Vat legal challenge could have wider implications
The next crucial chapter in the value-added tax (Vat) case before the Western Cape High Court relates to the power given to the minister of finance to alter a tax rate by virtue of an announcement in the annual budget.
Political parties the DA and EFF challenge the constitutionality of Section 7(4) of the Vat Act. However, this case may even have wider implications since the Income Tax Act bestows a similar power on the minister of finance to alter other tax rates, including income tax, donations tax and dividend-withholding tax.
In 2022 Ben Cronin, lecturer at the University of Cape Town and advocate of the high court, in his thesis 'Law by decree: A critique of section 5(2) of the Income Tax Act' addressed the question of whether the power to 'alter a tax rate by announcement' infringes on the separation-of-powers doctrine and the Constitution.
This unique power has never been tested in court.
However, this specific power and Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana's reliance on Section 7(4) of the Vat Act to raise the rate in his budget from 15% to 15.5% is now being challenged.
Section 7(4) of the Vat Act bestows the minister with the same powers as Section 5(2) of the Income Tax Act to increase the tax rate by way of an announcement in his annual budget.
The Western Cape High Court has suspended the Vat rate increase pending the passing of legislation regulating the rate or the final determination of Part B (of the applications) – whichever occurs first.
ALSO READ: Godongwana consents to court order against VAT increase
Constitutional validity
In Part B the DA asks the court to declare Section 7(4) of the Vat Act constitutionally invalid. The declaration should only be retrospective to 1 March 2025. It does not ask for full retrospectivity as that would undo the increase from 14% to 15% in 2018.
Two issues that came before the court when the DA, EFF, speaker of parliament, and the minister of finance presented their cases related to separation of power between the legislature and the executive, and public participation.
These issues were extensively dealt with in Cronin's thesis that questioned the delegation of power that allows the minister to increase tax rates in the Income Tax Act, 'whether income tax, donations tax, or dividends withholding tax'.
These taxes have all been amended subject to a ratification by parliament within 12 months.
This unique power given to the minister was first introduced in 2016 and has subsequently been substituted by Section 3 of the Taxation Laws Amendment Act of 2018.
'Section 5(2) of the Income Tax Act as it reads today, in fact, represents a dramatic departure from the pre-existing statutory regime which recognised the authority of Parliament to determine the income tax rate on an annual basis,' Cronin stated in his thesis.
An important question that he addressed is whether parliament could 'assign an inherently legislative power to a member of the executive – namely to make law'.
ALSO READ: Practical implications of reversing the 0.5% VAT increase – Sars
Delegation of power
Cronin quotes the Second Executive Council Judgment case before the Constitutional Court, where the court's position appeared to be that parliament simply cannot delegate its plenary function to make primary legislation.
There is scope for the delegation of secondary law-making powers to members of the executive, but in this regard the legislature must nevertheless jealously guard its exclusive legislative competence and can only justifiably delegate such secondary law-making powers within the context of clear legislative guidelines.
The 'outright assignment' of the power to announce new tax rates in Section 5(2) of the Income Tax Act is therefore incompatible with the application of the Separation of Powers Doctrine envisaged by the Constitutional Court.
Cronin added that when parliament purported to delegate the power to determine and amend the income tax rate in terms of Section 5(2), it was attempting to assign a power that 'exceeds the competence of Parliament itself'.
'The law-making process cannot be given effect to by mere fiat declarations and in its original or plenary form it certainty cannot be delegated away by Parliament,' he argued.
ALSO READ: Budget 3.0 not unexpected, possible decrease in social grant increase
Public participation
Cronin also noted in his thesis that parliament must create opportunities to comment and influence the final wording of legislation.
This is simply 'axiomatically not possible' where laws are amended by mere announcement by a member of the executive as is envisaged in Section 5(2) of the Income Tax Act.
He submitted that if the minister uses the section to 'unilaterally amend a standing law', he would be indirectly pulling the entire law-making process into the troubled waters of conflicting directly with the Constitution that requires public access to and involvement in the legislative processes of the National Assembly.
This article was republished from Moneyweb. Read the original here.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
26 minutes ago
- The Citizen
Bridge delays drag on
It has been two weeks since repairs to the Mzimkhulu River bridge came to an abrupt halt. Emergency repairs were supposed to run for six months but, with delays and issues in trying to close the river mouth, the October deadline does not look like it will be met. Leon Garbade (DA councillor in Ray Nkonyeni Municipality), said the ongoing issue of unpaid contractors, who have understandably ceased work, only serves to exacerbate an already dire situation. He said that observing the bridge, and what is labelled a construction site under Siboniso Duma's (MEC for Transport and Human Settlements) oversight, reveals a disheartening lack of progress with little to show, even during periods of contractor activity. 'We stand with the affected communities and demand immediate action from the Department of Transport (DoT) to revive this project and others that have similarly faltered. It is time to stop placing blame elsewhere and to focus on getting the government's house in order,' said Garbade. Nazir Shaikh, chairperson of the North Cluster Ratepayers' Association, said the operations of the DoT throughout the South Coast have ceased, including on Marine Drive. 'Regrettably, the public remains inadequately informed. An inspection of the bridge on Monday last week revealed an absence of workers and that construction machinery had been removed from below the bridge. In addition, the condition of the P464 roadway is deteriorating daily, with motor vehicle breakdowns and accidents occurring on a weekly basis,' he said. Meanwhile, Duma said in last Friday's Re-tabling of Budget speech that of the R13b budget, the DoT would need between R1.1b and R1.2b on a monthly basis to pay service providers. This applies to contractors who are responsible for the maintenance and construction of more than 54km of road networks on the South Coast. He said that the migration with regards the accounts payment system had given problems due to technical glitches, resulting in delays in the payment of invoices. Duma explained that currently, the DoT is getting only R800m from the provincial treasury and last month only received R560m. In short, it means ensuring payment to service providers within 30 days is not currently possible. Duma said the DoT would continue to engage with the provincial treasury to consolidate gains and address this challenge, in particular. 'The department has internalised the fact it will be blamed for not paying invoices, despite having enough budget,' he said. 'This has affected all government departments and the matter is being managed collectively. We have also briefed the Auditor General.' The spokesperson for the DoT, Ndabezinhle Sibiya, explained that the main aim for the bridge project now is to divert the water from pillar two to pillar eight, which has taken more than three months. 'Once closure of the mouth is concluded at pillar two the project will intensify.' HAVE YOUR SAY Like the South Coast Herald's Facebook page, follow us on Twitter and Instagram
The Citizen
41 minutes ago
- The Citizen
R270m budgeted to deal with crumbling road infrastructure
The City of Ekurhuleni (CoE) is beleaguered by a series of severe road infrastructure challenges, such as sinkholes, potholes, traffic light malfunctions and road maintenance backlog. Owing to that, the CoE announced on June 25 that it has set aside at least R275m for urgent maintenance of the city's road network in the 2025/26 financial year, with special focus on potholes, storm water drainage and damaged bridges. Metro spokesperson Zweli Dlamini said crews are already hard at work carrying out proactive maintenance. To prevent flooding ahead of the rainy season, crews are unblocking kerb inlets, repairing damaged drain systems and removing weeds and debris from stormwater systems. Full budget Presenting the city's budget, Finance MMC Jongizizwe Dlabathi acknowledged that the issue of potholes is steadily becoming an albatross for the city. He said this is not only impacting road users, but also the economy of the region, as roads are the backbone of the movement of goods and services. 'For this reason, of the total budget of R946m allocated for Roads and Transport Management, R527m will be for road rehabilitation and patching of potholes. 'Further to this, R41.3m will be used for repairing and maintaining traffic signals and R207m for the procurement of material and supplies to enable internal capacity to further patch potholes, to undertake road marking, signage and stormwater maintenance,' he said. Meagre budget The DA described the amount allocated for road repairs as a 'meagre' budget that represents 7% of what is needed to repair the city's crumbling road network. According to the party, a response to its written questions to the provincial government revealed that it will cost at least R65b to repair the worst of the CoE's 1 619km road network. The DA said the reply indicated that 8 245.53km of roads were assessed for their structural condition in 2019 and were categorised as follows: • Very good: 19.54% • Good: 12.97% • Fair: 37.27% • Poor: 9.98% • Very poor: 20.06% 'Since this assessment, the conditions of the city's roads have deteriorated considerably, and the cost of repairs would have ballooned. 'With the current budget set aside for road maintenance, the city cannot even keep up with repairing potholes and roads,' said MPL Michael Waters, DA constituency head Kempvale. Stormwater drainage system According to Dlamini, their teams discovered common debris clogging the drainage system at a recent stormwater drainage clearing operation on the corner of Edendale and Main roads in Eastleigh. These included empty bottles, plastic waste, motor oil and other hazardous substances and general litter and refuse obstructing water flow, increasing the risk of flooding and causing environmental pollution. 'While this societal problem does not absolve the city of its responsibility to maintain the road infrastructure and ensure that drain systems remains free from items that could leave them clogged, authorities urge residents to play their part, and join the metro in protecting the stormwater systems and the environment at large by taking responsibility for their waste disposal habits,' said Dlamini. Benefits of keeping drains clear include: • Preventing flooding that damages property and disrupts daily activities. • Protecting public health by reducing stagnant water that can harbor disease-carrying mosquitoes and bacteria. • Extending the lifespan of roads and infrastructure by preventing water-related erosion and structural damage. • Enhancing environmental quality by preventing polluted run-off from entering natural waterways. Also Read: Missing man found in Rondebult Road sinkhole with bullet wounds to the head
The Citizen
an hour ago
- The Citizen
What triggered Emma Powell's fall?
Emma Powell recently resigned from her position as DA spokesperson for International Relations citing a targeted campaign of intimidation. Politicians are fond of saying: 'If you expect loyalty, get a dog.' To which journalists might reply: 'If you expect basic human decency from a politician, get a grip.' Last week, the DA allowed the ANC to hound from office its own foreign policy lead. Emma Powell resigned from the position after a protracted campaign of abuse and threats from the ANC, which mobilised the state security apparatus and pliant media against her. Astoundingly, the DA parliamentary leadership uttered not a public word of rebuke that Powell felt so beleaguered by the campaign against her by their government of national unity partner that she threw in the towel. The biggest challenge for the DA in its partnership with the ANC was always going to be retaining its political integrity. It had to balance its place holder role – keeping at bay an alternative ANC coalition with the hard left – while continuing to challenge a corrupt and incompetent government. John Steenhuisen has failed to manage this tension well. The principled opposition part of the package has been largely abandoned. It's been traded for a handful of ministerial positions and the giddy excitement of accompanying Cyril Ramaphosa and Paul Mashatile on foreign jaunts, where the DA leader is trotted out as a show pony to illustrate the GNU's legitimacy. Not everyone in the DA is happy with this. While the parliamentary caucus and, more specifically, the ministerial handful, are preoccupied with preserving access and proximity to power, many within the party's broader membership base remain committed to the DA's traditional liberal-democratic values. Appeasement backfiring Ironically, appeasement does not strengthen Steenhuisen's hand with the ANC, but weakens it. Every DA red line that the ANC turns into a skipping rope makes inevitable the next concession. The campaign against Powell was orchestrated across multiple fronts, driven by intersecting resentments within the ANC, department of international relations and cooperation (Dirco). At the heart of it was her effectiveness – despite her comparative youth and only a couple of years in the job – as a critic of South Africa's foreign policy. This made her intolerable to a government that is increasingly allergic to scrutiny. First came ANC fury over Powell's participation, alongside then deputy minister of trade and industry Andrew Whitfield, in a DA delegation to Washington in March. Then came the backlash from the powerful pro-Hamas clique in Dirco to a fact-finding visit to Israel by opposition MPs. Perhaps most damaging to Steenhuisen's tjommie relationship with President Cyril Ramaphosa – now performing on the international circuit as the Smooth Cyril and Jovial John show – is her exposure of our president as a fantasist and flat-out liar about Mcebisi Jonas. Powell released an explosive statement asserting that the US had denied Jonas a diplomatic visa in May, had formally rejected his credentials as interlocutor and that the Presidency had repeatedly been told this. Now the heavy artillery was brought to bear. A leaked intelligence report originating from the National Security Council claimed that Powell was under investigation for treason for 'spreading misinformation' during her US trip. Again, the DA remained tjoepstil. In the face of the scale of ANC's disenchantment with Powell, it's not beyond imagining Ramaphosa laying down his own red line with Steenhuisen: get rid of that troublesome spokesperson, or else. NOW READ: The Jaundiced Eye: The building is burning – but it's fine
