logo
Starmer is about to repeat Blair's very worst mistake

Starmer is about to repeat Blair's very worst mistake

Telegraph17-07-2025
The Festival of Hounds at Peterborough is the largest annual gathering of the hunting community drawn from all parts of the country, cutting across all social divisions, backgrounds and age groups. United by a passion for hounds, hunting and the countryside, the festival itself is a celebration of a British tradition. For reasons which may stem from the ever-increasing distance between rural and urban lives, however, this community has been at the centre of a political storm for decades.
The last time Labour was in government, Tony Blair wasted 700 hours of parliamentary time and fought a bitter battle in the countryside for seven years before traditional hunting was eventually banned. In his memoirs he wrote that the ban was 'one of the domestic legislative measures I most regret', and Labour paid the price by being largely unelectable in rural constituencies for a political generation.
Strangely the new Labour government seems determined to repeat the mistakes of the not-too-distant past. It was elected with a manifesto commitment to ban trail hunting – the successor to traditional hunting – which involves chasing the scent of a fox, rather than a fox itself.
Class war has always been the underlying motivation
You would have thought that this was a benign activity and, indeed, it is exactly what hunts were told to do when the original ban came in, but there are a section of Labour MPs, often being pressed by animal rights activists embedded in their local Labour parties, for whom hunting has always been a cipher for class ward.
They think the hunting ban has failed because hunts still exist. The eradication of the hunting community has always been their primary, if unspoken, aim. They will never be satisfied until the last hunt has closed and will attempt to ensure that any new legislation achieves that goal.
Meanwhile, ministers know perfectly well that this is an issue which is completely irrelevant to the vast majority of voters, as polling has consistently shown. It would be very difficult to square the Government's narrative about a relentless focus on tackling the fiscal challenge, driving growth and heading off international crises with a diversion into such petty and prejudiced legislation.
How the Government extracts itself from this mess is a challenging question. We are barely a year into a five-year parliament but every week another urban Labour MP asks Ministers when they will bring forward legislation to ban trail hunting.
Tony Blair's government was elected with a manifesto commitment to ban hunting and faced a similarly obsessive campaign from the backbenches. But it took five years and a second election victory before he was finally worn down and committed to legislation. Faced with backbenchers seething over the invasion of Iraq and a bitter parliamentary battle over the introduction of foundation hospitals the advice was to feed them the 'red meat' of hunting.
As an observer who has lived through one unpleasant bout of hunting legislation and seen the impact on Labour's reputation in the countryside, I would counsel the current Prime Minister against any such thinking this time around.
Hugely damaging issue for the Government
The Countryside Alliance has been warning the Labour Party for years about the political danger of legislating on hunting, not just because of the issue of trail hunting itself, but because of the message it sends to rural voters that the Government is not interested in their priorities.
More than that I do not believe that the country as a whole is impressed by partial, prejudice politics or believes that this issue should be a priority for a Government with so many other serious issues on its agenda. As Peter Mandelson memorably put it to a rural audience a couple of years ago: 'If it is wrong…for the Right-wing to stoke culture wars against minorities, it is just as wrong for the Left-wing in our country to stoke culture wars against rural minorities'.
Trail hunting may be a niche activity carried out by a rural minority, but it is also potentially a hugely damaging issue for the Government. No one has ever won a political battle over hunting, as Tony Blair himself has admitted, so manifesto commitment or not the sensible course is to stick to real priorities and leave well alone.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Starmer raises case of Briton detained in India during meeting with Modi
Starmer raises case of Briton detained in India during meeting with Modi

The Independent

time2 minutes ago

  • The Independent

Starmer raises case of Briton detained in India during meeting with Modi

Sir Keir Starmer is believed to have raised the case of a British man detained in India for years, with the country's prime minister. Prime Minister Sir Keir met Narendra Modi on Thursday as the two countries signed a trade deal It is understood that Sir Keir raised the case of Jagtar Singh Johal, a Sikh activist from Dumbarton near Glasgow, who was arrested while in India for his wedding in 2017. Mr Johal's brother Gurpreet had suggested the meeting was a 'golden' chance for the UK Government to seek to secure his release. Mr Johan is being held in custody by the Indian authorities, despite having been cleared of one of the cases against him earlier this year. He still faces charges at a federal level, which his supporters, who claim an initial confession he made was as a result of torture, fear could take years to come to a conclusion. Speaking on BBC Radio Scotland on Thursday, Scottish Secretary Ian Murray said the issue was 'complex' but the Government was working to resolve it. 'The Government are doing all we possibly can to get this resolved,' he said. 'There was a recent meeting, just at the start of June, between the Foreign Secretary and his counterpart in India to try and get these issues resolved. 'So it's right at the top of the agenda and we can assure and reassure that we're doing everything we possibly can to get these issues resolved as quickly as possible.' Gurpreet Singh Johal, a Labour councillor in West Dunbartonshire, had earlier told BBC Radio Scotland: 'Raising the case is not enough, it's what we've been saying since day one. 'There's a golden opportunity here for the Prime Minister now, prior to the deal being signed or as the deal is being signed, that he strongly calls for Jagtar to be returned to his family so he can continue his married life.' Mr Murray said: 'The call is for these issues to be resolved and we're all fully on the same page in terms of having to get them resolved as quickly as possible.'

Scottish Secretary to give Donald Trump ‘warm welcome'
Scottish Secretary to give Donald Trump ‘warm welcome'

Telegraph

time3 minutes ago

  • Telegraph

Scottish Secretary to give Donald Trump ‘warm welcome'

Ian Murray, Labour's Scottish Secretary, has said Donald Trump will receive 'a warm welcome' when he arrives in Scotland, despite previously calling for a state visit by the US president to be blocked. Mr Murray was an opposition MP in 2019 when he supported a parliamentary motion stating that Mr Trump, then in his first term as president, should not be offered a state visit to the UK, citing his 'misogynism, racism and xenophobia'. In an interview on BBC's Good Morning Scotland show on Thursday, Mr Murray defended his past comments and said it was the 'duty' of the Labour Government to ensure foreign dignitaries were welcomed 'in the right way'. Opposition politicians seized on Mr Murray's 'U-turn' and accused him of taking the public 'for fools'. Andrew Bowie, the shadow Scottish secretary, said: 'He had no credible explanation for his complete U-turn on the importance of President Trump visiting this country. 'I'm glad that Ian Murray has belatedly recognised how vital it is for Scotland to welcome, and work constructively with, the US president – but he'd have more credibility if he put his hands up and owned his past juvenile opportunism. 'No wonder the public are turned off by politics and politicians when they hear the Scottish Secretary trying to take them for fools.' Mr Trump is set to arrive in Scotland on Friday for a five-day visit, where he is expected to visit his golf courses at Turnberry in Ayrshire, and Menie in Aberdeenshire. He will formally open the new 18-hole links MacLeod Course at Menie, named after his Lewis-born mother, Mary MacLeod. Mr Trump will also meet Sir Keir Starmer and John Swinney, Scotland's First Minister. During his BBC interview, Mr Murray was challenged over his support for an early day motion, tabled in the Commons six years ago, that called on then-prime minister Theresa May to rescind the offer of an official state visit to Mr Trump during his first term. The motion, backed by 106 MPs, 'deplored' Mr Trump's record 'including his previous comments on women, refugees and torture and 'condemned' his 'lack of action on climate change and failure to support the Paris climate change deal'. Asked if his view had changed since then, Mr Murray said there was 'global interest' in preserving the relationship between the UK and US. He told the programme: 'The long historic ties, cultural ties, economic ties between the US and the UK, we are the closest allies in the world and we have to make sure we are working together for the benefit of our national interest and the benefit of the global interest as well. Mr Murray also hinted at a potential meeting with the US president but said it had not yet been confirmed, adding: 'My predecessor, David Mundell, met with the president when he last landed in Scotland. 'It's a duty for us to make sure that we are welcoming foreign dignitaries to Scotland in the right way, particularly one that's our closest and nearest ally, both economically and [in] defence and security, and there's lots to talk about, of course.' Mr Trump's visit to Scotland comes after activists placed at his golf course a placard that claimed the luxury resort was 'twinned with Epstein Island' and is expected to be met by protests at his resorts and in Glasgow and Edinburgh. Police from England and Northern Ireland are being drafted in to support Police Scotland amid concerns raised by the Scottish Police Federation, which represents rank-and-file officers, that policing will be 'seriously affected'. Mr Swinney said this week that Mr Trump's time in Scotland would not put policing in a 'detrimental position'. The US president is due to return to the UK in September on a formal state visit during which he and his wife, Melania, will be hosted by King Charles and Queen Camilla at Windsor Castle.

Starmer raises case of Briton detained in India during meeting with Modi
Starmer raises case of Briton detained in India during meeting with Modi

Glasgow Times

time5 minutes ago

  • Glasgow Times

Starmer raises case of Briton detained in India during meeting with Modi

Prime Minister Sir Keir met Narendra Modi on Thursday as the two countries signed a trade deal It is understood that Sir Keir raised the case of Jagtar Singh Johal, a Sikh activist from Dumbarton near Glasgow, who was arrested while in India for his wedding in 2017. Mr Johal's brother Gurpreet had suggested the meeting was a 'golden' chance for the UK Government to seek to secure his release. Thankful to PM Keir Starmer for the warm welcome at Chequers. Our discussions reflect a shared commitment to deepen India-UK ties across sectors.@Keir_Starmer — Narendra Modi (@narendramodi) July 24, 2025 Mr Johan is being held in custody by the Indian authorities, despite having been cleared of one of the cases against him earlier this year. He still faces charges at a federal level, which his supporters, who claim an initial confession he made was as a result of torture, fear could take years to come to a conclusion. Speaking on BBC Radio Scotland on Thursday, Scottish Secretary Ian Murray said the issue was 'complex' but the Government was working to resolve it. 'The Government are doing all we possibly can to get this resolved,' he said. Scottish Secretary Ian Murray said the Government was doing 'all we possibly can' (Ben Whitley/PA) 'There was a recent meeting, just at the start of June, between the Foreign Secretary and his counterpart in India to try and get these issues resolved. 'So it's right at the top of the agenda and we can assure and reassure that we're doing everything we possibly can to get these issues resolved as quickly as possible.' Gurpreet Singh Johal, a Labour councillor in West Dunbartonshire, had earlier told BBC Radio Scotland: 'Raising the case is not enough, it's what we've been saying since day one. 'There's a golden opportunity here for the Prime Minister now, prior to the deal being signed or as the deal is being signed, that he strongly calls for Jagtar to be returned to his family so he can continue his married life.' Mr Murray said: 'The call is for these issues to be resolved and we're all fully on the same page in terms of having to get them resolved as quickly as possible.'

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store