It is important to note that the outcome of the custody proceedings between Ms Masete and Mr Mphafudi have no bearing on the order of this court,' Theron added. The ConCourt upheld Mutsila's appeal and ordered the MGF to make a fresh determination within three months of the judgment. The fund was also ordered to pay Mutsila's legal costs. NOW READ: This is what a divorce will do to your pension fund
Daily Maverick
a day ago
- Daily Maverick
IDT CEO Tebogo Malaka's mansion and the unpaid EPWP workers: key takeaways
A months-long Daily Maverick investigation exposes financial ties between suspended Independent Development Trust CEO Tebogo Malaka and an IDT contractor. We also shed light on a simmering scandal involving unpaid Expanded Public Works Programme workers. This, by all indications, is the story that Malaka so desperately hoped to quash. A contractor to the Independent Development Trust (IDT) paid at least R200,000 towards a new house in an upmarket residential estate currently being built for suspended IDT CEO Tebogo Malaka. Daily Maverick's months-long investigation identified two transfers from businessman Collen Mashawana towards the construction of Malaka's new house inside Gauteng's Waterfall Country Estate. At the time of the first transfer, Malaka was still firmly in her job as CEO, and the IDT was on the verge of appointing Mashawana's charitable foundation for an employment scheme funded by the government's Expanded Public Works Programme (EPWP). Read the full investigation The Collen Mashawana Foundation (CMF) ended up getting by far the largest portion of the IDT's EPWP spend for the previous and current financial years, trumping more than 400 other nonprofits. The foundation was appointed to employ and manage nearly 1,800 EPWP workers across five provinces. The allocations shocked stakeholders familiar with the IDT's EPWP initiatives, seeing as the CMF has no track record in managing an employment scheme of this magnitude. Our investigation unearthed two alarming sets of developments that unfolded in the same timeframe. First, the CMF short-changed or failed to pay hundreds of its EPWP workers. Second, Collen Mashawana himself became directly involved in a R16-million project to build the IDT CEO's new house in the Waterfall Country Estate, acting as something of a project manager. Mashawana also made at least two payments towards Malaka's property. The EPWP workers' outstanding salaries, and Mashawana's simultaneous involvement in the Waterfall development, raises serious questions. Were the workers' hard-earned wages perhaps diverted to the IDT CEO's new mansion? The foundation has come out to strongly deny any impropriety. 'The Collen Mashawana Foundation (CMF) strongly refutes the misleading implications published in a recent article by the Daily Maverick, which seeks to connect the Foundation's implementation of the Expanded Public Works Program (EPWP) to alleged irregularities involving the suspended IDT CEO, Ms. Tebogo Malaka,' it said in a statement released on Monday, 11 August 2025. However, our investigation identified several transactions and related factors that raise alarm bells. Satellite images of Malaka's stand, coupled with WhatsApp correspondence and other records, helped us to craft a reliable timeline of progress at the building project. Thanks to our bundle of evidence, we know that all major works for the new house only kicked off after the IDT had transferred millions of rands to the CMF. The CMF, meanwhile, was not using these funds for its intended purpose, namely paying the EPWP workers their rightful salaries; Collen Mashawana made at least two payments towards Malaka's property, totalling R200,000. The payments were made through two different companies controlled by the businessman. Mashawana made the first payment in July 2024, while the IDT was still considering his foundation's EPWP bid. The businessman made the second known payment in April this year, shortly after the CMF had banked substantial payments from the IDT; and Mashawana appointed a company called Two Putswa Maeba Construction and Projects as the main contractor for Malaka's new house. Two Putswa had to pay for all manner of materials and services related to the project. The contractor on several occasions settled invoices shortly after the IDT transferred funds to Mashawana's foundation. In one instance, Two Putswa fell behind on its payments for leasing a construction container. It later settled the bill, the very next day after the CMF received R1.1-million from the IDT. As progress continued at Malaka's Waterfall property, the CMF's EPWP workers started taking the nonprofit and the IDT to task over the problems with their wages. To date, the IDT has transferred at least R23-million to the foundation, but much of this money was not used for its intended purpose. The alleged misappropriation of these funds is seemingly affirmed by a Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration (CCMA) probe. A group of more than 200 EPWP workers from Kgotsong in the Free State took the Collen Mashawana Foundation to the CCMA. The CCMA considered the group's evidence and in April this year ruled that the foundation had failed to pay them for five months. The CMF collectively owes this group nearly R1.7-million in outstanding salaries. To date, however, the foundation has failed to comply with the CCMA's decision, further fuelling the group's resentment and frustration. In all, the CMF had nearly 1,800 workers on its payroll for the IDT initiative. They were from Gauteng, Limpopo, North West, the Free State and KwaZulu-Natal. The group worked at rubbish dumps, cleaned streets, parks and other public spaces, among other tasks assigned to them. On average, the workers were supposed to earn about R1,700 per month. Daily Maverick also identified scores of workers from Limpopo and elsewhere in the Free State who received only small portions of their rightful salaries. In some instances, the CMF failed to pay the workers anything at all. Malaka chose not to respond to any of the queries we put to her. Collen Mashawana received a set of nearly twenty detailed queries but provided only a broad denial of any impropriety. 'It will not be appropriate for me to defend myself in the media on unsubstantiated and untested allegations,' said the businessman. DM This investigation was made possible by funding from the Henry Nxumalo Foundation, an independent nonprofit company that supports investigative journalism in South Africa and elsewhere on the continent. Some of the satellite images used for this investigation are from Airbus Space and Defence's Pléiades Neo satellite and were generously supplied to us by the company.
