Gambhir, Stokes differ on 'ridiculous' injury replacement player debate; last hour drama on day 5
Ben Stokes
and India head coach
Gautam Gambhir
on Sunday expressed contrasting views on the use of injury replacements in Test cricket, with the former dismissing the debate as "ridiculous".
The question on the subject was asked in the light of injury to Rishabh Pant in the Manchester Test where he batted despite a broken foot. However, he was in no position to keep wickets and
Dhruv Jurel
stood behind the stumps to cover for Pant.
Explore courses from Top Institutes in
Please select course:
Select a Course Category
Technology
Digital Marketing
Healthcare
Others
Product Management
Management
Cybersecurity
Project Management
Public Policy
Finance
MCA
CXO
others
Leadership
Artificial Intelligence
Data Analytics
healthcare
Data Science
PGDM
Design Thinking
MBA
Operations Management
Data Science
Degree
Skills you'll gain:
Duration:
12 Weeks
MIT xPRO
CERT-MIT XPRO Building AI Prod India
Starts on
undefined
Get Details
"I think it is absolutely ridiculous there is a conversation around an injury replacement. There would be too many loopholes for a team to go through. You pick an 11 for the game, injuries are part of it. I think that conversation should be shut down," said Stokes.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Mountain Gear for Extreme Conditions
Trek Kit India
Learn More
Undo
Gambhir, however, is all for the injury substitute.
A
concussion substitute
was introduced in the wake of Australian opener Phil Hughes' untimely death in 2014 after being hit on the head but there is no such provision in case of any other serious injury.
Live Events
"Absolutely, I'm all for it, if the umpires and the match referee sees and feels that there's a major injury. It's very important to have this rule, where you can get a substitute. That is, if it's very visible, there's nothing wrong in doing that. Especially in a series like this, where it's been such a closely fought series, in the previous 3 Test matches," Gambhir said.
"Imagine if we would have had to play with 10 people, 10 men against 11. How unfortunate would this be for us."
Tensions over not calling off the game before start of mandatory overs
Stokes wanted to shake hands when 15 overs were left in the game and the only possible result was a draw. However, India did not accept the offer as Jadeja and Washington were closing on hundreds after batting for more than two sessions. The decision did not sit well with the England camp.
"We took the game as far as we could with our frontline bowlers to think we have a real chance of winning it. As soon as it got to the point where a draw was inevitable I was never going to risk any of my frontline bowlers with the short turnaround.
"The only other person who has got some bowling workload into them was Harry Brook (laughs) but I did have to tell him, don't do anything stupid."
Gambhir had an entirely different take on the developments of the last hour.
"If someone is batting on 90 and the other one is batting on 85, don't they deserve a hundred? Would they have walked off if someone from England's side would have been batting on 90 or 85? ," Gambhir asked.
"If someone has the opportunity to get his first Test hundred, won't you allow him to do it? They weathered the storm. It's up to them.
"If they want to play that way, that's up to them. I've got nothing more to say. I think both those guys deserved a hundred, and fortunately they got it," he added.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India Today
12 minutes ago
- India Today
Shubman Gill responds to Oval pitch row: No Instructions on 2.5-metre rule
India captain Shubman Gill has commented on head coach Gautam Gambhir's spat with the pitch curator at the oval. Gambhir got involved in a heated altercation with pitch curator Lee Fortis after he was denied to have a close look at the pitch. Indian batting Sitanshu Kotak also shared the details of the incident and revealed that the tone in which Fortis yelled at the Indian support staff made Gambhir Gill has also given his take on the controversy and revealed that there was no such instructions for them to stay 2.5 metres behind the wicket. He asserted that one is allowed to go near the pitch while being barefoot or wearing rubber spikes."As far as I remember, there's no such instruction (on staying 2.5 metres behind). As long as you're wearing rubber spikes or you're barefoot, I think you're allowed to look at the wicket closely. I don't know exactly what happened yesterday in terms of why their curator stopped them, but we've played four matches there before and no one has ever stopped us. We've all played a lot of cricket and have looked at wickets many times—whether it's the coach or the captain—so I don't know what all that fuss was about,' said Gill in the pre-match press conference. Furthermore, Gill called the moment unnecessary reiterating that the captain and the coach have every right to look at the wicket closely.'What happened yesterday, I thought is just absolutely unnecessary. If a pitch curator is going to come and ask us to not look at the wicket and look at the wicket from 3 m from behind, that's not something, that has happened to us before. It's not the first time that we were having a look at the wicket. Like I said, a coach and the captain has every right to be able to go close quarters and have a look at the wicket. And I didn't think that there was anything wrong with that,' he have once again heated up in the series after India denied Ben Stokes' offer to draw the fourth Test early and the Gambhir incident has only added fuel to the fire. It remains to be seen how these incidents will fire up the team to put up a remarkable performance in the fifth Test set to begin from July 31 at the Oval.- EndsTune InMust Watch
India.com
12 minutes ago
- India.com
Why Did Ben Stokes Pull Out Of Oval Test Against India? Heres What He Revealed
England Test captain Ben Stokes has been ruled out of the fifth and final match of the Anderson Tendulkar Trophy 2025 due to a shoulder injury. In his absence, Ollie Pope will lead the side in the series finale at The Kennington Oval in London. Stokes, who has played a pivotal role throughout the series, expressed disappointment at missing the match but emphasized that the risk of aggravating the injury was not worth taking. "I'm obviously disappointed. I've got the decent tear in the right shoulder in the muscles I can't pronounce. I came down here this morning trying to find ways just to contribute to the batting. After discussions with the medical team, it was decided. The risk was way too much high. I wouldn't have expected anyone else in my place to risk this as well. I'll start rehabbing now and start to focus on what we have coming up in the winter," Stokes said in a statement as qouted by Sports Tak. The England captain will now shift his attention to recovering in time for the upcoming Ashes series in Australia later this year. Series Situation and Stokes' Impact England currently lead the five-match series 2-1 heading into the final Test. Stokes has been a standout performer, particularly in the fourth Test in Manchester, where he overcame hamstring cramps and bicep tendon discomfort. He picked up a five-wicket haul and followed it up with a gritty 141 off 198 deliveries. He also dismissed KL Rahul on Day 5, though the match ended in a draw. Statistically, Stokes is the leading wicket-taker in the series so far, having taken 17 wickets from four Tests at an average of 25.25, including one five-wicket haul. He has bowled a total of 140 overs in the series. With the bat, he has scored 304 runs across seven innings at an average of 43.43. England's Revised Squad for the Fifth Test Along with Stokes, Liam Dawson, Jofra Archer and Brydon Carse have also been rested for the final match. Young talents Jacob Bethell, Jamie Overton, Gus Atkinson and Josh Tongue have been included in the playing eleven. England XI for the 5th Test Zak Crawley, Ben Duckett, Ollie Pope (captain), Joe Root, Harry Brook, Jacob Bethell, Jamie Smith (wicketkeeper), Chris Woakes, Gus Atkinson, Jamie Overton, Josh Tongue India's updated squad for the fifth Test: Shubman Gill (C), Yashasvi Jaiswal, KL Rahul, Sai Sudharsan, Abhimanyu Easwaran, Karun Nair, Ravindra Jadeja, Dhruv Jurel (WK), Washington Sundar, Shardul Thakur, Jasprit Bumrah, Mohd. Siraj, Prasidh Krishna, Akash Deep, Kuldeep Yadav, Anshul Kamboj, Arshdeep Singh, N Jagadeesan (WK). The fifth Test between England and India is scheduled to begin on July 31, with both teams eyeing a strong finish to an intense serie
NDTV
24 minutes ago
- NDTV
England's Hypocrisy Exposed? Oval Curator, Coach Brendon McCullum Stand Next To The Pitch Day After Gambhir Row
India head coach Gautam Gambhir 's heated altercation with Surrey pitch curator Lee Fortis on Tuesday sparked a major controversy, ahead of the fifth and final Test at The Oval, starting July 31. Fortis spoke rudely to Gambhir's support staff for standing close to the pitch, triggering a strong response from the Indian head coach. According to India's batting coach, Shitanshu Kotak, the curator insisted they remain at least 2.5 metres away from the deck. Gambhir blasted Fortis after the same, saying: "You can't tell us what do" A day after his clash with Gambhir, Fortis has now come under the scanner once again. In a viral picture, Fortis was seen standing close to the pitch, alongside England head coach Brendon McCullum and home team skipper Ben Stokes. Wednesday's open access pitch inspection was in complete contrast to events from the previous day, where the Indian team was denied access to the same. Interestingly, Fortis has been accused of being hostile to visiting teams in the past. According to rumours, he had a similar heated incident with the Indian Women's cricket team when they played the 3rd T20I against England Women at The Oval earlier this month. Batting coach Sitanshu Kotak had to step in to defuse the situation, escorting Fortis away while Gambhir continued to argue from a distance. The incident, captured on video, quickly went viral on social media, adding to the tension surrounding the Test series finale. India, trailing 1-2 in the five-match series, arrived in London just a day earlier after a gutsy draw in Manchester. The team was welcomed at a reception hosted by the Indian High Commission, where Gambhir delivered a passionate speech reflecting on the series. The heated exchange is the latest flashpoint in a series filled with emotional flare-ups - from Shubman Gill 's displeasure at England's delayed re-entry at the Lord's, to the standoff at Old Trafford where Ben Stokes and his team bristled after Indian batters refused an early handshake, prioritising their centuries instead. With the series on the line and tempers already flaring, the final Test at The Oval, starting on Thursday, promises to be a charged affair both on and off the field.
