Erin Patterson spends first night in prison as convicted killer
The 50-year-old mother of two was found guilty of three counts of murder and one count of attempted murder on Monday after a long trial.
Her estranged husband Simon's parents, Don and Gail Patterson, 70, and aunty Heather Wilkinson, 66, all died in hospital days after Patterson served them beef Wellington parcels laced with death cap mushrooms in July 2023.
Heather's husband Ian Wilkinson was the sole survivor.
There was a shout of 'murderer' as Patterson was driven out of the court precinct to prison in Melbourne on Monday evening.
The jury's guilty verdicts came seven days after they were sent away to deliberate and 11 weeks into the trial in the Victorian town of Morwell.
Brianna Chesser, a clinical forensic psychologist and criminal lawyer, said she was not surprised by the outcome.
She argued Patterson's testimony across eight days on the witness stand, as well as circumstantial evidence, likely proved critical to convincing the jury beyond reasonable doubt.
'Whenever you have any lies in a trial it is quite a difficult thing to overcome from a defence perspective,' the associate professor in criminology and justice at RMIT University told AAP.
'What came out regarding the mushrooms was almost insurmountable.
'When you've got particular searches on your phone and a dehydrator that you had and didn't have, it really speaks to the unusualness of the circumstances.'
The story had captivated the world because of the method, as well as the now-convicted murderer being a woman when the vast majority of homicides were perpetrated by men, Dr Chesser said.
Patterson faces a sentence of life in prison for the three murders and one attempted murder and is expected to return to court for a pre-sentence hearing later in 2025.
Options for appeal were usually restricted to points of law, a 'massive' error in fact or new evidence, Dr Chesser said.
'It's going to be quite a large sentence,' she said.
'We've heard during the cross-examination and examination in chief that there are some mental health concerns for Ms Patterson.
'That may well act a mitigating factor in any sort of sentence.
'We're also dealing with someone who's a middle-aged woman who has never offended before in their life and we've got four of the most serious crimes in Victoria being committed.'
Within hours of the verdict, the Supreme Court released dozens of pieces of evidence that helped prosecutors secure the convictions.
They included photos showing remnants of beef Wellington leftovers as they were tested by toxicologists, after police found them inside a bin at Patterson's home
A video of Patterson discharging herself from Leongatha Hospital minutes after she had arrived was also released, while images of her at the hospital revealed a pink phone police say they never recovered.
Prosecutors said this was Patterson's primary phone in 2023 and claimed she had used it to find death cap mushrooms online.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
7NEWS
an hour ago
- 7NEWS
Second person dies after car ploughs into pedestrians near Melbourne playground
A second person has died after a car ploughed into three people as police wait to speak to an elderly driver. The trio was walking on a footpath in suburban Wantirna South, in Melbourne's east, on Thursday when a 91-year-old driver lost control of her car. Know the news with the 7NEWS app: Download today The Toyota Yaris mounted a footpath before hurtling down a hill and smashing through a fence and into a bench. The woman, 59, died at the scene while the man, 60, was taken to hospital in a critical condition. A two-year-old boy was seriously injured but his condition had been stabilised in hospital on Friday. Police said late on Saturday the 60-year-old man had died from his injuries. Investigators, who are yet to interview the elderly driver, will assess whether speed was a contributing factor. The incident has prompted the state government to consider previous calls for older people to prove they are fit to drive, in line with rules in other states. Victoria does not have age-based driving safety requirements, although drivers aged 75 and older must renew their licence every three years, which can involve various tests. NSW, Queensland, the ACT, Tasmania and the Northern Territory require drivers older than 75 to have a health check, while older drivers in South Australia must complete self-assessments. In Western Australia, an annual medical assessment is required to renew a driver's licence from the age of 80. The crash happened during the first week of Victorian school holidays, bringing the state's road toll to 14 in seven days. CCTV has emerged of the aftermath of the tragic incident in which the Toyota Yaris can be seen hurtling down Coleman Rd for about 200m after it struck the trio. The video shows a hubcap flying off the car, rolling down the roads as it trails the car. Superintendent Justin Goldsmith said the car had been on the footpath for 40m to 50m before it hit the pedestrians. He said the driver sustained minor scratches but appeared emotionally shaken. Police have appealed to anyone who witnessed the incident or who has dashcam footage to come forward.
The Advertiser
2 hours ago
- The Advertiser
Second person dies after car crashes into playground
A second person has died after a car ploughed into three people as police wait to speak to an elderly driver. The trio was walking on a footpath in suburban Wantirna South, in Melbourne's east, on Thursday when a 91-year-old driver lost control of her car. The Toyota Yaris mounted a footpath before hurtling down a hill and smashing through a fence and into a bench. The woman, 59, died at the scene while the man, 60, was taken to hospital in a critical condition. A two-year-old boy was seriously injured but his condition had been stabilised in hospital on Friday. Police said late on Saturday the 60-year-old man had died from his injuries. Investigators, who are yet to interview the elderly driver, will assess whether speed was a contributing factor. The incident has prompted the state government to consider previous calls for older people to prove they are fit to drive, in line with rules in other states. The crash happened during the first week of Victorian school holidays, bringing the state's road toll to 14 in seven days. Police have appealed to anyone who witnessed the incident or who has dashcam footage to come forward. A second person has died after a car ploughed into three people as police wait to speak to an elderly driver. The trio was walking on a footpath in suburban Wantirna South, in Melbourne's east, on Thursday when a 91-year-old driver lost control of her car. The Toyota Yaris mounted a footpath before hurtling down a hill and smashing through a fence and into a bench. The woman, 59, died at the scene while the man, 60, was taken to hospital in a critical condition. A two-year-old boy was seriously injured but his condition had been stabilised in hospital on Friday. Police said late on Saturday the 60-year-old man had died from his injuries. Investigators, who are yet to interview the elderly driver, will assess whether speed was a contributing factor. The incident has prompted the state government to consider previous calls for older people to prove they are fit to drive, in line with rules in other states. The crash happened during the first week of Victorian school holidays, bringing the state's road toll to 14 in seven days. Police have appealed to anyone who witnessed the incident or who has dashcam footage to come forward. A second person has died after a car ploughed into three people as police wait to speak to an elderly driver. The trio was walking on a footpath in suburban Wantirna South, in Melbourne's east, on Thursday when a 91-year-old driver lost control of her car. The Toyota Yaris mounted a footpath before hurtling down a hill and smashing through a fence and into a bench. The woman, 59, died at the scene while the man, 60, was taken to hospital in a critical condition. A two-year-old boy was seriously injured but his condition had been stabilised in hospital on Friday. Police said late on Saturday the 60-year-old man had died from his injuries. Investigators, who are yet to interview the elderly driver, will assess whether speed was a contributing factor. The incident has prompted the state government to consider previous calls for older people to prove they are fit to drive, in line with rules in other states. The crash happened during the first week of Victorian school holidays, bringing the state's road toll to 14 in seven days. Police have appealed to anyone who witnessed the incident or who has dashcam footage to come forward. A second person has died after a car ploughed into three people as police wait to speak to an elderly driver. The trio was walking on a footpath in suburban Wantirna South, in Melbourne's east, on Thursday when a 91-year-old driver lost control of her car. The Toyota Yaris mounted a footpath before hurtling down a hill and smashing through a fence and into a bench. The woman, 59, died at the scene while the man, 60, was taken to hospital in a critical condition. A two-year-old boy was seriously injured but his condition had been stabilised in hospital on Friday. Police said late on Saturday the 60-year-old man had died from his injuries. Investigators, who are yet to interview the elderly driver, will assess whether speed was a contributing factor. The incident has prompted the state government to consider previous calls for older people to prove they are fit to drive, in line with rules in other states. The crash happened during the first week of Victorian school holidays, bringing the state's road toll to 14 in seven days. Police have appealed to anyone who witnessed the incident or who has dashcam footage to come forward.
West Australian
5 hours ago
- West Australian
Childcare in Perth: Daycare centres charging over maximum rate cap as daily prices surge above $200
More than one third of childcare centres are charging fees above the maximum recommended by the Federal Government — the highest percentage since the subsidy was introduced in 2018 — as daily prices in Perth surge to above $200 in some suburbs. According to Federal Government data, 34.9 per cent of childcare centres in Australia had hourly fees over the maximum rate cap of $14.29 in the March quarter, compared to 29.9 per cent in the previous quarter and 12.5 per cent five years ago. The hourly-fee cap is set by the Government as a guide for what a 'high fee' might be, and it's the maximum rate the government will subsidise. A family's Child Care Subsidy percentage applies to the lowest of either the cap, or the hourly fee charged by their childcare provider, so families pay the difference when childcare centres charge above the cap. Last Monday, July 7, the CCS hourly rate cap increased to $14.63 in line with the Consumer Price Index. But the industry has warned the rise is not enough. Rachelle Tucker, the chief executive of the Australian Childcare Alliance WA, said the increase in centres charging above the hourly cap was concerning from an affordability perspective. 'But it is a reflection of the growing gap between the actual cost of delivering quality early learning and the CCS system's capped rates,' she said. 'The fee cap has not kept pace with the real costs of service delivery, especially for services in high-cost areas or those with higher staffing needs to support quality ratios and educational outcomes.' She added it was important to note that charging above the cap did not necessarily mean services were over-charging. 'It often means they are trying to cover their genuine operating costs,' she said. The revelations come at a time of turmoil for the sector, with educators, parents and providers reeling from allegations against Victorian man Joshua Dale Brown, who was charged with dozens of child sex offences allegedly committed against eight children at a Melbourne childcare centre. The WA Government has ordered a snap review of child safety in the State in light of the allegations. Last weekend, The West Australian revealed that hundreds of WA childcare centres either don't meet minimum quality standards or are yet to be rated. The State has the lowest proportion of centres that exceed the minimum standards, and none of its almost 1500 childcare services are rated 'excellent'. Government data shows fees in WA have increased by 15 per cent or $1.90 an hour in the past two years, to an average of $13.90 an hour across the country. Daily fees across Perth have hit $200 — before the CCS — in some areas. In response to a Facebook post on a parents' forum this week, dozens of Perth mothers shared their daily fees, starting as low as $119 and reaching $215. The six Schools of Early Learning are among the most expensive. Its North Perth centre has a two-day minimum costing $424. The price decreases each additional day to $905 for five days. Last year the Federal Government announced a 15 per cent pay rise for almost 200,000 childcare educators as part of a $3.6 billion package — but centres could only access the funding if they agreed to cap any fee increases at 4.4 per cent. Ms Tucker said while many centres had done their best to remain within the cap, 'the reality is that it is becoming increasingly difficult to absorb the rising costs of operating without passing some of those costs on to families. 'The cap is a blunt instrument that doesn't account for the significant cost increases in wages, utilities, food, rent, and compliance,' she said. 'Services are trying to balance affordability for families with the financial sustainability required to maintain quality and retain staff. Many services are operating on very tight margins, with little financial buffer.' Minister for Early Childhood Education Jess Walsh said the Government's early childhood education reforms, introduced two years ago, had delivered relief to more than one million families. 'For a family earning $168,000, with one child in care 30 hours a week, our reforms have cut out-of-pocket costs by around $7440 than they otherwise would be,' she said. 'We want to make sure workers can be fairly paid without the costs being passed onto families.' The Government is taking compliance action against centres that breach the 4.4 per cent fee cap, but it is understood the vast majority of centres have kept within the rules.
