Aurangzeb tomb protest
Listen to article
Hindutva goons in India have a new target these days, as they have begun a violent campaign to try and get the tomb of Mughal emperor Aurangzeb "removed" and replaced with a memorial for Hindu Maratha rulers of the region. The recent violence in Nagpur has so far seen extremists — who were inspired by, if not directly affiliated with, the Vishva Hindu Parishad (VHP) extremist group — riot and attack the police to demand the removal of the tomb, which is over 400km away from Nagpur.
The trigger point for the protest was reportedly a recent Bollywood movie about Sambhaji — a Maratha ruler who fought and got defeated by Aurangzeb, who then ordered him to be tortured and killed. The movie includes a graphic depiction of him being tortured. However, it also ignores - or rewrites — the fact that the real Sambhaji was betrayed by upper-caste Hindus who were bribed by Aurangzeb, because this would go against the myth portraying them as noble religious warriors, rather than unscrupulous politicians.
Unfortunately, like most forms of extremist ideologies, logic is the greatest enemy of Hindutva. It is also worth noting that the VHP makes Modi's strain of Hindutva seem almost inclusive — VHP leaders have said they were the real masterminds of the 2002 Gujarat riots, and Modi was simply their pawn.
The group is one of the most virulent far-right extremist organisations in India and, thus, the source of some of the most outlandish historical conspiracy theories. The tomb removal demand is a reflection of this. Unlike most recent attempts to raze mosques and replace them with temples, Aurangzeb's tomb has little religious value for Muslims, and the Hindu extremists are not demanding a temple to replace it, or claiming that a temple once stood in its place.
The objective is a straight-up attempt at historical erasure — razing and replacing the tomb of the last great Mughal emperor with a monument to a Hindu Maratha ruler, never mind that Aurangzeb's tomb happens to be located on the shrine of a Muslim saint, which would be an odd location to memorialise a Hindu king.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
9 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Pakistan budget for FY2025-26 in brief
Finance Minister Muhammad Aurangzeb announced Pakistan's federal budget 2025-26 'for a competitive economy' on Tuesday, targeting a modest 4.2% growth for the coming fiscal year, compared to 2.7% expected in the outgoing FY25. 'Because every number is locked, so we have to get money from somewhere to provide relief somewhere,' Aurangzeb said in the post-budget press conference on Wednesday. 'This is a work in progress.' Business Recorder has brought to our readers a 'Budget in Brief' that gives an overview of the federal budget for FY2025-26. The brief provides a glimpse of key priorities and objectives of the federal government, offers a summary of revenue and expenditures, fiscal deficit targets and the corresponding financing plan. Income tax calculator for FY 2025-26 The following document also provides a detailed breakdown of tax and non tax receipts, projected share of provinces under the NFC Award, capital and external receipts, and current expenditures along with its functional classification. Allocations for subsidies, grants and transfers, as well as PSDP are also provided.
Business Recorder
9 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Finance Bill 2025 draws criticism for ‘overlooking youth-centric measures'
The federal government's Finance Bill 2025 has come under criticism from policy analysts and youth advocates for 'failing to include dedicated programmes or fiscal incentives' targeting Pakistan's youth, despite young people comprising over 60 percent of the population. The Finance Bill, which outlines the government's taxation and spending priorities for the fiscal year 2025–26, contains no explicit allocations for youth employment, entrepreneurship, skills development, or student-focused tax relief. 'There are no tailored measures that directly address the employment crisis faced by young people,' said Ahmed, a senior economist. 'With more than two million youth entering the workforce annually, the absence of structured support mechanisms is a significant oversight.' Speaking at the post-budget press conference on Wednesday, Finance Minister Aurangzeb acknowledged the demographic significance of Pakistan's youth and emphasised the government's broader approach. 'The government has to provide an enabling environment for youth,' the minister stated, acknowledging the $400 million freelancers contributed to the economy last year. He also added how the private sector has to lead this charge, while pointing to the bill's broader economic reforms and digital modernisation measures as indirect enablers. However, critics argue that the enabling environment remains largely undefined in fiscal terms. Limited indirect benefits through education sector The bill does grant tax exemptions to certain private universities and nonprofit educational foundations. Yet analysts say these provisions are legacy measures and do little to expand youth access to affordable or skills-oriented education. Notably, no direct funding or fiscal relief has been announced for technical and vocational training—an area widely regarded as essential to addressing the skills mismatch in the labor market. The government has allocated Rs39.488 billion in 2025-26 for Higher Education Commission (HEC), down from Rs61.115 billion the previous fiscal year in the Public Sector Development Programme (PSDP) - the main instrument for improving the socio-economic conditions in the country. Digital reforms, but no startup support While the Finance Bill 2025 introduces significant reforms in e-commerce taxation and digital tracking systems, including compliance requirements for online marketplaces and payment intermediaries, no financial incentives or startup support mechanisms have been included for small digital sellers, freelancers, or youth-led enterprises. 'There is increased enforcement, but no corresponding support for the entrepreneurs powering Pakistan's digital economy,' said a consultant in the startup ecosystem. 'This could discourage youth participation rather than promote formalization.' Policy experts suggest that the government could have introduced: Tax holidays or reduced corporate rates for youth-led startups. Special registration regimes for digital freelancers. Targeted subsidies or hiring incentives for businesses employing young workers. National entrepreneurship development grants or incubator networks. Instead, the budget emphasises enforcement, including provisions that allow the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) to freeze bank accounts and restrict property transfers of non-filers. Broader implications Observers say the absence of youth-focused fiscal measures points to a disconnect between demographic urgency and policy planning. 'A budget that does not invest in its youth is out of sync with the country's long-term economic needs,' said an analyst. The Finance Bill 2025 is currently under debate in Parliament and is expected to be passed before the end of June.
Business Recorder
11 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Post-budget presser: ‘Have to get money from somewhere to provide relief somewhere', says Auranzgeb
Federal Minister for Finance and Revenue Muhammad Aurangzeb on Wednesday addressed the concerns of stakeholders regarding the budget for fiscal year 2025-26 presented before the National Assembly (NA) a day ago. Addressing the media persons, Aurangzeb maintained that the income tax levy for the salaried persons earning between Rs600,000 and Rs1.2 million annually is 2.5%. 'Because every number is locked, so we have to get money from somewhere to provide relief somewhere,' he said. 'This is a work in progress.' During the budget speech, Aurangzeb proposed halving the income tax rate to 2.5% for the salaried persons earning between Rs600,000 and Rs1.2 million annually. However, it is important to note that there was a discrepancy between the rate announced during the speech and the rate stated in the Finance Bill — the latter sets the tax at an even lower 1% for this income bracket. The finance minister reiterated that the government remains committed to issuing the inaugural Panda bond during this calendar year. 'We do want to access the euro and US dollar market, we anticipate entering these markets in 2026, certainly not during this calendar year, as we need to achieve a certain rating,' he said. Aurangzeb said that the tariff reform mentioned during the budget speech 'is very significant' for the country and will enhance the country's exports. 'Out of a total of 7,000 tariff lines, the government has decided to eliminate additional customs duty on 4,000 of them,' he said. Fiscal space limited Aurangzeb said that the government wanted to provide maximum relief to the salaried class, but added, 'The reality is that we can only offer as much relief as our fiscal space permits.' The country's tax-to-GDP ratio has reached 10.3% in the current fiscal year. 'In FY26 we intend to increase it to 10.9%,' he said. 'We need enabling amendments and legislation to plug leakages in the system, so the government doesn't have to resort to additional taxation measures of around Rs400-500 billion,' Aurangzeb said. The finance minister noted that the government expenditure has increased by 1.9% this fiscal year. 'We have not imposed any additional tax on the agriculture sector,' he said. The government will provide soft-term loans to small farmers. The finance minister noted that the government expenditure has increased by 1.9%. Meanwhile, Finance Secretary Imdadullah Bosal clarified that the increase is limited to critical needs. Surcharge on Electricity Bills On reports regarding the imposition of a 10% surcharge on electricity bills, Chairman FBR, Rashid Mehmood Langrial, clarified that no additional surcharge has been imposed. Responding to a query on how the federal government could delink population from the National Finance Commission (NFC) award, Auranzgeb maintained, 'Everything will be done in consultation with provinces.' Responding to a query on why the government maintained the minimum wage at Rs37,000, Aurangzeb said the decision was made in consideration of industrial growth. On the imposition of 18% tax on solar panels, Langrial explained that the GST of around 16-18% was imposed on less assembled solar panels, whereas there was no GST on imported fully assembled solar panels. 'The local manufacturing was at a disadvantage. We want to create an enabling environment for the local sector,' the FBR chief said. Responding to a query, Imdadullah Bosal informed that the budget figures are 'locked with the International Monetary Fund (IMF)'. Govt salary increase Bosal stated that the budgeted increase in government salaries—from 6% to 10%—would have a fiscal impact of approximately Rs28–30 billion. He informed that the Ministry of Finance will hold consultations with the defence ministry regarding the introduction of a contributory pension scheme. Earlier, reporters staged a boycott of the press conference after the government failed to hold a scheduled technical briefing on the Finance Bill. Ruckus ahead of post-budget press conference Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif-led coalition government's Finance Minister Muhammad Aurangzeb on Tuesday presented the federal budget 2025-26 to the parliament, with a total outlay of Rs17.573 trillion, targeting a GDP growth target of 4.2% against 2.7% in the outgoing year. Aurangzeb termed the budget the start of a strategy to create a competitive economy and economic productivity to increase exports and fundamentally change the economy's DNA. The government has set an inflation target of 7.5% for the next fiscal year. Regarding the fiscal deficit, the government projected a target of 3.9% of the GDP — or Rs5,037 billion — from the outgoing fiscal year's target of 5.9%. The primary surplus is targeted at 2.4% of the GDP against the budgeted 2% in the current fiscal year, which has been revised to 2.2%. More to follow
