Why Trump wants Harvard to face a steeper penalty than Columbia in the federal funding standoff
The US President Donald Trump is pressing Harvard University to agree to a larger financial settlement than the $221 million deal struck with Columbia University, according to sources familiar with the ongoing negotiations, as reported by The Harvard Crimson.
The talks concern the restoration of over $2 billion in frozen federal research funds.
The White House is reportedly using Columbia's agreement as a "template" and is seeking harsher terms from Harvard to signal a broader policy shift in federal oversight of elite universities. Trump is personally involved in the discussions and has instructed his team to ensure that Harvard's penalty exceeds Columbia's, as reported by The Harvard Crimson.
Columbia's deal sets a precedent
Columbia University reached a settlement with the Trump administration earlier this week, agreeing to pay $221 million in exchange for the restoration of more than $400 million in previously frozen federal research funding. The settlement included $21 million to resolve a Title VII case and came with additional conditions.
As reported by The Harvard Crimson, these conditions included the acceptance of a federally endorsed definition of antisemitism, a rollback of certain diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) initiatives identified as unlawful by the administration, a review of its Middle East studies curriculum, and new screening procedures for international students.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Saharanpur: 1 Trick to Reduce Belly Fat?
Home Fitness Hack
Shop Now
Undo
US Education Secretary Linda McMahon described the Columbia agreement as a "seismic shift" and referred to it as a "roadmap" for future university settlements, including the ongoing negotiations with Harvard, in an interview with CNN as cited by The Harvard Crimson.
Funding freeze and legal disputes continue
Harvard has had more than $2.7 billion in federal research funding frozen following a series of administrative and legal challenges initiated by the Trump administration.
Since April, Harvard has faced investigations into foreign donations, its tax-exempt status, and student visa records. Multiple federal subpoenas have also been issued, according to The Harvard Crimson.
The administration issued a formal finding in late June that Harvard was in violation of Title VI, citing delays in its response to campus antisemitism. Harvard is currently involved in a lawsuit regarding the suspension of federal grants and contracts.
At a recent hearing, US District Judge Allison D. Burroughs expressed scepticism over the government's rationale but has not yet ruled on the case.
Negotiations remain ongoing and confidential
As per The Harvard Crimson, while President Trump stated publicly that Harvard "wants to settle," the university has not confirmed the existence of any official talks. Internally, it has acknowledged discussions with donors and has challenged the administration's demands as unconstitutional in legal filings.
T
he two parties have exchanged several offers in recent weeks, and the administration continues to increase pressure. The Department of Homeland Security has issued subpoenas related to international student conduct, while the Department of State is examining Harvard's capacity to host J-1 visa holders. Meanwhile, the Department of Education has urged Harvard's accreditor to consider revoking its status.
Preceding settlements and anticipated demands
Prior to the Columbia agreement, the University of Pennsylvania also restored its federal funding without paying a financial penalty. Instead, it agreed to prohibit transgender women from competing in women's sports and to strip records and titles from former student Lia Thomas. Unlike Columbia and Harvard, the Pennsylvania case did not involve Title VI or Title VII violations, as noted by The Harvard Crimson.
Although Harvard has yet to finalise an agreement, it has already adopted certain measures resembling concessions, including the adoption of the same antisemitism definition accepted by Columbia, the closure of DEI-related student offices, and administrative changes in its Middle East studies department.
The White House has set a deadline of September 3 for the liquidation of financial obligations tied to the first wave of cancelled grants. Whether a settlement with Harvard will be reached before that date remains uncertain.
TOI Education is on WhatsApp now. Follow us
here
.
Ready to navigate global policies? Secure your overseas future. Get expert guidance now!
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hindu
25 minutes ago
- The Hindu
The Hindu Morning Digest, July 28, 2025
MHA refuses to share data on CAA beneficiaries More than a year after the Citizenship (Amendment) Act, 2019 became effective, the Union Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA) has refused to share data on the total number of beneficiaries under the Act. A Bharatiya Janata Party MP from West Bengal told The Hindu that fewer than 100 people in his constituency had received citizenship under the CAA even though the number of intended beneficiaries, mostly belonging to the Matua sect, were around 1 lakh. There are around 2.8 crore people from the Matua and Namasudra communities who stand to benefit from the CAA in the State. U.S., E.U. reach an 'across the board' agreement on tariffs The United States and the European Union reached a tariff deal after a brief meeting between President Donald Trump and European Commission chief Ursula von der Leyen. A White House deadline was days away for imposing punishing import taxes on the 27-member E.U., which is America's leading global trading partner. Bihar SIR: 91.69% have submitted enumeration forms, says Election Commission of India The Election Commission of India (ECI) said 91.69% of electors registered in the 2025 voter list in Bihar had submitted enumeration forms as part of the ongoing Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls, and these voters will be included in the draft list to be published on August 1. Of the 7.89 crore registered electors as on June 24, over 7.24 crore had submitted enumeration forms indicating overwhelming participation, the poll body said in a statement. Stop SIR in Bihar, refrain from 'institutional arrogance', says INDIA bloc The Indian National Developmental, Inclusive Alliance (INDIA) bloc parties urged the Election Commission of India (EC) to refrain from 'institutional arrogance', and stop the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of the electoral roll in Bihar, saying it has effectively become a process of establishing citizenship. Speaking at a joint press conference, along with Communist Party of India (Marxist-Leninist) Liberation (CPI-ML-L) general secretary Dipankar Bhattacharya, Rashtriya Janata Dal (RJD) MP Manoj Jha, and Communist Party of India-Marxist (CPI-M) leader Nilotpal Basu, Congress Rajya Sabha member Abhishek Manu Singhvi said it was not an issue of 'political obstinacy' or 'institutional arrogance'. Haridwar Mansa Devi temple stampede: Eight dead, several injured; Uttarakhand CM Dhami orders magisterial probe Eight people died and about 30 were injured in a stampede at the Mansa Devi temple in Haridwar in Uttarakhand. Officials said a massive crowd had gathered along the stairway route of the shrine, and the stampede occurred after a rumour that an electric line snapped created panic among the devotees. Those who died include people from Uttar Pradesh, Bihar, and Uttarakhand and aged between 12 and 60 years. Heart-wrenching videos from the spot were making rounds on social media soon after the incident that took place around 9 a.m. Parliament to debate Pahalgam terror attack, but terrorists responsible for it are yet to be brought to justice, says Congress With the Lok Sabha scheduled to start a 16-hour debate on Pahalgam-Operation Sindoor on Monday (July 28, 2025), the Congress said the terrorists involved in the Pahalgam terror attack have not yet been apprehended. The party also pointed out that U.S. President Donald Trump had claimed 26 times that he stopped the India-Pakistan hostilities by 'threatening to stop trade with them'. The Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha Rahul Gandhi is likely to speak on Tuesday in the debate that could stretch for three days. NCB, police in Rajasthan and Maharashtra bust inter-State synthetic drug syndicate The Narcotics Control Bureau (NCB), in coordination with police in Rajasthan and Maharashtra, has busted an inter-State drug syndicate allegedly involved in the clandestine manufacture of synthetic drugs. The NCB said that on July 22, a laboratory was detected inside a buffalo barn located in a secluded village in Rajasthan's Barmer district. During the raid, the Barmer police recovered several precursor chemicals, including chloroform, ammonium chloride, propylene chloride, toluene and bromine, along with equipment used to manufacture Mephedrone. MEA 'nearly lost the plot' on Indus Treaty negotiations, says former Finance Secretary Subhash Garg The Ministry of External Affairs (MEA) nearly 'lost the plot' over the Indus Water Treaty talks with Pakistan in 2016, as senior MEA officials entered into a tussle with the World Bank, before the issue was retrieved — the claim is made by former Finance Secretary Subhash Chandra Garg, India-appointed Executive Director at the World Bank (2014-2017), in his latest book, which recounts for the first time the tensions between the Modi government and World Bank President Jim Kim over the Kishenganga hydropower project. The point of contention was whether the World Bank, which has a limited role in guiding any disputes or differences between India and Pakistan, would decide to appoint the 'court of arbitration' Pakistan had asked for, or a 'neutral expert', as India wanted. RBI monetary panel member sees no challenges in Indian economy growing over 6.5% in FY26 The Indian economy is growing at a robust pace and will not face any challenge in achieving a growth rate upwards of 6.5% in the current financial year, RBI Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) member Nagesh Kumar said. 'Actually, more than a third of global economies are under the debt industrialised economies are facing a lot of pressure, high inflation and the slowdown of economic growth,' he said. India recorded over 7,000 suspected heatstroke cases, 14 deaths in March-June period: RTI India reported 7,192 suspected heatstroke cases and only 14 confirmed deaths due to extreme heat between March 1 and June 24 this year, according to data obtained by PTI under the Right to Information (RTI) Act. The country had reported nearly 48,000 cases of heatstroke and 159 deaths due to extreme heat in 2024, the warmest year on record in India since 1901. The data, shared by the National Centre for Disease Control (NCDC), reveals that the majority of cases were reported in May, the peak of the summer season, with 2,962 suspected cases and three confirmed deaths. 26.34 lakh 'ineligible' beneficiaries will be temporarily suspended under Ladki Bahin scheme The Maharashtra government has revealed that 26.34 lakh beneficiaries, who are ineligible under the Ladki Bahin Scheme, have been temporarily suspended for the June instalment. 'The benefits for 26.34 lakh applicants have been temporarily suspended starting from June 2025. The instalments for the month have been disbursed to 2.25 crore eligible beneficiaries,' said Minister for Women and Child Development Aditi Tatkare, adding the suspended beneficiaries' eligibility will be verified by the respective District Collectors. TCS to cut workforce by 2%, affecting more than 12,000 jobs IT services provider Tata Consultancy Services will reduce its workforce by 2% in its 2026 financial year, primarily affecting middle and senior management, the company said. The company is retraining and redeploying staff as it enters new markets, invests in new technology and deploys AI, but about 12,200 jobs will be cut as part of the process, it said. The $283 billion IT sector has had to contend with clients holding back non-essential technology spending because of weak demand, persistent inflation and lingering uncertainty over U.S. trade policies. ICMR study finds only 28.5% of cancer patients receive radiotherapy in India Radiotherapy is a cornerstone of cancer treatment in India, yet its expansion is hindered by high investment costs and effective planning, target estimation based on cancer burden are crucial to meet the radiotherapy demands of patients with cancer, noted a recent Indian Council for Medical Research (ICMR) study published in the UK-based BioMed Central (BMC) cancer journal early this month. India is faced with a substantial shortfall in radiotherapy utilisation across all cancer types and 28.5 percent of cancer patients receive radiotherapy, which is lower than the estimated optimal rate of 58.4 per cent. Breast, head and neck, lung and cervical cancer account for 60 per cent of India's radiotherapy needs. NCERT developing special module on Operation Sindoor for classes 3 to 12: Sources The NCERT is developing a special classroom module on Operation Sindoor to help students learn about India's defence strategy and diplomatic response, according to sources. The module will have two parts — first for students from class 3 to 8 and another one for students from class 9 to 12. A source said that the special module prepared by the National Council of Educational Research and Training (NCERT) will have 8 to 10 pages focussing on India's strategic military response to the Pahalgam terror attack. Indian batters Ravindra Jadeja and Washington Sundar refused England thrived in high drama yet again to take down Spain in a penalty shootout and win another Women's European Championship title. England had fallen behind in the first half, fought back in the second and relied on its superb substitutes — including Kelly – just as it did against Italy and Sweden previously in the knockout rounds. ENG vs IND, fourth Test: Jadeja, Washington refuse Ben Stokes' offer to call off match before start of mandatory overs Drama unfolded in the high-intensity Anderson-Tendulkar Trophy in Manchester after Indian batters Ravindra Jadeja and Washington Sundar refused England skipper Ben Stokes' offer to call off the fourth Test and settle for a draw before the start of the final hour of play .Having worked hard to earn a creditable draw, Jadeja and Washington, batting on 89 and 80 respectively, refused Stokes' offer after he had approached the umpire, which irked the England skipper no end.
&w=3840&q=100)
Business Standard
25 minutes ago
- Business Standard
Trump calls Thailand-Cambodia truce easy, cites role in India-Pak talks
Following a major fallout after his attempted use of the trade leverage in reaching a ceasefire agreement between Thailand and Cambodia, US President Donald Trump on Sunday (local time) stated that he was optimistic about brokering the peace deal between the Southeast Asian nations, describing the talks as "an easy one," compared to his past claims of resolving the India-Pakistan conflict. Speaking to reporters during his meeting with European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen, Trump reiterated his commitment to using economic pressure to end the ongoing border war between the two Southeast Asian nations. "We're dealing with Thailand, and we do a lot of trade with Thailand and with Cambodia, and yet I'm reading that they're killing each other. You know, they're fighting. They're in a war. And I say this should be an easy one for me because I've settled with India and Pakistan and Serbia and Kosovo were going at it," Trump said. As per Al Jazeera, Cambodia and Thailand, earlier in the day, accused each other of launching artillery attacks, just hours after Trump said both countries had agreed to hash out a ceasefire. The attacks on Sunday came after both sides said they were willing to start talks to end the fighting over their border dispute after Trump spoke to their leaders late on Saturday. Bangkok and Phnom Penh are engaged in a territorial dispute dating back over a century, when colonial-era France first demarcated the border between them, CNN reported. He recounted calling the Prime Minister of Cambodia and the acting Prime Minister of Thailand, asserting, "I said we're not going to make a trade deal unless you settle the war... And I spoke to both of the Prime Ministers, and I think by the time I got off, they wanted to settle now." Trump drew confidence from his mediation efforts, particularly citing the India-Pakistan conflict, which he claimed was "really getting ready to go at it." Trump was referencing the recent India-Pakistan conflict in May, where he had claimed credit several times for brokering a ceasefire between the two nuclear nations, using trade as leverage. The conflict erupted after 26 civilians were killed in the April 22 terror attack in Pahalgam, after which India retaliated through precision strikes under Operation Sindoor, targeting terrorist infrastructure in Pakistan and Pakistan-occupied Jammu and Kashmir (PoJK). However, according to Indian officials, it was Pakistan's Director General of Military Operations (DGMO) who contacted their Indian counterpart to request an end to hostilities, following which the ceasefire was then agreed upon. "Getting those things settled if I can do it and if I can use trade to do that, it's my honour," he added, reflecting his belief in trade as a diplomatic tool. Four days after the worst fighting in more than a decade broke out between the Southeast Asian neighbours, the death toll stood above 30, including 13 civilians in Thailand and eight in Cambodia. Over 200,000 people have also been evacuated from border areas in the two countries, authorities said, as per Al Jazeera. (Only the headline and picture of this report may have been reworked by the Business Standard staff; the rest of the content is auto-generated from a syndicated feed.)
&w=3840&q=100)
Business Standard
25 minutes ago
- Business Standard
Best of BS Opinion: FTA with UK a clear shift in India's stance on trade
India and the UK last week signed on to free trade agreement that promises to be the most expansive the former has had in a few years. But more importantly, says our first editorial, it marks a shift in India's thinking on trade. How far that will carry remains to be seen, especially in the ongoing talks with the European Union, where India might have to concede some more ground in return for the outsize opportunities it can get from the European bloc. India hasn't raised any hackles domestically with the UK FTA, but the real challenge will come when it's time to finalise a similar deal with the US, with which it runs a significant surplus, where both sides are seemingly locked in a staring contest. Our second editorial welcomes the Reserve Bank of India's financial inclusion index, which shows the country is doing better in providing access to financial services. However, more needs to be done in terms of transparency of the diverse data points, which would help make better policy easier. Since the central bank hasn't released a sub-indice-wise score, it is hard to tell where it is lagging, making it harder to target specific areas of concern. It also does not offer much by way of regional disparity, masking continuing financial exclusion of those in underserved regions. More granular data, our editorial says, would go a long way in formulating meaningful policy interventions. It is clear that US President Donald Trump truly believes that high tariffs are a must if America is to succeed, whatever that might mean. Meanwhile, the Yale Budget Lab estimates that US buyers will have to pay at least 20 per cent more at the till - the highest tariff rate in more than a hundred years. While developing nations are likely to face the brunt of these trade deals (Exhibit A: Philippines @ 19% export tariffs, zero on US imports), they are hedging that they will be better off than their peers, notes Mihir S Sharma. But does the US really want to bring some of these low-end manufacturing jobs back home again? Sharma points out that young Americans likely do not want the same jobs that the Greatest Generation or even the Boomers did; it certainly would not bode well either for their weekly cheques or for the US' productivity. L'affaire Jane Street lays bare structural flaws in India's derivatives market, writes Debashis Basu, as he identifies two key issues. The first, he argues, is that the indices used for the futures and options (F&O) markets themselves are flawed. The second is that the claim that derivatives markets enable efficient price discovery and helps investors manage risk is incorrect because the large volumes are limited to just two indices - the Nifty50 and the Bank Nifty (and a bit to FinNifty). To elaborate on his proposition, he considers index construction and the efficiency of the F&O market. The former, Basu writes, is lopsided because of skewed weightages, while the latter has nothing to do with the cash market, making price discovery illusory, liquidity superficial, and hedging merely theoretical, all because the F&O market is limited to two indices, despite the NSE having launched over a dozen other indices. In her review of Sugata Srinivasaraju's The Conscience Network: A Chronicle of Resistance to a Dictatorship, Aditi Phadnis is struck by the author's meticulous research, nuance, and restrained elegance. The book, as she notes, approaches one of the most seminal moments of Indian democracy - the imposition of Emergency - from an angle not many are aware of: the resistance provided by Indians/Indian-Americans living in the United States. These men and women fought against the curtailment of democratic norms and civil rights, inspired by both American values as well as by Mahatma Gandhi and Jayaprakash Narayan, better known as 'JP'. Coincidentally, American democracy had just gone through its own wrenching democratic upheavals - the Vietnam War and Watergate - which helped Indians there find space to voice their protests.
